Baptism and God Parents

  • Thread starter Thread starter Oblaidon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

Oblaidon

Guest
Hi everyone. I hope I am posting this in the right forum.

I have a niece (wife’s brother’s daughter) who is baptising her child in the Catholic Church. She decided to make her cousin (my nephew), who is gay, one of the God Parents. She knows he has left the Catholic faith, but claims that only one of the two God Parents need to be Catholic. She is right, but it seems she is following the rules and not considering the consquences. I feel a God Parents role is to be a good spirtual leader.

My wife doesn’t want me to talk to her because someone in the family has already talked to my niece. My nephew leads a gay life style and believes that the Christian religion results in hate crimes. I want her to be aware of this.

I feel if I attend the baptism I am condoning the choice of the God father. I am sure my nephew’s lover will be there. They claim to be married, but I don’t view a man and a man can make that claim.

I feel my nephew has the right to live is life the way he wishes, but I don’t have to approve. And that is my right.

So, should I just not attend? Should I talk to my niece even though I don’t think she will change her mind and let her know why I won’t be attending. Should I talk to my nephew. Should I ask him to bow out for his religious reasons?

I guess there is a little resentment on my part, because my wife and I feel we would make good God Parents.
 
I don’t think attending a Baptism denotes that you approve of the choice of Godparents. It means that you are there to support that little child, who of course is unable to make the choice. If I were you, I would definitely attend.

Your neice is right that only one Godparent is necessary and that in such case, a Christian witness may also be utilized. However, in those cases, I believe the Christian witness must also be a practicing Christian. I do not think that non-practicing Catholics can serve as this Christian witness. Is the priest aware of the situation?

In any case, you mention that someone already approached your neice with their concerns. I’m not sure what you could add to that. If your relationship is such with your neice that you could bring it up non-confrontationally, then perhaps I would try, but I would be cautious as to how you go about it. I certainly wouldn’t recommend talking with your neice unless your wife was 100% on board with the idea. And in that case, it might be preferable for your wife to be the one to talk with her.
 
I don’t know if the priest knows the situation. I think they are on the don’t ask don’t tell policy.

I will find it awkward at picture time with the two men holding the baby together. What should be a very special day overshadowed by this. Maybe, I should let my brother-in-law (the mother’s father) worry about it all.

Am I just being old fashioned? It is a big, dark cloud over what should be a sunny day.

I really think I should voice my concern. It is not just that my nephew is gay, as much as it is he is so against the Church. It is just seems false, and I don’t want to be part of the facade.
 
I second talking to the priest about it. I also might say something to my gay nephew, in a very civil way, about Does he know what he is doing when he stands up as a godparent, or even as a witness? It sure seems like he would be denying his own convictions by doing so.

I leave it to someone older and wiser than me to say what might happen if you, also, talk to the niece and/or nephew and/or priest. I do say, though, that I for one certainly wouldn’t fault you for it. I wouldn’t worry about offending the nephew. He seems to have no fears of insulting the Church or Christians. And somebody has to speak up for traditional values. You wouldn’t want your niece to think there was only one person in the family who disagreed with her choice of godparents.

Yes, definitly still attend the ceremony for the sake of the baby.

As for not being godparents, remember that you can still pray just as much for the child, even if you don’t get worldly recognition for it. (I bet you would have made great godparents). In fact, in speaking up on behalf of the baby in favor of real Christian godparents, you would indeed be acting as the baby’s spiritual advocates already.
 
I don’t know if the priest knows the situation. I think they are on the don’t ask don’t tell policy.

I will find it awkward at picture time with the two men holding the baby together. What should be a very special day overshadowed by this. Maybe, I should let my brother-in-law (the mother’s father) worry about it all.

Am I just being old fashioned? It is a big, dark cloud over what should be a sunny day.

I really think I should voice my concern. It is not just that my nephew is gay, as much as it is he is so against the Church. It is just seems false, and I don’t want to be part of the facade.
I don’t think you’re being old-fashioned at all. It is a normal reaction to be uncomfortable with the whole thing. Too many people base their decision for godparents on who is their best friend or closest family member rather than basing it on who is actually the best model of what it means to be a practicing Catholic. That is very unfortunate.

I find it difficult to advise people online whether or not it might be better or worse to speak up. There are so many factors to consider: the temperments of those involved, their past relationship, etc. Discernment is really key. Would speaking up to your neice cause her to have hurt feelings and reduce the amount of time you are able to spend with the child as the child grows up? If you think that is a possibility, it could be best to hold your tongue knowing that someone has already said something. It would be better to be a strong Catholic example who is present throughout the child’s life rather than saying something and causing a rift with the mother from the outset. But then, maybe she would be receptive to a charitable explanation of why the Church wants you to choose godparents who are practicing Catholics. I really couldn’t say.

And maybe it would be better to get your brother-in-law on board so that he would be the one to talk to his daughter about it. Again, it’s difficult for me to say as I am not personally familiar with your family.

Although I would be cautious about going behind people’s backs to talk to your neice’s priest, have you talked this over with your priest? He is in a position to give you more useful advice than us here at CAF. That’s really the best advice I can give.
 
Thank you all for your advice. I will have to think and pray on this. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top