R
Rothchild
Guest
I have read through much of this thread, although admittedly, not all. I have a couple thoughts.
“Without [the Holy Spirit] what would the Church be reduced to? Certainly it would be a great historical movement, a complex and solid social institution, perhaps even a type of humanitarian agency. In truth many regard the Church in this way because they observe it from outside the viewpoint of the faith. Yet in reality, its true nature and its real historic presence has ceaselessly been guided and formed by the Spirit and the Lord.”
I don’t understand how this statement by Pope Benedict is directly addressing the charismatic movement. It is doctrine that the Holy Spirit directs and leads the Church.
As individuals, we all receive the gifts of the Holy Spirit at Baptism and these gifts are strengthened and sealed at Confirmation. We have ONE baptism in the Trinity. Personally, I think the term “baptism in the Holy Spirit” can cause confusion leading people to wonder whether the Sacrament of Baptism is enough. This is why the Church is very careful not to “rebaptize” someone who many have been previously validly baptized…hence, we have Conditional Baptism. It is an insult to the Holy Spirit to rebaptize. Archbishop Sheen preached that there is no baptism in the Holy Spirit apart from the Sacrament of Baptism.
I was recently at a charismatic conference for 3 days. Although it was a bit uncomfortable, I prayed for God’s will. If he wanted to pour additional gifts upon me I was open to receive them. It was a bit disconcerting when I went up to the priest with an open mind and heart and he tried to convince me that I had the gift of tongues.
Personally, if someone wishes to worship in a charismatic manner, more power to them. I don’t subscribe to the idea that if you don’t experience this outpouring you are somehow not open to receiving the gifts. I don’t recall Sister Faustina experiencing union with Christ in this way. As a matter of fact, she spent many years with her Confessors in a very guarded fashion, worrying that the voice she was hearing may not be Christ.
Many of the great saints talk about dark or dry periods, some lasting years. I don’t think they lacked faith that the Holy Spirit would guide them.
My biggest concern is that I see many people within the charismatic movement that tend to think that if you don’t receive gifts of tongues, slain in the spirit, etc, you are not being open enough to receive them. This bothers me. But I also see very devout, prayerful people producing much fruit within this movement as well.
“Without [the Holy Spirit] what would the Church be reduced to? Certainly it would be a great historical movement, a complex and solid social institution, perhaps even a type of humanitarian agency. In truth many regard the Church in this way because they observe it from outside the viewpoint of the faith. Yet in reality, its true nature and its real historic presence has ceaselessly been guided and formed by the Spirit and the Lord.”
I don’t understand how this statement by Pope Benedict is directly addressing the charismatic movement. It is doctrine that the Holy Spirit directs and leads the Church.
As individuals, we all receive the gifts of the Holy Spirit at Baptism and these gifts are strengthened and sealed at Confirmation. We have ONE baptism in the Trinity. Personally, I think the term “baptism in the Holy Spirit” can cause confusion leading people to wonder whether the Sacrament of Baptism is enough. This is why the Church is very careful not to “rebaptize” someone who many have been previously validly baptized…hence, we have Conditional Baptism. It is an insult to the Holy Spirit to rebaptize. Archbishop Sheen preached that there is no baptism in the Holy Spirit apart from the Sacrament of Baptism.
I was recently at a charismatic conference for 3 days. Although it was a bit uncomfortable, I prayed for God’s will. If he wanted to pour additional gifts upon me I was open to receive them. It was a bit disconcerting when I went up to the priest with an open mind and heart and he tried to convince me that I had the gift of tongues.
Personally, if someone wishes to worship in a charismatic manner, more power to them. I don’t subscribe to the idea that if you don’t experience this outpouring you are somehow not open to receiving the gifts. I don’t recall Sister Faustina experiencing union with Christ in this way. As a matter of fact, she spent many years with her Confessors in a very guarded fashion, worrying that the voice she was hearing may not be Christ.
Many of the great saints talk about dark or dry periods, some lasting years. I don’t think they lacked faith that the Holy Spirit would guide them.
My biggest concern is that I see many people within the charismatic movement that tend to think that if you don’t receive gifts of tongues, slain in the spirit, etc, you are not being open enough to receive them. This bothers me. But I also see very devout, prayerful people producing much fruit within this movement as well.