Ash Wednesday fast - Not a good idea for me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PatsWife922
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PatsWife922

Guest
Hello CAF members,

Quick question - I am currently in intensive day treatment for bulimia. My treatment team does not support me fasting during Lent this year. I agree that for me - fasting would not be a good idea for where I am at in trying to recover.

Would it be okay for me to not fast - the last thing I want is to sin…
 
I believe fasting can be dispensed if your doctor(s) say it’s not a good idea, or rather, would essentially be bad for your health. Food in this case is your medicine that you need.
 
Oh goodness! Ma’am I am so sorry to hear about your health troubles.

I am no priest or theologian, but I am very sure that your health trumps fasting.

Praying for you…
 
Hello CAF members,

Quick question - I am currently in intensive day treatment for bulimia. My treatment team does not support me fasting during Lent this year. I agree that for me - fasting would not be a good idea for where I am at in trying to recover.

Would it be okay for me to not fast - the last thing I want is to sin…
It seems like in your case fasting is giving into the temptation of your eating disorder. Why don’t you fast from something other than food? Maybe fast from TV, or from the forums?

It honestly would seem like fasting is sinful in your situation insofar as it’s a sin to willingly jeopardize your health.
 
The Church would never deny someone medical care and intervention. But you can give up other things instead: TV, music, pray more, go to Church more, other stuff that would serve the same purpose. 🙂
 
I think I just read over on one of the threads about being pregnant/nursing and fasting that the exemption also included health reasons and that that included mental health.

I googled to see what I could find and found this at EWTN:
Those who are excused from fast or abstinence Besides those outside the age limits, those of unsound mind, the sick, the frail, pregnant or nursing women according to need for meat or nourishment, manual laborers according to need, guests at a meal who cannot excuse themselves without giving great offense or causing enmity and other situations of moral or physical impossibility to observe the penitential discipline.
Since fasting would definitely be detrimental to your progress it seems like it would fall under the “mental health” dispensation. If it makes you feel better talk to your priest, but I’m sure he’ll tell you the same thing. We definitely don’t want Lent endangering your health.

I can’t fast either this time around and have been trying to come up with substitutions. TV sounds like a good fast. Or internet. Or even something like gossip (I’m constantly giving that up and then saying something and asking myself if it was gossip… I may be a little scrupulous there…).
 
If you have a prescribed treatment plan from competent medical authority (including dietitians and psychologists), I would take THIS to your pastor, and ask him to bless it for your Lenten Rule.

How does that sound?

That will give it a spiritual dimension and the grace of fasting as well.
 
The Church would never deny someone medical care and intervention. **But you can give up other things instead: TV, music, pray more, go to Church ******more, other stuff that would serve the same purpose. 🙂
As a depression sufferer, i may have to do the same thing.
Damaging your health would be violating the Fifth Commandment.
 
The Church would never deny someone medical care and intervention. But you can give up other things instead: TV, music, pray more, go to Church more, other stuff that would serve the same purpose. 🙂
I will probably be unable to fast, myself. I am a recently diagnosed diabetic, and I still do not have my blood sugar fully under control. I must eat particular amounts of carbs, proteins, fats, etc three times a day, or my blood sugar goes totally out of whack. Too high, I get neuropathy in my feet, as well as health issues down the road. Too low, I could die.

The day I was released from hospital, the wing I was in was locked down due to an outbreak of the Norovirus. It appeared that I had had symptoms two or three days previous, but not since, so they deemed me fit to be discharged. The next night, I had severe runs and vomiting – couldn’t keep down any food, blood sugar getting screwed up – and ended up being ambulanced back to hospital. I had to be kept under close observation because of the danger of hypoglycemia, and they withheld my insulin until I could get some food downrange and keep it there.

I had some severe nausea today (I overdid the sugar-free candies for Valentine’s), so I was unable to eat lunch. I had a light supper, but my blood sugar spiked from 4.1 before supper to over 14 after.

As Jennifer stated above, food is now my medicine, and I must take my correct “dosages” at the proper times.
 
I’m a recovered bulimic, and I cannot fast. I tried when I first converted, and found myself back in dangerous territory. You probably know what I mean - the rush, the buzz, the sense of purity… I quickly went and broke my fast with a normal meal and prayed on it. I think I even posted here because I was so troubled by my near-instant response. The entire experience scared me witless.

Now, a few years later, it’s easier for me. I don’t fast on any of the fasting days. I go to Mass, and I keep a quiet day - no music generally (I can’t turn it off when I’m in a public place!), no television, prayer & reflection. I eat simple meals but not overly bland. I do try to avoid meat but sometimes I goof because I try to keep my eating “regular.”

Just as I’ve learned my triggers, and I avoid them! - I also have learned to recognize my limits, and to honor them. I honor the Lord by honoring my limits. Eating disorders are as much of an illness as diabetes and hypoglycemia - and you should treat your ED as such. Once your are out of treatment, before Lent, come up with your plan for days of fasting & repentance. Perhaps using the day for a quiet personal retreat, or attending Mass, or praying the Rosary would be a useful and special alternative.

I think the key point is to treat fasting days as solemn and reflective days to honor God. By making them special and out of the ordinary, we remember to take the time to think outside of our daily lives and put God first.

My prayers of support and healing for you during your time of recovery. There is light on the other side. You should be very proud for the hard work you are doing, of the fact that by getting help and healing you are truly honoring God’s gift of life.
 
Hello CAF members,

Quick question - I am currently in intensive day treatment for bulimia. My treatment team does not support me fasting during Lent this year. I agree that for me - fasting would not be a good idea for where I am at in trying to recover.

Would it be okay for me to not fast - the last thing I want is to sin…
I am glad you got so many good answers. I hope your fear have been alleviated. It is not a sin to not fast in your circumstance. Since it is a day of penance, you might (as has been suggested) consider alternative penance. It need not be a fast, necessarily. You can offer your time as a volunteer, or perhaps offer more time in prayer. You could pray specifically for the forgotten in Purgatory. Think about how to make days like today penitential. Talk to your pastor, but not for permission to skip the food fast- you have it from the Church- but for advice on how to offer the day otherwise. Retain the meaning, even though you cannot fast. Ask yourself what you can sacrifice that will be meaningful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top