Actually he cares so much he gives us complete freedom to live our lives any way we want
No, he does NOT give the necessary freedom to care for all the sick, to feed all the hungry, to protect all the victims of violence.
You would have a god that so controlled our lives there was no good or evil
Bless your heart! (Here in the deep South this phrase takes away the insulting edge of ANY expression preceding or following it.) Here is a small exchange for your edification:
Prosecution: You saw your 10 years old son to go pick up your gun.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I did.
Prosecution: Then you saw him aiming the gun at his sister’s head.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I did.
Prosecution: You saw that he was about to pull the trigger.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I saw that, too.
Prosecution: And you just stood there, and watched him.
Defendant: Yes, sir, that is what I did.
Prosecution: Why didn’t you interfere?
Defendant: Well, sir, my first reaction was to take away the gun and give him a good spanking for disobedience.
Prosecution: What disobedience?
Defendant: Well, sir, I told him not to pick up that gun.
Prosecution: So why did you let him do it?
Defendant: Simple, sir. I love him so much that I let him conduct his life as he sees fit. I care about him very much. I did not want him to become a “robot”, who can only love his sister, who would only protect her… after all that would be an empty gesture, if I prevented him from causing harm to her.
Prosecution: But what about the sister, the victim? Didn’t you care about her?
Defendant: Of course I cared about her. But that is the price she had to pay for having the freedom.
Nothing is as precious as the freedom of the murders, the rapists and the torturers!
Judge: Take this defendant, put him into the deepest dungeon and throw away the key!
Disclaimer: this little parable is not a criticism of the church. It is a criticism of those ill-begotten apologists (bless their heart!), whose “defense” of God is actually worse than any “attack” on God’s non-interference policy.