L
LIT56RD
Guest
Thanks for the charity and Catholic understanding. It is greatly appreciated.This sounds like one of them anti-catholic whoppers in a new rapping:ehh:
Thanks for the charity and Catholic understanding. It is greatly appreciated.This sounds like one of them anti-catholic whoppers in a new rapping:ehh:
It seems your wounds from the past have blinded you from being able to see that Jesus identifies Himself completely with His Holy Bride, the Church. It is to His church He said:I really don’t have a problem with following God’s directions. I actually look forward to that. What I have a problem with is that the CC tells me what I must believe, act and say in order for me to gain eternal salvation. I believe there is a great separation between God and the CC. They are not synonymous.
You cannot have one without the other,m LIT, which is why you are now here on CAF. When we become members of Christ, we become members of His One Body, the Church. Reconciliation with Him is to be reconciled with the Church, since they are not separate from one another. Jesus is the Head of the Church. It is not a beheaded Church.It was between God and I, not the church and I.Code:It is between God and I, and He and I have had plenty of arguments and discussions. Some have been to my satisfaction and some have shown me that I was wrong in my thinking. Which I then changed.
It is, but he came by it innocently.This sounds like one of them anti-catholic whoppers in a new rapping:ehh:
Christ said to teach what he had taught. Not all the new man made up rules that the church does now. Christ did not say to not eat meat on Friday. He did not say this and this day were holy days of obligation. He did not say this is exactly how you say the mass. All this is done by man and not by God.It seems your wounds from the past have blinded you from being able to see that Jesus identifies Himself completely with His Holy Bride, the Church. It is to His church He said:
Luke 10:16
16 “He who hears you hears me, and he who rejects you rejects me, and he who rejects me rejects him who sent me.”
It is the duty of the Church to tell the people what must be believed and practiced to be saved. This is what Jesus meant when he commissioned them:
Matt 28:17 - 20
18 And Jesus came and said to them, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. 19 Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, 20** teaching them to observe all that I** have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always, to the close of the age.”
Guess I see it as I am rejecting man’s authority over me. Not God’s authority.So it seems that you do have a problem following God’s directions. It is rooted in the false belief you have that Jesus is not One with His Church.
You cannot have one without the other,m LIT, which is why you are now here on CAF. When we become members of Christ, we become members of His One Body, the Church. Reconciliation with Him is to be reconciled with the Church, since they are not separate from one another. Jesus is the Head of the Church. It is not a beheaded Church.
Jesus established a Church that is visible, and authoritative. In rejecting the authority He has placed over us, we reject His plan for us.
Your sarcasm is most welcome.Thanks for the charity and Catholic understanding. It is greatly appreciated.
New ‘man-made’ rules?Christ said to teach what he had taught. Not all the new man made up rules that the church does now. Christ did not say to not eat meat on Friday. He did not say this and this day were holy days of obligation. He did not say this is exactly how you say the mass. All this is done by man and not by God.
Guess I see it as I am rejecting man’s authority over me. Not God’s authority.
Okay, but yours isn’t. Lit is genuinely hurting, and he has come here with legitimate questions that are directly traceable to hurtful comments made to him by Catholics – including Catholic priests – in the past. Most people on this thread (particularly Guanophore) are trying to help Lit get past that.LIT56RD;7965560:
not read the Bible. I was told that once by a parish priest. That we as lay people do not have the ability to read and understand the Bible and that it is best left to those more learned and of more authority in the church. Are we devoid of any common sense that we can not read, and with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, glean some knowledge without someone else telling us EXACTLY what we need to think and do? Didn’t realize I, along with all the other Catholics, were just so stupid.Quarles47;7965553:
LIT56RD;7855981:
Are Catholics really that ignorant and stupid that we can not and should
This sounds like one of them anti-catholic whoppers in a new rapping:ehh:
Thanks for the charity and Catholic understanding. It is greatly appreciated.
Your sarcasm is most welcome.![]()
Godfollower;Okay, but yours isn’t. Lit is genuinely hurting, and he has come here with legitimate questions that are directly traceable to hurtful comments made to him by Catholics – including Catholic priests – in the past. Most people on this thread (particularly Guanophore) are trying to help Lit get past that.
Jumping in to make hurtful comments adds nothing helpful to the conversation, hurts Lit in particular, and demonstrates to all readers generally that there is some truth in the statement “Catholics are mean.”
The way I see it is that anyone within the church hierarchy can say and invoke anything they want and claim it is inspired by the holy spirit. No questions asked just some man or group of men saying this is the way it is. If you disagree, than tough, you are now a sinner.New ‘man-made’ rules?
OK, so Christ also didn’t say (Himself) to worship on Sunday instead of the Sabbath. Christ did not say that we were to use the Bible or what was to be contained in the Bible.
But Christ also gave us the Holy Spirit (who is God) and promised that Spirit would guide us to all truth.
Can you please tell me by what authority you can deem that the Church’s rules are ‘man-made’ and not from the Holy Spirit?
As I said above, The is no validation outside the high ups in the church. To me it is like the fox guarding the hen house. The lay members of the church have NO say in what is done within the church. So the Holy spirit only speaks to and guides those who are in high places in the church.If the Holy Spirit is God (and He is) and if the Holy Spirit is leading us to all Truth (and He is), then how do you figure that the Holy Spirit can’t be behind the rules of the Catholic Church?
Christianity did not lose its force with me. The catholic church lost all credibility when it starts to tell me how to think and act. I have a huge faith in Christians but very little faith in blind following Catholics.When did Christianity lose its force for you? If you accept the Bible (and you seem to), then you accept the Catholic Church at least until AD 380 when the Bible was made canon. (This, BTW, is also 50 years after the death of Constantine). You accept the ability of the Church to clearly identify the canon of Scripture (and note, there is absolutely nothing in Scripture itself which states that these books, and only these, are to be known as Scripture), but you don’t accept its teaching on celibacy, or penance, or abstinence, or the Perpetual Virginity of Mary. . .but these are all teachings which one can trace back to the times of the canon of Scripture or earlier. Even ‘back then’ there was a tradition of celibacy in the priesthood. Even then there were penitential practices of confession and there were (yes, even then) ‘holy days of obligation’ set aside, and there were times of fast and abstinence set by the Church. And Mary was taught as ever-Virgin and we sought the intercession of the saints and martyrs. Yes, even way back then.
**
Why do you ONLY accept the canon of the Bible but nothing else from that time?**
I’m probably showing my abounding ignorance what does “Bible was made canon” mean?When did Christianity lose its force for you? If you accept the Bible (and you seem to), then you accept the Catholic Church at least until AD 380 when the Bible was made canon. (This, BTW, is also 50 years after the death of Constantine). You accept the ability of the Church to clearly identify the canon of Scripture (and note, there is absolutely nothing in Scripture itself which states that these books, and only these, are to be known as Scripture), but you don’t accept its teaching on celibacy, or penance, or abstinence, or the Perpetual Virginity of Mary. . .but these are all teachings which one can trace back to the times of the canon of Scripture or earlier. Even ‘back then’ there was a tradition of celibacy in the priesthood. Even then there were penitential practices of confession and there were (yes, even then) ‘holy days of obligation’ set aside, and there were times of fast and abstinence set by the Church. And Mary was taught as ever-Virgin and we sought the intercession of the saints and martyrs. Yes, even way back then.
**
Why do you ONLY accept the canon of the Bible but nothing else from that time?**
Because it is mostly oral tradition that has been handed down. Tradition is good but we must realize that traditions change over generations. They are not the same as they were 3 to 10 generations ago. And to say the these traditions a sacred and unchanging over centuries is just hard to believe.Why do you ONLY accept the canon of the Bible but nothing else from that time?
I commend your blind faith. As the lamb was lead to the slaughter so have you just accepted every teaching that the church demands as the real deal. Never questioning what may be correct or not. If you are comfortable in that position than that is fine. But for me it is not. I can not accept blindly unless it is proved to MY satisfaction beyond a reasonable doubt that I should believe.It’s God’s world, universe. If He chose to give His Church through His priests the authority to forgive sins, to hold things bound on earth and heaven. Who am I to argue? Even if I can only speculate as to the reason He has done this, to increase my humility perhaps by submitting to His methods and His decisions through submission to His visible Church on earth?
First, you’re arguing a strawman.The way I see it is that anyone within the church hierarchy can say and invoke anything they want and claim it is inspired by the holy spirit. No questions asked just some man or group of men saying this is the way it is. If you disagree, than tough, you are now a sinner.
You aren’t really answering me, though. You’re just making a claim with nothing to back it up. Plus you’re getting the ‘hurt’ and ‘angry’ emotion from something that NOBODY said. IOW, YOU are the one claiming that ‘they’ are calling YOU a sinner. . .but nobody but you is making that accusation. . .
I see a lot of ‘anti-authority’ here, in fact, in centuries past this would be anti-clericalism. If Christ has set up an authority (and He has), wouldn’t you expect Him to communicate with those in authority? And just because (according to your personal view) Joe Catholic in the pew has ‘no say’ in what is done in church (and I don’t agree with this, in that there are plenty of non-doctrinal things that Joe Catholic has plenty of say on). . .so what? That doesn’t mean the Holy Spirit doesn’t guide ‘just’ the hierarchy. It means the Holy Spirit guides the hierarchy (and Scripture agrees), PLUS we (in the pews) can communicate with the Holy Spirit too.
But the foot is not the hand, nor is the eye the ear. . .the Body of Christ is not all 'Chiefs" and no 'Indians" and both leaders and followers are equally necessary even if one has more responsibility than the other in ONE aspect (leadership).
Christianity did not lose its force with me. The catholic church lost all credibility when it starts to tell me how to think and act. I have a huge faith in Christians but very little faith in blind following Catholics.
With respect, you keep on saying this and I just don’t see it. As a Catholic, I am not a BLIND follower. But you seem to imply that Catholics are just that. As a Catholic, CHRIST tells me what I need to do to follow Him. . .I have free will to obey Him. . .or not. The fact is, if I disobey Him, I’m doing wrong. . .and the Church is not ‘telling me how to think or act’, it is simply CONTINUING TO PREACH HIS MESSAGE. I’m free to listen. . .or not. That isn’t ‘the CHURCH’ being a nanny.
I’m probably showing my abounding ignorance what does “Bible was made canon” mean? You’re not ignorant. The Bible was not available to any Christian in the form we know it (Old Testament plus New Testament) until about AD 380, when the Church determined exactly what books made up that New Testament and Old Testament and it was all put together in that form. One of the first editions was St. Jerome’s Vulgate. Before that, there was no ‘Bible’. There were preachers who spoke using writings, some of which included what is now in the Bible, and some of which were NOT. Those things included works like the Didache, the Protoevangelium of St. James, The Shepherd of Hermes. . .all of which were good but not inspired inerrant Scripture. . .and some ‘not so good’ works.
But it was the CHURCH which went through ALL those works and deemed which were authentic, inerrant Scripture. . .and which were not. When you read the Bible, you are acknowledging the authority of the CATHOLIC CHURCH to give you that Bible.
Because it is mostly oral tradition that has been handed down. . . let alone 2000 years.
I have had plenty of people on this forum say that I will be damned to hell for my beliefs unless I conform to what everyone else is thinking.You aren’t really answering me, though. You’re just making a claim with nothing to back it up. Plus you’re getting the ‘hurt’ and ‘angry’ emotion from something that NOBODY said. IOW, YOU are the one claiming that ‘they’ are calling YOU a sinner. . .but nobody but you is making that accusation. .
That is the exact point. All the laity get is non doctrinal things. Anything if importance and deemed as heaven and hell issues is left to the hierarchy to decide and demand that the laity follow with no (name removed by moderator)ut what so ever. For they are stupid and do not have the greater ability to reason as the higher ups do.(and I don’t agree with this, in that there are plenty of non-doctrinal things that Joe Catholic has plenty of say on
Responsibility is one thing but power and ultimate authority is another.But the foot is not the hand, nor is the eye the ear. . .the Body of Christ is not all 'Chiefs" and no 'Indians" and both leaders and followers are equally necessary even if one has more responsibility than the other in ONE aspect (leadership).
The church tells you what THEY think is right and wrong. You are not given the clearance to read and interpret the bible how the spirit moves you . It must be interpreted by someone else and then they tell you what you should think. Yes you do have free will to follow them but they are telling you that if you don’t follow exactly as we tell you, than your mortal soul will be in danger of being damned to hell.With respect, you keep on saying this and I just don’t see it. As a Catholic, I am not a BLIND follower. But you seem to imply that Catholics are just that. As a Catholic, CHRIST tells me what I need to do to follow Him. . .I have free will to obey Him. . .or not. The fact is, if I disobey Him, I’m doing wrong. . .and the Church is not ‘telling me how to think or act’, it is simply CONTINUING TO PREACH HIS MESSAGE. I’m free to listen. . .or not. That isn’t ‘the CHURCH’ being a nanny
If this is true beyond any doubt what so ever. Than i guess I am about to give up believing anything that is in the Bible. I believed it was the word of God and now you are saying that it is man made by the catholic church. So much for belief in the bible.But it was the CHURCH which went through ALL those works and deemed which were authentic, inerrant Scripture. . .and which were not. When you read the Bible, you are acknowledging the authority of the CATHOLIC CHURCH to give you that Bible.
Those did not have heaven and hell in the balance.Works like the Iliad and the Odyssey came from. . .gasp. . .ORAL teachings.
So now we should start producing some documents. Such as a Complete list of all the infallible statements made by anyone within the church.We live in a literate society. They did not.
LIT, it’s not blind faith. I spent many years struggling with exactly the issues you raise. It took much research. It took watching the enormous number of competing denominations and sub-denominations and independent churches all asserting the same things you do to allow me to see how ‘individual’ interpretations lead to chaos and often away from God and truth.I commend your blind faith. As the lamb was lead to the slaughter so have you just accepted every teaching that the church demands as the real deal. Never questioning what may be correct or not. If you are comfortable in that position than that is fine. But for me it is not. I can not accept blindly unless it is proved to MY satisfaction beyond a reasonable doubt that I should believe.
This is a common misunderstanding. One must distinguish between doctrines and disciplines. Jesus established an authority over his flock. Do you think the “rules” made up at the Jerusalem Council in Acts 15 were from men?Christ said to teach what he had taught. Not all the new man made up rules that the church does now.
Well, let us look at what He did say:Christ did not say to not eat meat on Friday.
The Church is responsible for providing guidance and direction to the flock. For consistency, the Church designates certain days to honor the LordHe did not say this and this day were holy days of obligation.
This is not true, LIT. The Mass is structured exactly the way that Jesus gave it to the Apostles. It comes right out of the Jewish prayers during Passover, of which He is the sacrificial lamb. No human being has the right to change what He has put in place.He did not say this is exactly how you say the mass. All this is done by man and not by God.
Yes you must see it this way, so that you can excuse yourself for rebelling against the authority appointed by God. It was He that chose to exercise His authority through the Church.Guess I see it as I am rejecting man’s authority over me. Not God’s authority.
And you would be right. Not only that, one does not have to be in the church heirarchy to do this. In fact, every day, a new “bible church” is started by a believer that does not like what his pastor was doing and saying, and they believe they are called of God to “come out from among them” and start a new, more pure Christian community.Code:The way I see it is that anyone within the church hierarchy can say and invoke anything they want and claim it is inspired by the holy spirit.
It is regrettable, and much too frequent. How do you suppose that God wanted things to go instead?Code:No questions asked just some man or group of men saying this is the way it is. If you disagree, than tough, you are now a sinner.:mad:
This is no one’s fault but your own, LIT. Don’t get me wrong I had the same fault as well. I was not educated in my fiath. I never learned to read the Scripture, I never took it upon my self to read any history, study the creeds, or even the lives of the saints. When I was approached by Baptist and was told that the CC was the whore of Babylon, I fell for it because I was, as your title states “really that ignorant”.As I said above, The is no validation outside the high ups in the church. To me it is like the fox guarding the hen house. The lay members of the church have NO say in what is done within the church.
This is simply a lie. It would be best if you renounced it. It comes from the Father of Lies.So the Holy spirit only speaks to and guides those who are in high places in the church.
Well, LIT, I don’t know what to tell you. The NT is absolutely chock full of the Apostles telling the believers how to think and act. If you are unwilling to devote yourself to the Apostolic Teaching, that is your privilege.Code:Christianity did not lose its force with me. The catholic church lost all credibility when it starts to tell me how to think and act. I have a huge faith in Christians but very little faith in blind following Catholics.
This is a safe place for all of us to do that.I’m probably showing my abounding ignorance what does “Bible was made canon” mean?
It is very Catholic of you to say this.I disagree with certain interpretations of the Bible. I believe the Bible and to a greater extent God speaks to each of us individually regardless of what organized religion says around us.
Human customs do change, but the Word of God is imutable. When Jesus put His Word into the Church, and promised to infallibly preserve it there, He did so.Because it is mostly oral tradition that has been handed down. Tradition is good but we must realize that traditions change over generations.
Not when one understands that there is a difference between tradtions (customs of men) and Sacred Tradition (the Word of God in the Church). God is able to preserve His word where it was planted.Code:They are not the same as they were 3 to 10 generations ago. And to say the these traditions a sacred and unchanging over centuries is just hard to believe.
Yes it is a great object lesson. YOu are right, of course, with regard to communicaiton that is just from human to human. But Sacred Tradition is God’s communicaiton to us.Did you ever play the game gossip as a child? A group of children sit in a circle and one whispers something the child next to him. This message is whispered to all the children all around the circle. When it gets back to the original child. It is never the EXACT same thing that was said in the first place. The same happens to oral tradition and over the years things are embellished and changed.
If you do not believe that God is able to keep His word, then you have a trust problem with God.Code:Is oral tradition good? Yes but is it infallible and exactly what was believed 2000 years ago? NO. Therefore oral tradition can not be expressed as unchanging law for 200 years, let alone 2000 years.
This is disrespecful, LIT, inaccurate, and derogatory. On the contrary, you will find that those of us here on CAF that have chosen to submit to God’s authority in the CC are anything BUT blind. Many of us have had to study and pray our way back home fromI commend your blind faith. As the lamb was lead to the slaughter so have you just accepted every teaching that the church demands as the real deal. Never questioning what may be correct or not.
I am glad that you are not willing to persist in blind faith as you have for most of your life now. You were deeply wounded as a youngster, and have refused to grow in your CAtholic faith because of it. It is high time this resentment, unforgiveness, and blindness came to an end. Personally, I pray that the reason you came to CAF is so that you could be healed of the blindness with which you have been plagued. Satan loves someone who is blind and ignorant. He can make sport of such persons.If you are comfortable in that position than that is fine. But for me it is not. I can not accept blindly unless it is proved to MY satisfaction beyond a reasonable doubt that I should believe.
No, you have not, LIT. What you have been told is what was given to the Church by the Apostles. People have tried to warn you that, if you willfully disobey God’s commandments, then your soul is in jeapardy. It has nothing to do with conforming to other people’s thinking. It has to do with conforming yourself to God’s commandments.I have had plenty of people on this forum say that I will be damned to hell for my beliefs unless I conform to what everyone else is thinking.
So, you want to make up your own doctrine?Code:That is the exact point. All the laity get is non doctrinal things.
There is part of this that is true. The doctrine of the faith was given to the Church by Christ. The Church is forbideen to change what was committed to her, and is responsible to transmit “all” that He has taught. None of the sheep give the shepherd “(name removed by moderator)ut” into how He manages the flock. He calls, they follow. End of story. If you don’t want to follow the Shepherd, then you don’t belong to His flock.Anything if importance and deemed as heaven and hell issues is left to the hierarchy to decide and demand that the laity follow with no (name removed by moderator)ut what so ever.
It really has nothing to do with intelligence, LIT. None of the Apostles were learned men - at least, none of the 12. Paul was quite well educated, but the rest were just laborers, fishermen.For they are stupid and do not have the greater ability to reason as the higher ups do.
Not really. The two are inseparably entwined. One cannot be responsible for that over which he has no control or jurisdiction.Responsibility is one thing but power and ultimate authority is another.
Yes, this is the duty of the Church. The Apostles gave the TEachings of Jesus to the Church, and the Church is responsible for preserving and teaching the Teachings of Jesus to the flock. Why does that bother you? If this had not happened, we would be “sheep without a shepherd!”The church tells you what THEY think is right and wrong.
You have been asked repeatedly to stop spreading these lies, LIT.Code:You are not given the clearance to read and interpret the bible how the spirit moves you. It must be interpreted by someone else and then they tell you what you should think.
It is the duty of the Church to warn the disobedient. Did you expect those committed with the Gospel of salvation to stand by and watch people walk through the gates of hell, and say nothing?!Yes you do have free will to follow them but they are telling you that if you don’t follow exactly as we tell you, than your mortal soul will be in danger of being damned to hell.
Or, you could just open your mind to the Truth. The men who were moved by the Holy Spirit to speak from God were Catholics. The faith which produced the New Testament is preserved infallibly in the Catholic Church by the same spirit that inspired the Scirptures. It is one and the same faith.If this is true beyond any doubt what so ever. Than i guess I am about to give up believing anything that is in the Bible. I believed it was the word of God and now you are saying that it is man made by the catholic church. So much for belief in the bible.![]()
Definitely, LIT, is is high time you got started making some notes for yourself on the faith into which you were baptized. I think it is a great idea for you to list all the infallible statements made by anyone within the Church. This is commendable, and would help your spiritual growth a great deal. :bounce:So now we should start producing some documents. Such as a Complete list of all the infallible statements made by anyone within the church.
