Best approach to JWs...

  • Thread starter Thread starter DustinsDad
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DustinsDad

Guest
I might - might- for the first time get some JW folks to sit down and talk. I’ve had experience with other groups - Mormon’s and Protestants…but never got a Jehova’s Witness to actually sit down and talk.

So what’s the best approach to take? For example, with Mormon folks, I try to gently nudge them in a discussion of the “Great Apostasy” and go from there.

I don’t want to be too confrontational and just start hurling all the errors of their religioin at them - but I don’t want to waste tim either…I’ll probably just have one shot to plant some seeds.

Thanks for any responses.

Peace in Christ,

DustinsDad
 
Hi Dustinsdad,

as an ex-Jehovah’s Witness myself,
I can tell you that “The Great Apostasy” topic
would be a good thing to bring up with Jehovah’s Witness guests, too, because they basically believe the same thing happened.
They believe that the entire early Church created by the apostles throughout the Roman Empire was, doctrinally speaking,
a Jehovah’s Witness church which apostasized after the Apostles died. The same evidence against the Mormon false claim is also infallible evidence against the JW belief, too.

God bless,
Jaypeeto4
+JMJ+
 
Marcus Grodi had a great Journey Home roundtable discussion on this topic.
It would be a good primer for you if you can get a hold of it.

I know they mentioned a convert site for JW’s. They also mentioned getting into the history of the “witnesses”. The approach I would take would be openly inquisitive and ask how their views work with scripture.

One of my favorites is the 144,000. If you read the next couple verses they are identified as jews that have not been defiled by a woman(if memory serves me right). I, probably like you am reluctant to “pounce” on any hot button issues.

If I find anymore info I’ll get back to you.
 
JWs’ New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures is specifically altered to support their beliefs, so while they may CLAIM to honor other Bible translations they reject them all in reality. It won’t make any diff to them what Bible support you come up with or other scholarly literature–they reject everything but their own. Your best bet for JW apologetics is the sloppy Greek Interlinear they came up with. They are indoctrinated to believe that anything not published by the Watchtower Society is Satan’s attempt to mislead them. Even the good old King James. (very presumptuous actually.)
 
Personally, i am grateful any time i have an opportunity to speak with a JW. From what i understand from speaking with them, they are taught that anyone outside their church is a follower of Satan.

If i am a follower of Satan, i’m grateful for the chance to be set free. If i am not, i’m grateful for the chance to set them free.

It seems to me the best way to keep the conversation going so that one of us might be set free is to ask many questions and seek to understand one another.
 
Personally, i am grateful any time i have an opportunity to speak with a JW. From what i understand from speaking with them, they are taught that anyone outside their church is a follower of Satan.

If i am a follower of Satan, i’m grateful for the chance to be set free. If i am not, i’m grateful for the chance to set them free.

It seems to me the best way to keep the conversation going so that one of us might be set free is to ask many questions and seek to understand one another.
that sounds good if they were normal people. But I speak from 33 years experience and 15 as a pioneer (local missionary for the JWs) the ONLY reason they are even allowed to talk to you at all is to convert you. The second they think there is no chance of converting you they are obligated on penalty of eternal death to drop you like a bad habit. So get your questions/answers in before they decide you are a lost cause. And BTW the brainwashing is so complete that NOTHING made a difference to me. Only finding mistakes in their Greek Interlinear made me question the beliefs. I rejected anyone not a JW as being in cohoots with Satan and therefore not worth answering or even thinking about—even dangerous to answer or think about. You might be able to break a weak JW, but forget about the strong ones and just pray. It has to come from the ‘inside’. Out of decades of people trying to plant seeds of doubt, not one took root in me. What I remembered was the kindness of ‘nonbelievers’.
 
…You might be able to break a weak JW, but forget about the strong ones and just pray. It has to come from the ‘inside’. Out of decades of people trying to plant seeds of doubt, not one took root in me. What I remembered was the kindness of ‘nonbelievers’.
I imagine you did not care how much someone knew until you knew how much he cared?
 
I imagine you did not care how much someone knew until you knew how much he cared?
not exactly. it did not impress me at the time it happened, just afterwards when I was sitting in the Kingdon Hall listening to how evil everyone was and how no one but another JW wanted me to be alive and would do everything in their power to make sure my faith was corrupted and I died at Armageddon. Then it just didn’t jive with what I had experienced. The nicest people were Catholics…it jarred my perspective.
 
not exactly. it did not impress me at the time it happened, just afterwards when I was sitting in the Kingdon Hall listening to how evil everyone was and how no one but another JW wanted me to be alive and would do everything in their power to make sure my faith was corrupted and I died at Armageddon. Then it just didn’t jive with what I had experienced. The nicest people were Catholics…it jarred my perspective.
I’m not much of an apologist but I love, love, love inviting door-to-door missionaries of any faith into my living room to talk and exchange questions. I used to chide myself for not having the right answers to convert missionaries on the spot, but we always became good (if temporary:rolleyes:) friends.

Lately, I’ve come to believe that love, kindness and respect are most important when talking to missionaries. Knowledge of my Catholic faith is an important second, but second nonetheless. Your post confirmed for me how important it is to give a good, charitable witness for Catholicism.
 
Just a follow up note…

I’m getting ready to walk out the door to noon mass today(Immaculate Conception) and knock-knock-knock…finally got my follow up visit. Bad timing though.

Two fellas this time - one was the husband of the woman here before. Told me he used to be a catholic. I explained I was on my way out the door to mass and we agreed to try to meet later.

He wants, apparently, to talk to me about “death”. He gave me the two most recent of their pamplets - Awake and Watchtower.

I’ll let you know what happens next…

Peace in Christ,

DustinsDad
 
I had to learn the hard way, after sacrifices I served as a bethelite.
And watchtower basicly tossed me on my behind when they were done.
Had that not alerted me that something was not correct, I would have died jw.

HOWEVER if I knew the truth about the Catholic church in comparison with watchtower history its possible I would have atleast thought about questioning my position.
 
I might - might- for the first time get some JW folks to sit down and talk. I’ve had experience with other groups - Mormon’s and Protestants…but never got a Jehova’s Witness to actually sit down and talk.

So what’s the best approach to take? For example, with Mormon folks, I try to gently nudge them in a discussion of the “Great Apostasy” and go from there.

I don’t want to be too confrontational and just start hurling all the errors of their religioin at them - but I don’t want to waste tim either…I’ll probably just have one shot to plant some seeds.

Thanks for any responses.

Peace in Christ,

DustinsDad
A friend of mine who coverted to the JW faith recently informed me that he is done thinking for himself. In other words, he’s letting the watchtower do all his thinking for him, and he’s just going to blindly go along with them.

I think that it would be a good idea to bring up free thought and it’s roll in genuine conversion vs. mindlessly following an organization next time you speak to JWs.
 
A friend of mine who coverted to the JW faith recently informed me that he is done thinking for himself. In other words, he’s letting the watchtower do all his thinking for him, and he’s just going to blindly go along with them.

I think that it would be a good idea to bring up free thought and it’s roll in genuine conversion vs. mindlessly following an organization next time you speak to JWs.
Dear LaRock,

The JW are criticizing the RCC, and yet they copied the RCC magisterium in the Watchtower society, and even deeper. They also begin to copy the RCC organisation to maintain the JW organisation throughout the world. It is strange, for “a true christian (as they claim themselves)” to follow the method of whom they called the whore of Babel.
 
Dear LaRock,

The JW are criticizing the RCC, and yet they copied the RCC magisterium in the Watchtower society, and even deeper. They also begin to copy the RCC organisation to maintain the JW organisation throughout the world. It is strange, for “a true christian (as they claim themselves)” to follow the method of whom they called the whore of Babel.
They also use the RCC encyclepedia.
 
A friend of mine who coverted to the JW faith recently informed me that he is done thinking for himself. In other words, he’s letting the watchtower do all his thinking for him, and he’s just going to blindly go along with them. I think that it would be a good idea to bring up free thought and it’s roll in genuine conversion vs. mindlessly following an organization next time you speak to JWs.
What you are reporting is completely bizarre and I’ve never heard of such a thing in 30 years of being a JW.

To emphasize the point, here’s a discussion about “freedom of thought” from the WT magazine:

The Bible does not discourage the use ofthemind. In fact, Jesus encouraged each ofusto ‘love Jehovahwithour whole mind.’ (Mark 12:30) His ministry shows that he had a keen interest in current events (Luke 13:1-5), biology (Matthew 6:26,*28; Mark 7:18,*19), agriculture (Matthew 13:31,*32), and human nature (Matthew 5:28;*6:22-24). His illustrations indicate that he clearly understood the principles in God’s Word and the background and thinking of his listeners and that he thought carefully about how to bring the two together.

Paul entreated all Christians to render their service to God with their “power of reason.” (Romans 12:1) He encouraged the Thessalonians not to let misleading ‘inspired expressions shake them from their reason.’ (2Thessalonians 2:2) He had some knowledge of Greek and Cretan poetry (Acts 17:28; Titus 1:12) and military equipment and procedures (Ephesians 6:14-17; 2Corinthians. 2:14-16). And he was observant of local customs.—Acts 17:22,*23.

Although Jesus and Paul enjoyed so much freedom of thought, they did not view themselves as the sole authority on right and wrong. Rather than reject the Bible in favor of his own reasoning, Jesus repeatedly quoted from the Scriptures. His swift and severe reply when Peter urged him to consider a course different from the sacrificial death that was God’s will for him shows that he would not even contemplate that line of thinking. (Matthew 16:22,23) Similarly, Paul told the Corinthians: “When I came to you, it was not with any show of oratory or philosophy, but simply to tell you what God had guaranteed.” (1Corinthians 2:1, The Jerusalem Bible) Like Jesus, his reasoning was based solidly on the Scriptures.—Acts 17:2

The Bible encourages the use of one’s mental faculties to the full but not without all restraint. However, the burden of responsibility for keeping our thinking in harmony with that of Jehovah is placed on the individual Christian, not the congregation. Thus, when a number of Ephesians publicly renounced their practice of spiritism and became Christians, Paul did not take it upon himself to burn their books, but “a number of them who had practised magic collected their books and made a bonfire of them in public.”

On the other hand, the Catholic Church and the Pope have taken the initiative in the past to burn books to prevent freedom of thought:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_burning
 
This whole thing about JW’s not thinking is simply disinformation to convince people not to listen…

Question for you: Does the Catholic Church have a history of allowing “freedom of thought”? (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_burning)

Writings of Priscillian
In 383, the theologian Priscillian of Ávila became the first Christian to be executed by fellow-Christians as a heretic. Some (though not all) of his writings were condemned as heretical and burned. For many centuries they were considered irreversibly lost - but surviving copies were discovered in the 19th century.

Destruction of Cathar texts (Languedoc region of France)
A detail a Pedro Berruguete painting of a disputation between Saint Dominic of Guzman and the Albigensians (Cathars) in which the books of both were thrown on a fire, with St. Dominic’s books miraculously preserved from the flames. See the whole picture.During the 13th century, the Catholic Church waged a brutal campaign against the Cathars of Languedoc (smaller numbers also lived elsewhere in Europe), culminating in the Albigensian Crusade. Nearly every Cathar text that could be found was destroyed, in an effort to completely extirpate their heretical beliefs; only a few are known to have survived

Wycliffe’s books (at Prague)
In 1410 John Wycliffe’s books were burnt by the illiterate Prague archbishop Zbyněk Zajic z Házmburka in the court of his palace in Lesser Town of Prague to hinder the spread of Jan Hus’s teaching

Non-Catholic books (by Torquemada)
In the 1480s Tomas Torquemada promoted the burning of non-Catholic literature, especially Jewish Talmuds and, after the final defeat of the Moors at Granada in 1492, Arabic books also.

Arabic and Hebrew books (at Andalucia)
In 1490 a number of Hebrew Bibles and other Jewish books were burned at the behest of the Spanish Inquisition. In 1499 about 5000 Arabic manuscripts were consumed by flames in the public square at Granada on the orders of Ximénez de Cisneros, Archbishop of Toledo (See: Henry Kamen, The Spanish Inquisition, London: White Lion, 1965, p. 98; G.J. Toomer, Eastern Wisdome and Learninge. The Study of Arabic in Seventeenth-Century England (Oxford, 1996), p. 17). Many of the poetic works were allegedly destroyed on account of their symbolized homoeroticism. (See: Erskine Lane, tr. “In Praise of Boys: Moorish Poems from Al-Andalus”, 1975).

Tyndale’s New Testament (in England)
In October 1526 William Tyndale’s English translation of the New Testament was burned in London by Cuthbert Tunstal, Bishop of London.

Servetus’s writings (burned with their author at Geneva)
In 1553, Servetus was burned as an heretic at the order of the city council of Geneva on a remark in his translation of Ptolemy’s Geography. “Around his waist were tied a large bundle of manuscript and a thick octavo printed book”, his Christianismi Restitutio, three copies of which have survived [6].

Maya sacred books (at Yucatan)
1562 Fray Diego de Landa, acting bishop of the Yucatan, threw into the fires the sacred books of the Maya.[3]

Luther’s Bible translation (in Germany)
Martin Luther’s German translation of the Bible was burned in Germany in 1624 by order of the Pope.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top