Argument against the Rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter WesleyF
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
RBK:

I think there is a difference between art depicting a “scene” vs a specific “image” dedicated to a specific person. Don’t you think there is a difference between a painting of Noah, his family, with the animals… compared to a statue a saint?

One other thing - nativity scenes are to focus on Jesus. Jesus is worthy of being worshiped.

but…I can see your point. I take your point as maybe Nativity scenes are inappropriate, not as it is ok to create images of saints etc.
 
RBK:

I think there is a difference between art depicting a “scene” vs a specific “image” dedicated to a specific person. Don’t you think there is a difference between a painting of Noah, his family, with the animals… compared to a statue a saint?

One other thing - nativity scenes are to focus on Jesus. Jesus is worthy of being worshiped.

but…I can see your point. I take your point as maybe Nativity scenes are inappropriate, not as it is ok to create images of saints etc.
All this seems like a distraction from the OP. What does the Rosary have to do with idolotry? And don’t bother trotting out the worn out canard that Catholic idolize Mary. We don’t.
 
Tantum:

I think that Christianity cannot act too differently than Judaism on the big issues. The issue of idolatry was one of the biggest. ALL churches should be adhering the same way - but obviously aren’t.

I cannot see how such a large issue in the Hebrew scriptures (under Mosaic Law) all of a sudden disappears for us. You can say that many other things did disappear altogether, many of the apostles reinforced the stance on idolatry and images…unlike the other law points that specifically were mentioned as being done away with.
 
I agree David - sorry.

The Rosary is all about reciting the same prayer over and over. How can that be good when Jesus said not to?
 
RBK:

Don’t you think there is a difference between a painting of Noah, his family, with the animals… compared to a statue a saint?
I think both Noah and the saints are family, so I like having their pictures/likenesses around. If you’re going to condemn all statues, we need to get rid of a lot of them in Washington D.C. (Lincoln Memorial, etc.).
One other thing - nativity scenes are to focus on Jesus. Jesus is worthy of being worshiped.
You won’t get an argument from any Catholic here. Worship belongs to God alone. But that doesn’t get around that fact that every Nativity scene has a statue of Mary and St. Joseph. And I’ve never heard a protestant object to having them front and center in their churches. It just seems rather hypocritical for them to turn around and accuse Catholics of idolatry for same thing. 🤷
 
I agree David - sorry.

The Rosary is all about reciting the same prayer over and over. How can that be good when Jesus said not to?
Well there’s your problem, sugah. . .you made two mistakes.

A. The rosary is not about reciting the same prayers (that’s s as in plural, the Apostles’ Creed, Our Father, Hail Mary and Glory Be) over and over. Do you know the history of the rosary? Do you know what the original 150 prayers that it represents in 3 sets of 5 mysteries were? And do you know what the person is doing as he or she prays?

B. Jesus did not say not to repeat the same prayer over and over (how could He have done so when He Himself in praying the night before He suffered prayed to His Father using the very same prayers over and over? No, Jesus spoke of 'vain repetitions like the heathens." Are you aware of the type of prayer that was used by the Greeks in their religious ceremonies?

Since you made those mistakes, you have erected what we call a strawman. That is, you have mistakenly identified the rosary as ‘vain repetition’ and have added on a mistaken idea that Jesus’ use of the term ‘vain repetition’ means that one cannot repeat a prayer. No saying the Our Father twice for YOU, I suppose! But since the rosary is not vain repetition, and since Jesus never said that we could not pray the same PRAYER (not vain repetition but prayer) over again, your strawman has been ‘blown away. . .’
 
I agree David - sorry.

The Rosary is all about reciting the same prayer over and over. How can that be good when Jesus said not to?
So meditating on the life, death and resurrection of Jesus is not a good thing? This is what the rosary is. When did Jesus say we weren’t supposed to do this? I think you are confused.
 
So, I just typed a Google search “Rosary Prayer” and clicked on the first link, which was:

rosary-center.org/howto.htm

How is that not a scripted and repetitive prayer? SInce I am not Catholic, maybe I am missing something big - but the matter seems simple enough to evaluate. The instructions on saying this prayer is straight forward. Also, when someone sins and confesses, doesnt a priest instruct on how many “Hail-Mary’s” someone is suppose to recite?

Someone made the reference to 2000 years of Catholics doing the same thing - and I would categorically disagree. We have ample first, second, third century Christian documents - and I have never read one of those that contained these prayers. Please show me that those Christians prayed in this manner.
 
So, I just typed a Google search “Rosary Prayer” and clicked on the first link, which was:

rosary-center.org/howto.htm

How is that not a scripted and repetitive prayer?
Who said it wasn’t. Why is it wrong to use scripted and repetitive prayer.
SInce I am not Catholic, maybe I am missing something big - but the matter seems simple enough to evaluate.
You sure are missing something big - devotional prayers help you become holy, the kind of holiness that is needed to get into heaven.
The instructions on saying this prayer is straight forward. Also, when someone sins and confesses, doesnt a priest instruct on how many “Hail-Mary’s” someone is suppose to recite?
Sometimes. And, what is the problem with this?
Someone made the reference to 2000 years of Catholics doing the same thing - and I would categorically disagree. We have ample first, second, third century Christian documents - and I have never read one of those that contained these prayers. Please show me that those Christians prayed in this manner.
I think you misunderstood that poster. Catholics have used devotional prayer since the beginning.
 
So, I just typed a Google search “Rosary Prayer” and clicked on the first link, which was:

rosary-center.org/howto.htm

How is that not a scripted and repetitive prayer? SInce I am not Catholic, maybe I am missing something big - but the matter seems simple enough to evaluate. The instructions on saying this prayer is straight forward. Also, when someone sins and confesses, doesnt a priest instruct on how many “Hail-Mary’s” someone is suppose to recite?

Someone made the reference to 2000 years of Catholics doing the same thing - and I would categorically disagree. We have ample first, second, third century Christian documents - and I have never read one of those that contained these prayers. Please show me that those Christians prayed in this manner.
I looked at the site. It says exactly what people here have repeated (no pun intended). Each decade one is to mediate on the mystery. From the website above: “Say ten “Hail Marys,” while meditating on the Mystery.”.

I do not say the rosary to show God, look, I have said X pray this many times, and Y prayer this many times, etc. It is to mediate on the life, death and resurrection of Christ.

If saying the same thing over again is wrong, why did Jesus do it?

Matthew 26:44:

44 And he left them, and went away again, and prayed the third time, saying the same words.

If saying the same thing over again is wrong, why do the creatures in heave do exactly that?

Revelation 4:8:

*And the four beasts had each of them six wings about him; and they were full of eyes within and they rest not day and night, saying,

Holy, holy, holy, Lord God Almighty,
which was, and is, and is to come.*
 
Mt. 26:44 is talking about saying the same thing to the Apostles - NOT TO FALL ASLEEP. That scripture is not talking about his prayer. After all, what would Jesus be saying to the Father over and over??..to himself no less.

The scripture at Mt. 6:5-8 is very clear. I cannot see how you can spin this into anything other than what it says.

…and concerning your scripture in Rev., id like to know if you first think there are beasts with wings in heaven before commenting on what it says they are doing. Rev cant be taken at its face value like Matthew.
 
Mt. 6:5-8

5 “And when you pray, you shall not be like the hypocrites. For they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the corners of the streets, that they may be seen by men. Assuredly, I say to you, they have their reward. 6 But you, when you pray, go into your room, and when you have shut your door, pray to your Father who is in the secret place; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly.[a] 7 And when you pray, do not use vain repetitions as the heathen do. For they think that they will be heard for their many words.
8 “Therefore do not be like them. For your Father knows the things you have need of before you ask Him.

KJ
 
Mt. 6:5-8

5 “And when you pray, you shall not be like the hypocrites. For they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the corners of the streets, that they may be seen by men. Assuredly, I say to you, they have their reward. 6 But you, when you pray, go into your room, and when you have shut your door, pray to your Father who is in the secret place; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly.[a] 7 And when you pray, do not use vain repetitions as the heathen do. For they think that they will be heard for their many words.
8 “Therefore do not be like them. For your Father knows the things you have need of before you ask Him.

KJ
And? This in no way contradicts the Rosary. After all, you’re quoting Scripture–praying if you will–in a public forum, aren’t you?

Tell me, is “Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with you” found in Scripture? (Hint, Luke 2). How about, “Blessed are you among women?” (ditto).

Vain repetitions. I asked you before, might have missed your answer. .Would you care to enlighten us about the prayers used by the Greeks and Romans at the time of Jesus?

Now. . .at your church, ever hear people saying, “Praise the Lord”, “Amen, Alleluia!” Praise Jesus, Praise Jesus?" Etc. Um. . .over and over. So these aren’t vain repetitions, right?
And your continual posting of Matthew 6:5-8 isn’t 'vain repetition either even though you’ve posted it before, right?

Amazing how blind people can be when they’re attempting to point out the ‘speck’ they think they see in a brother’s eye while ignoring the mote in their own. . .and yes, I’m talking to YOU, hon. You’re so full of vainglory and false pride in trying to ‘take down’ the ignorant ‘heathen’ that you don’t even see your own contradictions and falsities. . .
 
Mt. 26:44 is talking about saying the same thing to the Apostles - NOT TO FALL ASLEEP. That scripture is not talking about his prayer. After all, what would Jesus be saying to the Father over and over??..to himself no less.

The scripture at Mt. 6:5-8 is very clear. I cannot see how you can spin this into anything other than what it says.

…and concerning your scripture in Rev., id like to know if you first think there are beasts with wings in heaven before commenting on what it says they are doing. Rev cant be taken at its face value like Matthew.
This is your OWN KJV: And he left them, and went away again, and prayed the third time, saying the same words

Unless you got so dizzy with your spin that you can’t understand plain English, there is no way that you can’t see the phrase “saying the same words” can modify nothing other than “prayed the third time.” NOT ‘speaking to the apostles’ whom in any case he had LEFT and WENT AWAY AGAIN.

I mean, your OWN KJV is clear that Jesus repeated Himself in prayer.
 
Mt. 26:44 is talking about saying the same thing to the Apostles - NOT TO FALL ASLEEP. That scripture is not talking about his prayer. After all, what would Jesus be saying to the Father over and over??..to himself no less.
Here are the verses surrounding 44 (from the KJV):

*39 And he went a little further, and fell on his face, and prayed, saying, O my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me: nevertheless not as I will, but as thou [wilt].

40And he cometh unto the disciples, and findeth them asleep, and saith unto Peter, What, could ye not watch with me one hour?

41Watch and pray, that ye enter not into temptation: the spirit indeed [is] willing, but the flesh [is] weak.

42He went away again the second time, and prayed, saying, O my Father, if this cup may not pass away from me, except I drink it, thy will be done.

43And he came and found them asleep again: for their eyes were heavy.

44And he left them, and went away again, and prayed the third time, saying the same words.

45Then cometh he to his disciples, and saith unto them, Sleep on now, and take [your] rest: behold, the hour is at hand, and the Son of man is betrayed into the hands of sinners.*

How do you come up with Jesus didn’t say the same prayer 3 times?
The scripture at Mt. 6:5-8 is very clear. I cannot see how you can spin this into anything other than what it says.
Yes, it is very clear. It says don’t use vain repetitions as the heathens do. IE, prayers to Pagan gods, who do not exist, thus vain.
…and concerning your scripture in Rev., id like to know if you first think there are beasts with wings in heaven before commenting on what it says they are doing. Rev cant be taken at its face value like Matthew.
If they are real or not, why would God show John something that he does not want to be done?

This article might help:

catholic.com/thisrock/1994/9409fea3.asp
 
Throughout history Catholics have adapted pagan and heathen practices only to incorporate them one way or another into Christianity. Why should prayer be any different?

Mt. 6 is speaking to the type of prayer Catholics have developed in an effort to make it easy for people of the world (ie pagans and heathens) feel more at home.

Prayer should not be a mere ritual, nor should it be read from a book. As if repetitive phrases makes it more effective - do you really think God needs to hear it more than once, when “he knows what we need before we even ask”??

I find it sad that people think forgiveness of sin can be made up by repeating a bunch of words over and over - as if that is the true quality of repentance. The Catholic Church is a church for the masses. Mt. 7:13
 
Prayer should not be a mere ritual, nor should it be read from a book. As if repetitive phrases makes it more effective - do you really think God needs to hear it more than once, when “he knows what we need before we even ask”??
I have said this before and I will say it one final time. I do not believe saying a prayer multiple times makes it more effective. When I say the rosary, I mediate on the life, death and resurrection of Christ. And Catholic do not ONLY pray pre-written prayers. I do both. For example, I will pray the Our Father like Jesus showed us and I will just talk to God.
I find it sad that people think forgiveness of sin can be made up by repeating a bunch of words over and over - as if that is the true quality of repentance. The Catholic Church is a church for the masses. Mt. 7:13
This is for another thread, but this shows a gross misunderstanding of confession. The Catholic church does not teach forgiveness of sin can be made up by repeating words.

There are lots of good articles on this site (at the top, click on Faith → Library → Faith Tracts). If you really are interested in learning about Catholicism and what the church teaches, please read the above with an open mind.

Your “Catholics are pagans” comments are very telling. I would invite you to start a new thread on this so we can discuss.
 
Alright - I started the thread. But now cant find where I started it under??? Will find and post.
 
I agree David - sorry.

The Rosary is all about reciting the same prayer over and over. How can that be good when Jesus said not to?
Hi Johnnyprc - Could you please tell us whether you actually really read a Scriptural Rosary from A - Z so we may be assured that you base your arguement on your own experience of meditating a Rosary? Much obliged. Thank you. 🙂
 
Mt. 6:5-8

5 “And when you pray, you shall not be like the hypocrites. For they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the corners of the streets, that they may be seen by men. Assuredly, I say to you, they have their reward. 6 But you, when you pray, go into your room, and when you have shut your door, pray to your Father who is in the secret place; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly.[a] 7 And when you pray, do not use vain repetitions as the heathen do. For they think that they will be heard for their many words.
8 “Therefore do not be like them. For your Father knows the things you have need of before you ask Him.

KJ
The key phrase in Matthew 6:5 is THAT THEY MAY BE SEEN BY MEN!!! which is not the case with meditation on the Rosary. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top