Bit scandalous but

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kts1816
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Kts1816

Guest
As we all know we must not reach Jesus (Eucharist) when with sin…i have always asked myself how were all sinfull people in NT been able to reach him in that state…(Maybe Protestants will be pleased with this topic).
Not sure of the Apostoles,too (in the last Supper).
Sometimes not quite sure of Judas,too.
So sorry if i offend you or seem ignorant.
 
The prostitutes in the NT did not reccieve the Eucharist. I would say their experiences could be likened to Eucharistic adoration.

As for Judas, nothing in the Bible (as far as I know) says at he reccieved the Eucharist at the Last Supper.
 
I thought he (Judas) left early…
Could the fallen women have taken part in the Eucharist following Pentecost?
 
I helieve that is true.

And if they had repented to the standards of the Early Church, yes. Nothing different from today.
 
I dont understant your comment about the prostitutes that didnt recieved the Eucharist…they were next to Jesus himself who forgave them…
 
yes, but they were not present at the Last Supper, where Jesus instituted the Eucharist. They were in the presence of the Bread of Life, but did not reccieve him in the same way the Apostles did.
 
But as we know Apostoles also were sinfull(peter)…do they confessed before eating with Christ?
 
They were not present to the Last supper but were with living Christ…
Who is greater Christ biologically alive or in form of bread and wine…
 
I Would say there is no reason to say thay had not.

Also, there is nothing in the Gospels to lead us to believe that any of the Apostles (save Judas) were in a state of mortal sin before the Last Supper.
 
I don’t think that’s how the Eucharist works. The Eucharist is the true body, blood, soul, and divinity of Christ. It should be exactly the same as standing next to Him when He was with His Apostles, since both are His physical presence.
 
Gospels also dont give us the information (dont want to offend you,just disscussing) that they were in a state of grace( maybe i am wrong) but as Peter stayes he is a sinfull man.
 
which is greater, .5 or 1/2?

neither. they are both the same thing.
 
yes, but I would say that nearly all of us here are in a state of venial sin.

one can be sinful, but not mortally so.
 
Again, back to Euchariatic Adoration- one can meet Jesus, talk to Him, and not consume him in the Eucharist.
 
But He forgave them,even touched some of the sinners.
How can somebody eat of Him when biologically alive?
Things has changed I guess.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top