Are all Roman Catholic liturgies the exact same?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CharitableFaith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

CharitableFaith

Guest
Are all the Roman Rite liturgies the exact same in every single roman rite church in the world? If not how are the liturgies different?

God Bless
 
Overall structure is the same (Liturgy of Word and Liturgy of Mass, aka the Order of the Mass), but language & music can be different.
 
Splagchnizomai said:
Overall structure is the same (Liturgy of Word and Liturgy of Mass, aka the Order of the Mass), but language & music can be different.
Click to expand...
I realized that, because at my parish my music is a little more upbeat and isent all slow with organs but a piano, while I seen at other parishes its all organ or guitar mass.

God bless
 
CharitableFaith said:
Are all the Roman Rite liturgies the exact same in every single roman rite church in the world? If not how are the liturgies different?

God Bless
Click to expand...
First of all there isn’t a single Roman Rite liturgy. There are several that the Latin Churches use. The most common, at least in the US are the Ordinary Form, Extraordinary Form and the Anglican Use. There is also an Ambrosian rite, the Gallican rite and the Mozabaric rite - maybe a few others.

Within a single rite or form, there are various options that can be used at Mass. For example, in the Ordinary Form of Mass there are three variations of the Penitential Rite and two forms of the Creed as well as four Eucharistic prayers. These options are for the priest to decide. Other options, such as when to kneel or how to receive Communion are decided at the Episcopal level or even by a Conference of Bishops.
 
Depends on what you mean by exactly the same. (And are you talking about just the Mass, or are you also thinking about other liturgies such as baptisms, funerals, reconciliation, etc?)

Regarding the Mass: The structure of the Mass will always be the same in the sense that the Mass consists of the Liturgy of the Word and the Liturgy of the Eucharist, and this is the same around the world. The Liturgy of the Word is the first part of the Mass in which we hear the readings (which will be the same readings wherever you are) and then the priest gives his homily. The Liturgy of the Eucharist is the second part of the Mass in which the consecration occurs. And then of course we all receive Communion.

Within the Mass are many prayers, songs, and responses. Many of these will be the same wherever you are, but at the same time, the Church offers options for some of them (i.e., the Penitential Rite has I believe 3 different options, and there are several different Eucharistic Prayers). The priest chooses which to use and so in that sense the Mass will be different among parishes as different priests will choose different options. And of course, the musical settings for the prayers are different, since I believe the bishop of the diocese chooses a preferred musical setting for his parishes to use, and the priest may choose different settings as well. And obviously the processional, recessional, and communion hymns will vary from parish to parish, and even from Mass time to Mass time in a given parish.
 
CharitableFaith said:
Are all the Roman Rite liturgies the exact same in every single roman rite church in the world? If not how are the liturgies different?

God Bless
Click to expand...
First off, excluding the other catholic non-roman rites, there are two forms of the roman rite: ordinary form and extraordinary form.

Within the extraordinary there are several variations such as pontifical High Mass, High Mass, Sung Mass Low Mass, for details of the various types I would consult a book like the ceremonies of the roman rite described by O’Connel, Fortescue and Reid. As there are far to many details for a forum such as this.

Within the ordinary form there are several options within the pennetential rite, again in choice of Eucharistic prayer, and. The music is often at the discresion of the Priest or Choir master.

And thats before you take local/national universal feast days into account!
 
I was wondering a simular thing. Being a newbie that is lol
I noticed on here someone mentioned a homily that was on the same theme as the one I heard at the Mass here.
It made me wonder if it was basicly the same everywhere?
 
IneedGod said:
I was wondering a simular thing. Being a newbie that is lol
I noticed on here someone mentioned a homily that was on the same theme as the one I heard at the Mass here.
It made me wonder if it was basicly the same everywhere?
Click to expand...
The Scripture readings are the same. Each priest gives his own homily therefore the teachings from the readings may be a little different. For example I went to Mass yesterday evening. The homily was about Christ being the good Shepherd. A friend said that her’s was for us to be shepherds to each other and to take care of each other like a good shepherd. I’m going to Mass shortly and this homily will be different from the other two.
 
Yes, in the sense that they are all designed to accomplish the same purpose.
 
There can also be different reading depending on the occasion.

For example. In Lent when there are catechumens preparing for reception at Easter, if it is during the time of the scrutinies, readings can be take from John’s gospel rather than the Sunday Lectionary for that Sunday in Lent.

Of if you are at a wedding, special reading may be used in place of those designated for that day. Similarly for baptisms or confirmations.

If a feast or solemnity falls on a particular day, the readings will then be changed to that feast (for example Immaculate Conception)
 
Sorry but I must disagree that all Roman Rites are the same (except for music & language). There is a difference between the Extraordinary Form and the Ordinary Form both in that they use different calendars and some of the prayers are very different. Some are similar, but not exactly.

Both are designed to achieve the same end (although there is even some different opinions on this issue). I tend to agree with Pro Vobis on this one.

Many gestures are different or at least done at different times during Mass.

God Bless
 
Theophorus said:
First off, excluding the other catholic non-roman rites, there are two forms of the roman rite: ordinary form and extraordinary form.!
Click to expand...
There are really several, not just two; add onto your list the Anglican Use, the Ambrosian, the Gallican, and the Mozabaric rites.

Those are all Roman Catholic rites.
 
Brendan said:
There are really several, not just two; add onto your list the Anglican Use, the Ambrosian, the Gallican, and the Mozabaric rites.

Those are all Roman Catholic rites.
Click to expand...
It can be disputed if the Ambrosian, Gallican and Mozarabic rites are part of Roman Rite, they are usually seen as separate Rites of the Western family of rites. So that makes them non-Roman rites.

Some sources attributed religious orders Rites as part of Roman Rite with different use, while other separate them as different Rites.

The Anglican use liturgy is not a separate rite, it is a different use of the Roman Rite.

There is one interesting use of the Ordinary Form, it is not well known, but exists. That is the Zaire use of Ordinary Form.

So, by conservative take, Roman Rite is executed (at least) either in the form of Extraordinary form, Ordinary form, Anglican use form, Zaire use form.
 
CharitableFaith said:
Are all the Roman Rite liturgies the exact same in every single roman rite church in the world? If not how are the liturgies different?

God Bless
Click to expand...
No. Even the Ordinary Form is not consistent from parish to parish. I’ve never been to two Masses using the Ordinary Form that have been the same. The only consistency I’ve found is in the Extraordinary Form.

The differences between the Extraordinary Form and the Ordinary Form are many. There is a different structure, different prayers, a different calendar and a different cycle of readings. That’s just the Mass. The Divine Office is radically different as well.

Decades ago we could have said that yes, every Roman Rite parish had the same liturgy. Not today.
 
Laudate_Dominum said:
No. Even the Ordinary Form is not consistent from parish to parish. I’ve never been to two Masses using the Ordinary Form that have been the same. The only consistency I’ve found is in the Extraordinary Form.
Click to expand...
To some extent this is true. However in both forms you will find the sequence to be almost the same:

Asperges Me (if any)
Confiteor
Kyrie
Gloria (if any)
Epistle
Gospel
sermon (if any)
Creed (if any)
Offertory
Lavabo
Preface
Sanctus
Canon
Minor elevation
Pater Noster
Agnus Dei
Domini non sum dignus
communion
Final prayers and Blessing.
 
The Catholic Church has the following liturgies which are still in use:

Latin (Western) Liturgical Tradition
  1. Ordinary Form
  2. Extraordinary Form
  3. Ambrosian Rite
  4. Mozarabic Rite
  5. Bragan Rite
  6. Anglican-Use Mass
Rites of Religious Orders
  1. Dominican Rite
  2. Carthusian Rite
  3. Carmelite Rite
  4. Cisternian Rite
Eastern Liturgical Tradition
  1. The Liturgy of St. Basil
  2. The Chaldean Mass
  3. The Order of the Divine and Holy Liturgy of Our Father Among the Saints Gregory the Theologian (or Liturgy of the Presanctified Gifts)
  4. The Liturgy of St. James
  5. The Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom
  6. The Liturgy of St. Mark
  7. The Holy Qorbono
In addition, there are a few others that may still technically be permitted, but are not normally used anymore, such as the Zaire Use and the Algonquian/Iroquoian Use.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top