Are Mormons saved?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mariahloves
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mariahloves

Guest
According to Catholic teaching? Any non-Mormon Protestant opinions? Sorry if this thread has been started before but I think the search terms “Mormon” and “saved” might have a few more results than I’m ready to sift through
 
The Catholic Church does not teach that anyone is automatically saved or not saved. What she does teach is that some groups have valid baptism and some do not. Thus, some are joined to Christ and others are not. The Mormon baptism is not valid, thus they are not joined to Christ in the same way. That said, some Mormons will make it to heaven and some will not
 
What are the Mormons? Aren’t they the religious group that are similar to the Amish in the sense that they have objections about new technology and don’t wear regular clothing?
 
What are the Mormons? Aren’t they the religious group that are similar to the Amish in the sense that they have objections about new technology and don’t wear regular clothing?
No, Mormons are also known as LDS, or The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.

They are very much into technology.
 
No, Mormons are also known as LDS, or The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.

They are very much into technology.
I saw some people that were dressed in what looked like Amish clothing, but with brighter colors and I pointed them out to my friend and he told me those were the Mormons. I have thought that for years now, lol.
 
I saw some people that were dressed in what looked like Amish clothing, but with brighter colors and I pointed them out to my friend and he told me those were the Mormons. I have thought that for years now, lol.
Some conservative Mennonites wear similar 'plain clothing" but are not adverse to colors. I have seem some conservative Mennonite women in the long “midi’s” with the cape around the shoulders wearing their prayer cap in bright pink or blue or green dresses. He probably mean Mennonite.
 
I saw some people that were dressed in what looked like Amish clothing, but with brighter colors and I pointed them out to my friend and he told me those were the Mormons. I have thought that for years now, lol.
Depending on where you are, they could have been FLDS, which is Fundamental Later Day Saints. They were the bunch that was all over the news a while back about child abuse, polygamy, etc.

The LDS and FLDS hold many similar views and doctrines, but their biggest difference is in the practice of polygamy.
 
Some conservative Mennonites wear similar 'plain clothing" but are not adverse to colors. I have seem some conservative Mennonite women in the long “midi’s” with the cape around the shoulders wearing their prayer cap in bright pink or blue or green dresses. He probably mean Mennonite.
AH! I think I just got messed up, I was thinking of Mennonites! Never mind. I wonder if any of them are on here? Or they should make a forum section for the Amish.😃
 
According to Catholic teaching? Any non-Mormon Protestant opinions? Sorry if this thread has been started before but I think the search terms “Mormon” and “saved” might have a few more results than I’m ready to sift through
“God is not willing that any should perish, but all come to repentance” God meets us where we are…we don’t have to be a “theological genius” or even theologically orthodox with every jot and tittle adhered to for the grace and mercy of God to be present in our lives.
 
According to Catholic teaching? Any non-Mormon Protestant opinions? Sorry if this thread has been started before but I think the search terms “Mormon” and “saved” might have a few more results than I’m ready to sift through
To answer closer to the spirit of your question: according to the Catholic Church, Mormons are not Christians. Mormons do not believe in the Trinity and they instead hold a polytheistic view. According to the CC, this makes their baptism invalid and the LDS church as a non-Christian religion.

I believe most protestant-faiths hold the same view as the Catholic Church.

(But as you will see as this thread unfolds, the LDS do not believe the CC or protestant faiths have the authority to baptize, serve communion, or any practice any of the other “sacraments.” So, both are pointing the finger at the other and saying they are invalid.)
 
To answer closer to the spirit of your question: according to the Catholic Church, Mormons are not Christians. Mormons do not believe in the Trinity and they instead hold a polytheistic view. According to the CC, this makes their baptism invalid and the LDS church as a non-Christian religion.
However this doesn’t really answer the question of whether Mormons are saved according to the Catholic Church. Catholicism teaches that it is possible for them to be saved (as it is possible for all non-Catholics to be saved), and perhaps baptism of desire will apply to some Mormons as it applies to others. Some Protestant churches have a more strict version of salvation, and reject a “baptism of desire” concept.

1260 "Since Christ died for all, and since all men are in fact called to one and the same destiny, which is divine, we must hold that the Holy Spirit offers to all the possibility of being made partakers, in a way known to God, of the Paschal mystery."63 Every man who is ignorant of the Gospel of Christ and of his Church, but seeks the truth and does the will of God in accordance with his understanding of it, can be saved. It may be supposed that such persons would have desired Baptism explicitly if they had known its necessity.
 
However this doesn’t really answer the question of whether Mormons are saved according to the Catholic Church. Catholicism teaches that it is possible for them to be saved (as it is possible for all non-Catholics to be saved), and perhaps baptism of desire will apply to some Mormons as it applies to others. Some Protestant churches have a more strict version of salvation, and reject a “baptism of desire” concept.

1260 "Since Christ died for all, and since all men are in fact called to one and the same destiny, which is divine, we must hold that the Holy Spirit offers to all the possibility of being made partakers, in a way known to God, of the Paschal mystery."63 Every man who is ignorant of the Gospel of Christ and of his Church, but seeks the truth and does the will of God in accordance with his understanding of it, can be saved. It may be supposed that such persons would have desired Baptism explicitly if they had known its necessity.
Well sure. You might even get me to agree that there are some Mormons out there who read only the Bible and have never really paid attention to the Book of Mormon, to the D&C, to the BoA. Or, that there are some who have rejected LDS theology but have not left the church (for family reasons or whatever).

My grandma used to say, every once in a while a blind pig will find an acorn. So, as I read the question, it was asking about the majority not a few exceptions.
 
Well sure. You might even get me to agree that there are some Mormons out there who read only the Bible and have never really paid attention to the Book of Mormon, to the D&C, to the BoA. Or, that there are some who have rejected LDS theology but have not left the church (for family reasons or whatever).

My grandma used to say, every once in a while a blind pig will find an acorn. So, as I read the question, it was asking about the majority not a few exceptions.
Which really doesn’t say anything about baptism of desire. The fact that Mormons are not validly baptized according to the Catholic Church does not take away from the fact that a baptism of desire can apply to many of them, i.e. those that are ignorant of the Gospel of Jesus Christ (according to the Catholic Church), and those that are ignorant of the “fact” that the Catholic Church is Jesus’ Church.

Maybe it’s just me, but I somehow doubt that the majority of Mormons know that the Catholic Church is Jesus’ Church. Replace “Mormon” with another religion and it applies as well. The Catholic Church also teaches that the plan of salvation includes Muslims (CCC 841), for example.

Again, many Protestants don’t seem to have a concept of baptism of desire (or baptism of blood for that matter).
 
The best answer to the OP from a Catholic perspective is “we don’t know” and “it’s possible”. Catholicism does teach that a baptism of desire can apply to unbaptized persons (obviously not every one). As the Catechism teaches:

1260 "Since Christ died for all, and since all men are in fact called to one and the same destiny, which is divine, we must hold that the Holy Spirit offers to all the possibility of being made partakers, in a way known to God, of the Paschal mystery."63 Every man who is ignorant of the Gospel of Christ and of his Church, but seeks the truth and does the will of God in accordance with his understanding of it, can be saved. It may be supposed that such persons would have desired Baptism explicitly if they had known its necessity.

As we see, not having a valid baptism in Catholicism does not automatically damn someone. Therefore, there is hope for the salvation of Mormons (presumably not all of them), according to Catholicism.
 
Are Mormons saved?

Not my call, it is up the God.

However, the fact that they do not worship the God and Christ of the Bible could be a problem.

Still, God will look on their hearts and decide
 
Which really doesn’t say anything about baptism of desire. The fact that Mormons are not validly baptized according to the Catholic Church does not take away from the fact that a baptism of desire can apply to many of them, i.e. those that are ignorant of the Gospel of Jesus Christ (according to the Catholic Church), and those that are ignorant of the “fact” that the Catholic Church is Jesus’ Church.

Maybe it’s just me, but I somehow doubt that the majority of Mormons know that the Catholic Church is Jesus’ Church. Replace “Mormon” with another religion and it applies as well. The Catholic Church also teaches that the plan of salvation includes Muslims (CCC 841), for example.

Again, many Protestants don’t seem to have a concept of baptism of desire (or baptism of blood for that matter).
Baptism of desire? I’d guess most protestant do believe it. Otherwise they are rejecting Christ’s words spoken to the repentant thief on the cross (St. Dismas for the Catholics).
 
According to Catholic teaching? Any non-Mormon Protestant opinions? Sorry if this thread has been started before but I think the search terms “Mormon” and “saved” might have a few more results than I’m ready to sift through
No, I do not believe that anyone who accepts the teachings of the Latter Day Saints will be saved.
 
Why don’t they have a valid baptism? Don’t they baptise in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit? I thought that was all that needed to be said in order for the baptism to be valid. I know Mormons are quite lost when it comes to theology and I never really considered them Christian per se but at the end of the day I know there are good Mormons out there who truly desire to please God and the only way they have been taught is through the LDS church. But the basic idea here is that some can be saved but we have no way of knowing under what circumstances. That’s really sad
 
No, I do not believe that anyone who accepts the teachings of the Latter Day Saints will be saved.
What if they lived in a rural area and grew up with only the Book of Mormon and LDS teachings and were convinced that the Church fell? I don’t think that’s fair for them
 
Why don’t they have a valid baptism? Don’t they baptise in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit? I thought that was all that needed to be said in order for the baptism to be valid. I know Mormons are quite lost when it comes to theology and I never really considered them Christian per se but at the end of the day I know there are good Mormons out there who truly desire to please God and the only way they have been taught is through the LDS church. But the basic idea here is that some can be saved but we have no way of knowing under what circumstances. That’s really sad
Their understanding of the Trinity is flawed, as is their understanding of the nature of Christ and his relationship to the Father.

Don’t forget that ALL non-Christians are judged by the natural law. Add to that fact that Mormons do understand that they sin and do ask to be forgiven
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top