At what point do we call it quits?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bohm_Bawerk
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The problem I have with the talk of God’s will is that it essentially is a cover for, “let nature take it’s course”.
Actually, it means, obey the commandments, and let the end result be the end result. Don’t sin or do anything that is against God’s will, but do what you know you are supposed to do, and things will go according to God’s plan.

Nature has very little to do with it, and there is nothing “laissez-faire” about obeying God’s commandments - sometimes, it can be hard work, especially if it means apologizing to people you have offended, or getting out of the house and serving the needy.
 
I don’t think this is an ironic situation at all. It makes sense that God wants to do things on His terms and not yours in order to make you more holy. It sounds like you are using prayer to bribe Him and get what you want. It is not how it works. He is not your servant. The situation you are in is very common. God often goes with ‘tough love’ approach to soften hardened hearts and to free a person of pride. I have a feeling this is your problem. I suggest (again) you seek spiritual direction and figure out what it means to really pray. (Clue: Your will be done)
Hello Contra Mundum,

I have certainly thought about what exactly is “God’s will”, and I have heard it said how we should not treat God as a vending machine. But after some considerable reading, I believe God rarely answers “No” to a prayer. Either He answers “Yes”, “Yes, but not now”, or “Yes, but I have something better in mind for you”. There are certain prayers which He will not answer which tend to be synthetically contradictory - for instance, praying for those in Hell to be saved. But by and large God answers prayers. I do not believe (at least for now) that those in the Bible were exaggerating God’s omnipotence, and I don’t think they were crazy. Talks of “God’s will” often tend to imply “just accept your lot in life”. That’s not what my understanding of the Bible, and of those who have experienced miracles, leads me to conclude.

I also believe that God is more likely to hear someone who prays persistently than someone who just says a single prayer (e.g. Our Father). How exactly this mechanism works, or how God decides to answer remains a mystery. But the Bible lays out in several places that we are to pray persistently - such to the extent that Jesus began sweating drops of blood in His Agony. But that’s just what I’ve concluded. I’ll be interested to hear your take.
 
Jacob fought with God and was blessed by Him as a result (Genesis 32:28).

For me, and I’m sure it is with others, aren’t so lucky. I think I’ve been like Jacob for a while and I haven’t really seen anything tangible. I’m exhausted and knackered, to say the least. At what point do we just call it quits and give up on prayer/spirituality?
I totally understand you!!! I’ve been suffering from IBS for the past 4 years. Been to a multitude of doctors, myriad of tests…have gone to Mass/Adoration often, Healing Masses, Healing services, Charismatic stuff…have had an army of people praying for me, over me, etc…I’m still not healed and still no “accurate” diagnosis (“IBS” is what’s diagnosed when the docs can’t figure it out). My Faith has been tested to the max myself.

The only way I can handle it is “one day at a time”…just keep pluggin’ along and keep praying, even during the ‘dry’ times. I’m sure there’s a bigger picture that is in the works and we just can’t see it right now!
 
I totally understand you!!! I’ve been suffering from IBS for the past 4 years. Been to a multitude of doctors, myriad of tests…have gone to Mass/Adoration often, Healing Masses, Healing services, Charismatic stuff…have had an army of people praying for me, over me, etc…I’m still not healed and still no “accurate” diagnosis (“IBS” is what’s diagnosed when the docs can’t figure it out). My Faith has been tested to the max myself.

The only way I can handle it is “one day at a time”…just keep pluggin’ along and keep praying, even during the ‘dry’ times. I’m sure there’s a bigger picture that is in the works and we just can’t see it right now!
Hello barb,

Wow, that’s even longer than what I’ve been through! You are the bastion of perseverance :). I haven’t been to Adoration in my life before, and I was thinking about going to a Charismatic Mass. I sort of have a mental checklist of the things I’ve done and haven’t done. I’ve said virtually every novena that exists, every prayer that exists; it really is annoying and outright irritating. I would actually be somewhat comforted if a voice from Heaven just said “No”, so then at least I’ll know not to waste my time praying and I can move on with my life…

I hope your situation improves. That’s as much as I can say. Clearly prayer hasn’t been very effective :(. But you’re an inspiration to those who are in “hopeless cases”. Have you tried a novena to St. Jude?
 
We should pray with hope and faith. When we waver and don’t believe can we expect anything? (rhetorical, not directed at you)

I don’t think that means if you don’t believe hard enough you don’t get positive answers. I think the way God works in these situation is he may say yes or no, or perhaps, later.

St. Paul tells us that he prayed to have God answer his petition and God’s answer was my grace is sufficient for you, my power is made perfect in weakness.Job said if God gives us good things should we not expect Him to also give us evil things? And still praise Him? The point I make is we may not get what we want or need, but by maintaining an open prayerful dialogue with God, God’s strength helps us cope and also we may change in how we view a situation. This is why we should not give up hope,

Maybe you should take this up with a priest because it couls be that none of our comments will help you and there is something very imortant a stake here…you.

I will pray for you during this rough time.
 
Hello Contra Mundum,

I have certainly thought about what exactly is “God’s will”, and I have heard it said how we should not treat God as a vending machine. But after some considerable reading, I believe God rarely answers “No” to a prayer. Either He answers “Yes”, “Yes, but not now”, or “Yes, but I have something better in mind for you”. There are certain prayers which He will not answer which tend to be synthetically contradictory - for instance, praying for those in Hell to be saved. But by and large God answers prayers. I do not believe (at least for now) that those in the Bible were exaggerating God’s omnipotence, and I don’t think they were crazy. Talks of “God’s will” often tend to imply “just accept your lot in life”. That’s not what my understanding of the Bible, and of those who have experienced miracles, leads me to conclude.

I also believe that God is more likely to hear someone who prays persistently than someone who just says a single prayer (e.g. Our Father). How exactly this mechanism works, or how God decides to answer remains a mystery. But the Bible lays out in several places that we are to pray persistently - such to the extent that Jesus began sweating drops of blood in His Agony. But that’s just what I’ve concluded. I’ll be interested to hear your take.
It is very difficult to give advice given that we don’t know what your situation is and what you are praying for. Maybe what you are praying for should not happen although it probably seems to you that it absolutely must.

What I have learned from personal experience and from the saints, is that prayer is not a direct A to B connection. For example, there are a couple of things for which I’ve prayed my heart out and nothing. I’m hoping that the answer is ‘not yet’ rather than ‘no’. I’m not losing hope and have accpeted that I am not in control. I know that God will do what is best and in His time. On the other hand, there have been instances where I prayed for A but something happened (B and C) that somehow ‘fixed’ A. It was not a direct answer to my prayer but the prayer was granted nevertheless.

God’s will is not always clear and sometimes it really takes time for us to understand it. It doesn’t mean we should just accept our lot in life, it means we have to be patient. That’s why the best prayer is the Our Father. So simple: it addresses everything and reminds us that God is in charge. You have a lot of knowledge and obviously like to think about this in depth. I wonder if going back to basics would help: praying with simple words, no agenda except that God’s will be done. You might not get what you desire in this particular situation, but that doesn’t mean that your prayers will not be answered.
 
It is very difficult to give advice given that we don’t know what your situation is and what you are praying for. Maybe what you are praying for should not happen although it probably seems to you that it absolutely must.
I’ve mentioned in a few of my posts outside this thread that under standard conditions, I’m not a religious person. If I believed I needed something, I would go out and get it myself. There was one time a couple of years ago where I recall mocking a person who prayed. Praying about something - to me at least at that time - seemed so strange.

I was a nonbeliever for about 4 years. Anyways, to cut a long story short, I noticed steadily that things in my life just did not seem to work out. One day, as I was studying, I had this kind of intellectual experience where I could literally feel God’s rage. It didn’t feel nice at all. This happened about last year. This, in conjunction with a few other ‘‘coincidences’’ that happened earlier that year, led me to believe that I had to start attending Church again. I also deduced - through a lot of reading and discernment - that what I went through occurred because of my disbelief. To use the words of the Catechism, God’s “temporal punishment”.

It’s unfortunate I have to be vague, but the issue is just so long-winded and sobering that it can not be related to anyone.

Yes, I do believe it is an absolute must that the prayer is answered. If God didn’t want to answer the prayer, then that’s perfectly acceptable. He could have just informed me about this a year ago so I wouldn’t have wasted my time coming back to the Church and praying for so long. Because I feel just that…that I have wasted my time.
What I have learned from personal experience and from the saints, is that prayer is not a direct A to B connection. For example, there are a couple of things for which I’ve prayed my heart out and nothing. I’m hoping that the answer is ‘not yet’ rather than ‘no’. I’m not losing hope and have accpeted that I am not in control. I know that God will do what is best and in His time. On the other hand, there have been instances where I prayed for A but something happened (B and C) that somehow ‘fixed’ A. It was not a direct answer to my prayer but the prayer was granted nevertheless.
I understand that some people are given “crosses to bear” (most especially when it comes to certain diseases). I have asked myself this question on several occasions - whether this is really my cross to bear? Again, through a lot of reading and personal discernment, this is not my “cross to bear”. This is something that could easily be answered by God, but He chooses to remain reticent for the most part, and I’ve lost my patience.
God’s will is not always clear and sometimes it really takes time for us to understand it. It doesn’t mean we should just accept our lot in life, it means we have to be patient. That’s why the best prayer is the Our Father. So simple: it addresses everything and reminds us that God is in charge. You have a lot of knowledge and obviously like to think about this in depth. I wonder if going back to basics would help: praying with simple words, no agenda except that God’s will be done. You might not get what you desire in this particular situation, but that doesn’t mean that your prayers will not be answered.
I have tried everything lol.

*PS: On a lighter note, I never knew you were from Scotland. By default, I assume that posters are American. I’m from the country beneath you ;).
 
Yes, I do believe it is an absolute must that the prayer is answered. If God didn’t want to answer the prayer, then that’s perfectly acceptable. He could have just informed me about this a year ago so I wouldn’t have wasted my time coming back to the Church and praying for so long. Because I feel just that…that I have wasted my time.
I have a feeling that this is the problem. A year is not long. It took about 5 years for a prayer to be answered and it happened after I gave up. Some people spend a lifetime waiting. We can’t just snap our fingers and say “C’mon God, pronto, things to do, people to see, I’m a busy person.”

Basically, the life of faith is something that constantly changes, it develops and we grow as people. God wants all of us, not just an hour a week when we go to Mass, or a year of dedicated prayer. He wants everything. And when we consent and open our hearts He takes over. It is not the case that a number of prayers will be answered, we will feel good and secure and just get on with things. That can be a nice side-effect of things but the point is our complete transformation. God won’t quit until He gets what he wants.
Have you considered praying just so you can enter into a dialogue with God? Just to show Him you care? Put this problem aside for a while and ask Him to give you what you need.

Have I mentioned spiritual direction yet? 😉 I think you really need to let go of these ideas on how to get things done and how it all works. It sounds like you are approaching a scientific project and trying several methods until one works. In case nothing works than the problem is with the object of analysis, rather than with the scientist and his methods.

It is always nice to chat to neighbours, by the way.
 
Jacob fought with God and was blessed by Him as a result (Genesis 32:28).

For me, and I’m sure it is with others, aren’t so lucky. I think I’ve been like Jacob for a while and I haven’t really seen anything tangible. I’m exhausted and knackered, to say the least. At what point do we just call it quits and give up on prayer/spirituality?
I suppose it depends on what you’re expecting to get. As you know I had the experence of my father turning up in my bedroom the night he died, but I was an atheist at the time. Nor did I expect it.

There have been other experiences, but the one event which proved to me that God and the spiritual world were real beyond any doubt was my first “double whammy” (term coined by my Catholic psychiatrist who’d had the same experience). It was like a breath going through me in waves from head to foot, and it left me in no doubt whatsoever that God was real and that He knew my frame of mind.

However that came after 20 years of cruel and consistent ridicule and humiliation by my own father, the complete destruction of my confidence, failure at university, depression, a divorce, not much help in the vocational sense, social isolation due to being hard of hearing, a sense of not belonging anywhere, a period without employment, manipulation by another person to some extent, and not much help from God. In other words, it was only after a fair amount of suffering by frustration at the age of 28 that it happened for the first time.

It didn’t come easy. Nor has it always been easy since. Since then I’ve had the only “career” I have ever had destroyed by other people, one of whom is a “pastor”. Even the man I looked up to as my spiritual “father” discouraged me, by his own admission (and as predicted by my father the night he died). I don’t like God much sometimes, and even though I’ve had certain experiences, the concept of God as “Father” means very little to me.

I’ve got no doubt He exists, as I’ve had too many spiritual experiences to doubt that, and the first was the “double whammy” which I can specifically state occurred at Forest Glen Caravan Park just south of Nambour in SE Queensland around Christmas 1983. But there was a long period of frustration before that. As the hymn says, “I have tried you in fires of affliction”.

With all due respect to your enthusiasm, and knowing your sincerity from other exchanges, I think you’re expecting God to give you a sign before you’ve been tested. Abraham had to wait till he was in his dotage, Moses spent 40 years in the backside of the desert, David was on the run for years after being chosen. Paul may have been snatched up to the third heaven, but he was also whipped, scourged, stoned, jailed and beaten.

God’s pretty tough at times, and not in a hurry.

Sorry to be blunt, but you might have to develop patience like you wouldn’t believe. He’s there rest assured. You might get your own “double whammy” one day. But I can tell you this much - you’ll be put to the test before you do.
 
Hey B squared,
Just checking the thread to see if you’ve made any progress. I had a thought as well. Jesus sometimes went to secluded places to rest and pray, get away from it all. Is this an option for you? If you try it, consider including a daily journal, just poor your thoughts into it, your disappointments, anger, frustration, questions, obstacles. Don’t be afraid of offending God in your writing. Sometimes laying everything bare will allow you to see the problem in a new way. If not it is still good to get it off your chest. After you’re done with that, start writing all the blessings God has given you, everything, no matter how small, clean water from the tap, light bulbs, warm slippers, toilet paper, nothing is too trivial. Stay strong brother.
 
I have certainly thought about what exactly is “God’s will”, and I have heard it said how we should not treat God as a vending machine. But after some considerable reading, I believe God rarely answers “No” to a prayer. Either He answers “Yes”, “Yes, but not now”, or “Yes, but I have something better in mind for you”.
That is beautiful, and I like your take. In reflection, the stories in the Bible, and of Saints, they all willingly carried their “crosses” in life, maybe not at first, but in the end. All I can do is encourage you to still pray…
I would actually be somewhat comforted if a voice from Heaven just said “No”, so then at least I’ll know not to waste my time praying and I can move on with my life…
I can relate to that feeling! If God does not want to aid me in my current situation, I wish he would just tell me! LOL
 
I think there’s a lot of good advice here, and I’d just like to add that you shouldn’t feel as if struggling with (or even fighting) the Lord is some kind of spiritual failing. It is indeed a lot like Jacob wrestling that angel - and an important thing to take away from that is it meant Jacob was right up close to the angel. Hand to hand, face to face. When we fight with God at least we’re making contact. We’re keeping Him close. Keep fighting, keep struggling. He wants to be there with you. And remember that God is big enough. I used to feel guilty whenever I had doubts or was wrestling with some aspect of my relationship with God. But He’s big enough to handle that. He still loves me. And He still loves you.

Grace and peace to you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top