Atheist Groups Promote a Holiday Message: Join Us

  • Thread starter Thread starter Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My question would be, why use any religion’s holy book to make an atheist argument? I would think atheists would have their own arguments for their belief (or lack there of) that could stand on their own merits. Using a holy book, no matter what the religion, comes off as being hateful more so than logical. And why advertise anti-religious advertisements around a particularly popular religious holiday? Would it be hateful to post anti-Muslim advertisements around Eid? If it is, why is Christmas/Hanukkah any different? “Hateful” is something the ads are claiming atheists are not. So it’s self defeating I would think.
Atheism is the rejection of belief in a god. If a Christian completely looses his or her belief in his or her own god and does not gain conviction in any other god, he or she becomes an atheist. That’s why using a religion’s holy book to disprove that religion may lead to atheism.

BTW, the believing that a proposition is not so is a default that doesn’t have to be proven. For the existence of Santa or unicorns, one aught to believe they don’t exist until it is proven otherwise.
 
I’m not familiar with the book.
What types of things does the author define as “charitable” vs not? For example, is giving to Kiva’s considered charitable (as its micro-loans, not exactly a gift)? Does volunteering time count?
I do not know what Kiva’s is.

Brooks’s first foray into the limelight was in 2006 with Who Really Cares: The Surprising Truth about Compassionate Conservatism.4] Originating in his research on philanthropy and drawing on survey data, he articulates a charity gap between the 75 percent of Americans who donate to charitable causes and the rest who do not. Brooks argues that there are three cultural values that best predict charitable giving: religious participation, political views, and family structure. Ninety-one percent of people who identify themselves as religious are likely to give to charity, writes Brooks, as opposed to 66 percent of people who do not. The religious giving sector is just as likely to give to secular programs as it is to religious causes. Those who think government should do more to redistribute income are less likely to give to charitable causes, and those who believe the government has less of a role to play in income redistribution tend to give more. Finally, people who couple and raise children are more likely to give philanthropically than those who do not. The more children there are in a family, the more likely that a family will donate to charity. One of Brooks’s most controversial findings was that political conservatives give more, despite having incomes that are on average 6 percent lower than liberals.

Brooks adopts what he calls a "polemic"1] tone when offering recommendations, urging that philanthropic giving not be crowded out by government programs and that giving must be cultivated in families and communities. He admits being surprised by his conclusion: "These are not the sort of conclusions I ever thought I would reach when I started looking at charitable giving in graduate school, 10 years ago. I have to admit I probably would have hated what I have to say in this book."4]

Who Really Cares was widely reviewed and critiqued. Many commentators thought that Brooks played up the role of religion too much, arguing that a charity gap is largely erased when religious giving is not considered. Eugene Volokh writes, "Although the liberal v. conservative split is the hook for the book, the data are not nearly as stark as the hype surrounding the book might indicate."5]unreliable source?] In February 2007, after the release of Who Really Cares, Brooks briefed President George W. Bush and first lady Laura Bush on his findings.6] Later that year, Brooks joined the American Enterprise Institute as a visiting scholar.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_C._Brooks#Who_Really_Cares

amazon.com/Who-Really-Cares-Compasionate-Conservatism/dp/0465008216

This study has been done by Brooks A. C. in 2003 for the Hoover Institution, part of Stanford University.

Making 30,000 observations over 50 different communities, they found that religious people are much more likely to donate money to charities (91 percent to 66 percent) more likely to volunteer time (67 percent to 44 percent). The amount they give is also quite different with religious people averaging $2,210, compared to only $642 among the secular, even though incomes and education levels are virtually the same. Religious people’s giving is not just to religious causes either, since they also out give secular people when donating to secular causes.

hoover.org/publications/policyreview/3447051.html

hoover.org/
 
The timing of the atheist ads seems to indicate intolerance. They would be better off wishing Christians a Merry Christmas, and evangelizing them in authentic ways during less offensive times.

However, this type of decent treatment is in short supply among those who are insulted by the caricature of religion they think people believe in. This comes from an unfairly unjust and false belief in the effects of religion in history.
 
I’m an atheist and I’m one out of five individuals in a self-financed charity that has given away over a million dollars to charity in the last decade.

I know this is an extraordinary claim. I wish I could back it up, but it would be imprudent for me to provide details.
Well done, charity is good.
 
A warrior who is risking his own life beside his fellow warrior is both being mutually cooperative and unselfish (it’s unselfish for an individual warrior to aggressively fight).
it’s NOT unselfish for an individual warrior to aggressively fight. It is in one’s self-interest and collective self-interest to aggressively fight. win war faster, go home faster.
Define unselfish. I am making this request because it seems that your usage of that word differs from conventional usages of that word.
Zero self-interest, either individually or collectively.
I was addressing your post in which you seemed to be saying that Darwinian evolution provided no explanation for unselfishness:
There isn’t.
Why would an atheist choose to work with Mother Theresa’s order as opposed to working for another organization? I’m sure that if you had the choice between working for a Muslim charity and a Catholic charity, you would choose the Catholic charity. You would especially choose the Catholic charity is the Muslim organization had the means to relieve suffering by administering pain killers, but chose not to.
And if there really was no need for religion to be a morally decent person, we would see the atheist equivalent of Mother Theresa spending their life unselfishly serving the poor.

We don’t.
 
it’s NOT unselfish for an individual warrior to aggressively fight. It is in one’s self-interest and collective self-interest to aggressively fight. win war faster, go home faster.
It would be in one’s best interest if everyone else fought aggressively while he backed off and tried to survive by playing things safe. An individual warrior is more likely to die if he fights more aggressively, thus, to fight aggressively instead of playing it safe while everyone else fought aggressively, that is unselfish. It is in the collective interest for everyone to fight aggressively, which may explain why people cooperate well for the benefit of others (or behave in a moral way). This is partly way you’re assertion that there is no explanation for unselfish behavior given by Darwinian evolution is not true.
BobObob;7309047:
Why would an atheist choose to work with Mother Theresa’s order as opposed to working for another organization? I’m sure that if you had the choice between working for a Muslim charity and a Catholic charity, you would choose the Catholic charity. You would especially choose the Catholic charity is the Muslim organization had the means to relieve suffering by administering pain killers, but chose not to.
And if there really was no need for religion to be a morally decent person, we would see the atheist equivalent of Mother Theresa spending their life unselfishly serving the poor.
You didn’t actually answer my question about why an atheist would choose working with Mother Theresa as opposed to an organization which actually tries to relieve suffering.

There doesn’t have to be an atheist equivalent of Mother Theresa if there’s no need for religion to be a morally decent person . Why would there have to be? To say that a lack of an atheist with certain levels of virtue would mean that there is a need for religion for people to be morally decent is a non-sequitor (meaning, it does not logically follow). Plus, atheists who do good things as likely to have their atheism advertised as those who are religious would have their religiosity advertised.

Are you aware that Mother Theresa had the means to alleviate pain with painkillers, but chose not to?

Put it this way, lets suppose, for the sake of argument, that Mother Theresa was an extremely virtuous individual (as opposed to a sadist who let people suffer) and that there happened to be no atheist who had as good, or better, qualities than she had. This would in no way mean that there is a need for religion in order to be a morally decent person. It could be that she had those good qualities in spite of her religion. Also, one aught to remember that atheists are far outnumbered, so having one particular religious person who appears more virtuous than everyone else is almost to be expected.

In case you reply to me, I do want to warn you that I probably won’t be able to respond, except for maybe brief responses, for a few days.
 
This is both a bad and good thing. First the bad: Americans aren’t usually an intellectual people because the leisure time that one needs to really think about stuff intellectually is not seen as productive. People would rather be busy doing something else. And so, it is really easy to fall into the kind of banal atheism that seems to be making the rounds. Now The good: maybe this encourage people who are already religious to think more critically and deeply. I am confident this is key to defeating the shallow atheism of today.I have noticed that when atheists stop wanting to contradict theists for the sake of contradicting them, and they actually start pursuing ultimate questions themselves, they radically soften or change their views. I have seen this over and over again.
 
Evangelical atheism? I’m not sure how I feel about that. I don’t much like Christian or Muslim evangelists, I can’t imagine why I’d like this kind. 😃
 
Because there is no atheistic reason to be unselfish.

Period.
Forgive me if I’m wrong, it seems as though you’re implying that unselfishness is an all-or-nothing thing. Atheists generally don’t take vows of poverty, obedience, and chastity.

You’re right- most atheists won’t give their whole life to a religious organization.

I disagree with you that this is a bad thing. If this is the only life they have and there is no afterlife at all, why are you asking them to give up their friends, family, home, job, and comfort to prove their unselfishness?

There are plenty of people who make smaller sacrifices and find way to donate their time and/or money in a way that suits them better. I enjoy making blankets for a charity that gives blankets to needy families.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top