Birth control and endometriosis?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TQGC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TQGC

Guest
I apologize if this question has been asked a dozen and one times, but I am honestly confused. Is it okay to use birth control if it’s specifically to treat a medical condition, such as endometriosis? I have been trying to find things to relieve my pain naturally, but nothing has helped so I am considering BC, as long as it doesn’t go against the Church. Thank you for your time.
 
I apologize if this question has been asked a dozen and one times, but I am honestly confused. Is it okay to use birth control if it’s specifically to treat a medical condition, such as endometriosis? I have been trying to find things to relieve my pain naturally, but nothing has helped so I am considering BC, as long as it doesn’t go against the Church. Thank you for your time.
Yes. there are numerous threads on the subject. You can use the search function.

The difference is if you are using a medication (birth control) to treat a legitimate condition then the primary purpose is not “birth control” The principle of double effect applies.
Though, (we cannot give out medical advice on the boards) I would think one can ask for alternative treatments if being on ABC is not desirable/healthy. The folks at NAPRO TECH could help. Have you contacted them? A good pro life doctor familiar with NFP and pro life issues is the best scenario…
 
I did a little research on this. It seems nothing is very pleasant in order to deal with this disease, and it is a disease.

Not only does the tissue grow outside the uterus, it can cause cysts and tumors. Also, endometriosis can cause infertility sometimes.

The one procedure I heard of, which was done by someone I know, is endometrial ablation, which means they burn the tissue out of the uterus as to thin the lining to avoid building on to the endometriosis and making it worse. Then there are two other drugs, one of which can cause weight gain and depression and the other one can cause acne and abnormal hair growth. They also sometimes look for growths surgically and remove them that way, or they resort to hysterectomy.
 
Contraception increases your risk for breast cancer. It will not treat endometriosis. It will merely mask the symptoms. Try to find an NFP doctor that will treat it naturally. Surgery can also remove it.
 
Hormonal medication can be an effective way to treat (yes - treat) endometriosis and is morally acceptable if medically advisable. My wife has needed to go down this route and it has been a great relief. Of course, you should not take medical advice given here but rely on your own doctors.

It is also worth noting that while some research has suggested a small increased risk of breast cancer in women taking the combined oral contraceptive, research also shows that those who suffer endo are at a far increased risk of other cancers (endometrial and cervical) and thus treating the endo had a greater benefit re cancer risks than detriment.
 
Contraception increases your risk for breast cancer. It will not treat endometriosis. It will merely mask the symptoms. Try to find an NFP doctor that will treat it naturally. Surgery can also remove it.
Just curious–what’s the risk?
 
That you might get breast cancer? Just a guess…😉
“The results of population studies to examine associations between oral contraceptive use and cancer risk have not always been consistent. Overall, however, the risks of **endometrial **and ovarian cancer appear to be reduced with the use of oral contraceptives, whereas the risks of breast, cervical, and liver cancer appear to be increased.”

cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/hormones/oral-contraceptives-fact-sheet

I bolded endometrial, because that might have some relevance to the OP.

She might want to talk to her doctor about her particular risk profile.
 
That you might get breast cancer? Just a guess…😉
HA ha ha.

I mean–what are the odds that a woman taking BCP gets breast cancer against the population of women who don’t take BCP. Or however it would be worded by a health statistics researcher.
 
From the link provided by Xantippe:

"A 1996 analysis of epidemiologic data from more than 50 studies worldwide by the Collaborative Group on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer found that women who were current or recent users of birth control pills had a slightly higher risk of developing breast cancer than women who had never used the pill (2). The risk was highest for women who started using oral contraceptives as teenagers. However, 10 or more years after women stopped using oral contraceptives, their risk of developing breast cancer had returned to the same level as if they had never used birth control pills, regardless of family history of breast cancer, reproductive history, geographic area of residence, ethnic background, differences in study design, dose and type of hormone(s) used, or duration of use. In addition, breast cancers diagnosed in women who had stopped using oral contraceptives for 10 or more years were less advanced than breast cancers diagnosed in women who had never used oral contraceptives.

"A recent analysis of data from the Nurses’ Health Study, which has been following more than 116,000 female nurses who were 24 to 43 years old when they enrolled in the study in 1989 (3), found that the participants who used oral contraceptives had a slight increase in breast cancer risk. However, nearly all of the increased risk was seen among women who took a specific type of oral contraceptive, a “triphasic” pill, in which the dose of hormones is changed in three stages over the course of a woman’s monthly cycle.

“Because the association with the triphasic formulation was unexpected, more research will be needed to confirm the findings from the Nurses’ Health Study.”
 
Fellow Endometreosis sufferer here! 🙂

Let me be the first to say I am so incredibly sorry you have to suffer through this nightmare. It’s just awful at times. :console:

First and foremost if you are blessed to have a doctor who has studied NaPro technology, they specialize in laparoscopic surgery for the removal of Endometriosis and the treating of infertility. An added bonus is they are often Catholic. If not, then ask various GYNs in your area and see if they specialize in endometriosis. Even if you don’t wish to have surgery now it’s good to know a doctor who knows what he’s doing if that desire or need arises.

You are certainly allowed to take the birth control pill for this reason, but ask for a progesterone only form. The formulas with estrogen will only make your Endo worse, and can potentially abort a child if it is managed to be conceived while on the BCP. It can and does happen. 😦

I have been very tempted, but managed to steer clear of the BCP through these surgeries (I’ve had 2) that do help relieve pain and symptoms. But I also have the luxury of being able to take time off for these surgeries and healings, not everyone does. You may work and can’t take time off and that is acceptable.

That being said, the BCP will not treat existing Endo. You need to have that surgically removed via laparoscopic surgery.
 
Contraception increases your risk for breast cancer. It will not treat endometriosis. It will merely mask the symptoms. Try to find an NFP doctor that will treat it naturally. Surgery can also remove it.
There isn’t anything in modern medical science that will reliably completely cure endo. Birth control will prevent the formation of new lesions, quite possibly preserving fertility.
 
There isn’t anything in modern medical science that will reliably completely cure endo. Birth control will prevent the formation of new lesions, quite possibly preserving fertility.
If that’s so, those are major points in favor of BCP for endometriosis.
 
There isn’t anything in modern medical science that will reliably completely cure endo. Birth control will prevent the formation of new lesions, quite possibly preserving fertility.
You are correct about there not being a cure yet for Endometriosis.

Yes the BCP can prevent new Endometriosis from forming, but it cannot give relief from endometriosis that already exists.

To experience the fullness of pain relief a laproscopic surgery is required and all Endometriosis must be completely destroyed, not just cauterized. This is why a doctor who specializes in Endometriosis is necessary, not just a basic GYN.
 
If that’s so, those are major points in favor of BCP for endometriosis.
After Endometriosis removal surgery it can be an effective measure to delay the growth of new Endometriosis. Some individuals will receive some pain relief from Progesterone based BCPs prior to surgery because their bodies are filled with estrogen and often don’t make much progesterone on their own. And it can also help delay the disease from spreading further. t least that’s what I’ve read. 🤷
 
Contraception increases your risk for breast cancer. It will not treat endometriosis. It will merely mask the symptoms. Try to find an NFP doctor that will treat it naturally. Surgery can also remove it.
My mother took it in order to help stop the symptoms and she is cancer free today. I am sure it can be bad but I would try not to focus on that part of it. The symptoms can be horrible and I have been told what they are like.
 
I also suffer from endometriosis. While it’s tempting to use BCP, they only treat the symptoms, not the cause. While it’s not completely understood, I’ve read plenty of articles discussing unbalanced hormones as a leading cause (which explains why many who have surgery to remove endo have to keep having surgery as it keeps growing back).

Go to the Pope Paul VI Institute’s website- you can search for a NaPro doctor there. Don’t hesitate to contact one even if they aren’t very near. The nearest one to me is 3 hours away. Besides the first visit and surgery, we do our consults on the phone and I get any bloodwork or testing at the local hospital. I’ve seen some of the best doctors Chicago has to offer, but my NaPro doctor is the first who’s actually helped me.
 
After Endometriosis removal surgery it can be an effective measure to delay the growth of new Endometriosis. Some individuals will receive some pain relief from Progesterone based BCPs prior to surgery because their bodies are filled with estrogen and often don’t make much progesterone on their own. And it can also help delay the disease from spreading further. t least that’s what I’ve read. 🤷
True, though a natural form of progesterone does the job just as well and without the risks. One problem with BCP is that they aren’t individually tailored to the woman. Most docs simply prescribe. They don’t test hormone levels and then work to make them normal. A NaPro doctor will test hormones and then work to harmonize. So if progesterone is low, a natural version, at the correct dose for that woman, is used. Hormones are routinely checked in case adjustment is needed. You don’t get that kind of tailoring with BCP.
 
The only answer you really need is yes, it is okay with the Catholic Church to use birth control pills to deal with your illness. All of the other things people are saying here are irrelevant, unless you’re looking for medical advice. It is probably a good idea to listen to your doctor, and if you don’t like what he or she says, find another doctor.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top