Are our achievements all done by God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jedpatrickdatu
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jedpatrickdatu

Guest
After winning a contest, acing an exam, or receiving an expensive item, I thank God for the blessing, but recently I thought about it more deeply. If He wishes to answer our prayers will he subtly control events? Will he partially possess me or possess others to make certain choices that will lead to me winning a quiz bee? I’m bothered by the thought because it conflicts with the concept of free will. Does that mean our accomplishments are not done by us, that we did no hard work to do it, that we shouldn’t give ourselves any credit? Are we like puppets who can take joy in the blessings God gives us, but not acknowledge ourselves to be strong, perseverant people?
 
When it came to achievements for the Kingdom, Paul repeatedly made it clear that he could only boast on behalf of Christ, for example in his beautiful prose of Galatians 6:14 “May I never boast except in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ, through which the world has been crucified to me, and I to the world.”

God bless +

Michael
 
When it came to achievements for the Kingdom, Paul repeatedly made it clear that he could only boast on behalf of Christ, for example in his beautiful prose of Galatians 6:14 “May I never boast except in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ, through which the world has been crucified to me, and I to the world.”

God bless +

Michael
👍
 
After winning a contest, acing an exam, or receiving an expensive item, I thank God for the blessing, but recently I thought about it more deeply. If He wishes to answer our prayers will he subtly control events? Will he partially possess me or possess others to make certain choices that will lead to me winning a quiz bee? I’m bothered by the thought because it conflicts with the concept of free will. Does that mean our accomplishments are not done by us, that we did no hard work to do it, that we shouldn’t give ourselves any credit? Are we like puppets who can take joy in the blessings God gives us, but not acknowledge ourselves to be strong, perseverant people?
I think that what you are describing here is, in essence, the delicate balance between:
proper self love (though which we love our neighbor)…
humility(by which we praise both God and others who have helped us)…
gratitude (for the good and the bad - for each has lessons to teach)…
cooperation with grace (also known as hard work on our part)…
and recognition of our total dependence on God.

Yes certainly God can work in subtle ways to influence things but mostly he allows things to proceed within the framework of His creation and limits most of his subtle influences to guiding and teaching our hearts to Love more fully…
Everything else is fleeting…only Love remains.

Peace
James
 
After winning a contest, acing an exam, or receiving an expensive item, I thank God for the blessing, but recently I thought about it more deeply. If He wishes to answer our prayers will he subtly control events? Will he partially possess me or possess others to make certain choices that will lead to me winning a quiz bee? I’m bothered by the thought because it conflicts with the concept of free will. Does that mean our accomplishments are not done by us, that we did no hard work to do it, that we shouldn’t give ourselves any credit? Are we like puppets who can take joy in the blessings God gives us, but not acknowledge ourselves to be strong, perseverant people?
In the moral/spiritual sphere, where man has fallen from righteousness, grace, alone, can lift man back up, restoring his righteousness, i.e. justifying him. And yet the Church teaches that man can resist this grace; he can snub God’s desire for reconciliation, just as his ancestor Adam spurned God in the first place by disobeying His first commandment. That’s a very radical freedom-the freedom to oppose God’s will.

But man cannot be whole-who he was intended to be-apart from God. We must elect to commune with Him, to give up the freedom/autonomy that Adam pursued, for our own good after learning for ourselves the futility and, indeed, the death, which results when man is separated from God, apart from whom he can do nothing. We must freely choose to limit our freedom, in a sense, whereupon we find that we were actually enslaved without God, who simply desires us to be free to love, where all goodness and happiness is found; we must search and find the value of love, the “value of God”, so to speak, and exercise that knowledge by turning back to Him, as we will to accept His help in doing so.

It’s a synergistic effort, God drawing us without force, wanting our wills involved; that’s a major part of our becoming just.
 
Acts done in grace should not be thought of as “possession,” as if one were possessed by a devil, puppetizing the person’s body. In a certain sense, good works are the property of both the soul and Christ. Remember the analogy of the vine and branches in Scripture. The branches produce fruit, but only because they receive from the vine, which is analogous to Christ.

Here is a pertinent paragraph from the Council of Trent, session 6:*CANON XXXII.-If any one saith, that the good works of one that is justified are in such manner the gifts of God, as that they are not also the good merits of him that is justified; or, that the said justified, by the good works which he performs through the grace of God and the merit of Jesus Christ, whose living member he is, does not truly merit increase of grace, eternal life, and the attainment of that eternal life,-if so be, however, that he depart in grace,-and also an increase of glory; let him be anathema.*Remember, in the preceding paragraph, Trent is condemning anyone who claims that good works are not “also the good merits of him that is justified.” God, in His generosity, shares with us, that we might be able to properly call His good work ours. Read more from Trent, session 6.
 
I would say that the blessing is not acing an exam,or winning because then loosing or failing would lead to think one has not been blessed. For me the blessing in this case is one of your last words,perseverance.
 
I would say that the blessing is not acing an exam,or winning because then loosing or failing would lead to think one has not been blessed. For me the blessing in this case is one of your last words,perseverance.
Amen -
RE: The bolded…This is how the Jews viewed things in the Old Covenant and it is part of the reason why the “rich young man” went away sad (and confused) after Jesus told him to sell everything he had, give to the poor and come follow Jesus.
It was also the central part of the follow-up question by the apostles…
Jesus said how hard it is for the rich to enter the kingdom and the apostles ask - “Who then can be saved?”…The underlying supposition being that the rich are “blessed by God”…But what Jesus was doing was separating the two things.
Material goods are NOT signs of being being blessed.

Similarly - acing an exam or winning a competition is not a sign of blessing - but perhaps it is a sign of how well you have used the gifts (talents, skills, determination etc) God has given you.

Peace
James
 
So winning things and material gifts aren’t blessings from God, but your talents are?
 
So winning things and material gifts aren’t blessings from God, but your talents are?
If God uses a material gift, or “temporal good,” as we might say, then certainly it can be a blessing. The Catechism describes them even as a “grace.”*CCC#2010 Since the initiative belongs to God in the order of grace, no one can merit the initial grace of forgiveness and justification, at the beginning of conversion. Moved by the Holy Spirit and by charity, we can then merit for ourselves and for others the graces needed for our sanctification, for the increase of grace and charity, and for the attainment of eternal life. Even temporal goods like health and friendship can be merited in accordance with God’s wisdom. These graces and goods are the object of Christian prayer. Prayer attends to the grace we need for meritorious actions.*Of course, if the material possessions be come an idol, or if they are acquired illicitly, or lead one away from God, they could also be a source of temptation. That’s where the virtue of discernment comes in.
 
So winning things and material gifts aren’t blessings from God, but your talents are?
Our very life is a blessing from God. Doing our very best in all things is how we thank God for that blessing. If, in doing our best we “win things” then that is fine…but it is necessary to keep the winning in proper perspective…

Consider a race…A race, by it’s very nature can have only one winner…only one trophy is given away. Everyone in the race strives to do their very best - - so is the person who wins more “blessed” by God than the rest?
Should the person who, after striving to their utmost, still finishes last (even if by a few milliseconds) feel that he is not blessed by God?

Obviously we don’t want the loser - after striving with all they have - to feel somehow not blessed by God…
We want everyone to recognize that God’s blessings are free to all - a gift. That God gives different gifts to different people in different ways - and that in competition, only one can win - even though all have been blessed if they have done their best.
Also - we need to recognize that there are lessons to be learned as we seek to grow in holiness - and often times these are better learned through losses and set-backs than they are through winning.

Talents are wonderful things…There is even a parable of the talents…where those who use them properly in the service of the master are rewarded while the one who did not was punished.
So that is the key…using your talents to the best of your ability in service to our master who is Christ. Competition to win some material trophy really should not even enter into it (IMHO)

Peace
James
 
Thanks for the replies everyone. I still wasn’t able to form a definite answer from your replies, but your posts made me realize that how God transfers blessings to us might just another of His incomprehensible mysteries. Whether he gives us the tools or intervenes with our lives, we’ll probably never know. God works in mysterious ways.
 
Thanks for the replies everyone. I still wasn’t able to form a definite answer from your replies, but your posts made me realize that how God transfers blessings to us might just another of His incomprehensible mysteries. Whether he gives us the tools or intervenes with our lives, we’ll probably never know. God works in mysterious ways.
Indeed…
I have found many times where, in trying to figure something like this out, the problem is that I am trying to impose some sort of order on it that fits with my outlook and worldview. Then when it doesn’t fit…I’m just left confused.

If I let go of trying to “figure it out” and just let God speak to me in his own time generally things begin to make more sense. Maybe not completely but better.
Of course this doesn’t mean that I can explain it very well…but…🤷

Anyway - Glad we could be of help…

Peace
James
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top