M
Mike_from_NJ
Guest
Okay. What specifically about dinner time? Just come out and say it.Think about dinner time.
Okay. What specifically about dinner time? Just come out and say it.Think about dinner time.
Well, I for one would not claim that the Bible is “never changing,” if by that you mean that there’s no change from one part of it to another, or that interpretations of it don’t change.If your answer is a resounding “NO”, I suggest you start pondering the following. In the Old Testament there are several verses, which deal with slavery, and those verses do not talk about the subject in a condemnatory manner. Slavery was an accepted way of life in the biblical times.
So, was slavery “immoral” back then?
Whenever this question is raised, the believers unanimously answer: “slavery in those times was something different. It is best described as indentured servitude”. True, indentured servitude was a variant of “real” slavery, but there was plenty of “real” slavery in those times. The members of conquered tribes became “real” slaves, and not just the males, but the females, too.
Anyhow, the life of those “indentured servants” was not an enviable existence. The master could beat them if he so chose, as long as the “servant” was able to get up within three days. Also their progeny, if conceived during the time of the servitude belonged to the master, who could sell them whenever he wanted. So there is not a lot of difference between “real” slavery and indentured servitude.
What is the ever-present response to the question: “was slavery moral in the biblical times”?
And the answer is always the same: Ah, but those were different times, and you cannot make a value-judgment based upon our era.And with this OOPS “rebuttal” they declare themselves “moral relativists”, unknowingly, of course.
So you have two options: 1) either accept that indentured servitude was (and thus IS) moral, or 2) admit that the Bible - the never changing word of God teaches seriously “immoral” behavior. Which one do you prefer?
I’m still amazed at your premise… Ok - just one example. Do 2 year-old kids sit quietly and eat their food with cutlery. No. They cannot. We could therefore spoon feed them (fine). And/or we could allow them to eat with their hands - unacceptable when one is 10 say, but of no consequence when they are 2. Later, we will chastise them for picking up a potato in their hands. There are some rules that are introduced over time. And there are some freedoms which are allowed over time.Okay. What specifically about dinner time? Just come out and say it.
2 years olds don’t cut their food either. Why? They can’t. They are not capable of doing so.I’m still amazed at your premise… Ok - just one example. Do 2 year-old kids sit quietly and eat their food with cutlery. No. They cannot. We could therefore spoon feed them (fine). And/or we could allow them to eat with their hands - unacceptable when one is 10 say, but of no consequence when they are 2. Later, we will chastise them for picking up a potato in their hands. There are some rules that are introduced over time. And there are some freedoms which are allowed over time.
If a town allowed for rape every day except Tuesdays, would it not be endorsing it but merely regulating it?I would also point out, as others have done, that the Bible doesn’t advocate slavery so much as it regulates it.
Clearer for who? Remember we’re talking about God giving details on how to do something evil. Is it God that wasn’t clear on the conceptions of good and evil?However, the “difference” of times is still relevant to how we view people who did these things, not because something was once good and is now bad, but because conceptions of good and evil have become clearer.
Hence we could spoon feed them. But no, we allow - we may even encourage - picking up food in hands. We would chastise an older child for doing the same. You asked for an example in these terms: *"Do you have any examples, especially any behaviours or practices we teach children and then tell them not to engage in later? "2 years olds don’t cut their food either. Why? They can’t. They are not capable of doing so.
In the part you clipped I said that any society, including the Hebrews, were more than capable of not owning slaves. They are not the 2 year old in your analogy.Hence we could spoon feed them. But know, we allow - we may even encourage - picking up food in hands. We would chastise and older child for doing the same. This simple example makes the point.
I was not speaking of slavery. Just answering the question you posed. See post #26.In the part you clipped I said that any society, including the Hebrews, were more than capable of not owning slaves. They are not the 2 year old in your analogy.
You asked if I was a parent. It doesn’t take a parent to know that kids naturally pick up things and put them in their mouths. We don’t teach kids to put food in their mouths.I was not speaking of slavery. Just answering the question you posed. See post #26.
I see you’re not a parentYou asked if I was a parent. It doesn’t take a parent to know that kids naturally pick up things and put them in their mouths. We don’t teach kids to put food in their mouths.
A lot of posters have already provided an answer to this question of slavery. But I found a well articulated one here:What is the ever-present response to the question: “was slavery moral in the biblical times”?
On the other hand, Torah is the essence of all things. As the sages called it, “the blueprint of the universe.” So the Torah effects change not by imposing an exogenous order, but by revealing the inner, hidden order latent within all things. Torah is very much like a good teacher, one who shows you who you really are–which may be very different, even the opposite, of who you think you are.
The Torah effects change not by imposing an exogenous order, but by revealing the inner, hidden order latent within all things. So the Torah, of necessity, has two faces. Unlike human wisdom which has one face. Human wisdom must either reject or accept the status quo. But Torah is a voice heard from beyond–and so it may have two faces at once.
On the one hand, the Torah speaks from a future that has yet to occur, inspiring us with its vision, pulling us toward that time.
On the other hand, the Torah must deal with the world as it is, not artificially imposing upon it a foreign mold, but bringing it on its own from the place it stands by nature and circumstance to the place it truly belongs.
Let’s start simple:
Take an agrarian society surrounded by hostile nations. Go in there and forcefully abolish slavery. The result? War, bloodshed, hatred, prejudice, poverty and eventually, a return to slavery until the underlying conditions change. Which is pretty much what happened in the American South when the semi-industrialized North imposed their laws upon the agrarian South. And in Texas when Mexico attempted to abolish slavery among the Anglophones there.
Not a good idea. Better idea: Place humane restrictions upon the institution of indentured servitude. Yes, it’s still ugly, but in the meantime, you’ll teach people compassion and kindness. Educate. Make workshops. Go white-water rafting together. (Hey, why didn’t Abe Lincoln think of white-water rafting?) Eventually, things change and slavery becomes an anachronism for such a society.
Which is pretty much what happened to Jewish society. Note this: At a time when Romans had literally thousands of slaves per citizen, even the wealthiest Jews held very modest numbers of servants. And those servants, the Talmud tells us, were treated better by their masters than foreign kings would treat their own subjects.
Torah teaches us how to run a libertarian society–through education and participation. Elsewhere in the world, emperors and aristocracy knew only how to govern a mass of people through oppression. Look what happened to Rome: When Roman slaves began demanding a day of rest among other privileges, along with talk of a personal relationship directly to G‑d, Emperor Constantine made sure to dismiss the whole concept of mitzvahs and human dignity by adopting a stripped-down, benign version of Judaism for his empire. That’ll keep 'em quiet, he thought. (And it did, for about one thousand years.)
So the “conservative-radical” approach of Torah is this: Work with the status quo to get beyond it. Torah is more about process than about content.
Climbing Deeper
Are you satisfied with this answer? I’m not. I’m convinced there’s a deeper effect that Torah is looking for. Call it “the participatory effect.” A.k.a. nurture.
The Participatory Effect tells us that if you want people to follow rules, you put guns to their heads. But if you want them to learn, grow, internalize those rules and be able to teach them to others, you’re going to have to involve them in the process of forming those rules.
School teachers do this when they work with their class on the first day to design rules that everyone will see as reasonable and useful. Parents do this when they allow their child to makes mistakes so that s/he will learn from them. A skilled wife is doing this when she gets her husband to believe that he came up with the idea of re-tiling the kitchen floor.
chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/305549/jewish/Torah-Slavery-and-the-Jews.htmIn general, this strategy comes more naturally to women than to men. Men find it much easier to shove their opinions down other people’s throats and, if need be, argue the other into the ground until he surrenders. All variations of the old gun-to-the-head technique. Women are designed to nurture, physically and emotionally, so they take naturally to the participatory technique. To quote Gluckel of Hameln, “She was a true woman of valor. She knew how to control her husband’s heart.”
This is a very meaningful commentary on Torah teaching. Thank you for quoting it.A lot of posters have already provided an answer to this question of slavery. But I found a well articulated one here:
chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/305549/jewish/Torah-Slavery-and-the-Jews.htm
The point is participatory morality, not a completely forced morality from God.
This is all well and good, until you realize that it took over 4000 years for this participatory morality to finally rid the world of the definitely immoral concept of slavery. I thought that the example that you provided relating the story of the American Civil War was a very good example. Although you tried to use it as an example of “forcing one’s opinion on another is not a good idea,” look at the consequences! Within 120 years or so, the vast majority of the anti-black sentiment has been reversed. You may not realize, but although it took a significant amount of years we have actually come a long ways. Instead of treating a certain race as non-human, we now treat them with equal respect as others. Think about what could have happened if such ideas were introduced much earlier! Even if it had taken a bloody war and some offended people, I think that the values of our modern society could have been in place long before now.The point is participatory morality, not a completely forced morality from God.
I already said I wasn’t. Now since we have demonstrated that your example of kids putting food in their mouths is not an example of something we teach kids that we later try to unteach them, do you have any other examples that would work?I see you’re not a parent![]()
No, because that doesn’t describe most Biblical slavery. I’ve already quoted one passage from Leviticus which allows for the Hebrews to get slaves from neighboring nations.Have we explored yet the possibility that there does exist some sort of moral “slavery” both back then and today, much like the indentured servitude defense you quoted? Perhaps one that begins by the free will choice of the participant, does not involve violence, etc?
How so?False dichotomy.
I own a copy of that book, and I’m going through it and posting my responses to each chapter in my blog. As you can see I haven’t updated in a while, but now that I have my replacement computer up to speed I hope to continue on.Mike from NJ, perhaps you would find the book “Hard Sayings” by Trent Horn to be useful for understanding the Catholic position. I have not read it, but I believe it addresses the topic of slavery in the bible.