Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich -- worth reading?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JesuXPIPassio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JesuXPIPassio

Guest
This isn’t about her sanctity, which is unquestionable.

But I read that her writings were heavily edited and made more sensationalistic. It’s not that she wrote untruths, but it’s that the man who edited it put questionable things in.

I did start off by trying to read her Dolorous Passion. I was immediately suspicious when it talked about how Jesus consecrated the Apostles as Bishops at the Last Supper, using oil and chrism. I don’t know much about the history of that custom and articles about it can’t really mention much except that it was mentioned by some early saints, but my instincts tell me it probably developed through time. I stopped reading right there because I was afraid of getting disinformation. Lo and behold, I read up about it and found that Emmerich’s editor may have altered things.

Is her stuff worth reading? Why or why not?
 
I read this on the internet:
Using the revelations of Emmerich, Heinrich Schliemann discovered the Chaldean’s City of Ur. Using the books of Emmerich over a 100 years after her death two Lazarist priests from Smyrna, Fathers Poulin and Yung, determined to check the authenticity of Sister Emmerich.

Emmerich had described the exact location of Our Lady’s house in Ephesus and her death and bodily resurrection from that place. Every detail was given in her revelations, to the location, to its size, its interior, a cave next to it, the stations of the Cross John built for Her, the later Basilica built for Her there, the cave of John’s death and his Basilica, all in Ephesus.

After five days’ search in the mountains south of the ancient city the two priests were led by some natives of the region to a small ruined building near the summit of an isolated peak. The site and the plan of the house corresponded accurately to Sister Emmerich’s description (See Vol. IV, pp. 451-455). The explorers learned that the place had been locally venerated since time immemorial by villagers descended from the early Christians of Ephesus, who called it Panaya Kapulu, “The House of the Holy Virgin”, and who made annual pilgrimages there on the Feast of the Assumption.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top