Baptism rules changed for 5-year-olds

  • Thread starter Thread starter CindyC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

CindyC

Guest
My mom told me that the baptism rules have changed. She said anyone over the age of 5 is supposed to go through RCIA. Is this true? I’ve heard of RCIC, but I think that is for 7 and over. Did something change or did my mom hear wrong?

Thank you!
 
My mom told me that the baptism rules have changed. She said anyone over the age of 5 is supposed to go through RCIA. Is this true? I’ve heard of RCIC, but I think that is for 7 and over. Did something change or did my mom hear wrong?

Thank you!
The rule is that anyone who has the ability to understand what is going on needs to receive age-appropriate catechesis before receiving any Sacrament. Perhaps at your mother’s parish, they have determined that five year olds have this ability. (I don’t see why they would not, in most cases.) The process would include the rites of RCIA, since this is the norm of the Church for baptism.
 
It is usually the age of reason, which is about the same age as one would normally receive First Communion. Personally, 5 years old is too young for RCIA, even RCIA for children.
 
My mom told me that the baptism rules have changed. She said anyone over the age of 5 is supposed to go through RCIA. Is this true? I’ve heard of RCIC, but I think that is for 7 and over. Did something change or did my mom hear wrong?

Thank you!
It is not an age, but a Stage of development. Called the “Catechetical Age”. The stage at which a particular child is capable of being Catechized. It is spoken of as being “about” seven. For a particular child it could be 6 or it could 7 or 8 or even 9.
 
The rule is that anyone who has the ability to understand what is going on needs to receive age-appropriate catechesis before receiving any Sacrament. Perhaps at your mother’s parish, they have determined that five year olds have this ability. (I don’t see why they would not, in most cases.) The process would include the rites of RCIA, since this is the norm of the Church for baptism.
canon law actually says anytime after the age of discretion, generally recognized as age 7, the child is considered an adult for the purposes of initiation sacraments. It is possible for a 5 year old to be at the level, and pastoral exceptions can be made, but generally a 5 year old is considered an infant for the purposes of baptism and other initiation sacraments
 
canon law actually says anytime after the age of discretion, generally recognized as age 7, the child is considered an adult for the purposes of initiation sacraments. It is possible for a 5 year old to be at the level, and pastoral exceptions can be made, but generally a 5 year old is considered an infant for the purposes of baptism and other initiation sacraments
It needs to be age appropriate, but I have even seen two year olds being asked whether they wanted to be baptized. They had an understanding of what the question meant, and were able to respond appropriately. The parents were the ones who were explaining it to their children, of course.
 
RCIA = Rite of Christian Initiation of ADULTS.

Five is considered an “adult” by the Church? Please state the source.

Maybe this is why so many people fall away from the Church. There are a few prodigies who are capable of understanding adult-level lectures and curricula, but most 5 year-olds are doing really well to understand Thomas the Train. Our nephew, who will be 5 in March, is still very babyish and doesn’t even remember all of our names, let alone understand the concepts of sin and salvation.

The Lord said to let the children come to Him and hinder them not. But IMO, using adult materials and adult methods to teach a child about God will hinder the child. It’s almost abusive when people expect little ones to be adults. They’re not.
 
RCIA = Rite of Christian Initiation of ADULTS.

Five is considered an “adult” by the Church? Please state the source.
The concepts of “childhood” and “teenager” are very recent - in the Middle Ages, people went to work as soon as they could form complete sentences, and were considered to be adults.
Maybe this is why so many people fall away from the Church. There are a few prodigies who are capable of understanding adult-level lectures and curricula,
Nobody is expecting that. The RCIA recognizes the need to provide age-appropriate Catechesis.
but most 5 year-olds are doing really well to understand Thomas the Train.
That’s a bizarre story - I doubt that I understand it very well, either. 😉
That Our nephew, who will be 5 in March, is still very babyish and doesn’t even remember all of our names, let alone understand the concepts of sin and salvation.
Of course not, but he does understand things like “Mommy gets mad when I run in the house,” and “Jesus loves me, anyway, even though He’s sad that I ran in the house and made my Mommy get mad.”
The Lord said to let the children come to Him and hinder them not. But IMO, using adult materials and adult methods to teach a child about God will hinder the child. It’s almost abusive when people expect little ones to be adults. They’re not.
“Adult” is just the distinction between, duck the kid under without telling him ahead of time what’s going to happen (infant), or ask him whether he would like to be baptized, and explain it to him in terms that he can understand (adult). The Church doesn’t have any concept of “child,” “teenager” or “youth” in its official policies regarding the Sacraments. (The definition of “youth” is especially fuzzy - I recently heard of a Catholic “youth group” that is going to be open to four year olds.)
 
The follow is the Church’s response to some ideologies pushing to delay the baptism of infants and children.

INSTRUCTION ON INFANT BAPTISM
By the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith

Approved by His Holiness Pope John Paul II October 20, 1980

ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDFINFAN.htm
 
RCIA = Rite of Christian Initiation of ADULTS.

Five is considered an “adult” by the Church? Please state the source.

not.
as stated “adult” in this context means catechetical age, or age of discretion, generally recognized as about age 7. this means in the context of RCIA for the purposes of the initiation sacraments. not in any other context, matrimony for instance. It is up to OP to provide a source for the “5 yrs old” she said it, I didn’t.
 
As one who teaches baptism classes at our parish, the canonical rule is that a child must attend catechism lessons if they have reached the age of 7, considered the age of reason.

However, we strongly encourage parents and godparents to instruct any child who is able to understand and is already speaking, age 2,3,4…to be told what to expect, even practice pouring water over them. Bring them to church, show them the font…etc…Tell them what is happening, so they are not frightened when a priest or deacon is baptizing them. Common sense tells you that, as well as loving parents who want to share the faith with their little one. Age appropriate of course.
 
The Church doesn’t have any concept of “child,” “teenager” or “youth” in its official policies regarding the Sacraments. (The definition of “youth” is especially fuzzy - I recently heard of a Catholic “youth group” that is going to be open to four year olds.)
I wouldn’t use such strong wording as to say that the Church doesn’t have any concept of child, teenager, or youth. After all, there is a Rite of Christian Initiation for Children (which, IIRC, is meant to cover children from the age of reason to about 14). There are also canonical distinctions between adults (over 7) who are still minors (under 18) and those who have reached majority, though this distinction doesn’t affect access to the sacraments. Other distinctions within adulthood do, though, including mitigated communion fast for the elderly, minimum ages of 25 or 35 for orders…

…and, most importantly here (because it applies to teenagers), minimum age for marriage (16 for boys, 14 for girls) below which the sacrament is invalid. Why invalid for the young? Because, though adults, they are not considered to have a sufficient grasp of the sacrament to know what they’re consenting to.
 
<<My mom told me that the baptism rules have changed. She said anyone over the age of 5 is supposed to go through RCIA>>

And where did she get her information?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top