Attending Services at Non-Catholic Christian Congregations

  • Thread starter Thread starter obvious_ron
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I just don’t get the where’s and why’s of being so anti-(insert other Christian here).
It is just human behavior rooted in our fleshly or carnal nature. We are tribal creatures, and tend to harbor animosity and suspicion against those not of our tribe.

Jesus calls us to rise above our carnal nature, and love others as He has loved us. The only people Jesus criticized were those of His own tribe, who claimed they belonged to God, but behaved opposite. He was welcoming of all those who were not part of his “tribe”, and affirmed that many of them had more faith than the Jews.
 
I have been advised by my spiritual director that attending my fiance’s church is not wrong as long as I make sure to fulfill my Sunday obligation as well.
 
When the two of us met with my priest, we filled out a form to be sent to the diocese for a request for a dispensation to marry at her church with her pastor officiating.
 
Unless they don’t believe in sacramental marriage : / I have not met one that does, what nonCatholic denomination believes in sacramental marriage?
 
When the two of us met with my priest, we filled out a form to be sent to the diocese for a request for a dispensation to marry at her church with her pastor officiating.
so how do you plan to raise the children?
 
Sorry, I guess I may not follow.

I’m a non-Catholic baptized Christian…, when we were getting ready for our wedding my wife got all the paperwork, permission, we did precana, and were married in the Catholic church.

Our marriage is sacramental.
 
apparently, our marriage would be accepted as sacramental with a canonical dispensation from the diocese.
 
I’m non-denominational.

Still not following…What does that have to do with the Catholic church recognizing whether or not our marriage is a sacrament?
 
I’ve been married to a Presbyterian for almost 25 years and we were dating/ close friends/ what you call it for 10 years before we got married. And in all that time, I have never stepped foot in a Presbyterian church and made it clear from the beginning of our relationship that I was not going to do that. I would have made an exception for a wedding or a funeral - as it turned out, the “funerals” in his family have consisted of short wakes/ prayer services occurring at the funeral home so there was no church service involved - but no way would I go hanging around some Protestant church on a regular basis enjoying the “community”, nor would I have married anyone who expected that of me.

I was raised by what thistle said: you don’t go to a non-Catholic church unless it is some very special occasion. My mother actually looked askance even at that because as a girl pre-Vatican II, her mother and her priest would not let her go to the wedding of a Catholic girl who was getting married in a Protestant church. I realize the rules have become more relaxed over the years and I have been to several Protestant or non-denominational weddings among my circle of friends. I also might stop by the Protestant church next door to one of my houses no more than once a year, as they are my neighbors and I want to be neighborly. I can hear their choir right through my wall anyway as they’re 10 feet away, and I chat with them coming and going out of their church, or when we need to discuss yard work and that sort of thing. But that’s about it.
 
How has your marriage been? Do you see any difficulties by not being able to share this part of your lives together?
 
I’m confused…why do you belong to a church that does not teach sacramental marriage if you believe in Sacramental marriage?
 
Nope. In fairness, I will say that my husband did not like to attend Protestant services even before he met me. I asked him why he didn’t go to his own church when we met, and he said he didn’t like sermons. His mother also didn’t go to church much. His father went from time to time, more as a social activity than out of any great religious fervor. Like I said, if he or his family had been really fervent and had been pushing me to go to Presbyterian church with them, this marriage would not have happened and we probably would have broken up. I just was not going to do that. Ever.

I generally do not make him come to the Catholic church with me unless it is a special occasion or we need to go together because we are going someplace else afterwards, such as to lunch. I also spend a lot of time on the road so I am attending by myself frequently as a matter of necessity. We did not have kids; if we had had kids, I probably would have pushed the idea of “Daddy” attending Mass a little harder than I did. When he comes to Mass, he is fine with it and well behaved, though I bicker with him a bit over genuflecting and that sort of thing.
 
Last edited:
FYI, selected Anglican jurisdictions account matrimony one of the 7 sacraments.

Anglicans, as you may know, are not uniform on most anything.
 
I’m confused too…

What does what I believe have to do with the Catholic church recognizing my wife and I’s marriage as a sacrament?
 
Um…OK, ya…I got that.

I’m so confused.

What does that have to do with my marriage being viewed as a Sacrament (which it is) by the Catholic church?

You stated up thread that Catholic/Non-Catholic marriages wouldn’t be a Sacrament (which is wrong, given the correct steps prior are taken).
.
 
So if I understand what you are saying…you belong to a church that does not believe in sacramental marriage but you believe in sacramental marriage?
 
Um…I did.

It has nothing to do with what I believe.

A marriage between a Catholic and baptized NC IS a sacrament in the Catholic Church (given the proper permission is given). @tifischer asked how a marriage can be sacramental between a Catholic and NC, and I answered.

Somewhere shortly there after we made a hard right to my faith, which has nothing to do with whether or not the Catholic Church recognizes my marriage as a sacrament (which it is).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top