Are there denominations within the CC?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dje101
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dje101

Guest
Hi all,

I was reading a website that said that there are over 250 different denominations within the Catholic Church. Is this true? If so, why? If not, where do people get this misconception?
 
Officially, there are 22 or 23 Rites of Worship in the Catholic Church.

But there is only one Catholic Church.

However… in a way…it could be said that all protestant denominations contain some of the Truth of the Catholic Church.

For instance, all protestant denominations who base their faith on the Bible, received Sacred Scripture from the Catholic Church.
 
Hi all,

I was reading a website that said that there are over 250 different denominations within the Catholic Church. Is this true? If so, why? If not, where do people get this misconception?
What website did you get it from? There are no denominations in the Catholic Church. There are 23 or so different regional churches, all unified in theology and under the authority of the Pope.

I read something once that pointed out the error in the supposed number of 33,000 Prtoestant denominations. The same study counted one Catholic Church for each country, arriving at 200. But there is only ONE Catholic Church. The misconceptions are from sloppy scholarship:)
 
What website did you get it from? There are no denominations in the Catholic Church. There are 23 or so different regional churches, all unified in theology and under the authority of the Pope.

I read something once that pointed out the error in the supposed number of 33,000 Prtoestant denominations. The same study counted one Catholic Church for each country, arriving at 200. But there is only ONE Catholic Church. The misconceptions are from sloppy scholarship:)
Thanks. Here’s the link…

aomin.org/aoblog/index.php?itemid=2218
 
This may be too much info…but this Wiki page talks about the Western Rite and the Eastern Rite Catholic Churches:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church
The Catholic Church is made up of a number of churches and rites.[184]
The largest of these is the Latin Church which developed in Western Europe before spreading throughout the world.
As well as the Latin Church there are 22 self-governing (in Latin, sui iuris) Eastern Catholic Churches with a membership of 13.865 million.[185]
The Eastern Catholic Churches comprise:
the **Byzantine tradition **(e.g., the Melkite Church, Ukrainian Catholic Church, Ruthenian Catholic Church, Romanian Catholic Church, Italo-Albanian Catholic Church),
the **Antiochian or West Syrian tradition **(Maronite Church, Syriac Catholic Church, Syro-Malankara Catholic Church),
the **Chaldean or East Syrian tradition **(Chaldean Church, Syro-Malabar Catholic Church), the Armenian tradition (Armenian Catholic Church)
and the **Alexandrian tradition **(Coptic Catholic Church, Ethiopian Catholic Church).
 
No, the Catholic Church is not a denomination and does not have denominations within Herself. However, the Catholic Church does have Rites such as the Byzantine Rite and the Latin or Roman Rite.
 
No, the Catholic Church is not a denomination and does not have denominations within Herself. However, the Catholic Church does have Rites such as the Byzantine Rite and the Latin or Roman Rite.
So these rites, as I have heard, are just different ways that these groups believe that the mass should be conducted? Maybe conducted is the wrong word…they believe that there are certain ways to worship God, is that right?
 
So these rites, as I have heard, are just different ways that these groups believe that the mass should be conducted? Maybe conducted is the wrong word…they believe that there are certain ways to worship God, is that right?
The Eastern Churches use to be members of the Eastern Orthodox Church but seperated to be in communion with the one, true Catholic Church. They have kept their Eastern Orthodox traditions but are still in communio with Pope Benedict XVI.

Hope that helps.👍
 
Hi all,

I was reading a website that said that there are over 250 different denominations within the Catholic Church. Is this true? If so, why? If not, where do people get this misconception?
There are approximately 250 dioceses in the Catholic Church. They are not separate denominations.

This “250 denominations” thing is an oft-repeated anti-Catholic claim based on some table that was published years ago of statistics on Christian denominations.

The table clearly indicated that the Catholic column contained dioceses, not denominations, but that hasn’t stopped the anti-Catholic polemicists from abusing and misrepresenting the data for their own ends.
Officially, there are 22 or 23 Rites of Worship in the Catholic Church.
Well, not technically. That’s not 23 rites but rather 23 churches of their own governance (“sui iuris churches”) who are nonetheless in communion with the bishop of Rome and who accept his primacy.

In any case, we all certainly agree that the twenty-three Catholic churches united together in full communion as the Catholic Church cannot be compared to separate “denominations,” as we all share the fullness of the same Catholic faith.
So these rites, as I have heard, are just different ways that these groups believe that the mass should be conducted? Maybe conducted is the wrong word…they believe that there are certain ways to worship God, is that right?
Yes, but we must admit there is greater diversity than that: the 23 Catholic churches are each self-governing. None of them is truly autocephalous, though, since they’re all in full communion with the Supreme Pontiff, but many of them essentially run themselves.

For instance, on a practical level no one in the Melkite Greek Catholic Church reports to the pope. They’re headed by a patriarch - the Melkite Patriarch of Antioch - and governed by synods of bishops. When the patriarch dies, the Melkite bishops in synod elect a new patriarch.

They simply inform Rome whom they have chosen as patriarch. That’s it. Any internal problems - doctrinal, liturgical, etc. - are handled by their bishops in synod or, if necessary, by their patriarch. (Other Catholic churches don’t have nearly this level of autonomy; only the patriarchal ones like the Maronites, Copts, etc. do)

In any case, this is diversity, not disunity. Protestants can’t even agree on the Sacraments (does baptism regenerate? is the Eucharist a mere memorial? are there even such things as Sacraments?), the basic structure of the Church (the episcopal model? the presbyterian one? the congregational one?), etc.
 
250 Dioceses? In the whole Church? I think there are probably 250 dioceses in the state of California. Maybe you’re thinking of metropolitan bishops? They’re fairly rare.
 
There are approximately 250 dioceses in the Catholic Church. They are not separate denominations.

This “250 denominations” thing is an oft-repeated anti-Catholic claim based on some table that was published years ago of statistics on Christian denominations.

The table clearly indicated that the Catholic column contained dioceses, not denominations, but that hasn’t stopped the anti-Catholic polemicists from abusing and misrepresenting the data for their own ends.

Well, not technically. That’s not 23 rites but rather 23 churches of their own governance (“sui iuris churches”) who are nonetheless in communion with the bishop of Rome and who accept his primacy.

In any case, we all certainly agree that the twenty-three Catholic churches united together in full communion as the Catholic Church cannot be compared to separate “denominations,” as we all share the fullness of the same Catholic faith.

Yes, but we must admit there is greater diversity than that: the 23 Catholic churches are each self-governing. None of them is truly autocephalous, though, since they’re all in full communion with the Supreme Pontiff, but many of them essentially run themselves.

For instance, on a practical level no one in the Melkite Greek Catholic Church reports to the pope. They’re headed by a patriarch - the Melkite Patriarch of Antioch - and governed by synods of bishops. When the patriarch dies, the Melkite bishops in synod elect a new patriarch.

They simply inform Rome whom they have chosen as patriarch. That’s it. Any internal problems - doctrinal, liturgical, etc. - are handled by their bishops in synod or, if necessary, by their patriarch. (Other Catholic churches don’t have nearly this level of autonomy; only the patriarchal ones like the Maronites, Copts, etc. do)

In any case, this is diversity, not disunity. Protestants can’t even agree on the Sacraments (does baptism regenerate? is the Eucharist a mere memorial? are there even such things as Sacraments?), the basic structure of the Church (the episcopal model? the presbyterian one? the congregational one?), etc.
Whoa, a lot of information…still a bit confused. So these rites are churches that are in communion with Rome, but are self governing. So if there is a liturgical or doctrinal problem, do they make a decision on their own or do they make a decision that is based on what the CC would do?

I’m new to all this “rite” stuff. I’m a little confused how they can be different churches that are self-governing that make their own decisions but are in communion with the Pope. Could you explain that part a little more please?
 
^ It is confusing, because we Latin Catholics tend to think of the Pope as the King of the Universal Church. And, yeah, he kind of is, but not really. (Moreover, our ultramontanism is sort of new, too, but that’s another story.) We have to respect the Pope not only in his doctrinal position as Supreme Pontiff of the Universal Church, but in his administrative capacity as Patriarch of the West.

Other rites have their own heads and their own administrative systems, which govern non-doctrinal matters like internal canon law, appointments of bishops, form of liturgical worship, and stuff like that. They are part of and in communion with the ordinary Magisterium on doctrinal issues of faith and morals, however, so, on those matters, they bow to the authority of Rome.
 
^ It is confusing, because we Latin Catholics tend to think of the Pope as the King of the Universal Church. And, yeah, he kind of is, but not really. (Moreover, our ultramontanism is sort of new, too, but that’s another story.) We have to respect the Pope not only in his doctrinal position as Supreme Pontiff of the Universal Church, but in his administrative capacity as Patriarch of the West.

Other rites have their own heads and their own administrative systems, which govern non-doctrinal matters like internal canon law, appointments of bishops, form of liturgical worship, and stuff like that. They are part of and in communion with the ordinary Magisterium on doctrinal issues of faith and morals, however, so, on those matters, they bow to the authority of Rome.
Well then, I guess the main issue that I’m getting confused on is, what does it mean to “be in communion with the Pope”.
 
Whoa, a lot of information…still a bit confused. So these rites are churches that are in communion with Rome, but are self governing. So if there is a liturgical or doctrinal problem, do they make a decision on their own or do they make a decision that is based on what the CC would do?

I’m new to all this “rite” stuff. I’m a little confused how they can be different churches that are self-governing that make their own decisions but are in communion with the Pope. Could you explain that part a little more please?
Here is a response I wrote about a year ago that sums up much of what you need to know:

Most people are not aware that the “Catholic Church” is actually comprised of twenty-three independent Catholic Churches, all in union with the pope. The Western, or Latin Catholic Church, is so large, however, that many people, even Catholics, are completely unaware of the other twenty-two churches, which make up the Eastern Branch. (Some have from only a few thousand members to a few million.)

Originally, there was only one denomination… the Catholic Church (the word Catholic meaning “universal”). However, there were five cities that early on were singled out as being important centers of Christianity. They were Jerusalem, Antioch, Alexandria, Constantinople, and of course, Rome. Each developed its own unique traditions and liturgy, but ALL shared a common theology and were in communion with each other and the Bishop of Rome, known as the Pope. However, about 1000 years ago, due to a variety of unfortunate problems, the other four cities, allied with the Byzantine Empire, mutually broke off from Rome, forming the various Eastern Orthodox Churches. Although doctrinally, they are virtually identical to Catholics, they refuse to acknowledge that the pope is more than a “first among equals”. (A couple groups broke of much earlier in the 400s AD also, to form what are known as the Oriental Orthodox Churches).

What has happened is that over time, some portions of each of the various Orthodox groups have decided to reconcile with the Catholic Church and come back into communion with Rome. When they do, they are allowed to keep all of their traditions and much of their independence, although they acknowledge the authority of the Pope. They become truly Catholic, in that anyone from ANY branch of the Catholic Church can participate in the liturgy and ceremonies of any OTHER branch of the Catholic Church. The only two Eastern groups that never fell out of communion with the Catholic Church were the Maronite Catholic Church, and the Italo-Albanian Catholic Church. So… for every branch of the Orthodox Churches that are NOT in communion with Rome, there is a corresponding and virtually identical branch of the Eastern Catholic Church that IS in communion with Rome. Since their customs and liturgies date from before the Council of Trent, they are allowed to remain.

The following liturgies are used by the Eastern Catholic Churches:
  • The Liturgy of St. Basil
  • The Chaldean Mass
  • The Order of the Divine and Holy Liturgy of Our Father Among the Saints Gregory the Theologian (or Liturgy of the Presanctified Gifts)
  • The Liturgy of St. James
  • The Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom
  • The Liturgy of St. Mark
  • The Holy Qorbono
continued…
 
Here is a listing that includes EACH of the twenty-three Catholic Churches in union with the Pope. Do not confuse “churches” with “rites”. A rite is a series of traditions, that includes different customs and liturgies. Several different churches may use the exact same rite. A Church has its own rules and separate line of authority to the Pope. It may also have a figure in charge, like a Metropolitan or a Patriarch (like an Archbishop), since these churches are generally very small and work very hard to preserve their unique traditions. The major rites are the Latin, Alexandrian, Antiochian, Armenian, Chaldean, and Byzantine.

**The Western (Latin) Catholic Church

Latin liturgical tradition**
  1. Ordinary Form (This is the form of the Mass that you will find in virtually every Latin Catholic Church almost every day of the week. This Mass has existed since the mid-1960s, ever since reforms were made following the Second Vatican Council.)
  2. Extraordinary Form (This is the form of the Mass that was used in virtually every Latin Catholic Church from the Middle Ages until the mid-1960s. It may still be said in Catholic Churches should a priest choose to use it. Some of the differences from the Ordinary Form include the exclusive use of the Latin language (except for the homily), the receipt of Communion exclusively on the tongue and kneeling, the priest facing the same direction as the people (toward the altar and God) so he can lead the people in prayer, no lay participation on the altar, and usually, no responses by lay people.)
  3. Ambrosian Rite (Only permitted in the Archdiocese of Milan)
  4. Mozarabic Rite (Only permitted in the Cathedral of Toledo, Spain and a few surrounding churches of the diocese)
  5. Bragan Rite (Only permitted in the Archdiocese of Braga, Portugal)
  6. Anglican-Use Mass (This form was once only permitted in the extremely rare circumstance in which an Anglican priest converted to Catholicism and brings his entire parish with him. In that event, a parish could continue to use the Anglican liturgy, with corrections to make it conform with Catholic teachings. It was originally meant as a transitional liturgy, and upon the death of the pastor, the church would revert to the Ordinary Form. With the recent provisions announced by the Vatican to allow Anglicans into the Catholic Church and keep their traditions, it seems that the Anglican-Use will now become both far more widespread AND permanent.)
**Rites of Religious Orders **
  1. Dominican Rite
  2. Carthusian Rite
  3. Carmelite Rite
  4. Cisternian Rite
Note: Technically, the forms of the Latin liturgy listed above are NOT different rites, but variations of the SAME rite, although people do tend to commonly use the term somewhat erroneously in this context. The differences between the Latin “rites” are FAR less than those between the Latin liturgy and any of the Eastern Rites.)

The Eastern Catholic Churches

1. Alexandrian liturgical tradition

  1. Coptic Catholic Church (patriarchate): Egypt (1741)
  2. Ethiopian Catholic Church (metropolia): Ethiopia, Eritrea (1846)
    **2. Antiochian (Antiochene or West-Syrian) liturgical tradition
    **1. Maronite Church (patriarchate): Lebanon, Cyprus, Jordan, Israel, Palestine, Egypt, Syria, Argentina, Brazil, United States, Australia, Canada, Mexico (union re-affirmed 1182)
  3. Syriac Catholic Church (patriarchate): Lebanon, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Palestine, Egypt, Sudan, Syria, Turkey, United States and Canada, Venezuela (1781)
  4. Syro-Malankara Catholic Church (major archiepiscopate): India, United States (1930)
    3. Armenian liturgical tradition:
  5. Armenian Catholic Church (patriarchate): Lebanon, Iran, Iraq, Egypt, Syria, Turkey, Jordan, Palestine, Ukraine, France, Greece, Latin America, Argentina, Romania, United States, Canada, Eastern Europe (1742)
    4. Chaldean or East Syrian liturgical tradition:
  6. Chaldean Catholic Church (patriarchate): Iraq, Iran, Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Turkey, United States (1692)
  7. Syro-Malabar Church (major archiepiscopate): India, Middle East, Europe and America.
    5. Byzantine (Constantinopolitan) liturgical tradition:
  8. Albanian Greek Catholic Church (apostolic administration): Albania (1628)
  9. Belarusian Greek Catholic Church (no established hierarchy at present): Belarus (1596)
  10. Bulgarian Greek Catholic Church (apostolic exarchate): Bulgaria (1861)
  11. Byzantine Church of the Eparchy of Križevci (an eparchy and an apostolic exarchate): Croatia, Serbia and Montenegro (1611)
  12. Greek Byzantine Catholic Church (two apostolic exarchates): Greece, Turkey (1829)
  13. Hungarian Greek Catholic Church (an eparchy and an apostolic exarchate): Hungary (1646)
  14. Italo-Albanian Catholic Church (two eparchies and a territorial abbacy): Italy (Never separated)
  15. Macedonian Greek Catholic Church (an apostolic exarchate): Republic of Macedonia (1918)
  16. Melkite Greek Catholic Church (patriarchate): Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Israel, Jerusalem, Brazil, United States, Canada, Mexico, Iraq, Egypt and Sudan, Kuwait, Australia, Venezuela, Argentina (1726)
  17. Romanian Church United with Rome, Greek-Catholic (major archiepiscopate): Romania, United States (1697)
  18. Russian Catholic Church: (two apostolic exarchates, at present with no published hierarchs): Russia, China (1905); currently about 20 parishes and communities scattered around the world, including five in Russia itself, answering to bishops of other jurisdictions
  19. Ruthenian Catholic Church (a sui juris metropolia, an eparchy, and an apostolic exarchate): United States, Ukraine, Czech Republic (1646)
  20. Slovak Greek Catholic Church (metropolia): Slovak Republic, Canada (1646)
  21. Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church (major archiepiscopate): Ukraine, Poland, United States, Canada, Great Britain, Australia, Germany and Scandinavia, France, Brazil, Argentina (1595)
 
Here is a listing that includes EACH of the twenty-three Catholic Churches in union with the Pope. Do not confuse “churches” with “rites”. A rite is a series of traditions, that includes different customs and liturgies. Several different churches may use the exact same rite. A Church has its own rules and separate line of authority to the Pope. It may also have a figure in charge, like a Metropolitan or a Patriarch (like an Archbishop), since these churches are generally very small and work very hard to preserve their unique traditions. The major rites are the Latin, Alexandrian, Antiochian, Armenian, Chaldean, and Byzantine.

**The Western (Latin) Catholic Church

Latin liturgical tradition**
  1. Ordinary Form (This is the form of the Mass that you will find in virtually every Latin Catholic Church almost every day of the week. This Mass has existed since the mid-1960s, ever since reforms were made following the Second Vatican Council.)
  2. Extraordinary Form (This is the form of the Mass that was used in virtually every Latin Catholic Church from the Middle Ages until the mid-1960s. It may still be said in Catholic Churches should a priest choose to use it. Some of the differences from the Ordinary Form include the exclusive use of the Latin language (except for the homily), the receipt of Communion exclusively on the tongue and kneeling, the priest facing the same direction as the people (toward the altar and God) so he can lead the people in prayer, no lay participation on the altar, and usually, no responses by lay people.)
  3. Ambrosian Rite (Only permitted in the Archdiocese of Milan)
  4. Mozarabic Rite (Only permitted in the Cathedral of Toledo, Spain and a few surrounding churches of the diocese)
  5. Bragan Rite (Only permitted in the Archdiocese of Braga, Portugal)
  6. Anglican-Use Mass (This form was once only permitted in the extremely rare circumstance in which an Anglican priest converted to Catholicism and brings his entire parish with him. In that event, a parish could continue to use the Anglican liturgy, with corrections to make it conform with Catholic teachings. It was originally meant as a transitional liturgy, and upon the death of the pastor, the church would revert to the Ordinary Form. With the recent provisions announced by the Vatican to allow Anglicans into the Catholic Church and keep their traditions, it seems that the Anglican-Use will now become both far more widespread AND permanent.)
**Rites of Religious Orders **
  1. Dominican Rite
  2. Carthusian Rite
  3. Carmelite Rite
  4. Cisternian Rite
    snip
Awesome explanation. I think I’ll have to read it a couple of times, but it summarizes things nicely. Thanks for that.
 
Hi all,

I was reading a website that said that there are over 250 different denominations within the Catholic Church. Is this true? If so, why? If not, where do people get this misconception?
False. Denominations have different doctrines and beliefs. All of the Catholic Churches and Rites have the same Teachings as handed down by the Apostles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top