Birth control not allowed but it is allowed

  • Thread starter Thread starter upant
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have attended two weddings in the last twenty years or so where the husband either suffered from a horrible neuromuscular disorder and, in the second case, where the husband had been in a near fatal bike accident and is a paraplegic from the chest down. Guess what??? These very joyful weddings were both held in Catholic churches and the marriages were celebrated by priests. In the real world, not the perfect internet forum world, I think that compassion and human kindness really does trump some dogma. Our Holy priests know their flock and are more discerning than they are given credit for.🙂
 
I have attended two weddings in the last twenty years or so where the husband either suffered from a horrible neuromuscular disorder and, in the second case, where the husband had been in a near fatal bike accident and is a paraplegic from the chest down. Guess what??? These very joyful weddings were both held in Catholic churches and the marriages were celebrated by priests. In the real world, not the perfect internet forum world, I think that compassion and human kindness really does trump some dogma. Our Holy priests know their flock and are more discerning than they are given credit for.🙂
The Long answer to this is:

And you have absolutely no idea whether either of these men were capable of having sex or if there was a chance their inability to have sex could possibly be rectified in the future.(the Church errs on the side of believing it can) The Priest who married them would have investigated this and come to the conclusion that they met the requirements to be married in the Church

The short answer is:

Anecdotal evidence proves nothing
 
No. I think that if a married couple wants to have sex, they should engage whenever they want, whether it is the fertile period or not.
So the bible doesn’t say
Do not deprive each other except by mutual consent and for a time, so that you may devote yourselves to prayer. Then come together again so that Satan will not tempt you because of your lack of self-control.
1 Corinthians 5

So if a couple agrees to abstain for a time, because they do not think they can have another child and devote themselves to prayer during this time. But they decide to use infertile times so they are not tempted beyond their self-control this is sinning?

Lets put children out of the question all together. The church says we may not disorder the marital act. This is what makes contraception a sin. Abstinence is not disordering sex.

According to your logic, complete abstinence would also be contraception?

Lets us use a logic trail.
  1. It is not a sin to engage in the marital act while infertile.
  2. It is not a sin to abstain from the marital act while fertile.
  3. Therefore it is not a sin to engage in the marital act while infertile and to abstain from the marital act while fertile.
The only thing that can make the above actions a sin, would be intentions. But the Church is clear. We may use “birth control” for a just reason. Therefore the only sin in using NFP would be using it while having an unjust reason. Which frankly would be a hard thing to judge.

*birth control here is either complete or periodic abstinence.
 
The translation is we have free will-next to life the greatest gift God gave us
I sincerely HOPE that neither you nor your loved ones will ever have to experience that “great gift” of free will at the hand of a psychopath. You would learn to curse the “gift” of free will very quickly.
 
I sincerely HOPE that neither you nor your loved ones will ever have to experience that “great gift” of free will at the hand of a psychopath. You would learn to curse the “gift” of free will very quickly.
How do you know we haven’t? It’s not God’s fault it’s the psychopaths fault
 
How do you know we haven’t? It’s not God’s fault it’s the psychopaths fault
I will try it one more time. If you have knowledge of an act of rape, murder and torture BEFORE it happens, and if you have the power to PREVENT it, and you don’t interfere, then you are exactly as guilty as the actual perpetrator.
 
No. I have noticed that a few people on the board use NFP and they don’t do anything on their fertile days because they don’t want more children. IMO, that is contraception. Still using a method to avoid conception. Just because someone isn’t using condoms or taking ABC doesn’t mean they aren’t contracepting.
What do you mean no? If they are not having sex on their fertile days, doesn’t that intrinsically mean that they don’t want to have sex, whatever the reason for not having sex? Here is your quote, where you seem to say not having sex is against God’s will:
I agree. I don’t understand it, either. BC is BC, whether artificial or natural. Either way, two people are interfering with God’s will.
Then you said:
No. I think that if a married couple wants to have sex, they should engage whenever they want, whether it is the fertile period or not.
You are sending mixed messages here. First you say not having sex is against God’s will, then you say they should have sex whenever they want. So in your opinion, is it a bad thing if a couple does not want to have sex during the fertile period? Doesn’t that go against your statement about having sex when they want?

Do you understand that an NFP’r has done nothing to alter the natural ends of the act itself, but that an ABC’r has blocked the natural ends of the act? The timing of the act does not alter the natural ends of the act at that particular moment. That is a huge difference.
 
I will try it one more time. If you have knowledge of an act of rape, murder and torture BEFORE it happens, and if you have the power to PREVENT it, and you don’t interfere, then you are exactly as guilty as the actual perpetrator.
Can you imagine the pure hell a world without free will would-be ? I prefer freedom to slavery
 
Can you imagine the pure hell a world without free will would-be ? I prefer freedom to slavery
Nonsense. If you would be a total automaton, you would not even be AWARE of it, therefore you could not resent it. It would be perfectly normal and natural to you.

It is funny that you keep on avoiding the problem. Can you give some rational arguments against what I stated:
If you have knowledge of an act of rape, murder and torture BEFORE it happens, and if you have the power to PREVENT it, and you don’t interfere, then you are exactly as guilty as the actual perpetrator.
Furthermore, I did not suggest “slavery”. I suggested “limited freedom”. Can you see the difference? This is not a rhetorical question. I expect an answer.
 
Nonsense. If you would be a total automaton, you would not even be AWARE of it, therefore you could not resent it. It would be perfectly normal and natural to you.

It is funny that you keep on avoiding the problem. Can you give some rational arguments against what I stated:
If you have knowledge of an act of rape, murder and torture BEFORE it happens, and if you have the power to PREVENT it, and you don’t interfere, then you are exactly as guilty as the actual perpetrator.
Furthermore, I did not suggest “slavery”. I suggested “limited freedom”. Can you see the difference? This is not a rhetorical question. I expect an answer.
It seems you are making a claim concerning the problem of evil. If you are trying to say that God is responsible for evil acts then He is only in so far as He allows them to occur. His permissive will certainly does allow evil acts.

But as with any act if it is part of a greater good then there is no problem. For instance, a surgeon cutting into a person is evil in so far as it causes pain and runs the risk of killing the person. But the act is good because it is part of a surgical procedure that is intended to heal the person of some sickness.

If God allows evil because a greater good results then there is nothing wrong with allowing evil acts. And of course with problem of evil arguments the bigger issue is what comfort does the other side offer? How much better will you feel if suffering and death has no redemption? You may have, in your mind, disproved God but you haven’t in any way put an end to evil.
 
But as with any act if it is part of a greater good then there is no problem. For instance, a surgeon cutting into a person is evil in so far as it causes pain and runs the risk of killing the person. But the act is good because it is part of a surgical procedure that is intended to heal the person of some sickness.
I agree. All you have to do now is to PROVE without a shade of a doubt (not just reasonable doubt!) that each and every instance of SEEMINGLY evil acts actually are necessary to bring forth some “greater good”. You cannot argue that MAYBE there is some greater good, and if only we would be aware of it we would accept it. You need concrete, rational arguments.
If God allows evil because a greater good results then there is nothing wrong with allowing evil acts.
Indeed. Start with the holocaust.
And of course with problem of evil arguments the bigger issue is what comfort does the other side offer? How much better will you feel if suffering and death has no redemption? You may have, in your mind, disproved God but you haven’t in any way put an end to evil.
That is irrelevant. A make-belief “comfort” is worthless. In a godless universe there is no NATURAL evil. Things are what they are. We can try to predict the acts of “Mother nature”, and we can try to avoid the consequences. We are getting pretty good with predicting hurricanes, though not with Earthquakes. Unfortunately we can only react to the acts of evil people. So we do what little we can do, and that is isolating them (jails and prisons) so that their freedom is limited.

And that is what my “complaint” is all about. We have far too much freedom to create mayhem, and far too little freedom to prevent it. Also not enough freedom to “fix” the consequences. It is rather discouraging that people keep harping about “automatons” and “robots”. They are either unable to comprehend the difference, or pretend not to understand.

By the way, the existence of evil does NOT disprove God. It simply proves that God cannot be “good”. At best God is neutral or uncaring.
 
I agree. All you have to do now is to PROVE without a shade of a doubt (not just reasonable doubt!) that each and every instance of SEEMINGLY evil acts actually are necessary to bring forth some “greater good”. You cannot argue that MAYBE there is some greater good, and if only we would be aware of it we would accept it. You need concrete, rational arguments.

Indeed. Start with the holocaust.

That is irrelevant. A make-belief “comfort” is worthless. In a godless universe there is no NATURAL evil. Things are what they are. We can try to predict the acts of “Mother nature”, and we can try to avoid the consequences. We are getting pretty good with predicting hurricanes, though not with Earthquakes. Unfortunately we can only react to the acts of evil people. So we do what little we can do, and that is isolating them (jails and prisons) so that their freedom is limited.

And that is what my “complaint” is all about. We have far too much freedom to create mayhem, and far too little freedom to prevent it. Also not enough freedom to “fix” the consequences. It is rather discouraging that people keep harping about “automatons” and “robots”. They are either unable to comprehend the difference, or pretend not to understand.

By the way, the existence of evil does NOT disprove God. It simply proves that God cannot be “good”. At best God is neutral or uncaring.
Actually he cares so much he gives us complete freedom to live our lives any way we want You would have a god that so controlled our lives there was no good or evil
 
Actually he cares so much he gives us complete freedom to live our lives any way we want
No, he does NOT give the necessary freedom to care for all the sick, to feed all the hungry, to protect all the victims of violence.
You would have a god that so controlled our lives there was no good or evil
Bless your heart! (Here in the deep South this phrase takes away the insulting edge of ANY expression preceding or following it.) Here is a small exchange for your edification:

Prosecution: You saw your 10 years old son to go pick up your gun.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I did.
Prosecution: Then you saw him aiming the gun at his sister’s head.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I did.
Prosecution: You saw that he was about to pull the trigger.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I saw that, too.
Prosecution: And you just stood there, and watched him.
Defendant: Yes, sir, that is what I did.
Prosecution: Why didn’t you interfere?
Defendant: Well, sir, my first reaction was to take away the gun and give him a good spanking for disobedience.
Prosecution: What disobedience?
Defendant: Well, sir, I told him not to pick up that gun.
Prosecution: So why did you let him do it?
Defendant: Simple, sir. I love him so much that I let him conduct his life as he sees fit. I care about him very much. I did not want him to become a “robot”, who can only love his sister, who would only protect her… after all that would be an empty gesture, if I prevented him from causing harm to her.
Prosecution: But what about the sister, the victim? Didn’t you care about her?
Defendant: Of course I cared about her. But that is the price she had to pay for having the freedom. Nothing is as precious as the freedom of the murders, the rapists and the torturers!

Judge:
Take this defendant, put him into the deepest dungeon and throw away the key!

Disclaimer: this little parable is not a criticism of the church. It is a criticism of those ill-begotten apologists (bless their heart!), whose “defense” of God is actually worse than any “attack” on God’s non-interference policy.
 
No, he does NOT give the necessary freedom to care for all the sick, to feed all the hungry, to protect all the victims of violence.

Bless your heart! (Here in the deep South this phrase takes away the insulting edge of ANY expression preceding or following it.) Here is a small exchange for your edification:

Prosecution: You saw your 10 years old son to go pick up your gun.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I did.
Prosecution: Then you saw him aiming the gun at his sister’s head.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I did.
Prosecution: You saw that he was about to pull the trigger.
Defendant: Yes, sir, I saw that, too.
Prosecution: And you just stood there, and watched him.
Defendant: Yes, sir, that is what I did.
Prosecution: Why didn’t you interfere?
Defendant: Well, sir, my first reaction was to take away the gun and give him a good spanking for disobedience.
Prosecution: What disobedience?
Defendant: Well, sir, I told him not to pick up that gun.
Prosecution: So why did you let him do it?
Defendant: Simple, sir. I love him so much that I let him conduct his life as he sees fit. I care about him very much. I did not want him to become a “robot”, who can only love his sister, who would only protect her… after all that would be an empty gesture, if I prevented him from causing harm to her.
Prosecution: But what about the sister, the victim? Didn’t you care about her?
Defendant: Of course I cared about her. But that is the price she had to pay for having the freedom. Nothing is as precious as the freedom of the murders, the rapists and the torturers!

Judge:
Take this defendant, put him into the deepest dungeon and throw away the key!

Disclaimer: this little parable is not a criticism of the church. It is a criticism of those ill-begotten apologists (bless their heart!), whose “defense” of God is actually worse than any “attack” on God’s non-interference policy.
Actually the problem is those who condemn God because he doesn’t act the way they want him to. Without free will we are nothing
 
I agree. All you have to do now is to PROVE without a shade of a doubt (not just reasonable doubt!) that each and every instance of SEEMINGLY evil acts actually are necessary to bring forth some “greater good”. You cannot argue that MAYBE there is some greater good, and if only we would be aware of it we would accept it. You need concrete, rational arguments.
I think we are getting a bit off the main topic so it might be better to start a new thread. But I don’t think one has to prove, without a shade of doubt (which would be another serious issue to address), that all acts are actually necessary. If you are making an argument against God because of evil we’d first need to know your actual argument. But generally as long as the logical possibility exists that a greater good can follow it is sufficient to refute the argument.
By the way, the existence of evil does NOT disprove God. It simply proves that God cannot be “good”. At best God is neutral or uncaring.
What is evil without God? Where does this standard of goodness come from? In order to disprove God you are using goodness, which I would argue can only come from God, to disprove him. But that will not work. If you are arguing against God because he is not good you’d first need to explain where goodness comes from. And I think you’ll have a problem with that if there is no God.
 
If you are making an argument against God because of evil we’d first need to know your actual argument.
I am not interested in bringing up arguments against the existence of God. Unfortunately God is not sufficiently well defined to argue against his existence. It is not God’s actual existence which is in question, rather God’s alleged “goodness”. Against the problem of evil, there are several defenses. One is the “greater good” defense, which you started to talk about. The other is the “free will” defense, which is even worse.
But generally as long as the logical possibility exists that a greater good can follow it is sufficient to refute the argument.
No, that is not sufficient. Something that is “logically” possible does not entail that the object is physically possible or that it actually (not just logically) exists.
What is evil without God? Where does this standard of goodness come from? In order to disprove God you are using goodness, which I would argue can only come from God, to disprove him. But that will not work. If you are arguing against God because he is not good you’d first need to explain where goodness comes from. And I think you’ll have a problem with that if there is no God.
Good, bad, evil are all easy to define based upon biology (and its derivatives). If you are interested, we can explore this field.
 
No. I think that if a married couple wants to have sex, they should engage whenever they want, whether it is the fertile period or not.
Do you mean that if and when desire strikes, the couple ought feel bound to pursue it?
 
a couple practicing NFP is using NFP as a contraceptive. If the intent is to not get pregnant then the timing of the act is used in lieu of latex or something else and is still BC. Thanks for everyone’s answers but most skirt the issue of intent. If BC is wrong then NFP should also be wrong.

What am I missing that hasn’t been said in prior post
Your error is thinking that “BC” is wrong. It is perfectly fine to defer /avoid conception by choosing not to have sex during fertile times. Contraception is a very specific act - one that interferes with a sexual act. That is the thing the Church teaches as immoral
 
No. I have noticed that a few people on the board use NFP and they don’t do anything on their fertile days because they don’t want more children. IMO, that is contraception. Still using a method to avoid conception. Just because someone isn’t using condoms or taking ABC doesn’t mean they aren’t contracepting.
But you would be in error (In so far as Catholic teaching is concerned). It is permissible to be averse to more children, and it is permissible to limit sexual relations (NFP) to that end. It is not permissible to utilize ABC to that end.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top