[B][SIZE="3"]Is your priest creative as mine?[/SIZE][/B]

  • Thread starter Thread starter wisdomseeker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wisdomseeker

Guest
Is it appropriate for the priest to be calling people to the Sanctuary to tell their stories after the homilies?

does your parish does such a thing?

what is going on in the CC? every priest does a different thing in different parishes.

God bless all.
 
Is it appropriate for the priest to be calling people to the Sanctuary to tell their stories after the homilies?

does your parish does such a thing?

what is going on in the CC? every priest does a different thing in different parishes.

God bless all.
Not after the homily, but occasionally at the time of the announcements he may ask someone to give a brief witness for a specific reason, such as a couple may get up and briefly tell how God has blessed them in their practice of stewardship during the Stewardship drive. This type of thing happens only once or twice a year, always for a specific reason.
 
Ugh, definitely not appropriate. It’s also not appropriate during the announcements – GIRM 90 covers the concluding rites and allows only "rief announcements, if they are necessary." This sort of thing should be saved for after the final dismissal if it’s to be done at all. Oh wait, people won’t stay for that? Then no one wants to hear "witnesses."
 
It is a Liturgical Abuse – not allowed. It is in violation of the Rubrics, the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM). You should tell him it’s not okay.
YES. It’s that serious.
 
It is a Liturgical Abuse – not allowed. It is in violation of the Rubrics, the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM). You should tell him it’s not okay.
YES. It’s that serious.
Yes. thank you. he doesnt care about what i say. he and the parishoners think they own the Church. i believe that the people has become very anti pope also. today, i heard a parishoner calling for the pope to step down. they dont want to recognize the pope is the authority of the Church. they are franciscans.
 
Yes. thank you. he doesnt care about what i say. he and the parishoners think they own the Church. i believe that the people has become very anti pope also. today, i heard a parishoner calling for the pope to step down. they dont want to recognize the pope is the authority of the Church. they are franciscans.
…And I’m guessing that their complaint isn’t that the Pope is too liberal either. 😛
 
Time to find another parish. “These Boots were made for walkin’”.
 
Yes. thank you. he doesnt care about what i say. he and the parishoners think they own the Church. i believe that the people has become very anti pope also. today, i heard a parishoner calling for the pope to step down. they dont want to recognize the pope is the authority of the Church. they are franciscans.
Ultimate hypocrisy. If they were traditionalists, they’d be called sedevacantists. As it stands, however, they are credited and praised for being in full communion with the Vatican.
 
Ultimate hypocrisy. If they were traditionalists, they’d be called sedevacantists. As it stands, however, they are credited and praised for being in full communion with the Vatican.
and so they think.
 
and so they think.
This is quite serious. I would suggest informing the priest that parishioners are openly talking about the Pope while at the parish. If they have an opinion than whatever, but to talk like this openly in front of others while in a Catholic parish, should not be allowed. Maybe the priest can speak with them about it.

As for the liturgical abuse, I recommend talking to the priest about it. If it continues, contact your Bishop. You shouldn’t feel trapped in to attending a parish because it is the lesser of two “evils.” You have a right to sound doctrine.
 
This is quite serious. I would suggest informing the priest that parishioners are openly talking about the Pope while at the parish. If they have an opinion than whatever, but to talk like this openly in front of others while in a Catholic parish, should not be allowed. Maybe the priest can speak with them about it.

As for the liturgical abuse, I recommend talking to the priest about it. If it continues, contact your Bishop. You shouldn’t feel trapped in to attending a parish because it is the lesser of two “evils.” You have a right to sound doctrine.
i agree with you. but i am afraid it is the priests who are leading the people as such.

i dont participate in their teachings or gatherings because i am afraid of what they are teaching the people is not Catholic teachings.
 
Ultimate hypocrisy. If they were traditionalists, they’d be called sedevacantists. As it stands, however, they are credited and praised for being in full communion with the Vatican.
That’s an excellent point.
 
i agree with you. but i am afraid it is the priests who are leading the people as such.

i dont participate in their teachings or gatherings because i am afraid of what they are teaching the people is not Catholic teachings.
I still think you should discuss this with your priest. If he does not know that people disagree with what they’re doing, they’re going to think that everything is just fine and maybe push the envelope a little more. I would also be very surprised if your priest was ok with parishioners openly calling for the Pope to step down while at the parish. This can cause scandal on so many levels and the priest needs to address it.

I will be praying for you. I wish you weren’t so trapped there! I’m blessed to be in an area where there are several options and I wish everyone (like you) had these options.
 
I still think you should discuss this with your priest. If he does not know that people disagree with what they’re doing, they’re going to think that everything is just fine and maybe push the envelope a little more. I would also be very surprised if your priest was ok with parishioners openly calling for the Pope to step down while at the parish. This can cause scandal on so many levels and the priest needs to address it.

I will be praying for you. I wish you weren’t so trapped there! I’m blessed to be in an area where there are several options and I wish everyone (like you) had these options.
thank you. i might go and talk to the bishop if i can.
 
Yes. thank you. he doesnt care about what i say. he and the parishoners think they own the Church. i believe that the people has become very anti pope also. today, i heard a parishoner calling for the pope to step down. they dont want to recognize the pope is the authority of the Church. they are franciscans.
Not sure what being Franciscan has to do with anything, but the Mass shouldn’t be interupted at the homily for ‘lay witness’. Please do speak respectfully to your priest about it again. You’ll want to be able to say you’ve talked to him when you do contact the bishop.

Possibly suggest a coffee time after Mass when those kinds of witnesses, discussions, conversations can take place more properly. It always helps to have a suggested solution when you identify a problem.

If he refuses to change, than please do contact the bishop. You may also want to change parishes in the meantime, but for the sake of the other parishioners at this parish, do contact the bishop.
 
Not sure what being Franciscan has to do with anything, but the Mass shouldn’t be interupted at the homily for ‘lay witness’. Please do speak respectfully to your priest about it again. You’ll want to be able to say you’ve talked to him when you do contact the bishop.

Possibly suggest a coffee time after Mass when those kinds of witnesses, discussions, conversations can take place more properly. It always helps to have a suggested solution when you identify a problem.

If he refuses to change, than please do contact the bishop. You may also want to change parishes in the meantime, but for the sake of the other parishioners at this parish, do contact the bishop.
thank you. i always speak respectfully to all priests. i am afraid there is nothing that i can say to this priest that is going to make him change his mind on the things he is doing.

i hope i can speak to the bishop.

Florida Priest Threatens to Have Catholic Pro-Lifers Arrested
for Leafleting Cars. yep this is the diocesan priest where the bishop resides. scrow down and you will see.

stjohnsvaldosta.blogspot.com/2008_01_01_archive.html
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top