I am trying to develop a list of Protestant Biblical scholars who based on their growing knowledge of Scripture eventually converted to Catholicism. The first one I think of is Scott Hahn. I know many others exist but I need some help in identifying them. Can anyone add more names?
I agree Scott Hahn and Steve Ray are the first names I could think of, but keep in mind that they are pretty much popular-level authors/apologists rather than more in-depth, ‘serious’ academics. I don’t know of any
prominent scholars in the latter category who are converts
to Catholicism: everyone I could remember off the top of my head are either non-Christians/former Christians (Bart Ehrman, Robert M. Price), non-Catholic Christians (N.T. Wright, Craig Blomberg, Ben Witherington III, Ed Sanders, Marcus Borg), cradle Catholics (Luke Timothy Johnson, Dom Bernard Orchard, Fr. Roland de Vaux, Fr. Raymond Brown, Fr. Joseph Fitzmyer, Fr. John P. Meier), or former/fallen-away Catholics/priests (John Dominic Crossan, J.T. Milik). I suspect that there
are less-well known academics who are converts out there, but I haven’t looked deep enough.
The late
Geza Vermes (known mainly for his work on the Dead Sea Scrolls) was a Catholic once but he’s not really what you’re asking for: he was born into a non-practicing Jewish family, he and his parents converted to Catholicism when he was seven to escape the increasing anti-Jewish sentiment of the 1930s (his parents however never survived the Holocaust), he even became a priest but later eventually left the priesthood to marry and reverted to Judaism.
As I’m writing this, I did find
William Reynolds (1544-1594), a convert from Anglicanism who became one of the translators of the Rheims New Testament. He’ll probably fit your bill better, but he might be a little too ‘ancient’ for your liking (he was from the 16th century).