Are Jesuit schools really Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ProdigalSon1211
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

ProdigalSon1211

Guest
Are Jesuit high schools and Universities really faithful to the teachings of the Catholic Church or have they become completely secular? Are there any Jesuit educational institutions today that are still FAITHFUL to the Catholic Church or no?

How would you rate Santa Clara University or Seattle University?
 
Are Jesuit high schools and Universities really faithful to the teachings of the Catholic Church or have they become completely secular? Are there any Jesuit educational institutions today that are still FAITHFUL to the Catholic Church or no?

How would you rate Santa Clara University or Seattle University?
I don’t know about the ones you mentioned, but Creighton is the closest Jesuit school where I live and among jesuit schools it is pretty faithful. That being said, you still have a lot of secular types at the school and while you have a good catholic community, there are a lot of secular types there.
 
I don’t know about the ones you mentioned, but Creighton is the closest Jesuit school where I live and among jesuit schools it is pretty faithful. That being said, you still have a lot of secular types at the school and while you have a good catholic community, there are a lot of secular types there.
I went to a Vincentian school (St. John’s) that was sometimes in line with the Faith, other times it struggled, much like we as humans do. I don’t expect the majority of Catholic schools to be perfect, and I think size is a definite disadvantage in the matter.

Without wanting to judge any Jesuit institutions, I will say that the ‘perception’ about Georgetown is that it lacks a strong Catholic identity. I hope I am wrong about that, but that is my understanding of how other Catholics in the DC area perceive the school.
 
I went to a Vincentian school (St. John’s) that was sometimes in line with the Faith, other times it struggled, much like we as humans do. I don’t expect the majority of Catholic schools to be perfect, and I think size is a definite disadvantage in the matter.

Without wanting to judge any Jesuit institutions, I will say that the ‘perception’ about Georgetown is that it lacks a strong Catholic identity. I hope I am wrong about that, but that is my understanding of how other Catholics in the DC area perceive the school.
According to some of the alumni at local Jesuit secondary schools, they were taught the Catholic religion constantly…they were also told to go to college, get a good job, and donate to their alma mater…
 
Are Jesuit high schools and Universities really faithful to the teachings of the Catholic Church or have they become completely secular? Are there any Jesuit educational institutions today that are still FAITHFUL to the Catholic Church or no?

How would you rate Santa Clara University or Seattle University?
At this site at the Cardinal Newman Society you can find out about colleges and universities.

The majority of them (Catholic) are not loyal to the Magisterium, and this site gives a lot of info on what is happening on Catholic Campuses.

cardinalnewmansociety.org/TheNewmanGuide.aspx
 
I have to side with the Jesuits mainly because I believe ALL of their teaching (viewed enmass / on-the-whole) is a journey of faith. It encompases the full four years, but they drag along the weirdly matriculated as well.

It’s a several step process of [the] journey (in a long loop) that forces the learner to 1) View faith in a way that attempts to gel what the learner considers “reality” with what they know of their faith and the Bible. Usually a no-go, lots of gaps/holes/overlap/un-overlap. Outcome = learner says “faith/religion/god” cannot be.

Next: 2) They examine the World’s faiths and beliefs / belief systems in the history of the World’s Philosophy [philosophies]. Outcome = learner gets a sense of how imbued humanity is with basic Logic while also heavily steeped in faith.

Next: 3) They return to study the Bible (O.T. / N.T.) along with Philosophy in higher forms: Metaphysics, Cosmology. Outcome = learner establishes a personal grounding in the complexity of WHAT IS (in the “Universe”). And you (the learner) again finally embrace your faith with a peaceful and resolute surrender to THE ALMIGHTY.

Thank you Fr. O’Brian, S.J.! Thank you Fr. Kent, S.J.! (and many others) I know GOD has taken you in his arms.
 
Some are more so than others. The state of Catholic higher education has been changing for the last 40 years, just like everything else. Do some research.

I attended a great Jesuit Prep school in Chicago. From a faith perspective, it is substantially lacking compared to the old days. Boy, I hate admitting that, but that’s the truth. 😦

My niece attends Santa Clara and loves it. It is a beautiful place. From her perspective, you don’t have to look hard to continue your Catholic faith there…but you do have to look.

If you have no prior experience with the Jesuits, college may not be the place to start. Again, do some homework, make some visits, ask questions of the schools themselves. Find out how often Mass is offered, how the faith is communicated and lived on campus, etc.
 
I don’t know about the ones you mentioned, but Creighton is the closest Jesuit school where I live and among jesuit schools it is pretty faithful. That being said, you still have a lot of secular types at the school and while you have a good catholic community, there are a lot of secular types there.
I think some of that has to do with where the school is located. I have heard that about Creighton, but Creighton mainly draws from the Midwest and the prairie states to the west and north of it for students.

The last I knew, Rockhurst was still pretty faithful, but again, it largely draws from the Midwest.

I won’t mention some others with which I am familiar because I don’t want to say anything too terribly unkind.

The composition of the student body seems to make a difference.
 
Maybe with Pope Francis now, things could change for the better for the Jebbies:D
 
Ok, my answer is somewhat dated. I have to say too that my alma mater magazine is full of liberal c_ _ p and has been for the last 10 years. That kind of stuff was relegated to the “fringe” when I went there. If they are finally getting around to affecting the "religious’ aspect of their institutions as much as “school life” and curriculum, they will suck themselves into the sink.

Don’t forget, if there is a flaw in any higher education, it only persists due to people’s continuing to patronize it, and it’s flaws typically reflect the flaws of those patronizing it.

If you live in a blue state, you are part of the problem, if you have a (D) after your name, the problem is part of you.
 
I hope not. I sure hope God willing I can help with problems like that.
 
I went to a Jesuit college at a university. The priests are great, but the campus minister… uh… need a new one. I was never sure if she is Catholic, Buddhist or humanist. I was supremely unimpressed when the university did NOTHING for Lent because they wanted to plan a few things for Catholic Students Week. I asked if I could plan stuff, if we could have Adoration for a couple hours every Friday, and I’d be there the whole time so it’s not like they had to worry about sign up sheets. People could just drop in. But nope, not happening. Clearly free coffee to promote the Catholic College is more important than Lent. Ugh.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top