Arguing over words vs. what's really important

  • Thread starter Thread starter Elixir
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Elixir

Guest
I didn’t know where to put this thread and I really didn’t know what title to give to it. I’ll try to lay out my thoughts as sensibly as possible.

When I visit this and other message boards that discuss Christianity in general and Catholicism in particular there are always numerous (seemingly infinite) threads about differences in denominations, who’s right vs. who’s wrong, bickering over liturgical forms, unhappy with this priest or bishop, haggling over the definitions of words, etc. ad nauseum.

To me this all seems like a dog chasing it’s tail while the car is getting ready to run it over.

Look at this article from MLive.com in Michigan about a possible Eucharistic miracle. Read the comments. Look at the outright hatred and venom spewed towards Christians in general and Catholics in particular, and it’s safe to say this is a fair representation of what is said whenever there is a story published in a secular newspaper about some happening in the Church.

Shouldn’t Christian unity be at the front of people’s minds when we’re clearly confronted with a world reverted to paganism and hostility to believers?

I don’t know how to clearly articulate my frustrations about this. I hope I at least made some kind of point.

Any thoughts?
 
The problem is, and not many will admit this, is that every break-off from the main Church happens out of pride. Because they can’t accept a teaching, because they think their way is better, because they think they themselves are better. So when an issue comes up, they have to be argumentative and disprove that or prove they are right, because if they are not right then the opposite is true, they were wrong. So its all just pride. That is why Christ asks humility from us. Even Christ himself didn’t get everyone to accept His teaching, we need to lower ourselves and know that we don’t know all the answers to life. All these denominations should be humble enough to accept the authority of the Church. But they aren’t.
 
Your sense of what is missing “Christian Unity” is profound and accurate and it has been lacking since the days of JESUS. ( I am for Paul, I am for Peter, I am for CHRIST… to paraphrase the Gospel).

So the question is what IS Christian “Unity”. The simple answer is following the teaching of CHRIST. However, those “teachings” have been spun, split, reversed engineered, redefined, edited, eroded, and just plain ignored by so many people so that the actual count of “professed” christian churches is well over 20,000.

So what do we do? I will quote Cardinal and now Saint John Henry Newman from his writings in PAROCHIAL AND PLAN SERMONS III, " We did not make the Church, we may NOT unmake it."

My emphasis in the word NOT. If anyone is NOT living and teaching as JESUS has provided, then they are outside of the “Unity” which JESUS desires. HE wants everyone to “join HIM”, and not HIM to be diluted and filtered until HIS teachings are so thin, that sin is accepted and promoted by the appointment of gay bishops, or slaughter of infants in the wombs.

Unity begins with just one person choosing to live “…through HIM, with HIM and in HIM…” and in that becoming the light and salt necessary to bring others into HIS unity.

It is hard and becoming harder. It is easier to dilute, filter and thin HIS teachings so we can all just get along.
 
I was drawn into this thread by the title.

I know what you are saying by referring to little petty arguments, but some theological and liturgical conversations are vitally important to have. Also, the WORDS we use can have a vital impact on what we’re saying. Most of the time, we don’t realize the implications of what we say, and the positive or negative effects that our mere word choice can have on others.

Sorry to drive off-subject a little, but I thought that it was an important point to make.
 
I hear ya heather_rose.

There are clear divisions among Christians…and they are not unimportant and I do not intend to try and sweep them under the rug.

Words are important. Jesus said certain things and meant those things so it’s not as if that can be put aside easily.

No easy answer to my concern to be sure.
 
I think what you’ve identified is very important, but I would also suggest that people talk to each other in different situations. So the people in a thread that may be discussing something the Bishops have said or done may disagree vehemently, but if they found themselves in a different forum where the faith was being attacked then you would find that pretty quickly they’d be agreeing.

On these forums people are also attracted to the different topics they find most interesting, so they’ll post on the topics that excite them most, making it more likely they could get heated.

I suppose a lot of the heat can be situational. In one forum they’ll argue about vestments, liturgy and things bishops say, in another situation they’ll support the bishop regardless of what they said against the vile and hateful attacks of others.

ChadS
 
I think of Christianity like the British-American Alliance in WWII. We had serious disagreements among our two nations. They were known and public differences. They were sometimes quite serious. We talked about them seriously. We didn’t sweep them under the rug.

But when there were Nazis to defend against, we spoke “No” with one loud voice.

It’s good that our denominations argue. It’s especially good whenever a Protestant realizes how wrong his or her denomination is and rejoins full communion with Christ. (Zing!) But when the secularists are on the march, we should – and mostly do – present a united front.
 
Before my coming back to the Church - and particularly during the time of the sexual abuse scandals - I was anti-Catholic.

I watch almost all the “Journey Home” programs on EWTN (also available on EWTN youTube) and most clergy converts will admit that they either grew up with - or developed an anti-Catholic attitude.

I’ve heard quite a bit of anti-Catholic language on Christian radio and television. Some protestant denominations are more anti-Catholic than others. However, every person within those denominations will have a different life experience in relationship to contact with Catholicism.

I’ve learned that it’s much more difficult for me to talk with fallen away Catholics about “religion” than it is to talk with people of protestant denominations.
 
I get what you’re saying, and I understand your frustration, but it’s important to keep in mind the fact that words mean things, and they have power. Twisting the meaning of a word, or substituting one word for another is one of the most common techniques of people who try to change or get around the truth. Lawyers and legislators do it all the time, simply because the tiny nuances of difference between one word and the next have POWER. Language in and of itself is a truly powerful thing, and it can be used to either defend the truth, or twist it.

Also keep in mind that when it comes to some of the really important stuff, like defending the unborn and fighting against the normalization of sexual immorality, Christians are pretty much united. But the “small” differences still need to be worked out, and forums such as this are the perfect place to start doing that. As Dennis Prager says, “Clarity is preferable to agreement.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top