Arctic ice refuses to melt as ordered

  • Thread starter Thread starter b_justb
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Seems rather odd. We’ve lost the Larsen A ice shelf,
(1,600 sq km) in 1995, the Wilkins ice shelf (1,100 sq km) in 1998, and the Larsen B (13,500 sq km) 2002. That’s a whole lot of sea ice.
How many times have they melted before?
 
Barbarian observes:
Seems rather odd. We’ve lost the Larsen A ice shelf,
(1,600 sq km) in 1995, the Wilkins ice shelf (1,100 sq km) in 1998, and the Larsen B (13,500 sq km) 2002. That’s a whole lot of sea ice.
First, you can’t refute historical data with anecdotal events.
The progressive collapse of ice shelves in Anarctica are historical data. Perhaps you don’t know what “data” means? Perhaps you don’t know what “anecdotal” means, either. You seem to think it means “data I would rather not think about.”
Second, the total amount of ice that you mention as being lost amounts to 16,200 sq km. The units of the anomaly are measured in 1 million sq km so 16.2K is a relatively trivial amount of ice.
Would be, if it was as thick as other sea ice. But that’s not the case. Ice shelves vary from about 100 to 1000 meters thick. Other sea ice is usually a few meters thick; the Arctic sea ice has declined markedly in draft, now less than 2.5 meters thick at the most. Most of it is thinning, BTW, except near the North Pole, where (as you know) warming has resulted in increased precipitation at the poles.

Barbarian asks:
It’s hard to imagine what made those ice shelves collapse, if it wasn’t warming. What do you think?
Well, you earlier confirmed that continental ice has been increasing and this would increase the pressure exerted on the ice shelves.
Continental glaciation is what makes ice shelves. But at the margins of the continent, ice is thinning, and so the shelves were not being renewed as quickly. Ice takes a long time to move from the center of the continent.
That would seem to be a reasonable explanation.
Except for the facts.
Surely you don’t believe that the only reason an ice shelf could collapse is because of warming?
So far, no one seems to be able to find a different one. And the data show warming to be the culprit.

**The break-up of the Larsen B ice shelf in early 2002. This event has been attributed to the effects of global warming. That it occurred is beyond dispute and that it is a result of the warming of the Antarctic Peninsula where it is situated is also beyond dispute. What remains unclear is whether or not this is a taste of things to come and an indicator of an Antarctic-wide phenomena or simply a localized result of the localized warming of the Antarctic Peninsula region alone.

An ice shelf is a thick layer of ice that is floating on the sea. They are fed from the land by glaciers. Where the ice leaves the land and starts to float on the sea is a region known as the “hinge zone” where the ice is particularly chaotic, broken-up and a nightmare to try and travel over. Ice shelves surround much of Antarctica.

The Larsen B ice shelf was about 220m thick (720 feet) and during a 35 day period in early 2002 lost about 3,250 km2 of ice into the ocean. It is thought to have been in existence for at least 400 years prior to this and probably as long as 12,000 years since the end of the last ice age.

Such a disintegration in such a short time period is therefore an extremely significant event. What now remains of the Larsen B is about 40% of what was there in 1995. It had been breaking up at what was considered to be a rapid rate anyway before this major event. The break-up is thought to be a consequence of higher temperatures and large amounts of summer melt-water running down crevasses in the ice shelf so speeding the disintegration process.

Overall in the Antarctic Peninsula, seven ice shelves have between them declined in area by about 13,500 km2 since 1974.

A more recently seen phenomena that follows this ice shelf collapse is that the glaciers that fed the ice shelf seem to now be speeding up their flow down to the sea. This will certainly deposit more water in the oceans, and as this was previously on the land it will add to an increase in sea-level. The Antarctic peninsula doesn’t have enough ice to make much of a difference to sea level in itself even if it were all to melt, but it is best seen as an indicator region that can be observed to enhance understandings of the mechanisms in other parts of the world.**
coolantarctica.com/Antarctica%20fact%20file/science/global_warming.htm
 
Would be, if it was as thick as other sea ice. But that’s not the case. Ice shelves vary from about 100 to 1000 meters thick. Other sea ice is usually a few meters thick; the Arctic sea ice has declined markedly in draft, now less than 2.5 meters thick at the most.
Interesting point but perhaps you’ve forgotten the difference between area and volume. The graph showed the southern hemisphere sea ice anomaly as an area measurement. If the ice shelves were included in that measurement - as you assured us they were since they were not continental ice - then their loss only counts against the area, not the total volume of sea ice. By that measure, their loss was trivial.

If loss of sea ice in the arctic shows that the earth is warming, what does the growth of sea ice in the antarctic show? And if the models predicted that sea ice would diminish at both poles, which is shown not to be happening, what does that say about the models?

Ender
 
Interesting point but perhaps you’ve forgotten the difference between area and volume.
I just reminded you of the difference. Most sea ice is relatively thin, compared to the ice shelves which have collapsed and largely melted. While sea ice is several meters thick on the average, the shelves can be anywhere from 100 to 1000 meters thick. The amount of sea ice is greatly reduced, although the surface area has not been reduced.
The graph showed the southern hemisphere sea ice anomaly as an area measurement. If the ice shelves were included in that measurement - as you assured us they were since they were not continental ice - then their loss only counts against the area, not the total volume of sea ice.
If you suppose that the amount of ice is only dependent on surface area. If you count total amount of ice, then it has diminished considerably, although the models don’t necessarily predict it. The prediction was that warming should produce more precipitation at the poles, and produce more ice. Not necessarily more sea ice.
what does the growth of sea ice in the antarctic show?
That the amount of sea ice has been reduced, but the surface has actually increased slightly. Primarily, this is due to the fact that the Antarctic Penninsula was first affected by global warming, and the ice shelves there have already collapsed. It is long and narrow, and therefore would naturally be more quickly affected by warming. That collapsed ice contributed to the increase in surface ice.
And if the models predicted that sea ice would diminish at both poles
As you know, it has diminished. There is much less sea ice in Antarctica now than formerly. What’s left is just spread over a slightly larger area. Which is what you’d expect if several large ice shelves melted sufficiently to collapse and let the remaining ice float off.
 
That the amount of sea ice has been reduced, but the surface has actually increased slightly. Primarily, this is due to the fact that the Antarctic Penninsula was first affected by global warming, and the ice shelves there have already collapsed. It is long and narrow, and therefore would naturally be more quickly affected by warming. That collapsed ice contributed to the increase in surface ice.

As you know, it has diminished. There is much less sea ice in Antarctica now than formerly. What’s left is just spread over a slightly larger area. Which is what you’d expect if several large ice shelves melted sufficiently to collapse and let the remaining ice float off.
Merely conjecture. There is plenty of data that shows the increase in Antartic ice along with the decrease in Artic ice. Global warming alarmists often even rationalize away trends that oppose or seem counterintuitive to thier views (ex. 'We are having a snowier winter because of global warming", “There will be more hurricanes due to global warming - no wait, there are less huricane due to global warming”, “There is more ice because of previous global warming”).

It is clear that global warming has become a matter of faith for some, when it should be viewed objectively through the lens of science - and not just from “consensus” and cherry-picking studies / data that one finds agreeable.
 
Merely conjecture.
Nope. It’s a fact. All those ice shelves, with many thousands of cubic kilometers of ice are gone. Go check how many thousands of cubic kilometers of sea ice remain. Might be a wake up.
Global warming alarmists often even rationalize away trends that oppose or seem counterintuitive to thier views (ex. 'We are having a snowier winter because of global warming",
Since heavier snowfall at the poles was a prediction of the model, that’s not surprising. Warming produces more humidity at the poles, and hence more precipitation. If this confuses you, it might be good to review the model.
“There will be more hurricanes due to global warming - no wait, there are less huricane due to global warming”, “There is more ice because of previous global warming”).
You’ve been misled about that. The model predicted not more hurricanes, but more severe ones. Might be good for you to go check that data. Turns out the model got that right, to.
It is clear that global warming has become a matter of faith for some
Could be for some. But as you learned, it’s about evidence for most climatologists.
when it should be viewed objectively through the lens of science - and not just from “consensus”
Consensus is how science works. There is no official body deciding, no “decider.” Just the consensus of people working on the problems.
and cherry-picking studies / data that one finds agreeable.
Like “Well, yes, there is less sea ice around Anarctica, but there is almost 2% more surface area.”

Stuff like that? Or “Well, the surface is warmer, but we think the troposphere is cooler (or maybe just a little warmer) so that means the surface can’t be warmer.” That kind of thing?

If you don’t know what that’s about, it might be good to go find out.
 
Consensus is NOT how science works. You don’t take a poll of a certain number of people and proclaim it must be fact because it is consensus after all. Science is based on empirical evidence and experimentation. It is not based on shouting down opposing views and relying on strength in numbers. I have not seen much source data or citations quoted by you. I have seen your personal opinion on the matter.

If we really want to talk about consensus, there is this:

epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Minority.SenateReport
Over 400 prominent scientists from more than two dozen countries recently voiced significant objections to major aspects of the so-called “consensus” on man-made global warming. These scientists, many of whom are current and former participants in the UN IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change), criticized the climate claims made by the UN IPCC and former Vice President Al Gore.
The new report issued by the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee’s office of the GOP Ranking Member details the views of the scientists, the overwhelming majority of whom spoke out in 2007.
Even some in the establishment media now appear to be taking notice of the growing number of skeptical scientists. In October, the Washington Post Staff Writer Juliet Eilperin conceded the obvious, writing that climate skeptics “appear to be expanding rather than shrinking.” Many scientists from around the world have dubbed 2007 as the year man-made global warming fears “bite the dust.” (LINK) In addition, many scientists who are also progressive environmentalists believe climate fear promotion has “co-opted” the green movement. (LINK)
And then there is NASA’s Dr. James Hansen:
The real deal is this: the ‘royalty’ controlling the court, the ones with the power, the ones with the ability to make a difference, with the ability to change our course, the ones who will live in infamy if we pass the tipping points, are the captains of industry, CEOs in fossil fuel companies such as EXXON/Mobil, automobile manufacturers, utilities, all of the leaders who have placed short-term profit above the fate of the planet and the well-being of our children. The court jesters are their jesters, occasionally paid for services, and more substantively supported by the captains’ disinformation campaigns.
This was shortly before his infamous ‘hockey stick’ was unmasked as a fraudulent study intentionally manipulated to make the case for global warming.

This is what happens when alarmists with agendas put thier agenda before science.

I realize that some people have a certain lock-step mindset and cannot be convinced no matter the data. I am sure you will try to turn that around. I have shown graphs and cited scientists. You have offered personal opinion. At the very least, I think we can establish that there is no “consensus”. There may be groups on both sides that have thier own opinions, but there is clearly not enough evidence to chisel this alarmism in stone as fact.

Good day.
 
I realize that some people have a certain lock-step mindset and cannot be convinced no matter the data. I am sure you will try to turn that around. I have shown graphs and cited scientists.
All I’ve seen on this thread is Barbarian presenting good science and you guys presenting propaganda which only turns out to be true at the surface. Barbarian has answered every one of your claims.

Science might not be about majority rule but concensus is a different thing.
 
All I’ve seen on this thread is Barbarian presenting good science and you guys presenting propaganda which only turns out to be true at the surface. Barbarian has answered every one of your claims.

Science might not be about majority rule but concensus is a different thing.
I dunno Neil. I have posted several charts from sources in the scientific field and have also posted a report from the U.S. Senate Committee on the environment detailing 400 scientists who have a view opposed to the conventional alarmist view. You can page back and look for yourself. Certainly not propaganda. For you to call solid research and a U.S. committee report propaganda is very telling. At least have the courage to be intellectually honest and admit that there are two valid and opposing views to this issue.

🤷 But I guess you’ve made up your mind. You’re entitled to your opinion and I’ll respect that, but I think it is folly to dismiss the contrary evidence as propaganda. :rolleyes:
 
I dunno Neil. I have posted several charts from sources in the scientific field
Takes a bit more than a chart or two. The data have to indicate what you say they do.
and have also posted a report from the U.S. Senate Committee on the environment detailing 400 scientists who have a view opposed to the conventional alarmist view.
Politicians aren’t the best source, either. If you depend on Imhofe or Gore for your info, you will be continuously misled, as you were this time.
You can page back and look for yourself. Certainly not propaganda. For you to call solid research and a U.S. committee report propaganda is very telling.
Certainly, we can trust politicians to always tell the truth, um? :rolleyes:
At least have the courage to be intellectually honest and admit that there are two valid and opposing views to this issue.
In science, the only valid view is the one supported by evidence. Even if your favorite congressman doesn’t like it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top