Bible vs. Papal Bull

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bubba_Switzler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bubba_Switzler

Guest
What is the theological distinction between the books of the Bible, on the one hand, and Papal Bulls and council constitutions, declarations, and decrees, on the other hand?

Is one regarded as more inspired or authentic than the other?

What is the distinction in the closure of the biblical canon? What distinguished the letters of Paul from the letters of Clement or Benedict?
 
What is the theological distinction between the books of the Bible, on the one hand, and Papal Bulls and council constitutions, declarations, and decrees, on the other hand?
Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition are Divine Revelation and form the deposit of Faith. Papal documents, Church councils, etc, explain, defend, and interpret Divine Revelation and/or issue juridical/disciplinary pronouncements and decisions.
Is one regarded as more inspired or authentic than the other?
They are different.
What is the distinction in the closure of the biblical canon? What distinguished the letters of Paul from the letters of Clement or Benedict?
Apostolic in origin, read in the assembly, consensus

I suggest you read this article:

newadvent.org/cathen/03274a.htm
 
Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition are Divine Revelation and form the deposit of Faith. Papal documents, Church councils, etc, explain, defend, and interpret Divine Revelation and/or issue juridical/disciplinary pronouncements and decisions.

They are different.

Apostolic in origin, read in the assembly, cosensus

I suggest you read this article:

newadvent.org/cathen/03274a.htm
Just to clarify, my question is not about who authored them or what is their repsective history. That’s quite obvious.

My question is rather in regard to how they are treated theologically.

What distinguishes divine revelation from an explanation of divine revelation?
 
Just to clarify, my question is not about who authored them or what is their repsective history. That’s quite obvious.

My question is rather in regard to how they are treated theologically.

What distinguishes divine revelation from an explanation of divine revelation?
It’s a question of authority. Scripture can’t explain or interpret itself-only a living authority can do so. The Church is considered to be the “pillar and foundation of truth”, and therefore the Church’s role is to interpret both scripture and tradition. Likewise, the bible can’t determine its own canon-it requires an outside authority to do so. So whether interpreting scripture or promulgating the faith in a bull or a councillar decree or some other way, the magisterium of the Church holds authority.
 
It’s a question of authority. Scripture can’t explain or interpret itself-only a living authority can do so. The Church is considered to be the “pillar and foundation of truth”, and therefore the Church’s role is to interpret both scripture and tradition. Likewise, the bible can’t determine its own canon-it requires an outside authority to do so. So whether interpreting scripture or promulgating the faith in a bull or a councillar decree or some other way, the magisterium of the Church holds authority.
Living vs. “dead” is certainly a clear distinction. Pope Benedict can explain his meaning, Paul can’t.

But then neither can John Paul to Clement. Living vs. “dead” doesn’t distinguish Paul and Clement.

And I have as much trouble understanding Humanae Vitae as the Gospel of John.
 
Living vs. “dead” is certainly a clear distinction. Pope Benedict can explain his meaning, Paul can’t.

But then neither can John Paul to Clement. Living vs. “dead” doesn’t distinguish Paul and Clement.

And I have as much trouble understanding Humanae Vitae as the Gospel of John.
Not sure I understand. The Church made the distinction between Paul and Clement’s writings.
 
Well, yes, but what precisely is that distinction?
I see. I can’t answer that question. The Church is considered by Catholics to be guaranteed leadership on these matters by the HS. But even after being included in the canon, the Church is still required to determine meaning.
 
I see. I can’t answer that question. The Church is considered by Catholics to be guaranteed leadership on these matters by the HS. But even after being included in the canon, the Church is still required to determine meaning.
Ok, but is there a difference between determining the meaning of Paul’s letters and Clement’s letters that might explain the distinction or the meaning of it?
 
Maybe this will help.

catholic-resources.org/Bible/NT_Canon.htm

QUOTE:

Four Criteria for Canonicity (why certain books were eventually accepted into the NT Canon, while others were rejected):

Apostolic Origin - attributed to and/or based on the preaching/teaching of the first-generation apostles (or their closest companions).

Universal Acceptance - acknowledged by all major Christian communities in the Mediterranean world (by the end of the fourth century).

Liturgical Use - read publicly along with the OT when early Christians gathered for the Lord’s Supper (their weekly worship services).

Consistent Message - containing theological ideas compatible with other accepted Christian writings (incl. the divinity and humanity Jesus).

END QUOTE

St. Clement was the fourth Pope: St. Peter - died A.D. 64 or 67; St. Linis - 67-76; St. Anacletus or Cletus - 76-88; St Clement I - 88-97. (From Our Sunday Visitor’s Catholic Encyclopedia, Rev. Peter M. J. Stravinskas, Ph.D, S.T.L., Editor)

The NT had to comply with the teaching of the Church, not vice versa.
 
Maybe this will help.

catholic-resources.org/Bible/NT_Canon.htm

QUOTE:

Four Criteria for Canonicity (why certain books were eventually accepted into the NT Canon, while others were rejected):

Apostolic Origin - attributed to and/or based on the preaching/teaching of the first-generation apostles (or their closest companions).

Universal Acceptance - acknowledged by all major Christian communities in the Mediterranean world (by the end of the fourth century).

Liturgical Use - read publicly along with the OT when early Christians gathered for the Lord’s Supper (their weekly worship services).

Consistent Message - containing theological ideas compatible with other accepted Christian writings (incl. the divinity and humanity Jesus).

END QUOTE

St. Clement was the fourth Pope: St. Peter - died A.D. 64 or 67; St. Linis - 67-76; St. Anacletus or Cletus - 76-88; St Clement I - 88-97. (From Our Sunday Visitor’s Catholic Encyclopedia, Rev. Peter M. J. Stravinskas, Ph.D, S.T.L., Editor)

The NT had to comply with the teaching of the Church, not vice versa.
This is a step closer to what I am interested in figuring out.

(Let’s set aside the issue of trustworthyness which is part of the above criteria, e.g. why the Gospel of Luke and not the Gospel of Judas.)

To some extent, the criteria are begging the question. Why are the letters of Paul read liturgically and not the letters of Clement? What explains the solidification of the liturgy?

Of course the early Christians would have read what was available to them, the older the more it would circulate. But is the distinction merely an arbitrary chronological marker?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top