Barbarism Rising - The Black Hole Where Piety Used to Be

  • Thread starter Thread starter NeelyAnn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

NeelyAnn

Guest
**Barbarism Rising

The Black Hole Where Piety Used to Be**

Anthony Mazzone
REMNANT COLUMNIST, Pennsylvania

(Posted 12/15/09 www.RemnantNewspaper.com) It is mid-Lent sometime in the 1950’s. Deep within a large Eastern city early morning Mass is about to begin. The sanctuary bell rings and the priest enters with two altar boys. He places the sacred vessels on the altar and gets right down to business. There is no greeting of the people, never any eye contact. His movements are practiced, precise and quick. Those in the front pews can hear the whispered Latin phrases.

The congregation consists largely of elderly women dressed in black who continuously tell their beads. Scattered about are a few school children who try to follow along in their missals. Once in a while a huge workman enters. He kneels heavily, rolls up his sleeves, and remains absolutely still for the duration of Mass. Less often another fellow, better tailored, comes in. He favors lighting candles and stuffing money into the poor box but never stays for Mass.

Other scattered memories surface from around the same time: priests occasionally conversing in Latin, statues of saints carried in procession through the streets, every home having a crucifix on one of the walls and somewhere else a picture St Anthony. Once I was standing on some corner when the parish priest came hurrying by, black bag in hand. My friends and I weren’t accustomed to seeing Father outside of Church. We stared open-mouthed until a harsh whisper from a teenager startled us: “Inginocchiati, stronzo!” “Kneel down, idiot!”

Reciting the Angelus at noon, making the Sign of the Cross when passing a church, keeping silent between one and three on Good Friday, having Masses said for deceased family members, naming one’s children after favorite saints: such customs were innumerable and rather instinctual, little things that came naturally simply from being Catholic. They signified continuity and stability and among us constituted a kind of common patois. This is what our parents and grandparents did; it was what we should do in reverence of their memory.

I can admit that this is to some extent an idealized portrait of the past, and will acknowledge that there is little merit in merely following custom without understanding or devotion. We can all recognize and reprobate those elements of hypocrisy, or worse superstition, that often infected many of these customs. Nevertheless there is no question that, when well ordered, works of popular piety are indications of spiritual health and of a robust Catholic culture.

So it is disheartening to recognize that the time of universal Latin Masses in cold churches, of fervent street processions, of fidelity to long standing customs has long since passed. No longer do we dwell in a world that takes outward expressions of religious faith for granted. Instead, sincere displays of piety are increasingly unwelcome in public and tolerated only as vague invocations of the deity on national holidays or, at most, charming vestiges of ethnic culture. We are all to some extent intimidated, if not cowed. And what are the chances these days of a young man, hanging in front of the pool hall, taking anyone to task for not kneeling as a priest passes by carrying the Sanctissimum?

In fact the term has been so inverted that to call someone “pious” today is practically to insult him, to intimate that he is ipso facto a hypocrite, likely ignorant and intolerant also. This is truly an inversion, for Piety is one of the Seven Gifts of the Holy Spirit. Aquinas tells us that it is the gift “whereby, at the Holy Spirit’s instigation, we pay worship and duty to God as our Father.”[1] It corresponds to the Cardinal Virtue of Justice and along with Fortitude and Fear of the Lord, directs the will towards God.

But we are a modern people and in our hubris and luxury have emphatically rejected this gift. We do not prize it because it will make nobody any money, and is suitable only for duds and flunkies. Could anyone say that dutiful respect and docility of soul are admired today? Rather the stylish masses prefer to revel in gross confrontation and ugly “attitude.”

Lack of reverence toward the past, disrespect for what has been handed down, disdain for the virtue of humility, outright revulsion toward the compliant fulfillment of duties—simply a revolt from piety—is the acid bath of modernity.

We all experience the corrosive effects in our daily lives. The most noticeable symptom is that coarseness of language and rudeness of behavior are ubiquitous, and tolerated. Turn on the TV, listen to the radio and the crassness seems to get worse every day. Not even the most insular among us can escape the relentless onslaught of advertising: the primary outlet for creativity in our time. It is literally borne on the air, thrust into our faces, rammed into our ears. It aims not at enlightenment or elevation of mind but instead suborns the artistic talents for the purposes of manipulation. In the world of marketing value is not measured by intrinsic worth but by the possibility of profit; absolutely nothing is sacred or beyond exploitation. Advertising touches everything and trivializes everything it touches.

Continued here: remnantnewspaper.com/Archives/2009-1215-mazzone.htm
 
It’s a very good article! These are my thoughts exactly. My parents’ and grandparents’ generation have been content with removing crucial chunks out of popular devotions and piety, and so people like me are left with no idea what to do, with only God to move our hearts into action and the internet for somebody from afar to educate us in basic Catholic teaching. It’s truly disturbing. I know some countries still have a few remnants of devotion left, and I’m hoping to see that in Poland, my ‘homeland’, so that one day I can provide for my children something I never had, and am scrambling to find.

Excuse my rant :rolleyes: and thanks for posting this:thumbsup:
 
Consider that cultural trends are the cumulative result of individual actions - people have to “go along” with a practice in order for it to become the “norm”. Reversing the trend or redefining the norm requires that more and more individuals decline to “go along”. Obviously, this is much more easily said than done.

Consider, too, that the Gifts of the Holy Spirit do not operate in isolation, but rather support and reinforce one another - after all they have the same Source. Fear of the Lord, then, leads the person to a heightened awareness of the proper relationship between God and self. Knowledge acquaints the individual with the history, purpose, and value of various pious practices. Understanding places that information in the context of daily life and suggests opportunities for Piety’s expressions. Counsel leads one to seek guidance and support from rightly-formed individuals whom Wisdom helps to recognize. Then on a daily (or even a moment-to-moment) basis, Fortitude strengthens us to act as we know we ought.

Finally, consider the cultural millieu in which the early Church existed. Is today’s any worse? Is it even as bad? May the early martyrs inspire us by their example and strengthen us by their prayers to live as faithful witnesses to Christ.

Hope that helps.
 
It’s a very good article! These are my thoughts exactly. My parents’ and grandparents’ generation have been content with removing crucial chunks out of popular devotions and piety, and so people like me are left with no idea what to do, with only God to move our hearts into action and the internet for somebody from afar to educate us in basic Catholic teaching. It’s truly disturbing. I know some countries still have a few remnants of devotion left, and I’m hoping to see that in Poland, my ‘homeland’, so that one day I can provide for my children something I never had, and am scrambling to find.

Excuse my rant :rolleyes: and thanks for posting this:thumbsup:
I know what you mean. It can be frustrating. It is not just family customs that have slipped by the wayside, but all common courtesy and basic manners are gone these days.

I know this will be basic, but it is a start. There are a number of older books that discuss traditional Catholic devotions for holidays, feast days,etc. from various countries. Perhaps you could get a few of those and start implementing some of the customs that were once prevelent in Poland. By doing so, you would be helping to restore and pass along those once valued Catholic customs. Just adding one here and there would be a big improvement and your children will enjoy it.

The Angelus Press used to carry one or two books. Over the years, I have come across others. Try searching online. I try to go with older books, or books published by trusted sources.

God bless you.
 
Great article. this is exactly what i see today in our world. just look at the shows on tv for teenagers. it is all about sex, bad language and bad attitudes. these are permitted everywhere. the Word of God is not permitted. this is what the holy father is talking about when he says that men have become their own gods. they became lovers of themselves.

i truly believe that if the CC heals herself from the inside, things will begin to change.
if the CC begin to purge out the bad apples, new beautifull apples will grow.

but first the CC must change from the ugliness that it is right now. the scandals continue to appear. the CC cannot have a voice in the world when she is not behaving herself well. the world will be led by her.
 
Some of the practices described above continue in Catholic south Louisiana. We still routinely have Masses said for friends’ deceased relatives and I named my two sons after my favorite saints. People still make the sign of the cross in New Orleans when passing in front of a church. We have/had a crucifix in all of our bedrooms.

The parish in which I grew up was ethnically Irish, French and Sicillian and I am well familiar with the little old ladies in black and their rosaries. Unfortunately, many of our contemporaries point to them as “not paying attention to Mass” instead of recognizing their intrinsic piety.

My old parish (a suburb of New Orleans) still has an annual St. Rosalie procession - a Sicilian devotion.

youtube.com/watch?v=avQNuZZNEWw I have a newspaper picture of a blond haired, blue eyed Irish kid as crucifer for the same procession in 1960. That kid was me. (The street wasn’t paved then. :D)

The absolute shock of Katrina was a wake up call. Archbishop Hughes of New Orleans has reinstituted a Corpus Christi procession in downtown NO. We have lost so much since the 70s but as Fr. Z says, one brick at a time.

We need to step up to the plate. Just as Archbishop Hughes reinstituted a Corpus Christi procession, we need to pray (first) and be proactive. There are so many of us still alive today who remember what it was like before the guitars got whipped out in 1968/69, who remember what it was like to kneel and receive Our Lord on the tongue.

It starts at home. My oldest son (28) floored me the year before last when he came home and recited the Pater Noster in Latin! It was then that I knew we had hope of reclaiming our Roman Catholic heritage. One brick at a time!
 
I know what you mean. It can be frustrating. It is not just family customs that have slipped by the wayside, but all common courtesy and basic manners are gone these days.

I know this will be basic, but it is a start. There are a number of older books that discuss traditional Catholic devotions for holidays, feast days,etc. from various countries. Perhaps you could get a few of those and start implementing some of the customs that were once prevelent in Poland. By doing so, you would be helping to restore and pass along those once valued Catholic customs. Just adding one here and there would be a big improvement and your children will enjoy it.

The Angelus Press used to carry one or two books. Over the years, I have come across others. Try searching online. I try to go with older books, or books published by trusted sources.

God bless you.
Well I’m 18 now, so no children as of yet 😃 I’m just thinking ahead. This year, probably the last Christmas with my family, I started a Polish Christmas Eve tradition of 12 meatless dishes (12 apostles) and that was a lot of fun! Good suggestion with the older books too, I guess I’ll buy some cheap used ones off Amazon and the like.
Some of the practices described above continue in Catholic south Louisiana. We still routinely have Masses said for friends’ deceased relatives and I named my two sons after my favorite saints. People still make the sign of the cross in New Orleans when passing in front of a church. We have/had a crucifix in all of our bedrooms.

The parish in which I grew up was ethnically Irish, French and Sicillian and I am well familiar with the little old ladies in black and their rosaries. Unfortunately, many of our contemporaries point to them as “not paying attention to Mass” instead of recognizing their intrinsic piety.

My old parish (a suburb of New Orleans) still has an annual St. Rosalie procession - a Sicilian devotion.

youtube.com/watch?v=avQNuZZNEWw I have a newspaper picture of a blond haired, blue eyed Irish kid as crucifer for the same procession in 1960. That kid was me. (The street wasn’t paved then. :D)

The absolute shock of Katrina was a wake up call. Archbishop Hughes of New Orleans has reinstituted a Corpus Christi procession in downtown NO. We have lost so much since the 70s but as Fr. Z says, one brick at a time.

We need to step up to the plate. Just as Archbishop Hughes reinstituted a Corpus Christi procession, we need to pray (first) and be proactive. There are so many of us still alive today who remember what it was like before the guitars got whipped out in 1968/69, who remember what it was like to kneel and receive Our Lord on the tongue.

It starts at home. My oldest son (28) floored me the year before last when he came home and recited the Pater Noster in Latin! It was then that I knew we had hope of reclaiming our Roman Catholic heritage. One brick at a time!
Fr. Z sounds very smart 👍

The bolded part really scares me 😦 Sometimes the horror of all that has happened just makes me cry, and I’ve had nightmares about, and can vividly imagine, the remnants of Eucharist that are being trampled all around our churches, and in the holy water, in the books, on peoples’ laundry, etc. So it’s definitely a very emotional thing for me.

I just wish I had lived a longer time ago, or further into the future, so that I wouldn’t have to be stuck in this mess. It makes me wonder if all of us were put in this era to help others out 🙂

What also bothers me is how nonchalant my parents and grandparents are about the change, and from their kurt, identical answers it feels like they were catachized against the Latin and tradition. Very sad:(

How nice it would be to teach a first communion class how to receive on the tongue! 🙂
 
You can do what I have done for the last 45 years - pray and serve. We have driven 25 miles (one way) since 1983 because…I loved HMC in which I grew up. I did not need to sing Simon and Garfunkle or all those awful insipid songs which followed.

I will say this, however. I would prefer to be able to celebrate the TLM but I do not need it. A properly celebrated NO even in English is OK. My father converted from Protestantism after 1969. I cannot forget that. I love the Latin I grew up with and have no problems with it being a “foreign language”. I love chant and sacred motets and sang in a cathedral choir for 20 years, where Deo gratias, ite Deo gratias! we were able to exercise OUR sacred traditions instead of mimicking our Protestant neighbors.

The baby got thrown out with the bathwater in 1967. We are CATHOLICS! We have our own traditions.

I am 58 years old. I made my First Communion in 1958. I have never received in the hand and would love to kneel.
 
Consider that cultural trends are the cumulative result of individual actions - people have to “go along” with a practice in order for it to become the “norm”. Reversing the trend or redefining the norm requires that more and more individuals decline to “go along”. Obviously, this is much more easily said than done.

Consider, too, that the Gifts of the Holy Spirit do not operate in isolation, but rather support and reinforce one another - after all they have the same Source. Fear of the Lord, then, leads the person to a heightened awareness of the proper relationship between God and self. Knowledge acquaints the individual with the history, purpose, and value of various pious practices. Understanding places that information in the context of daily life and suggests opportunities for Piety’s expressions. Counsel leads one to seek guidance and support from rightly-formed individuals whom Wisdom helps to recognize. Then on a daily (or even a moment-to-moment) basis, Fortitude strengthens us to act as we know we ought.

Finally, consider the cultural millieu in which the early Church existed. Is today’s any worse? Is it even as bad? May the early martyrs inspire us by their example and strengthen us by their prayers to live as faithful witnesses to Christ.

Hope that helps.
Yes, it has been a fight to get the Latin Mass reinstated as a form of legitimate worship. Never in the history of the Church has a legitimate Mass and those who attended it been vilified and harassed as much as the traditionalists. I lived through this whole attack for the past 40+ years and I can only conclude that it is diabolical in scope and breadth. There is no rationale for the way traditionalists have been treated in the Church, as if they are some kind of pariah not worthy of seriousness. If progressives had to take action to keep them silent, even to the point of making their spiritual lives so miserable as to force them to leave their parishes of worship, they take it as a victory. It’s not the progressives who will make sure in the continuity of the Church, but the Holy Spirit and traditionalists who are re-discovering the beauty of a history that has been closed to them for too long. May this trend continue among the faithful through Our Lod. Amen! 👍
 
I strongly appreciate this article. I converted to Catholicism just a few months ago, and do find the piousness of traditional catholic culture to be incredibly fulfilling to my own life, personally. And yes, my greatest fear of my piousness are that I will be scorned by those who see me practice it publicly, whether I pray before lunch at college or openly wear a scapular.

And there IS a double standard. When someone in America publicly demonstrates being Muslim, people would say “oh, that’s cool that you’re so into your beliefs.” If someone publicly demonstrates being Christian, particularly being Catholic, one will receive frowns and an awkward “ok” even from one’s friends.

Nonetheless, the best we can do as traditional Catholic Christians is be great, kind people, and show that our piousness has helped to make us great people. If every Catholic were to fulfill this today, oh, what an impact it would make! 👍
 
It’s a very good article! These are my thoughts exactly. My parents’ and grandparents’ generation have been content with removing crucial chunks out of popular devotions and piety, and so people like me are left with no idea what to do, with only God to move our hearts into action and the internet for somebody from afar to educate us in basic Catholic teaching. It’s truly disturbing. I know some countries still have a few remnants of devotion left, and I’m hoping to see that in Poland, my ‘homeland’, so that one day I can provide for my children something I never had, and am scrambling to find.

Excuse my rant :rolleyes: and thanks for posting this:thumbsup:
Catholicism is quite evident in Poland. I briefly visited the city of Wrocław and one could tell that the citizens took their faith seriously. In addition, public displays of devotion are more or less common, e.g. Kraków:

Corpus Christi 2009
flickr.com/photos/ilvic/sets/72157619595360130/
 
I hear this a lot. What exactly was the bathwater?
I was in high school in the late 60s. I liked Latin. I liked/like chant and sacred motets. In the course of two short years we virtually abandoned our heritage. The “bathwater” as such was all of our traditions and heritage. Novenas, 40 hour Devotions, processions - all of the peripherals which defined us as Catholic went out the window. In came the guitars. In came the a’strummin’ and a’grinnin’ folks and out went the Communion rails - none of which were mandated by Vatican II but done in the “spirit of Vatican II”. I had no idea that the NO could be said in Latin until I saw the Peruvian priests on EWTN a few years ago.

Like peary, I have prayed for the last 45 years that we would reclaim that heritage while there are still some of us who are “not dead yet!” It is an uphill battle.

It took Katrina to get the Archbishop of New Orleans to reinstitute the Corpus Christi procession two years ago. Public displays of devotion used to be common.
 
I was in high school in the late 60s. I liked Latin. I liked/like chant and sacred motets. In the course of two short years we virtually abandoned our heritage. The “bathwater” as such was all of our traditions and heritage. Novenas, 40 hour Devotions, processions - all of the peripherals which defined us as Catholic went out the window. In came the guitars. In came the a’strummin’ and a’grinnin’ folks and out went the Communion rails - none of which were mandated by Vatican II but done in the “spirit of Vatican II”. I had no idea that the NO could be said in Latin until I saw the Peruvian priests on EWTN a few years ago.

Like peary, I have prayed for the last 45 years that we would reclaim that heritage while there are still some of us who are “not dead yet!” It is an uphill battle.

It took Katrina to get the Archbishop of New Orleans to reinstitute the Corpus Christi procession two years ago. Public displays of devotion used to be common.
In the end, I believe we’re succeeding in bringing back the traditions of Catholicism even if it’s an uphill battle in particular dioceses.
 
Ljubim, dobra noc!
One custom my family has and we still do on Christmas Eve is the sjaring and breaking of the oplatki(oh-pwat-kee). It’s basically square wafer thin sheets of the same type of bread(?) as the communion wafers are made of. We each take a piece and offer to our friends and relatives to break off a piece while they offer good wishes, luck, good health and blessings to the other person for each piece they break off, and then consume it. The process continues with you doing the same to the other person. My Grandma, who came from Poland, gave this custom to her four daughters and as far as I know, most of the grandkid’s families still do it. Also, don’t forget the pierogi, mushroom soup and herring.
If you do the herring and you come across a bone in it, save it, wrap it in a paper towel, or maybe nowadays some plastic wrap and stick it in your wallet. According to the custom, if you do this, your wallet will never be empty during the coming year. If anything, I guess, it will have at least an old fishbone in it. Lotsa fun those old customs and they shouldn’t die!👍
Looking ahead to Easter, another Polish custom you may want to try is finding a parish that has the blessing of the food you’ll eat on Easter Sunday. This is usually offered on Holy Saturday. Folks come with wicker baskets full of freshly baked breads, hams, and other victuals. I’ll tell you as much as I like the incense smell of a good Catholic Church, the aroma of a Polish parish on Holy Saturday afternoon is REALLY HEAVENLY!!! In the greater Detroit area, most parishes feature this!👍
 
Excellent article!

The current plight of the Church in society reminds me of the plight the Faithful/Elf-friends in Numenor, when their traditions were done away with by Sauron and wicked rites introduced, perverting the people and causing havoc. I cannot but see those of us who support the Faith (and especially, those of us who support traditional Catholicism as opposed to the contemporary) as those Faithful, in an uphill battle with the King’s Men of the rest of society who adore their secularist ways.

Of course, if you haven’t read The Silmarilliion, just ignore me 😃
 
I bookmarked this article because it brings up an issue that is lost in our current generation. And that is the loss of ancestral legacy. In America we keep trying to ‘reinvent’ ourselves, ‘reimagining’ what we consider old and outdated. As if all of history awaited our coming. But the more we do this, the worse things become. I know my traditional Catholic parents would not recognize many of the changes in the Church. And, I suppose we believed those changes were for the better. But have those changes made religion better? Or more confusing to those who do not remember what the Church was like 50 years ago?
This generation thought throwing off the trappings of what we called rigidity was a good thing, but all it did was reveal what was underneath.
The title is interesting. I remember reading this quote once:
“Barbarism is the natural state of man, civilization is unnatural (for him)”.
We need a return to religious civilization.
 
The “Black Hole” into which piety dissolved is the void created by every family that has disintegrated, and every community, village or municipality, wherin a collective group of people lived, worked and prayed, which has dwindled and died. The spiritual, cultural revolutions of the sixties, combined with dissociation caused by globalization have proven to be tenacious foes of piety. I believe, at least this is my reality, that sanctity and piety now find a home in the hearts of those who “choose” to embrace them. In other words, those who responded with piety out of mere habit, peer pressure, or any of a number of artificial means, can now easily abstain without any fear of recrimination. Those who embraced piety as a genuine expression of worship, while undoubtedly fewer in number, still strive to maintain in their lives the sacred traditions in a hostile world. The question we have to ask ourselves is: If we were forced to worship in secret, seeking out dark places to meet and pray together, in fear for our lives…would we be among that sort of congregation? Our traditions were born of people who risked, and in many instances, lost their lives for the Faith. Piety shows respect to Christ, but also honors the martys who passed down to us our Religion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top