Blaming it all on Vatican II?

  • Thread starter Thread starter agr4028
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My apologies JR. XO and make up?

In my post (#184) I was quoting dyspepsic, not JR. Sorry for the confusion. Computer’s on a high or something.:confused:

dyspepsic, you have a quote backing up your claim?
 
DustinsDad said:
Not exactly - He is three persons in one Divine Being.

The Son of God, the Word, is the Second Person of the Trinity - and this Divine Person took on flesh at the Incarnation. This is Jesus, the Divine Person that is both fully human, and fully God.

Ah the mystery of the Hypostatic Union! We could meditate on that for the rest of our lives.

Peace in Christ,

DustinsDad
Click to expand...
Ok lets do it this way the Trinity, the 3 Persons made up of one = God. Cant we agree on that one, And then lets just call it a good day, Will that work?
 
dyspepsic said:
“The presumption is that the Council was hijacked”.

Let’s see.

You are a Sedevacantist. So you don’t believe we even have a Pope.

But the rest of the Roman Catholic Church does believe we have a Vicar of Christ on earth. And that Vicar of Christ on earth convocked a General Council, known to all as the Second Vatican Council.

And as practicing Catholics believe the Holy Spirit guides his Church, and was present at this Council. So the Council could not have been hijacked by anybody, since his Spirit was there.

He guided it, and saw to its fulfillment.

Accept it, and stop telling us about your presumptions. You should return to the Roman Catholic Church, so we have no more of these strange Sedevacantist views on this website.
Click to expand...
I woudn’t begin the presumptions again, there are very few Sedevacantists on this site. And nobody with a brain will join the Church when false charity presides over truth. The two go hand in hand.

The promise of Christ does not guarantee the proper implementation of Councils, just as it doesn’t guarantee Christian behavior from Popes. I believe you said (I apologize if it was someone else) that after every Council in the Church there was a time of confusion. Why do you not accept that the same thing is happening today? That the *implementing *of the Council was a bit off, not quite right?
 
rinnie said:
Ok lets do it this way the Trinity, the 3 Persons made up of one = God. Cant we agree on that one, And then lets just call it a good day, Will that work?
Click to expand...
Absolutely - I knew what you meant, it was just the wording was off a bit. Not hard when discussing the Mystery of the Trinity!

Peace in Christ,

DustinsDad
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top