I’m not familiar with the book.
What types of things does the author define as “charitable” vs not? For example, is giving to Kiva’s considered charitable (as its micro-loans, not exactly a gift)? Does volunteering time count?
I do not know what Kiva’s is.
Brooks’s first foray into the limelight was in 2006 with Who Really Cares: The Surprising Truth about
Compassionate Conservatism.
4] Originating in his research on philanthropy and drawing on survey data, he articulates a
charity gap between the 75 percent of Americans who donate to charitable causes and the rest who do not. Brooks argues that there are three cultural values that best predict charitable giving: religious participation, political views, and family structure. Ninety-one percent of people who identify themselves as religious are likely to give to charity, writes Brooks, as opposed to 66 percent of people who do not. The religious giving sector is just as likely to give to secular programs as it is to religious causes. Those who think government should do more to redistribute income are less likely to give to charitable causes, and those who believe the government has less of a role to play in income redistribution tend to give more. Finally, people who couple and raise children are more likely to give philanthropically than those who do not. The more children there are in a family, the more likely that a family will donate to charity. One of Brooks’s most controversial findings was that political conservatives give more, despite having incomes that are on average 6 percent lower than liberals.
Brooks adopts what he calls a "
polemic"
1] tone when offering recommendations, urging that philanthropic giving not be crowded out by government programs and that giving must be cultivated in families and communities. He admits being surprised by his conclusion: "These are not the sort of conclusions I ever thought I would reach when I started looking at charitable giving in graduate school, 10 years ago. I have to admit I probably would have hated what I have to say in this book."
4]
Who Really Cares was widely reviewed and critiqued. Many commentators thought that Brooks played up the role of religion too much, arguing that a charity gap is largely erased when religious giving is not considered.
Eugene Volokh writes, "Although the liberal v. conservative split is the hook for the book, the data are not nearly as stark as the hype surrounding the book might indicate."
5]
unreliable source?] In February 2007, after the release of Who Really Cares, Brooks briefed President
George W. Bush and first lady
Laura Bush on his findings.
6] Later that year, Brooks joined the
American Enterprise Institute as a visiting scholar.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_C._Brooks#Who_Really_Cares
amazon.com/Who-Really-Cares-Compasionate-Conservatism/dp/0465008216
This study has been done by Brooks A. C. in 2003 for the Hoover Institution, part of Stanford University.
Making 30,000 observations over 50 different communities, they found that religious people are much more likely to donate money to charities (91 percent to 66 percent) more likely to volunteer time (67 percent to 44 percent). The amount they give is also quite different with religious people averaging $2,210, compared to only $642 among the secular, even though incomes and education levels are virtually the same. Religious people’s giving is not just to religious causes either, since they also out give secular people when donating to secular causes.
hoover.org/publications/policyreview/3447051.html
hoover.org/