Yeah, I was the kind of kid that would die guessing rather than admit that I didn’t know what they were talking about, and I think my kids are kind of the same way, but I also think that when an adult is frustrated or hurried, they aren’t always a clear as they think they are. Over Christmas, I got on my stepfather because he was sitting in a room full of active grandchildren and began bellowing, “Get your hands off that!” and got really irate that the correct kid didn’t immediately drop the object he was referring to. I had to point out that,
a) No one knew who the heck he was even talking to.
b) Everyone in the room was touching at least one thing and he did not specify which “that” he was concerned about.
c) It was Christmas and at least 75% of the “decorations” in the room were either designed to look like children’s playthings or literally were antique toys, scattered among a pile of actual toys that the children were playing with. Unless it was wired to the tree, it was really hard for toddlers to know what was a toy and what was off limits.
and d) No one can read his mind.
(PS- It turned out that the kid in question didn’t even have their “hands” on the object anyway, but was leaning against it while reaching for something else.)
He had a really hard time believing that the kid in question didn’t know exactly who and what he was talking about and wasn’t just being defiant.