Atheism in Wikipedia-boycott it

  • Thread starter Thread starter eschator83
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

eschator83

Guest
Are you sensing the persistent and accelerating expansion of atheistic, anti-religious, and anti-Catholic comments in Wikipedia?
Try any sort of religious inquiry; I think you will be stunned and dismayed at a great percentage of them. Today I feel almost every inquiry I tried was grossly biased. The Wiki entry for my fifth or sixth inquiry, on age of enlightenment, set off my blood pressure and sent me looking for my old draft posts to protest Wiki. If I thought the problem was just Wiki, I might be tempted to shrug it off as only the inherent pain freedom of speech, coupled with the general deterioration of moral standards, especially honesty. But most search engines give first place position to Wiki–and that seems like the new world, atheist, universalist conspiracy. I ask others to comment and offer other specific examples. Also, I ask someone to do a poll (I don’t know how) to see to what extent we agree on this:
yes-I’ll boycott
yes-but not a big problem
don’t care
too busy
no-don’t see atheism-I looked
no-didn’t look but don’t remember any and doubt it
Or please use whatever format you think best.
 
HUH! I haven’t noticed that yet and thought I had a good propaganda and BS detector too. I start paying closer attention.
 
Out of question, what did you even notice on the Age of Enlightenment page? If it’s just the fact that it mentions a shift away from religious lifestyles, that’s because it was what actually happened. Wikipedia is a scholarly website. Excluding the Criticism of [Insert Religion Here] pages, it seems fairly neutral to me.

The MOST I’ve seen, ignoring Criticism pages is gasp they didn’t post the Nicene Creed claiming it was copyrighted. :eek:
 
I have also noticed an increase in hostility on wikipedia, especially towards Catholicism. I usually just edit whatever it is and make it sound more neutral, because that is what an encyclopedia should be.
 
I haven’t noticed what you described. However, I think just about anybody can add information to Wikipedia and I take anything I read there with a grain of salt.
 
Some are insanely anti-Catholic. As a hint, try clicking the “Talk” tab next to the “Article” tab at the upper left of the top of a wiki entry. It contains all the arguments about what to include or not include on a page, what was edited and the reason why, what constitutes fact and what constitutes opinion and it all can get pretty vitriolic and full of claims of partisanship and bias by both sides of an issue, and can often be more interesting than the entry itself.
 
I think many Wikipedia articles are based on the false premise that “neutrality” is acheived by presenting two or more conflicting/contrasting views. Like as long as every voice gets a chance to be heard, somehow it’s “neutral”. It is not “neutral” to give equal airtime to crackpots, and then expect an uninformed reader to be able to discern who the crackpots are. It’s very post-modern that way.

There is something to be said for old-fashioned encyclopedias like Britannica. These would tend toward more “conservative” (not in the political sense) academic consensus. I would recommend reading side-by-side a traditional source, and then Wikipedia, and then you get an idea of what all the fringe voices are. Only problem is that a traditional encyclopedia isn’t going to give you an episode-by-episode synopsis of “Battlestar Galactica” and all the other triviality that fills Wikipedia.
 
I think many Wikipedia articles are based on the false premise that “neutrality” is acheived by presenting two or more conflicting/contrasting views. Like as long as every voice gets a chance to be heard, somehow it’s “neutral”. It is not “neutral” to give equal airtime to crackpots, and then expect an uninformed reader to be able to discern who the crackpots are. It’s very post-modern that way.

There is something to be said for old-fashioned encyclopedias like Britannica. These would tend toward more “conservative” (not in the political sense) academic consensus. I would recommend reading side-by-side a traditional source, and then Wikipedia, and then you get an idea of what all the fringe voices are. Only problem is that a traditional encyclopedia isn’t going to give you an episode-by-episode synopsis of “Battlestar Galactica” and all the other triviality that fills Wikipedia.
:clapping:
 
I think a lot of people consider atheism (or agnosticism) itself to be the neutral POV on religious matters. I do think it’s hard to be neutral on topics that many people disagree about, since you can’t really just dismiss people’s views without evidence. For instance, if Atheists can’t dismiss our POV even though it runs on faith and not evidence, I don’t see why anyone else would be able to dismiss the POV of, say, a conspiracy theorist. It’s hard for secular sites to stay balanced- it isn’t like a Catholic site, where anything not in line with catholic teaching can be removed.

Anyway, I wouldn’t boycott wikipedia unless it did something much worse than defaulting to an atheist POV every now and then, since I consider it a useful tool. I’m not sure how boycotting will help anyway, since wikipedia runs on donations and not ads or anything else that a boycott would affect. 🤷
 
Wikipedia has never been a source of information for me. Usually a waste of time.
 
I think many Wikipedia articles are based on the false premise that “neutrality” is acheived by presenting two or more conflicting/contrasting views. Like as long as every voice gets a chance to be heard, somehow it’s “neutral”. It is not “neutral” to give equal airtime to crackpots, and then expect an uninformed reader to be able to discern who the crackpots are. It’s very post-modern that way.

There is something to be said for old-fashioned encyclopedias like Britannica. These would tend toward more “conservative” (not in the political sense) academic consensus. I would recommend reading side-by-side a traditional source, and then Wikipedia, and then you get an idea of what all the fringe voices are. Only problem is that a traditional encyclopedia isn’t going to give you an episode-by-episode synopsis of “Battlestar Galactica” and all the other triviality that fills Wikipedia.
Very true. I pretty much only use Wikipedia to look up info on TV episodes or music groups.
 
What about Conservapedia? One of Phyllis Schlafly’s sons created it.
They think evolution is fabricated, even on the theistic evolution page.

conservapedia.com/Secularized_Language They think Christmas, Easter, the Fourth of July, Christian, old man, afterlife, fetus, pregnant, and first name are all secular terms

They think the theory of relativity is a liberal conspiracy

conservapedia.com/John_1-7_(Translated) Their translation of the Bible mangles John even worse than the Watchtower Society “In the beginning was the Truth; its Word was with God; its Perfection was God.”
 
conservapedia.com/John_1-7_(Translated) Their translation of the Bible mangles John even worse than the Watchtower Society “In the beginning was the Truth; its Word was with God; its Perfection was God.”
It’s not even a grammatically accurate translation like the Watchtower. They at least had the decency to only play with articles. “In principio erat Verbum, et Verbum erat apud Deum, et Deus erat Verbum.” How did they get Verbum to alternately mean Truth, Word or Perfection? Truth and perfection aren’t even valid translations of λόγος

Nt to mention that their page on liberals is FAR more biased than anything I’ve EVER seen on Wikipedia
 
I haven’t trusted Wikipedia as a good source of information ever since I visited the page about Vietnam and found a bunch of racist slurs. The whole idea of an encyclopedia that anyone can contribute to and edit is just too prone to mistakes, fabrications, and bias.
 
I definitely agree with Razanir that Conservapedia is not a reliable source. 😦

Honestly, I always thought it was good practice to question everything one read. 🤷 I don’t see why we can’t accept wikipedia as one semi-reliable source in a sea of other semi-reliable sources. If the Church can’t have a teaching about everything that exists, people are always going to have to use their own reason and judgement and do their research thoroughly before coming to a conclusion about most matters. Why would we avoid wikipedia just because it is, in fact, biased? Isn’t almost everything? :confused:

Anyways, I suppose I’ll say there is a problem and it isn’t major enough to merit a boycott. I’d just recommend being cautious with all research.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top