Being Catholic, Protestant, or Orthodox, is not essential to being Christian.

  • Thread starter Thread starter One_in_Christ_1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What can I say. It was promulgated by a pope who kissed the koran :mad:. As much as I respect him…I don’t understand why he did that??? I don’t consider myself to be a pig or a dog. What can I say?
Kissing the Quran is not the kind of unity that I am selling. Muslims need the historic Biblical Jesus Christ and not the Jesus found in the Quran.
 
Kissing the Quran is not the kind of unity that I am selling. Muslims need the historic Biblical Jesus Christ and not the Jesus found in the Quran.
Absolutely…we are in complete agreement! That’s why I don’t understand why a pope would kiss a book inspired by a false angel. It bothers me. The jesus found in the koran is not the Jesus of the Bible. It’s a pretend jesus that only Satan could take pride in. Who has the most to gain by the denial of Jesus as the great I Am? Certainly not an angel of God. They have been mislead by a dark angel.
 
Absolutely…we are in complete agreement! That’s why I don’t understand why a pope would kiss a book inspired by a false angel. It bothers me. The jesus found in the koran is not the Jesus of the Bible. It’s a pretend jesus that only Satan could take pride in. Who has the most to gain by the denial of Jesus as the great I Am? Certainly not an angel of God. They have been mislead by a dark angel.
We have gone full circle back to the OP. Your statement is why I believe that we are Christians first and foremost, and Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox a distant second.
 
I believe our hope is found in God and not the Eucharist. Does that make me your enemy in Christ?
silly goose, of course you are not my enemy in Christ! it’s just that i don’t understand how anyone could claim to be a Christian, but then go against Christ’s words and the teachings that have been handed down for 2000 yrs. surely you have read the writings of the early Church fathers? the truth is most people haven’t. i still have much to read myself.

lately, i’ve been a lousy commenter (or maybe i always am who knows :)), but i have been pretty sick and am now on meds that are making me more goofy than usual. when i get over this, i will try to read though all the comments and see if i can be of any help.

your friend in Christ,
jen
 
Being Catholic, Protestant, or Orthodox is not essential of being Christian. What are your thoughts with this belief.
It was considered a heresy by the Early Church.

It also seems like an attempt on your part to minimize or dismiss the departures from the Apostolic Teaching that resulted in these separations. You seem to want to be One in Christ while maintaining disobedience from the authority appointed by Christ.
 
Why is my point incorrect? You are Christian because you have been united to Christ and not because you are Orthodox.
There is no separation between the two. When one is fully united to Christ, it is because one has fully embraced the Truth (orthodoxy). All who depart from that Truth are separated to a greater or lesser extent.
 
Our lives are hidden in Jesus Christ first and foremost. Our identity in our traditions and denominations are a very distant second in comparison to our identity of being united to Christ.
Clearly this is what you would like to believe, but it is not true. Denominations are all departures from the Apostolic faith, and Sacred Tradition, the Teaching of the Apostles, cannot be watered down or disregarded if unity is to exist. To be hidden in Christ is to be hidden in the Truth.
Code:
 I don't think the Apostles boasted in their particular corner of Christianity;
Exactly! That is because there IS NO CORNER. The Apostolic Faith is One, Holy, and Catholic. The corners were all created by humans, who, through pride and fear, denominated themselves.
the Apostle Paul rebuked those who identified with their particular corner as compared to Christ. Did the Catholic Church, Orthodox Churches, or Protestant churches die for you?
When one is fully united to the Head, who is Christ, then one will be completly in unity with the Body. To the extent that divisions exist, the separated persons are not fully united to the Truth.
To not be Catholic, Protestant, or Orthodox, is being Christian first… and to love those who happen to come from other traditions with very different theological distinctives. Yet, the ecumenical creeds can still unite us as one, regardless of our differences.
You seem to want to minimize the “theological distinctives”. However, this is only a way to justify the perpetration of heresies.
 
Our lives are hidden in Jesus Christ first and foremost. Our identity in our traditions and denominations are a very distant second in comparison to our identity of being united to Christ. I don’t think the Apostles boasted in their particular corner of Christianity; the Apostle Paul rebuked those who identified with their particular corner as compared to Christ. Did the Catholic Church, Orthodox Churches, or Protestant churches die for you?

To not be Catholic, Protestant, or Orthodox, is being Christian first… and to love those who happen to come from other traditions with very different theological distinctives. Yet, the ecumenical creeds can still unite us as one, regardless of our differences.
The tone and language of this thread,forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5734020&postcount=117 and particularly this post, puts me in mind of another post I read with similar vocabulary.

All I can imagine is that the writer is certainly persistent, and seems to have a single minded agenda that brings him back to CAF over and over.

Over the course of time, and thousands of posts, it seems clear that one of the goals is to entice Catholics to leave the beauty and depth of the Apostolic Faith for any "theological distinctive’ one might desire, since they are not relevant to being Christian.
 
If being united with Christ in your faith and your church is not essential to be a Christian what is?
 
Code:
How can we non-Catholic Christians be your separated brothers and sisters and follow heretics at the same time?
This is a very good question. The answer is found in the catechism. Modern day Protesatants cannot be charged with the sin of heresy committed by their spiritual forebears. Most modern protestants have never been exposed to the Apostolic faith, in order to willfully refuse to embrace it (heresy). When they are exposed to it, it is so foreign to them that they think Catholics “made up or added a bunch of stuff to the plain gospel”. This is because they come from a spiritual tradition that is separated from the Apostolic Succession for 500 years.
 
Jn 6:53 “Unless you eat the Flesh of the Son of man and drink His Blood, you have no life in you; he who eats My Flesh and drinks My Blood has eternal life.”

If only Catholics and Orthodox Christians actually eat the literal flesh and drink the actual blood of Jesus Christ, how can non-Catholics have eternal life, or be your separated brother and sisters? It sounds like theological chaos for you guys on this point.
This is also an important point. Jesus gave this command to the Church He founded. The commandment applies to persons who are under the teaching and authority of the successors of the Apostles. We understand that this is how He intends to keep His life within us.

However, God can save whoever He wants, however He likes. If He wants to save someone who does not partake of His Body and Blood in the manner in which we are commanded, that is His perogative.

The command applies to those who have recieved His teaching, not to those who have not.
 
This is a very good question. The answer is found in the catechism. Modern day Protesatants cannot be charged with the sin of heresy committed by their spiritual forebears. Most modern protestants have never been exposed to the Apostolic faith, in order to willfully refuse to embrace it (heresy). When they are exposed to it, it is so foreign to them that they think Catholics “made up or added a bunch of stuff to the plain gospel”. This is because they come from a spiritual tradition that is separated from the Apostolic Succession for 500 years.
And there you have it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top