Assault-weapons ban no guarantee mass shootings would decrease, data shows

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cavman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
When the government does not fear the people it is supposed to represent, it usually bodes poorly for the people.
The government isn’t afraid of private gun owners. Politicians are only afraid of two things: 1. Looking bad on television and 2. Not being reelected. The intended weapon of choice for the people is the ballot box not an uzi.
 
Jefferson’s philosophy in such matters was a radical product, even then, of a revolutionary age but the true purpose of second amendment cannot be ignored. It was only intended to provide for a means of defense in lieu of a standing army and, as Madison noted, a militia for, organized by, and at the command of each State in the event that the Federal Government formed its own standing army.

The idea that the people have a right to be a unique and unregulated defense force unto themselves is wrong and not supported by the historical stated intent of the founders. Furthermore; the current state of things would render such a position moot. The Federal Government does have a standing army solely at its command and the States do have their own militias solely at their command (the National Guard). The intended need for the second amendment no longer exists.

We don’t need unregulated Billy Joe Bob to pop out of a swamp with a musket to defend the nation or the States. Besides, the States lost that war and Congress made it clear that its not afraid of 100,000 gun-toting Tea Party activists milling around the Mall or their “second amendment solutions.” 😉
sorry i missed that,is there video?
 
The Federal Government does have a standing army solely at its command and the States do have their own militias solely at their command (the National Guard). The intended need for the second amendment no longer exists.
Those conditions existed prior to the ratification of the Constitution. Apparently the founders decided to include the “has nothing to do with limiting the power of the federal government” 2nd Amendment with 9 amendments all about limiting the power of the federal government because 9 isn’t an even number.
 
sorry i missed that,is there video?
The Beck rally.
Those conditions existed prior to the ratification of the Constitution. Apparently the founders decided to include the “has nothing to do with limiting the power of the federal government” 2nd Amendment with 9 amendments all about limiting the power of the federal government because 9 isn’t an even number.
Read Federalist number 46.
 
The Beck rally.

Read Federalist number 46.
I did and couldn’t figure out why you wanted me to as it seems to invalidate your claim. He is basically saying that an armed populace (like America of his time) and subordinate levels of government (here he means the States) could not be defeated by a tyrannical government (here meaning the federal level) and it’s limited sized army. Then he goes on an theorizes that the kingdoms in Europe keep their citizens disarmed out of fear of them and that if these citizens had the same advantages as the Americans those kingdoms would not last long. I’m sorry but that doesn’t speak to me as if the 2nd Amendment was just about militias and a federal army. Well it does, but first you have to ignore why the militias are needed (tyrannical government). Fed 46 also doesn’t disprove my point about a Federal Army and state militias already being in existence prior to the drafting and ratification of the Constitution.
 
Sen Feinstein posts proposed ‘assault weapons’ legislation - and it includes provisions on handguns and ‘grandfathered’ weapons
Last week, Sen. Dianne Feinstein promised to on the first day of new the Congress introduce legislation that would ban
so-called assault weapons and certain types of ammunition.

Now, the Californian senator has posted a summary of this legislation that would be introduced in 2013, showing more details about the provisions that she would hope would be included. And it doesn’t just have to do with what she calls “assault” weapons.

Here are a few bullet points on the guns that would be banned from sale, transfer, importation and manufacturing:
  • 120 specifically-named firearms
  • Certain other semiautomatic rifles, handguns, shotguns that can accept a detachable magazine and have one military characteristic
  • Semiautomatic rifles and handguns with a fixed magazine that can accept more than 10 rounds
Those who have acquired weapons recently under the pretense of being “grandfathered” in under prior laws see mention in Feinstein’s provisions as well. It requires these weapons to be registered under the National Firearms Act that will include collecting the following information
  • Background check of owner and any transferee;
  • Type and serial number of the firearm;
  • Positive identification, including photograph and fingerprint;
  • Certification from local law enforcement of identity and that possession would not violate State or local law; and
  • Dedicated funding for ATF to implement registration
In addition, Feinstein proposes banning large-capacity magazines, which for her includes those that can hold more than 10 rounds.

he proposed legislation would protect hunters and existing gun owners’ rights by:
  • Grandfathering weapons legally possessed on the date of enactment
  • Exempting over 900 specifically-named weapons used for hunting or sporting purposes and
  • Exempting antique, manually-operated, and permanently disabled weapons
The legislation also proposes to strength the 1994 Assault Weapons Ban and some state bans by forbidding “thumbhole stocks” and “bullet buttons,” among other suggestions. Thumbhole stocks allow for easier more ergonomic grip of the weapon and bullet buttons release an empty magazine quickly to allow the user to pop in a new one, which some have said skirts around existing assault weapon bans.

Check out the legislation’s summary in PDF form here.

“[The legislation] will be carefully focused on the most dangerous guns that have killed so many people over the years while protecting the rights of gun owners by exempting hundreds of weapons that fall outside the bill’s scope,” Feinstein said in a December 17 statement. “We must take these dangerous weapons of war off our streets.”
theblaze.com/stories/sen-feinstein-posts-proposed-assault-weapons-legislation-and-it-includes-provisions-on-handguns-and-grandfathered-weapons

Doubt this will pass in the House
 
Sen Feinstein posts proposed ‘assault weapons’ legislation - and it includes provisions on handguns and ‘grandfathered’ weapons

theblaze.com/stories/sen-feinstein-posts-proposed-assault-weapons-legislation-and-it-includes-provisions-on-handguns-and-grandfathered-weapons

Doubt this will pass in the House
Pointless, liberal, feel-good legislation that will have no impact whatsoever on violent crime. I hope Republicans tell her to take her legislation back to the Left Coast and stop wasting everyone’s time.
 
Pointless, liberal, feel-good legislation that will have no impact whatsoever on violent crime. I hope Republicans tell her to take her legislation back to the Left Coast and stop wasting everyone’s time.
Bill is expansive and could be used to ban all kinds of handguns infringing 2nd amendment. There was backlash against democrats in the senate after they supported the 1994 assault weapons ban. If they keep pushing bills that are more expansive than that as Sen Feinstein has, I suspect you are going too see backlash again in their reelection campaigns
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top