M
Mijoy2
Guest
I have a suspicion this is a very common question and, for whatever reason, it just never occured to me before.
I heard this question referenced at the tail end of a call to Catholic Answers.
The basic premise of the question is; Original sin is where we get our propensity to sin (maybe this is where I am wrong). If this is so, and Adam and Eve was not created with original sin, this would imply they effectively could not sin. Yet, of course, they did. How were they able to be subject to temptation if they were created without original sin?
This would imply our willingness to sin does not come from our fallen nature. If so, then just exactly what is the ramification of original sin?
Seems like a chicken and egg thing.
I heard this question referenced at the tail end of a call to Catholic Answers.
The basic premise of the question is; Original sin is where we get our propensity to sin (maybe this is where I am wrong). If this is so, and Adam and Eve was not created with original sin, this would imply they effectively could not sin. Yet, of course, they did. How were they able to be subject to temptation if they were created without original sin?
This would imply our willingness to sin does not come from our fallen nature. If so, then just exactly what is the ramification of original sin?
Seems like a chicken and egg thing.