Behind Liberals' Wal-mart War

  • Thread starter Thread starter estesbob
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow!

Just how do you force this mythical trading partner to buy more from us than they sell us?

Let’s drop this, and restart it after you’ve taken a course in economics.
Like I said, go campaign on your definition of free trade, (where 200 billion trade deficits are unimportant) especially in areas like Ohio, Illinois, Iowa and Minnesota. At least your not trying to fool the american people by saying China is a legitimate trading partner also interested in buying our products as both Clinton and Bush have tried saying.👍
 
Like I said, go campaign on your definition of free trade, (where 200 billion trade deficits are unimportant) especially in areas like Ohio, Illinois, Iowa and Minnesota. At least your not trying to fool the american people by saying China is a legitimate trading partner also interested in buying our products as both Clinton and Bush have tried saying.👍
So does this mean you will buy from Wal Mart? 😉
 
So does this mean you will buy from Wal Mart? 😉
If your point is to say we are off subject, please do so. I will then explain my focus on China and how it relates to the dislike many have for Wal-Mart in this country.

If you are being sincere and asking a legitimate question, which is what I am going to assume, I will say I only shop at WalMart at 3:00 in the morning when needing an emergancy supply due to something unforseen. Otherwise, I do not frequent their location.👍
 
This may come as a surprise to you, but there is a great deal more written about mercantilism than a simple definition in Websters.😉

The fact that China trades with us – who are not a “foreign trading monopoly” is solid proof that they are not mercantilists.

You might also pick up on the mention of bullion – a key tenent of mercantilism is that the only true value is bullion, and that trading is a zero-sum game.
I think the main point might be that markets are a force of nature just like a tornado or a river and they aren’t easily controlled. What Walmart does or doesn’t do is unimportant. People will spend as little as possible for what they buy in a sort consumer existentialism. We ALL do this.

Many goods are cheaper if produced in other countries. We will buy them and the deficits will mount until the preload on the economic fault line releases and we have a disruption.

This is part of natural economic cycles. My friends are always screaming about Ricardo’s “theory of Comparative Advantage” and that everything is fine because whoever can produce things for less should be allowed to. Yes they should, but it isn’t a cause for celebration. When Ricardo wrote this the British East India Company was in it heyday. I would argue that globalization probably rendered Ricardo all but moot.

Like Friedman says, the “herd” is in control and will spend its money along the path of least resistance and greatest personal gain. Markets are part of nature and it’s not nice to fool [with] Mother Nature…or even to try.
 
I think the main point might be that markets are a force of nature just like a tornado or a river and they aren’t easily controlled. What Walmart does or doesn’t do is unimportant. People will spend as little as possible for what they buy in a sort consumer existentialism. We ALL do this.

Many goods are cheaper if produced in other countries. We will buy them and the deficits will mount until the preload on the economic fault line releases and we have a disruption.
Probably not. The point is, Mercantilism was built around the idea that only gold and silver have real value. Because the amount of gold and silver was limited, Mercantilists saw economics as a zero-sum game.

That is not the case, however. Wealth is in many things – from ideas to land to tools. The United States is becoming wealthier and the trade deficit needs to be looked at in terms of the total wealth (net worth) of the country.
This is part of natural economic cycles. My friends are always screaming about Ricardo’s “theory of Comparative Advantage” and that everything is fine because whoever can produce things for less should be allowed to. Yes they should, but it isn’t a cause for celebration. When Ricardo wrote this the British East India Company was in it heyday. I would argue that globalization probably rendered Ricardo all but moot.

Like Friedman says, the “herd” is in control and will spend its money along the path of least resistance and greatest personal gain. Markets are part of nature and it’s not nice to fool [with] Mother Nature…or even to try.
That is absolutely correct. We have a trade deficit because we buy things we want or need from countries that make them cheaply. If we switched suppliers, all that would happen is that our trade deficit would increase.

However, the current deficit is much smaller than the net increase in wealth over the same period – which means it is sustainable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top