Are you Thomists or Molinists

  • Thread starter Thread starter Odell
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

Odell

Guest
From my understanding catholics can be either. Thomist claim that grace is intrinsically efficaious by its very nature it always produces the effect of salvation. Molinists claim that Gods enabling grace is only sufficient and is made efficacious by mans free choice rather than by the nature of the grace itself. Molinists say that enabling grace is extrinsically efficacious rather than intrinsically efficacious.
 
I understand the difference to be that the Thomists and Molinists understand a difference in capacity to respond to grace. I don’t know that the Church as Magisterium has an official definition, but Dr. Ludwig Ott describes them here.

All that being said, I tend to be a Molinist, but of course have respect for the Thomist position. 🙂 I see in Scripture much evidence for man’s free response to grace, and I feel that God’s “foreknowledge” is a better theological understanding of predestination and God’s generosity in permitting us to participate in the work of salvation.
 
The Church’s teaching are based on the Truth, which is Jesus Christ, not on the teachings of men. The teachings of men, however, are based on the teachings of the Church. This is why the Church has different spiritualities, theological approaches, orders, and works. The Church is One in Unity and United in Oneness, being fashioned after the likeness of God, given that she is the Body of Jesus Christ, the God-Man.
 
Both schools seem to have merit…I think I just might be a Thomoli.😃
 
I tend to be more Molinist. But I say that with the utmost respect to St. Thomas Aquinas, who is a saint that is very dear to me.
 
Molina said that the Virgin Mary did no work.

This, he says? About a mother?!

So, no, not a Molinist. 🙂
 
Molina said that the Virgin Mary did no work.

This, he says? About a mother?!

So, no, not a Molinist. 🙂
That’s a different subject than predestination though, no? And as I cited earlier, Dr. Ludwig Ott, whose book *Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma *is used in seminaries to teach priests the faith, writes that both Thomism and Molinism are acceptable understandings of predestination for Catholics.

I’m curious what writing of Molina’s are you referring when you said he said “Mary did no work.”???
 
It is OK to be inbetween Molinism and Thomism.

I think Father Most’s explanation of grace is pretty close to the mark.
 
As Catholics, we are bound to believe in a balance between God’s plan and Man’s free will, where neither impinges on the other. The exact mechanism is unknowable in this life, therefore the church has never taken a position between Molina and Aquinas. For us on earth, we simply need to recognize that we need to make the choice to do God’s will to be saved and also recognize that we have no rights before God, who made us. So while considerable amounts of effort have been expended debating between the two, there is no practical distinction between the two on how we should live our lives in order to gain entrance to heaven.
 
Re: Mary did no work

I ran into some old Vatican documents a while back, and there was one condemning various erroneous propositions. That was one of them. (And yes, I know it probably wasn’t meant that way, but it just sounded so unlikely!)

I just went back to where I found that, and… oops! I recalled incorrectly! It was actually a proposition by some guy named Miguel de Molinos, not the famous Luis de Molina. (I think the proposition guy was into Jansenism or something. And obviously didn’t run his theology past his mother.)

I apologize to all Molinists!
 
Is this something a catholic must take a position on either way? Do they have only these 2 options and must decide which they agree with even if it is both? Are there other options to consider or just these 2? What if a catholic person choses not to delve into the matter and believes there is no way of knowing? Would they be negligent or guilty of something?

I see so many threads dealing with so many topics and wonder how many things a catholic has to be versed in vs. what they just want to delve into themselves, but are not required to. There is simply so much information from so many years of theology people out there and how many can know this all? It seems too overwhelming to even try to learn this.
 
Is this something a catholic must take a position on either way? Do they have only these 2 options and must decide which they agree with even if it is both? Are there other options to consider or just these 2? What if a catholic person choses not to delve into the matter and believes there is no way of knowing? Would they be negligent or guilty of something?

I see so many threads dealing with so many topics and wonder how many things a catholic has to be versed in vs. what they just want to delve into themselves, but are not required to. There is simply so much information from so many years of theology people out there and how many can know this all? It seems too overwhelming to even try to learn this.
You bring up a good point. A good Catholic doesn’t have to be a theologian. Obviously, most are not. To be a faithful Catholic you must agree with the Apostle’s creed:

The Catechism of the Catholic Church gives the following English translation of the Apostles’ Creed. In its discussion of the Creed,The Catechism maintains the traditional division into twelve articles, the numbering of which is here added to the text.
  1. I believe in God, the Father almighty, creator of heaven and earth.
  2. I believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord.
  3. He was conceived by the power of the Holy Spirit and born of the Virgin Mary.
  4. He suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, died, and was buried.
  5. He descended into hell. On the third day he rose again.
  6. He ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of God the Father Almighty.
  7. He will come again to judge the living and the dead.
  8. I believe in the Holy Spirit,
  9. the holy catholic Church, the communion of saints,
  10. the forgiveness of sins,
  11. the resurrection of the body,
  12. and the life everlasting.
    Amen.
To be saved, you must be baptized , which will give you the necessary grace to be saved. After that, you must stay in the state of grace by doing God’s will, which is to love him and to also love your neighbor as yourself. If you fail in this and sin, you will need to reconcile with God through the sacrament of reconciliation, which requires contrite confession to a priest, repentence, and completion of the assigned penance. If you die in the state of Grace you will be saved.

finally, the Church has laid out the absolute minimum required:

THE PRECEPTS OF THE CHURCH

2041 The precepts of the Church are set in the context of a moral life bound to and nourished by liturgical life. The obligatory character of these positive laws decreed by the pastoral authorities is meant to guarantee to the faithful the very necessary minimum in the spirit of prayer and moral effort, in the growth in love of God and neighbor:

2042 The first precept (“You shall attend Mass on Sundays and holy days of obligation and rest from servile labor.”) requires the faithful to sanctify the day commemorating the Resurrection of the Lord as well as the principal liturgical feasts honoring the Mysteries of the Lord, the Blessed Virgin Mary and the saints; in the first place, by participating in the Eucharistic Celebration, in which the Christian community is gathered, and by resting from those works and activities which could impede such a sanctification of these days.

The second precept (“You shall confess your sins at least once a year.”) ensures preparation for the Eucharist by the reception of the sacrament of reconciliation, which continues Baptism’s work of conversion and forgiveness.

The third precept (“You shall receive the sacrament of the Eucharist at least during the Easter season”) guarantees as a minimum the reception of the Lord’s Body and Blood in connection with the Paschal feasts, the origin and center of the Christian liturgy.

2043 The fourth precept (“You shall observe the days of fasting and abstinence established by the Church”) ensures the times of ascesis and penance which prepare us for the liturgical feasts and help us acquire mastery over our instincts and freedom of heart.

The fifth precept (“You shall help to provide for the needs of the Church”) means that the faithful are obliged to assist with the material needs of the Church, each according to his own ability.

Obviously, this can lead to other questions, which are covered in great detail in the catechism: scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
 
Is this something a catholic must take a position on either way? Do they have only these 2 options and must decide which they agree with even if it is both? Are there other options to consider or just these 2? What if a catholic person choses not to delve into the matter and believes there is no way of knowing? Would they be negligent or guilty of something?
Being an undefined issue, one could opine some form of predestination for their belief so long as it does not contradict already defined matters of the faith.
 
Originally Posted by StrawberryJam
Is this something a catholic must take a position on either way? Do they have only these 2 options and must decide which they agree with even if it is both? Are there other options to consider or just these 2? What if a catholic person choses not to delve into the matter and believes there is no way of knowing? Would they be negligent or guilty of something?
All Catholics must believe that men have true free will and that God has a definitive plan that will be executed without impinging on that free will. The mechanism that allows man’s free will to work in perfect harmony with God’s plan is the nub of the debate between the Molinist and the Thomist. But the mechanism is unknowable on earth and does not effect how men must live their lives to be saved, so the issue is nothing more than an intellectual exercise. BAck in the 1600s, the pope ruled that no decision would be made between the two becasue of those reasons. Catholics are free to speculate either way.

Here is a helpful article form teh Catholic Encyclopedia explaining this (in more academic terms than I used):newadvent.org/cathen/10437a.htm
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top