T
TheBoss918
Guest
As a fellow songwriter/musician myself (who once discerned the seminary), I was happy to come across this thread.
Since it’s 3:00am and I only got to glance at the discussion, I’ll just reply to the original poster.
Of course it is OK to play rock/blues music! In fact, it’s more than OK: it’s a blessing. Music, specifically rock for me, has been a huge sacrament (lower case “s”) in my life. I always say that The Beatles are a wonderful proof of God’s existence
Of course there are some artists and art that stray from Catholic teaching, but you’ll find that in ANY vocation. Not all fiction books are moral: so should C. S. Lewis not have written Narnia, or Tolkien written LOTR? Not all politicians are incorrupt: so should people stop running for office? Even religion is not always safe. Some religious in the Church have done horrible, evil things: so should men avoid the seminary? People are imperfect.
There is nothing inherently wrong or evil in rock music. The idea that it’s the devil’s music because of the beat is fanatical. If that is someone’s belief, I respect it, but I also believe it is just not in touch with reality.
I encourage you, my friend, to avoid the temptation to judge some artists because they have done drugs or have slept with a lot of women. We all have sinned. The sin of pride is a lot worse than premarital sex, anyhow.
There are many Christian artists out there who are quite vocal about their faith: Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, and Bono to name a few. And by the way, a priest friend of mine last year baptized a child. Guess who the godfather was??? Robert Plant!!!
Good luck to you! Know that you are in my prayers.
Since it’s 3:00am and I only got to glance at the discussion, I’ll just reply to the original poster.
Of course it is OK to play rock/blues music! In fact, it’s more than OK: it’s a blessing. Music, specifically rock for me, has been a huge sacrament (lower case “s”) in my life. I always say that The Beatles are a wonderful proof of God’s existence
Of course there are some artists and art that stray from Catholic teaching, but you’ll find that in ANY vocation. Not all fiction books are moral: so should C. S. Lewis not have written Narnia, or Tolkien written LOTR? Not all politicians are incorrupt: so should people stop running for office? Even religion is not always safe. Some religious in the Church have done horrible, evil things: so should men avoid the seminary? People are imperfect.
There is nothing inherently wrong or evil in rock music. The idea that it’s the devil’s music because of the beat is fanatical. If that is someone’s belief, I respect it, but I also believe it is just not in touch with reality.
I encourage you, my friend, to avoid the temptation to judge some artists because they have done drugs or have slept with a lot of women. We all have sinned. The sin of pride is a lot worse than premarital sex, anyhow.
There are many Christian artists out there who are quite vocal about their faith: Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, and Bono to name a few. And by the way, a priest friend of mine last year baptized a child. Guess who the godfather was??? Robert Plant!!!
Good luck to you! Know that you are in my prayers.