QUOTE=Melchior_;10437127]You continually describe how the pill is an abortificant, … I already am familiar with the mechanics of how this works though, and you have yet to provide scientific evidence that indicates a woman on the pill can ovulate on the same day as her period, which is a claim you made earlier.
I am saying bleeding because a woman stops adding artificial Rx hormones (the pill) to her body is not the same as bleeding because she is having a normal hormonal change (a period) which puts her in Phase I of a fertility cycle.
A woman in Phase I is not going to ovulate. She will not ovulate until all her hormones line up to put her in the ovulation stage of Phase II.
The woman on the pill who ovulates does not ovulate because of the same changes in hormones. She ovulates for some reason in which the Rx hormone did not keep her body in the “I think I’m pregnant mode.” The level of Rx hormone in her body is not tricking her body into thinking she is pregnant, so her body ovulates.
Perhaps I’m not making myself clear here; I never denied this. In my very first post, I said we would actively do everything we can to avoid the abortifcant qualities. You have missed this throughout every one of your posts.
I have not missed the fact that you want to avoid the abortifacient qualities. That is exactly why I keep saying a woman is not going to know when her body decides to have a break through ovulation while on the pill.
We’re not talking going hog wild and renewing the marriage covenant every day, multiple times each day. We’re talking having sex once after the period, which doctors and the literature I have read said that can happen while on this medication. If there isn’t a period, then we’re not having sex. It’s a straightforward concept.
I’m saying the bleeding is not equal to Phase I - a period - infertile time. There are no Phase I, Phase II, or Phase III for the woman on a pill.
I understand everything that you’re saying, however two pharmacists, two doctors, three nurses,and several websites I have seen have mentioned that, yes, you can have a real period while on the pill. Especially if you have not had one in some time. You have yet to provide links, papers, or documents to prove that after a real period, ovulation can happen the day you have an actual period.
Not everyone uses terminology the same way. Maybe they are using “real period” in a different way than I am trying to express. I am trying to express that a period is a part of a fertility cycle with several different hormones cycling through the body so that the body has all three phases.
These hormones are shut off when you add a Rx hormone (the pill). The hormones are not going to function from the woman’s body. She only has a steady supply of the Rx hormone. If the Rx hormone level is not maintained at a specific level then the woman can ovulate, but she is not ovulating based on being in Phase II.
You seem very determined to deny having a couple who hasn’t had sex in almost a year and a half due to a woman’s cycle being either irregular or non-existent from re-consummating their marriage once. Once. After a period, which medical professionals have told us would be fine. I understand your concern, it mirrors ours. Which is why we asked as many professionals as we could find. If you or anyone else have evidence from medical professionals that prove that we cannot have sex after her period (assuming that she gets a real period), please post it, as we do want to avoid any abortificantation,
I am sorry that you think I am determined to deny anyone a sexual relationship through intercourse with their beloved spouse. I am sorry you and your beautiful wife are bearing the cross of having a fertility cycle that is not functioning properly. I admire you both for your faithfulness in love to each other and Church teachings.
My only concern is that if your wife has bleeding (withdrawal bleeding as it is sometimes called when on the pill) - what if she ovulates while your sperm have a chance to meet with the egg she released.
Maybe this will explain what I am not able to convey:
ccli.org/nfp/stm-method/hormones.php
Maybe the visual pie chart will be better:
ccli.org/nfp/stm-method/female-cycle.php
Looking at the pie chart, we see a woman with a healthy fertility cycle has a small “part of the pie chart” when she is fertile. We also see that she goes through a cycle of hormonal changes which causes physical changes in her body before and after the ovulation.
The woman who ovulates while on the pill is not going through this normal cycle. There is no way to predict when this will happen.
Maybe ask professionals if withdrawal bleeding is the same as being in Phase I of the fertility cycle. The withdrawal bleeding is a reaction to the change in the Rx hormone level. Some women choose to take Rx pills that do not take the break in hormones that offers the withdrawal bleeding. I am saying withdrawal bleeding and a period are not the same.
Maybe calling ccli and asking, “If my wife is on the birth control pill to help “regulate her cycle”, can we know beyond a doubt that if we have sexual relations on the last day of her “withdrawal bleeding” that she will not ovulate then or anytime until after my sperm have all died in her body.
Can we know we have nothing to worry about, as we do not want to experience the abortifacient properties of this drug?”
Peace my friend.