Are there different levels to purgatory?

  • Thread starter Thread starter randirhoades
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

randirhoades

Guest
Or do we suffer from the same purification? Does it depend on your sins? I don’t know if I even asked this question correctly. Anyway, anyone know? Thank you for your responses in advance.

Love ya’ll lots,
Sheila is my real name and many blessings from our Loving God to every single person on earth.
 
Although I don’t know, I believe so. I believe there are levels for heaven, purgatory, and hell.
Different level of virtues and sanctity put people on different positions in heaven. Different sins require different levels of purification. And different degree of evil suffers different levels of hell. Right or wrong, this is purely my own guess.
 
Look at purgatory as a process of purging the soul from imperfections still in place after death.

Purgatory will be a learning process as well as a growing process in becoming closer to perfection, where you will be able to receive the beatific vision of Almighty God.

Don’t look at it as a place of punishment, which only serves despair instead of hope, but as a place of consequence for the imperfections we have on our soul as the result of our resistance to letting go of things in our life, which prevented us from being perfected enough to go directly
to heaven.

Anyway, purgatory is a state in which our soul will be in, according to those imperfections, so yes, there will be levels.

BTW, I just found this, which was Pope John Paul II’s explanation of Heaven, Hell and Purgatory.

ewtn.com/library/papaldoc/jp2heavn.htm

Jim
 
I already did some purgation, Dark Night style. :heaven:

If that’s any indicator, I can assure you it is a 100% unique experience for each of us. 👍

It was like one huge “horror movie” scene custom made for me alone. Not that it was always scary, but there were times it was. “Trust” was probably the biggest advice I could give to a soul in my predicament. Just know that God is, and that He has you in His loving hands. :gopray:

The hardest part was the effects of my behavior on other people, and becoming a social leper. That seems to be a common effect among others who do Dark Night and psychosis at the same time. 😛

All that said, I don’t think there are “levels” per se in that you might be at level 4, then move up to level 3, or whatever, as you are cleansed. In my purgation, things went from serene to intense and back, routinely. My moods were all over the place. But it wasn’t like I did one thing and then went to the next harder one or anything. I don’t think “severity” of sin even is a measurable quantity, except for the “nature” of the sin. Mortal, venial, it’s all part of our psyche and the Holy Spirit has some pretty amazing ways of taking a soul through a set of experiences that reverse and heal those damages. And being fixed by God is better than never being broken in the first place. :egyptian:

Alan
 
Common sense suggests that a horrible sinner who has a last-minute repentance, and a devout Christian who has only a few minor sins to atone for, will experience Purgatory very differently.

There are private revelations which indicate the same. See this page for example. Look for the section titled “From the manuscript of Sister M. de L.C.”
 
Common sense suggests that a horrible sinner who has a last-minute repentance, and a devout Christian who has only a few minor sins to atone for, will experience Purgatory very differently.

There are private revelations which indicate the same. See this page for example. Look for the section titled “From the manuscript of Sister M. de L.C.”
I don’t see that. We have no idea of the state of heart anybody is in, no matter what we saw on the outside that they did.

They will have entirely different purgatory, for sure. But “level” and is it going to be easier for the devout Christian? That would be like saying the Passion was easy for Jesus; yes it was but not because He got time off for good behavior, it was because He was spiritually sound and was therefore in the kingdom not of this world – that in fact He calls us all to be in.

I read part of Sister M. de L.C. from your link, and it really doesn’t do much for me. She was grouping people into categories, etc. It’s nice from an academic standpoint, I guess, to think that we can classify and categorize sinners into different buckets for different treatment. Maybe this is what she envisioned; that’s fine for her ways of thinking. But still it’s a very sterile, heirarchal, viewpoint and I think it is overly simplistic. I think in reality each sinner is an entirely different case than any other, and I don’t think there is a rating system that tells them like a progress bar how much percent purged they are; purging is non-linear. Is there any evidence Sister M. de L.C. ever went through a Dark Night experience herself, because right offhand it doesn’t really sound like it?

Alan
 
Look at purgatory as a process of purging the soul from imperfections still in place after death.

Purgatory will be a learning process as well as a growing process in becoming closer to perfection, where you will be able to receive the beatific vision of Almighty God.

Don’t look at it as a place of punishment, which only serves despair instead of hope, but as a place of consequence for the imperfections we have on our soul as the result of our resistance to letting go of things in our life, which prevented us from being perfected enough to go directly
to heaven.

Anyway, purgatory is a state in which our soul will be in, according to those imperfections, so yes, there will be levels.

BTW, I just found this, which was Pope John Paul II’s explanation of Heaven, Hell and Purgatory.

ewtn.com/library/papaldoc/jp2heavn.htm

Jim
I like your take on it, which I share. There’s healing and purification, each day that passes is one day closer to God. The Damocles’ sword of Hell is forever gone, no despair or misery is possible.
Common sense suggests that a horrible sinner who has a last-minute repentance, and a devout Christian who has only a few minor sins to atone for, will experience Purgatory very differently.

There are private revelations which indicate the same. See this page for example. Look for the section titled “From the manuscript of Sister M. de L.C.”
I agree with you. Same can be said of Heaven: there are many houses (degrees of joy, glory, union with God) in Heaven, my hunch is that Mother Theresa’s will be huge compared to that of a last-minute, death-bed penitent. God’s justice would never have it any other way.
 
I agree with you. Same can be said of Heaven: there are many houses (degrees of joy, glory, union with God) in Heaven, my hunch is that Mother Theresa’s will be huge compared to that of a last-minute, death-bed penitent. God’s justice would never have it any other way.
It is human justice that would not have it any other way.

[BIBLEDRB]matt 20:1-16[/BIBLEDRB]

It’s certainly more complicated than “last shall be first” but Jesus uses this simplified model for simple people, to make a point that we do not all line up in order of merit, or of time of service, and treating preferentially based on that ranking.

And do you think the deathbed convert will create less rejoicing in heaven? Another truth that is counter-intuitive to the worldly mind:

[BIBLEDRB]luke 15:7[/BIBLEDRB]

Alan
 
One reads that there are different portions of purgatory, each type of sin has a particular place and type of punishment. This is a matter of Justice. Hell is similar. Each kind of expiatory punishment fits the crime. Sinners of like type, are punished in the same vicinity.

But on the larger general scale it’s said there are three levels. The lowest is nearest to Hell, the middle, the punishments are lesser, the highest, the only punishment is longing for God.

This of course is not noting exceptional cases, where the purgatorial souls visit here.

‘Is this, then, Hell, my brother?’

St. Lidwina of Schiedam

‘No, sister, but this part of Purgatory is bordering upon Hell.’

The Angel Guardian of St. Lidwina of Shiedam

‘Liars are confined in a place in the vicinity of Hell, and their sufferings are exceedingly great. Molten lead is poured into their mouths; I see them burn, and at the same time tremble with cold.’

St. Mary Magdalen de Pazzi

‘The greatest punishment of purgatory is in the first level above the darkness where you saw the aforesaid soul being purged. The demons can touch it there; poisonous vermin and wild beasts are symbolically present there. There is heat and cold, darkness and confusion, all coming from the punishment of hell. Some souls are punished less there, some more, according as sins were atoned for or not while the soul remained in the body.’

An Angel, to St. Bridget of Sweden

‘Tell me, Lord, what was your design in discovering to me those terrible prisons, of which I knew so little, and comprehended still less? Ah! I now see; you wished to give me the knowledge of your infinite sanctity, and to make me detest more and more the least stain of sin, which is so abominable in your eyes.’

St. Mary Magdalen de Pazzi

‘Do not think any sin to be light or negligible! Anything you neglect I will remind you of and judge. No sin of yours will come under my judgment if it has been expiated in this life through your penance. Those sins for which penance has not been made will be purged either in purgatory or by means of some secret judgment of mine, if satisfaction has not yet been made for them here on earth.’

The Lord, ‘The Revelations of St. Bridget of Sweden’

Rev. F.X. Schouppe, S.J.'s book on Purgatory is a great read, and goes into further detail about these matters.
 
Or do we suffer from the same purification? Does it depend on your sins? I don’t know if I even asked this question correctly. Anyway, anyone know? Thank you for your responses in advance.

Love ya’ll lots,
Sheila is my real name and many blessings from our Loving God to every single person on earth.
No, we will not all experience the purging of our imperfections in the same state of purgatory.

This reality of purgatory, even though the actual word does not exist in Scripture, is described, and in 1 Corinthians 3, the Latinate word purgatory means *a purgation or burning by fire. *

Here is an example from the Bible:

1 Corinthians 3:12-15

12 Now if any one builds on the foundation with gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay, straw-- 13 each man’s work will become manifest; for the Day will disclose it, because it will be revealed with fire, and the fire will test what sort of work each one has done. 14 If the work which any man has built on the foundation survives, he will receive a reward. 15 If any man’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss, though he himself will be saved, but only as through fire.

The works are what Christians have done, some referred to as gold, silver, etc - those are the “good” works that will not be consumed by fire, for they are pure, (good works). The other works described as wood, hay, straw - those are the “sinful” works, the ones that will be consumed and purged by fire. This “place” is typically referred to as “purgatory” - and it is more a “state” than an actual place, just as the fire is not a literal fire, but the state of being purged of impurities than those who are saved (going to heaven) must be cleansed of before entering heaven. God has declared that nothing unclean (impure; sinful) can enter heaven, and how many of us die in a state of sinlessness? So, because some people have more imperfections than others, they may spend more “time” per se being purified (purged).

Those people who are in grave sin, and bound for hell, do not get to be purged. Nothing can cleanse them for they have turned their backs on the saving grace of God (Jesus).

blessings,

CEM
 
Or do we suffer from the same purification? Does it depend on your sins? I don’t know if I even asked this question correctly. Anyway, anyone know? Thank you for your responses in advance.

Love ya’ll lots,
Sheila is my real name and many blessings from our Loving God to every single person on earth.
Probably not physical levels as we understand them but varing degrees of purification needed depending on the sins that a person has that need to be expiated before admision into heaven.
 
Alan, that parable doesn’t say that everyone in Heaven will have the same level of glory or proximity with God, don’t you think that those who died martyrs are gonna shine in a special way in Heaven? What the parable does say, I think, is that death-bed penitents will go to Heaven just like the person who’s been a faithful, God-fearing, God-loving Catholic for eight decades whereas our last-minute penitent never said no to any enticing mortal sin. With all due respect, saying these two will have the exact same level of joy, closeness with and reward from God is a parody of justice. The parable of the talents supports the idea of different retribution for everyone. What I will grant you, though, is that we don’t know people’s hearts, childhoods, up-bringings, mental illnesses, psychological wounds etc. but God knows, so he is perfectly able to know to what extent someone did respond to him in relation to how much they could respond to him.
 
Alan, that parable doesn’t say that everyone in Heaven will have the same level of glory or proximity with God, don’t you think that those who died martyrs are gonna shine in a special way in Heaven?
I don’t know about heaven after death, I only know about the kingdom here and now. Rank means nothing in the kingdom. I feel equally at ease with a beggar in the streets, as with the bishop. I don’t feel superior or inferior to either one. They both have their specialties, their niche, and their assets. They are different members of the Body of Christ, and I choose not to say one is greater than the other.

[BIBLEDRB]1 Cor 12[/BIBLEDRB]
What the parable does say, I think, is that death-bed penitents will go to Heaven just like the person who’s been a faithful, God-fearing, God-loving Catholic for eight decades whereas our last-minute penitent never said no to any enticing mortal sin. With all due respect, saying these two will have the exact same level of joy, closeness with and reward from God is a parody of justice.
It is not a parody of justice. The way you are describing it, like some sort of point system, is what we all are subject to as children our PERMANENT RECORD, well check this out; when God forgives somebody they are no longer the sinner they were. Saints and sinners are equalized in this way, through the mercy of Christ, at the sincere repentance and desire.

You probably can’t go along with the idea because you are caught up in the worldly system that tells us Who’s Holy and Who’s Not. As I’ve heard, Vatican II reaffirmed that holiness was for everybody, not just the religious.

And hey let’s make sure that St. Paul has a lower place because of all that evil he did as Saul. 😉
The parable of the talents supports the idea of different retribution for everyone. What I will grant you, though, is that we don’t know people’s hearts, childhoods, up-bringings, mental illnesses, psychological wounds etc. but God knows, so he is perfectly able to know to what extent someone did respond to him in relation to how much they could respond to him.
Why do you even talk of “retribution” when the topic is purgatory? Purgation has nothing to do with judgment. By the time you get there, you no longer are candidates for hell. It is a cleansing of the garments to make us ready for dinner. We all get stripped of our worldly garments, including our name tags and job description, and are prepared for the banquet. Those who cling to the old garments of judgment and comparing one Christian to another, might not be admitted to the banquet. That’s why purgatory can be so hard; it has to break very strongly programmed patterns of errant thought. People go crazy during the process, but under the trustworthy guidance of the Divine Therapist aka the Holy Spirit, they will be healed.

Besides, I bet if you ask any saint if they want a “higher” or “lower” place than some deathbed convert, I’d bet I know what the answer would be.

Alan
 
Why do you even talk of “retribution” when the topic is purgatory? Purgation has nothing to do with judgment. By the time you get there, you no longer are candidates for hell. It is a cleansing of the garments to make us ready for dinner. We all get stripped of our worldly garments, including our name tags and job description, and are prepared for the banquet. Those who cling to the old garments of judgment and comparing one Christian to another, might not be admitted to the banquet. That’s why purgatory can be so hard; it has to break very strongly programmed patterns of errant thought. People go crazy during the process, but under the trustworthy guidance of the Divine Therapist aka the Holy Spirit, they will be healed.

Alan
Retribution is the dispensing of either reward or punishment, I thought the topic had slightly veered off from levels of Purgatory to levels of Heaven. Perhaps I’m a judgemental son of a gun. Yet I know that God is the ultimate judge, is the only qualified judge.
 
Retribution is the dispensing of either reward or punishment, I thought the topic had slightly veered off from levels of Purgatory to levels of Heaven. Perhaps I’m a judgemental son of a gun. Yet I know that God is the ultimate judge, is the only qualified judge.
OK yes I think it did kind of go that way. I see why you were saying it. 👍

Alan
 
Alan, that parable doesn’t say that everyone in Heaven will have the same level of glory or proximity with God, don’t you think that those who died martyrs are gonna shine in a special way in Heaven? What the parable does say, I think, is that death-bed penitents will go to Heaven just like the person who’s been a faithful, God-fearing, God-loving Catholic for eight decades whereas our last-minute penitent never said no to any enticing mortal sin. With all due respect, saying these two will have the exact same level of joy, closeness with and reward from God is a parody of justice. The parable of the talents supports the idea of different retribution for everyone. What I will grant you, though, is that we don’t know people’s hearts, childhoods, up-bringings, mental illnesses, psychological wounds etc. but God knows, so he is perfectly able to know to what extent someone did respond to him in relation to how much they could respond to him.
🙂

‘He therefore that shall break one of these least commandments, and shall so teach men, shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven. But he that shall do and teach, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.’

Matthew 5:20

‘The greater the charity of the saints, in their heavenly home, the more they intercede for those who are still on their journey and the more they can help them by their prayers; the more they are united with God, the more effective those prayers are. This is in accordance with divine order, which makes higher things react upon lower things, like the brightnees of the sun filling the atmosphere.’

St. Thomas Aquinas

‘I would willingly endure alone all the sufferings of this world to be raised a degree higher in Heaven and to possess the smallest increase of the knowledge of God’s greatness.’

St. Teresa of Jesus

‘It is related of Blessed Stephanie of Soncino, a Dominican nun, that she was one day carried in spirit to Heaven to see the happiness of the saints. She saw their souls mingling with the choirs of angels according to each one’s degree of merit, and noticed among the Seraphim several persons she had known before their deaths. Having asked why these souls were raised to such a high degree of glory, she was told it was because of the conformity and perfect union of their will with God’s while they lived on earth. Now, if this conformity to the will of God raises souls to the highest degree of glory in heaven among the Seraphim, it must be concluded that it raises them on earth to the highest degree of grace and on it is founded the highest perfection man can attain.’

The Secret of Peace & Happiness, Fr. Jean Baptiste Saint-Jure, S.J.

‘The majority of souls appear before the Judgment empty-handed. They did nothing good for eternity.’

Ven. Mary of Agreda

'The Holy Gospel says of the elect: “In my Father’s house there are many mansions.” Now, if the righteous in that eternal blessedness enjoyed its good things in the same way, then there would be reason to believe that there is but one mansion, not many. However, there are many mansions in which the elect will be distributed, according to their worthiness, that they might together rejoice and be glad.

The fact that all of the chosen who are distributed among the different mansions receive only one coin shows that there is but one blessedness, enjoyed by all of those who are saved; the amount returned to each of the elect, however, differs according to the various works of virtue that they performed.

As for sinners, the Lord, referring to the Day of Judgment, says: “I will say to the reapers, gather ye together first the tares, and bind them in bundles to burn them.” The reapers, that is, the Angels, bind up those sinners who have committed the same sins, so that they can be sent to Hell together, and thus the proud are tortured together with the proud, the immoral with the immoral, the greedy with the greedy, liars with those who lie, murderers together with murderers, and unbelievers together with unbelievers. All of these, joined together according to their types of sins, will burn in the various places of torture into which the Angels throw them.’

Pope St. Gregory the Great

'There are various degrees of beatitude in heaven corresponding to the various degrees of merit.** This is a dogma of faith, defined by the Council of Florence** (Denz., n. 693 — old, n. 588). The Bible teaches this truth in very many passages (e.g., wherever it speaks of eternal happiness as a reward), and the Fathers defend it against the heretical attacks of Jovinian. It is true that, according to Matthew 20:1-16, each labourer receives a penny; but by this comparison Christ merely teaches that, although the Gospel was preached to the Jews first, yet in the Kingdom of Heaven there is no distinction between Jew and Gentile, and that no one will receive a greater reward merely because of being a son of Judah. The various degrees of beatitude are not limited to the accidental blessings, but they are found first and foremost** in the beatific vision itself**. For, as we have already pointed out, the vision, too, admits of degrees.

The Catholic Encyclopedia [see further for more information]

'St. Teresa revealed to one of her nuns, appearing to her after her death, that God loves a soul that, as a spouse, gives itself entirely to him, more than a thousand tepid and imperfect ones. From these generous souls, given entirely to God, is the choir of Seraphim completed.

The Lord himself says that he loves a soul that attends to its perfection, so much that he seems not to love any other. “One is My dove, My perfect one is but one.”’ [Cant. 6,8.]

St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori

How precious every moment of life is!
 
Shin,

That is a great deal of information; I’m impressed with what you have brought to bear on the discussion. I’m not particular impressed by some of the things they say. When you get down to it, nobody has died, gone to purgatory, and then came back to life to tell us about it. So it will always remain a matter of speculation.

To the degree that purgatory after we die is the same as “purgative contemplation” during the Dark Night, I saw nothing that reminded me of some of these things they are talking about. For me it was an interactive full-body sort of learning and knowing; it wasn’t just intellectual. Purgatory is a state of being, not a place. I have my ideas on why the saints might have seen the types of things they did, not the least of which is they saw things that were compatible with their beliefs; I saw the crucifix change into a serpent so that doesn’t add much to the mix. 😛

That said, I will offer a bit of point/counterpoint to the quotes you took the time to assemble. Like I said it’s a matter of speculation so my comments are just personal reactions, not intended to be definitive answers on the matter. 😉
🙂
‘He therefore that shall break one of these least commandments, and shall so teach men, shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven. But he that shall do and teach, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.’

Matthew 5:20
Let’s look at this with a little more context Matt 5:17-20
“Do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. I have come not to abolish but to fulfill. Amen, I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest letter or the smallest part of a letter will pass from the law, until all things have taken place. Therefore, whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do so will be called least in the kingdom of heaven. But whoever obeys and teaches these commandments will be called greatest in the kingdom of heaven. I tell you, unless your righteousness surpasses that of the scribes and Pharisees, you will not enter into the kingdom of heaven.

To me this sounds like a warning. If a person thinks they will be justified when they get to heaven because the “earned it” then they are bound to follow every part of the law, even the tiniest parts because you have to be (impossibly) perfect in order to achieve this grace. I’d say that Jesus and Mary are in this category, but others are only there through Jesus’s mercy, at having wiped away sins. The scribes and the Pharisees are regarded as righteous, having followed all of the law, right? To the degree that it’s humanly possible? So we have to be better than them … perfect in fact if we think we’re going to “good behave” ourselves into heaven.

So Jesus isn’t saying that a righteous person won’t get into heaven, just that they’d have to be absolutely perfect – something we humans have a hard time being.

Also consider Jesus came for sinners, not the righteous. Also He said there will be more rejoicing in heaven over a repentant sinner than 100 righteous, not in need of repentance. Does it really follow that their rejoicing will be greater, but then they will put that person at the bottom of the heap, underneath the one they rejoiced less over?
St. Thomas Aquinas
Very interesting quote about the communion of saints.
‘I would willingly endure alone all the sufferings of this world to be raised a degree higher in Heaven and to possess the smallest increase of the knowledge of God’s greatness.’
St. Teresa of Jesus
Perhaps the saint would be comforted by Matt 13:11-12
He said to them in reply, “Because knowledge of the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven has been granted to you, but to them it has not been granted. To anyone who has, more will be given and he will grow rich; from anyone who has not, even what he has will be taken away.
‘It is related of Blessed Stephanie of Soncino, a Dominican nun, that she was one day carried in spirit to Heaven to see the happiness of the saints. She saw their souls mingling with the choirs of angels according to each one’s degree of merit, and noticed among the Seraphim several persons she had known before their deaths. Having asked why these souls were raised to such a high degree of glory, she was told it was because of the conformity and perfect union of their will with God’s while they lived on earth. Now, if this conformity to the will of God raises souls to the highest degree of glory in heaven among the Seraphim, it must be concluded that it raises them on earth to the highest degree of grace and on it is founded the highest perfection man can attain.’
The Secret of Peace & Happiness, Fr. Jean Baptiste Saint-Jure, S.J.
This one interests me because of the “conformity of the will” part. I don’t see anything here about how righteous a person lived or whether they were deathbed convert, just conformance of the will. Surrender. Being the one who serves.
‘The majority of souls appear before the Judgment empty-handed. They did nothing good for eternity.’
Ven. Mary of Agreda
Amen, sister!

(continued in next post)
 
(continued from last post)
'The Holy Gospel says of the elect: “In my Father’s house there are many mansions.” Now, if the righteous in that eternal blessedness enjoyed its good things in the same way, then there would be reason to believe that there is but one mansion, not many. However, there are many mansions in which the elect will be distributed, according to their worthiness, that they might together rejoice and be glad.
The fact that all of the chosen who are distributed among the different mansions receive only one coin shows that there is but one blessedness, enjoyed by all of those who are saved; the amount returned to each of the elect, however, differs according to the various works of virtue that they performed.
As for sinners, the Lord, referring to the Day of Judgment, says: “I will say to the reapers, gather ye together first the tares, and bind them in bundles to burn them.” The reapers, that is, the Angels, bind up those sinners who have committed the same sins, so that they can be sent to Hell together, and thus the proud are tortured together with the proud, the immoral with the immoral, the greedy with the greedy, liars with those who lie, murderers together with murderers, and unbelievers together with unbelievers. All of these, joined together according to their types of sins, will burn in the various places of torture into which the Angels throw them.’
Pope St. Gregory the Great
It’s only natural for the pope to see heaven as a merit system with an organizational heirarchy, because he, among all other people on earth, got to “enjoy” that position of authority.

Funny thing though if you notice that among the righteous we are making distinctions about how they work, but the sinners they all get lumped together. So I guess if they get less than 70%, they get an F and they all swim in the same blood. Above and F we have credentials. I’m sorry but I’d have to read more of this pope before I felt like I could accept his visions on this issue.
'There are various degrees of beatitude in heaven corresponding to the various degrees of merit.** This is a dogma of faith, defined by the Council of Florence** (Denz., n. 693 — old, n. 588). The Bible teaches this truth in very many passages (e.g., wherever it speaks of eternal happiness as a reward), and the Fathers defend it against the heretical attacks of Jovinian. It is true that, according to Matthew 20:1-16, each labourer receives a penny; but by this comparison Christ merely teaches that, although the Gospel was preached to the Jews first, yet in the Kingdom of Heaven there is no distinction between Jew and Gentile, and that no one will receive a greater reward merely because of being a son of Judah. The various degrees of beatitude are not limited to the accidental blessings, but they are found first and foremost** in the beatific vision itself**. For, as we have already pointed out, the vision, too, admits of degrees.
The Catholic Encyclopedia [see further for more information]
This is the one I need the biggest block of salt to take with it, but it defines it as dogma. And while the parable of the laborers may indeed speak to the Jews v. Christians, I cannot see how it fails to speak of rewards for heavenly labor.
'St. Teresa revealed to one of her nuns, appearing to her after her death, that God loves a soul that, as a spouse, gives itself entirely to him, more than a thousand tepid and imperfect ones. From these generous souls, given entirely to God, is the choir of Seraphim completed.
The Lord himself says that he loves a soul that attends to its perfection, so much that he seems not to love any other. “One is My dove, My perfect one is but one.”’ [Cant. 6,8.]
St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori
How precious every moment of life is!
These are wonderful quotes. Thank you!

Alan
 
You’re welcome, and thank you Alan. Your reply has brought back some fond memories of some favorite books.

Here, further…

'There was in Northumberland a man named Drithelm, who, with his family, led a most Christian life. He fell sick, and his malady increasing day by day, he was soon reduced to extremity, and died, to the great desolation and grief of his wife and children. The latter passed the night in tears by the remains, but the following day, before his interment, they saw him suddenly return to life, arise, and place himself in a sitting posture. At this sight they were seized with such fear that they all took to flight, with the exception of the wife, who, trembling, remained alone with her risen husband. He reassured her immediately:

"Fear not," he said; **“it is God who restores to me my life; He wishes to show in my person a man raised from the dead. I have yet long to live upon earth, but my new life will be very different from the one I led heretofore.” **

Then he arose full of health, went straight to the chapel or church of the place, and there remained long in prayer. He returned home only to take leave of those who had been dear to him upon earth, to whom he declared that he would live only to prepare himself for death, and advised them to do likewise. Then, having divided his property into three parts, he gave one to his children, another to his wife, and reserved the third part to give in alms. When he had distributed all to the poor, and had reduced himself to extreme indigence, he went and knocked at the door of a monastery, and begged the Abbot to receive him as a penitent Religious, who would be a servant to all the others.

The Abbot gave him a retired cell, which he occupied for the rest of his life. Three exercises divided his time prayer, the hardest labour, and extraordinary penances. Ihe most rigorous fasts he accounted as nothing. In winter he was seen to plunge himself into frozen water, and remain therefor hours and hours in prayer, whilst he recited the whole Psalter of David.

The mortified life of Drithelm, his downcast eyes, even his features, indicated a soul struck with fear of the judgments of God. He kept a perpetual silence, but on being pressed to relate, for the edification of others, what God had manifested to him after his death, he thus described his vision:

"On leaving my body, I was received by a benevolent person, who took me under his guidance. His face was brilliant, and he appeared surrounded with light. He arrived at a large deep valley of immense extent, all fire on one side, all ice and snow on the other; on the one hand braziers and caldrons of flame, on the other the most intense cold and the blast of a glacial wind.

"This mysterious valley was filled with innumerable souls, which, tossed as by a furious tempest, threw them selves from one side to the other. When they could no longer endure the violence of the fire, they sought relief amidst the ice and snow; but finding only a new torture, they cast themselves again into the midst of the flames.

“I contemplated in a stupor these continual vicissitudes of horrible torments, and as far as my sight could extend, I saw nothing but a multitude of souls which suffered with out ever having repose. Their very aspect inspired me with fear. I thought at first that I saw Hell; but my guide, who walked before me, turned to me and said, No; this is not, as you think, the Hell of the reprobate. Do you know, he continued, what place this is? No, I answered. Know, he resumed, that this valley, where you see so much fire and so much ice, is the place where the souls of those are punished who, during life, have neglected to confess their sins, and who have deferred their conversion to the end. Thanks to a special mercy of God, they have had the happiness of sincerely repenting before death, of confessing and detesting their sins. This is why they are not damned, and on the great day of judgment will enter into the Kingdom of Heaven. Several of them will obtain their deliverance before that time, by the merits of prayers, alms, and fasts, offered in their favour by the living, and especially in virtue of the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass offered for their relief.”

Such was the recital of Drithelm. When asked why he so rudely treated his body, why he plunged himself into frozen water, he replied that he had seen other torments, and cold of another kind.

If his brethren expressed astonishment that he could endure these extraordinary austerities, “I have seen,” said he, “penances still more astonishing.” To the day when it pleased God to call him to Himself, he ceased not to afflict his body, and although broken down with age, he would accept no alleviation.

This event produced a deep sensation in England; a great number of sinners, touched by the words of Drithelm, and struck by the austerity of his life, became sincerely converted.

This fact, adds Bellarmine, appears to me of incontestable truth, since, besides being conformable to the words of Holy Scripture, Let him pass from the snow waters to excessive heat, [Job xxiv:19]

Venerable Bede relates it as a recent and well-known event. More than this, it was followed by the conversion of a great number of sinners, the sign of the work of God, who is accustomed to work prodigies in order to produce fruit in souls.

THE learned and pious Cardinal then proceeds to relate the history of St. Christine the Admirable, who lived in Belgium at the close of the twelfth century, and whose body is preserved to-day in St. Trond, in the church of the Redemptorist Fathers.

Rev. F.X. Schouppe, S.J.'s book on Purgatory and priceless reading, I encourage all to do so.]
 
While purgatory is sometimes spoken of as a state of expiatory punishment, it is too a place for this. When we see extraordinary incidents like souls experiencing purgatory outside of the place, and on this earth – perhaps for the sake of provoking devotion to help the holy souls, then we might say the soul is in the state of purgatory but not the general place.

Interestingly, more than one saint has spoken about how the lowest purgatory has the particular punishment of fire and ice.

This is a bit digressing forgive me I pray.

Today there’s a strong emphasis on egalitarianism. For one reason this is very much emphasized because of political reasons… these political reasons have roots in such historical tragedies as the French Revolution, Masonry, Communism… and their ultimate, evil sources… It’s near impossible to escape the influence of these.

We must certainly in some respects treat and view people the same way, 🙂 but in other respects we must not under pain of sin.

Hard to remember in most of society today!

For example, it would be sinfully irreverent to treat our children with the same respect as our spouse or another adult – it’s a sin for children to treat their parents disobediently or irreverently, their is the special courtesy and respect due priests, and so too, judges in court… and unfamiliar to many, royalty… The office of fatherhood and the office of motherhood each have special duties, and so special respect shown them due to these, special courtesies due these offices, as well as special courtesies due to simply being an adult man or woman…

And so too in Heaven…

In Heaven everyone is different, yet united… Everyone is higher or lower, in a beautiful hierarchy, like an ocean of stars, each shining with a different intensity, different virtues, all surrounding the brightest light, the source of all. All surrounding innumerably the bright source of God.

The light of knowledge and love flows from God through the highest down to the lowest, communicated through each… There is a thread on the Angels in this sub-forum that gives an idea of this…

Communism and its derivatives politically, emphasize envy and warfare between men and women, rich and poor, child and adult, etc. and try to reduce everything to a very base level. If someone is more wealthy than someone else – envy, tear down, hate. If someone is poor – a victim, raise the person up higher, etc.

But in Heaven no one envies anyone who has more of anything – more good, more love, more authority, more virtue than another. Everyone in fact, rejoices in others who have more of God’s gifts, and are grateful for it.

I’m putting this poorly, but isn’t it interesting?

And so too on earth, there is the virtue of charity and then the sin of envy which from some notes I have, I read this about:

ENVY

Sorrow at another’s well-being, because of the belief that one’s own excellence is in consequence made less. The special malice of this comes from its opposition to the supreme virtue of charity.

The law of charity requires us to rejoice rather than be distressed at the good of our neighbor.

Envy is in direct contradiction to the spirit of solidarity which should characterize the human race, and especially Christians.

The envious torture themselves without cause. The sin is as a norm mortal, although lessened as is the norm, by small matter, and lack of deliberation, and so often venial. Envy is at its most evil when it sorrows due to another’s spiritual good. It is then said to be a sin against the Holy Ghost.

Capital sin because of the other vices it begets.

Regret at another’s success is not always envy or jealousy, the motive must be scrutinized. Sorrow at another’s rise because it is truly undeserved, or it will cause true injury to oneself or others, is, provided it is not to excess, rational. Then too, sorrow at another’s happy condition may be due to grief one has not imitated the other – if the subject matter is praiseworthy, this is not jealousy, but laudible desire to be emulous.

DAUGHTERS: hatred, detraction, rejoicing over the misfortunes of one’s fellow, whispering.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top