D
dolphinlove
Guest
This thread is comical!
Ask a question, but dont get an answer it should be called.
Ask a question, but dont get an answer it should be called.
I am trying to answer the questions I have seen, but there are more questions than people to answer… I’m sorry but I can’t answer them all right away though I am doing my best.This thread is comical!
Ask a question, but dont get an answer it should be called.
Here is a good video on youtube which briefly explains the answer to this question in about 7 minutes: youtube.com/watch?v=iMhgt3JRqeU The major difference was originally political–dealing with succession of Muhammad after his death. Since then doctrinal differences crept in, most particularly the belief among the Shi’a that the descendents of Muhammad through his daughter Fatima had more authority in the religion.just curious as to the differences between these two sects?
I think you might be referring to “sufism.” Tasawwuf (the Arabic term for it) is a kind of purification of the heart or soul, sometimes called spirituality. There are certain parts of the world where it is more common, and some where it is especially rare. The views among Muslims are varied, and complicated by the fact that there are different kinds of sufism. One kind, practiced in parallel with islamic jurisprudence, is generally accepted, widespread, and practiced by scholars and laypeople in a very benign fashion.also, what do most muslims think about muslim mystics?
Wa alaikum as-salaam (and peace/salaam to you)Hello or Salaam as you say,
I also feel that Islam is from God looking at how it rooted out rampant idolatry, paganism, human sacrifice etc… In basically one generation where the Jews failed to do for thousands of years. Although I don’t acknowledge the Qu’ran to be perfect.
Numerous theories have arisen to explain this discrepancy, and I don’t think any are worth mentioning because none can be proven. Let me just give you the aya in the Qur’an which mentions this:That said the biggest issue I have with Islam is the idea that Jesus wasn’t crucified. To me there is more written testimony to this than Caesar crossing the rubicon. To me Jesus crucifixion (not necessarilyy his ressurrection, that I am unsure of) is a matter of history and without dispute. I have never been able to get my head around someone stating hundreds of years later that this did not in fact take place, when there is much evidence that it did.
I am sorry that I cannot adequately answer these questions. The first is a yes/no question–the Qur’an talks at length about the Day of Judgment and things that will happen in the future–a future which has not come to pass so I will say that the answer is no.I do have questions of my own, but I probably will get the same type of answers.
Have all the prophecies in the koran been fulfilled?
How many of the prophecies in the koran were fulfilled by muhammed?
How many prophecies have not yet been fulfilled?
The reason for the dress code is for women’s protection in some ways, like modesty. The woman by covering can maintain her dignity without having to suffer the gaze of anyone–Muslim or non-Muslim. Covering also protects her from becoming proud or arrogant about her beauty by showing it off. Muslims actually don’t view covering as a “strict dress code.” They look at everything in Islam as being moderation, including this. So rather than displaying the whole body, Muslim women cover most of their body while leaving open their face and hands which for practical reasons need to be left uncovered. (There are some scholars who disagree and say that a woman’s entire body needs to be covered, but most do not take that opinion.)hi my question/comment is in regard to the dress code for women.why the strict dress code for women? can not the men guard their own thoughts?are they that weak?can not the men trust in God to help them overcome their weakness in regards to women?thanks in advance for the reply.
i understand what you are saying here thanks for the informative replyThe reason for the dress code is for women’s protection in some ways, like modesty. The woman by covering can maintain her dignity without having to suffer the gaze of anyone–Muslim or non-Muslim. Covering also protects her from becoming proud or arrogant about her beauty by showing it off. Muslims actually don’t view covering as a “strict dress code.” They look at everything in Islam as being moderation, including this. So rather than displaying the whole body, Muslim women cover most of their body while leaving open their face and hands which for practical reasons need to be left uncovered. (There are some scholars who disagree and say that a woman’s entire body needs to be covered, but most do not take that opinion.)
About men guarding their thoughts, before women were told to cover, men were in fact told to lower their gaze. The commandment in the Qur’an which tells women to cover also tells them to lower their gaze, but only after the men have first been commanded.
Only part of covering is about men being weak. It is the nature of man to look at women. And women like being looked at. So to protect both of them, the women cover and the men aren’t supposed to look. But what about men who are weak? What about those who aren’t even Muslim or don’t care about this commandment? The woman who covers is still protected from them. And of course from herself.
I wanted to emphasize that the covering is not just for the men, but it is for the women–it’s not a punishment, but a blessing really. Many women who begin to cover as adults acknowledge how more dignified they feel–less like an object to be looked at, and treated more like a person. And I am talking about women in a non-Muslim environment. That is also the experience that I had–I feel I am given more respect from men when I cover.
Exactly; its not worth the time if you dont get answers.This thread is comical!
Ask a question, but dont get an answer it should be called.
No. Allah doesnt need to lie to us and he wouldnt ask us to worship idols. May be if you have anexample i would give you a more better answer.I have a question:
Is it true that according to Islam that you believe that Allah is SO transcendent, that if Allah told us to be idolaters we would have to do what he said? Basically that Allah can lie to humans if he wanted to for his own good pleasure?
Peace–I will try my best to answer In shaa Allah (God willing.) There are many questions, I’m not sure if I’ll be able to answer them all at once. Also because there are so many I will try to keep my answers as brief as possible.Hello,
Some questions on Islam:
What is Islam? Cream cheese? That it was spread by the sword?Islam today is said to be a religion of peace - if this is so, why is Islam spread by the sword?
And why should ye not fight in the cause of Allah and of those who, being weak, are ill-treated (and oppressed)?- Men, women, and children, whose cry is: “Our Lord! Rescue us from this town, whose people are oppressors; and raise for us from thee one who will protect; and raise for us from thee one who will help!” (4:75)Why is their the requirement to partake in Jihad?
Ignorance and a lack of understanding of the sanctity of human life in Islam. The Qur’an says that killing one innocent person is like killing all of humanity, and saving one person’s life is like saving all of humanity.Why are Muslims so willing to kill anyone for the slightest little perceived insult?
Throughout the history of the world, women are the most oppressed people. On the planet, more than any other people, women are the most oppressed. So what should we expect in a religion from God Almighty? One that preserves the rights of women. In fact, it’s something not seen in any other religion that I know of. Islam preserves the right of a woman to choose her husband, to get a divorce, to receive inheritance, among many other rights of women in Islam. People today think it’s a poor view of women which I as a Muslim find very odd. As a religion, Islam mandates certain responsibilities on men–fathers, husbands, etc.Why does Islam have such a poor view towards women?
The word “Qur’an” means “recitation.” A recitation, like poetry or opera, exists only in the original language. It is more than meaning, but the words, the order, their meter, flow, rhythm, etc., all that is part of it. This is like the Qur’an.Why can the Quran only be in Arabic?
Muslims get their beliefs from the Qur’an–which they believe was revealed by God Almighty. That said, the Qur’an says that God will preserve it.How does Isalm know that the Quran has not been corrupted - as they claim has happened to the Bible?
If every single “text” of the Qur’an–the pages and papers of every single written copy in the world–just disappeared… the entire thing could be reconstructed from memory. Because countless Muslims have memorized the entire Qur’an, word for word (I know several people myself who have done so!). (This is, by the way, the primary way of preservation.) The same Qur’an will be recited in Fez, Morocco, as you will find in Hyderabad, India, the same as in Singapore and Mogadishu and Kabul and London.What would happen to Islam if the Quran disappeared?
The Qur’an is central. Muslims must believe in God, and His messenger. Believing in the messenger means believing in the message as well. The Qur’an is the guidance, revealed to Muhammad, the message for mankind. So yes.Is the Quran absolutely necessary to Islam?
As part of the five daily prayers, a portion of the Qur’an is recited in every prayer. So I will answer yes, but understand that this is reciting, and not necessarily reading. Muslims should read the Qur’an–they should try to understand it, even if that means reading a translation only. If they can read it in Arabic that’s even better.Are Muslims required to read the Quran?
I don’t know how many. The Prophet of Islam said that there will be sects, and that there will be divisions, and explained how to know what is the truth–it is the one which adheres to his example and to the Qur’an.How many sects of Islam are there? Why?
Muslims believe that when people die they can no longer repent for sins, and that they might suffer (based on their faith/deeds) a punishment in the grave. And that one day everyone will be resurrected and judged for their faith and their actions, and that some people will go to Hellfire and some will go to Paradise.What do Muslims believe about the afterlife?
I do not think that this is an appropriate question to ask about the Lord of Worlds, the Creator of the Universe. Therefore I am not going to answer it.Does Allah have emotions that run away with him at times?
Glorified is Allah, God Almighty, above such things.Can Allah sin?
Friday is not so much a “holy day” as just the day of congregational prayer. Instead of the 2nd prayer around noon (of five daily) on Fridays Muslims will gather to listen to a sermon and then pray a shorter version of the noon prayer. Friday is considered special because it is said that Adam was created on a Friday (6th day) and that the world is going to end on a Friday, and also that it comes before the Jewish day of worship which is Saturday, and the Christian day which is Sunday.Why is Friday your weekly holy day?
You are absolutely welcome to attend one, if you can find a mosque near you, to observe first-hand. People will come early and begin praying extra optional prayers in the prayer hall. Then someone will make a call to prayer (adhaan in Arabic) signifying that the service is about to begin. Then someone will get up to give a sermon (khutbah), and will lecture to the people. Because people are lazy (What is a Friday gathering at a mosque like? What happens?
I hope I was able to sufficiently answer your questions.I guess that is enough for now.
Why not? The question (actually its two questions rolled into one) is not an assertion. It is a query. The answer is either yes or no. I see nothing inappropriate about it.I do not think that this is an appropriate question to ask about the Lord of Worlds, the Creator of the Universe. Therefore I am not going to answer it.
Now, I didn’t perceive any death threats in your reply, it did seem in the same vein as those who do. It was an “how dare you insult Islam!” type answer - though very mild in form.Why are Muslims so willing to kill anyone for the slightest little perceived insult?
I have a question:
Is it true that according to Islam that you believe that Allah is SO transcendent, that if Allah told us to be idolaters we would have to do what he said? Basically that Allah can lie to humans if he wanted to for his own good pleasure?
Because I replied to your post so recently I would like to follow-up now because my post is still fresh in my mind.Hello,
The answer cannot be either “yes” or “no,” because there is an assumption built in to it. I myself am not going to answer the question, because I am afraid that my answer will be wrong. And not afraid of you, but afraid before God. I don’t feel qualified to answer any question about God Almighty having “emotions.” The question doesn’t even make sense to me, because God Almighty, the Creator, is above the creation, not a part of it, so the question is set up in such a way that it cannot be answered.Why not? The question (actually its two questions rolled into one) is not an assertion. It is a query. The answer is either yes or no. I see nothing inappropriate about it.
For example, if you were to ask this question to a Catholic, the answer would be:
Then apply this answer to Islam if you want. The Islamic understanding of God and monotheism (tawheed) is in three ways–God is ONE in His Lordship, ONE is His Godhood, and ONE in His Names and Attributes. Names–like the Creator, Sustainer, the Loving One, Provider, etc. Attributes–like sitting above the throne, forgiving, etc. This is not emotions at all in the human sense. Anything beyond that I don’t know, and so I simply cannot answer.God in His divinity does not have emotions as humans understand emotion.
Eh? Because I didn’t want to answer one of your questions? What would you do if I were to insult your beliefs? I’m just curious. I think if anyone here gets a little bit too pushy with Catholicism they will get the boot.Now, I didn’t perceive any death threats in your reply, it did seem in the same vein as those who do. It was an “how dare you insult Islam!” type answer - though very mild in form.
When I asked this your reply was:
Ignorance and a lack of understanding of the sanctity of human life in Islam. The Qur’an says that killing one innocent person is like killing all of humanity, and saving one person’s life is like saving all of humanity.
Obviously, I meant those Muslims who do these things are ignorant.I am not sure if you meant I was ignorant or those Muslims who do these things are ignorant.
The same as the definition of an “innocent person” as you will find in the dictionary.You stated an innocent person - I ask what does an innocent person mean for a Muslim? What is the Islamic definition of “innocent person”?
a couple examples of totally out of proportion responses from the Muslim communities throughout the world:
the non-Muslim woman who allowed her Muslim students name a teddy bear Mohammad, sent to prison, was pardoned from death (why is this a capitol offense?)
the reaction to Pope Benedict’s speech in Regensburg
the cartoon of Mohammad in the Danish newspaper
And my answer is the same–the reason is ignorance on the part of the Muslims. The people who do this, are often not educated in the first place (in the Third World) and in all cases are not educated about Islam. I’m not going to defend stupidity–the problem is ignorance on the part of the Muslims. a teddy bear named Muhammad is not a capital offense–what you see is IGNORANCE ON THE PART OF THE MUSLIMS.all of these resulted in numerous death threats being made (I am not sure if any were carried out - I at least know the Pope is still alive)
I already gave you the “Islamic definition of peace.”Islam claims to be a religion of peace (I would ask for the Islamic definition of peace, too), but these and many other examples give the impression of Islam as a religion of violence and a very angry religion.
One more question:
I don’t know.Do Muslims watch the Ten Commandments (Charlton Heston, Yul Brenner)?
FYI:I don’t feel qualified to answer any question about God Almighty having “emotions.”
I don’t know. Like JMJ_coder said himself, God does not have emotions the way we humans understand them. The Qur’an says Allah “loves” this group, “does not love” that group–it happens a number of times in the Qur’an. But I know that does not mean “love” in the way that we humans understand it.FYI:
**Koran 002.190 **
Is that proof of an emotion or what?
- And fight in the way of Allah with those who fight with you, and do not exceed the limits, surely Allah does not love* those who exceed the limits.
![]()