Attraction and the near occasion of sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter McatholicN
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

McatholicN

Guest
There’s a girl I like who goes to my Church. When I’m around her I often have impure thoughts (which I wish I didn’t have) in which I, unfortunately, consent to often.

Our parish is closing and so we’re having a big party tonight, but I was worried that I could be committing a mortal sin by placing myself in the near occasion of sin.

Kind of a wierd question, but…

Thanks for any help!
 
Also, is it a sin to put one’s self into temptation, even if there is no history of sin there, or very little?
 
Attraction to the opposite sex is normal and not sinful. Thoughts can also arise out of the attraction and obviously they will be sexual in nature. You mention that you wish that you did not “go there” with your thoughts but that it just happens. I would bring this up in confession but at face value I would say that you are not sinning unless you are causing those thoughts to linger and giving full consent to the entertainment of those thoughts. Otherwise I believe that every man would not be able to have an attraction to a particular woman since it will involve a sexual attraction at some point.

So, again, I believe that you need to bring this up to your confessor so that he can help you to discern whether or not you are lusting or just experiencing normal sexual attraction… God bless…teachccd 🙂
 
Well, it’s pretty tricky when the near occasion of sin is your own church. Most other occasions for sin can be avoided, but you can’t avoid going to church. If it’s only one particular girl that causes you to sin, then you could try going to a different service. But I’d guess if one girl has this affect, then other girls at other services will be a potential problem too.

Firstly, are you sure your thoughts are sinful? Finding girls attractive is fine; God intended this. Lustful thoughts are not, or more specifically dwelling on lustful thoughts. For most men, lustful thoughts enter our consciousness without our intention, so we can’t help this, but we can avoid dwelling on them. Since it will be impossible to avoid seeing attractive women at church and in other parts of our lives, you need to find ways to tackle this problem…the dwelling on lustful thoughts. Being at church should be the easiest occasion to find something else to focus on to eliminate impure thoughts…the tabernacle, the altar, any icons around the church. It’s hard to be thinking impure thoughts when you focus your gaze onto a crucifix. I presume your party will be in a church hall or the like, so might not have icons around, but I presume your priest and maybe other religious will be there, so think of what the priest represents to the parish, as Christs representative…again, you bring your thoughts back to Christ, and the more you do this, the harder it is to indulge impure thoughts. Good luck, and I’ll say a prayer for you tonight.
 
PS I posted the above before reading what teachccd said. Well said teachccd!
 
There’s a girl I like who goes to my Church. When I’m around her I often have impure thoughts (which I wish I didn’t have) in which I, unfortunately, consent to often.

Our parish is closing and so we’re having a big party tonight, but I was worried that I could be committing a mortal sin by placing myself in the near occasion of sin.

Kind of a wierd question, but…

Thanks for any help!
It is not a sin to go to a party!!

As all your threads indicate you have a problem with scrupulosity this is something we cannot solve for you.
Please talk to your priest.
 
I often have impure thoughts (which I wish I didn’t have) in which I, unfortunately, consent to often.

Kind of a wierd question, but…

Thanks for any help!
Not a wierd question. St. Pau said that there is no temptation except that which is common to man. We all experience what you are experiencing. It is not wierd at all. Your question is the exact reason why I sit near the front at Mass.

I would pose a question in response. Do you believe in God?

No, not “Do you believe that God exists?” but do you believe that God is,everything he claims to be and that he can take that struggle away from you? If you believe that, then what are you willing to do to so that God takes it away from you?

Most people will tell you to avoid the near occasion of sin and that is certainly necessary but I would counter that God didn’t take on flesh and die on a cross to give us coping mechanisms. Christ came to really and truly transform us into his likeness. Of course we will always struggle with sin and lust due to our fallen nature blah blah blah…

Maybe I’m not being practical or realistic but I just think that most of the time, myself included, people are looking for a quick fix and are not willing to do what it takes to actually be healed of these sins so they don’t come back, namely pray pray pray in front of the blessed sacrament, confess confess confess, receive the Eucharist often and seek God always, 24x7.

Instead of accusing you of scrupulosity, I would rather think that you are struggling with something. Trust God and actively seek him in very real, concrete ways such as reading books, listening to MP3 and the methods mentioned above. Seeing a priest wouldn’t hurt either.

-Tim-
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top