Board: Druggists can't refuse prescriptions

  • Thread starter Thread starter a_priori
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Indeed. Benjaim Franklin, at a time when the enemy was on our shore, our very existance was at stake, and loss of the war would have resulted in his own execution, defended the rights of his Quaker neighbors to refuse military service on grounds of conscience.

Now, merely for convenience sake, the left wants to force pharmacists to violate their consciences. It won’t be long before physicians are forced to perform abortions – whether they have religious scruples or not.
I believe that to be a real possibility.
 
Yes, if you’re prepared to ignore a huge body of law, it would be fair to make that argument.
And if you’re prepared to ignore the Constitution, it would be fair to make the opposite argument.
Of course, you’d also be ignoring other issues, such as whether the pharmacists are qualified.
What gives you the right to accuse me of that? When did I say unqualified people should be physicians, pharmacists, or pilots?

I challenge you to provide a quote!
Unchanged - I still maintain that states have the right to regulate a minimum number of hours a pharmacy is open, or what drugs are available, if they choose. There is well-established justification for the states to have this power. How overbearing or intrusive these regulations are is a matter to be determined by each state.
No. The Constitution guarentees us the freedom to follow our religion, and the states cannot intrude on that.

Once again, if what you say is true, the state could force Catholic physicians to perform abortions.
 
Well, Hillary Clinton’s 1993-94 proposed Health Care reform had provisions in it FORCING all medical school students to learn how to perform abortions. So the day is coming.

As for selling immoral products,
there is a big difference between being the PROPRIETOR of the business and merely being a cashier.
I rang up condoms, cigarets, PLAYBOY magazines, PENTHOUSE magazines, pagan trinkets, immoral literature of all types (not porn!!), etc., when I worked as a cashier at department stores years ago. It was against my beliefs to use such things, and had I been the store OWNER, I wouldn’t have stocked them,
but ringing them up never bothered my conscience.
 
Well, Hillary Clinton’s 1993-94 proposed Health Care reform had provisions in it FORCING all medical school students to learn how to perform abortions. So the day is coming.

As for selling immoral products,
there is a big difference between being the PROPRIETOR of the business and merely being a cashier.
I rang up condoms, cigarets, PLAYBOY magazines, PENTHOUSE magazines, pagan trinkets, immoral literature of all types (not porn!!), etc., when I worked as a cashier at department stores years ago. It was against my beliefs to use such things, and had I been the store OWNER, I wouldn’t have stocked them,
but ringing them up never bothered my conscience.
And if you have the right to decide to ring them up, should not others have the right to follow their consciences, even if their conclusions differ from yours?
 
…Once again, if what you say is true, the state could force Catholic physicians to perform abortions.
…and this is all in the name of “choice”…unless you think the baby should have a choice…or the taxpayer…or pharmacists…or med students…or nursing students…or the handicapped…or the elderly…
 
…and this is all in the name of “choice”…unless you think the baby should have a choice…or the taxpayer…or pharmacists…or med students…or nursing students…or the handicapped…or the elderly…
Liberals will always defend your right – to agree with them.:rolleyes:
 
To be fair, you won’t catch me defending their right to take the pro-choice position…how down-right un-American of me.
Oh, they can say anything they want. And I can say what I want. And I will say abortion is murder – deliberated, pre-meditated mass murder.
 
"Digitonomy:
Yes, if you’re prepared to ignore a huge body of law, it would be fair to make that argument.
And if you’re prepared to ignore the Constitution, it would be fair to make the opposite argument.
Here I thought we were talking about the law, rather than your personal opinion about what is just. It’s pretty plain that states have a wider government interest in regulating pharmacy than simply the purity and effectiveness of drugs (which due to the interstate commerce involved, is mostly a federal area anyway). If it were not the case, aggrieved parties would have successfully challenged the status quo and won. It’s not like pharmacy regulation is a recent untested fad. But as far as I know, only vern humphrey has seriously contested the constitutionality of boards of pharmacy having a wider scope than purity and effectiveness, and I’m not even sure he is serious. If you are going to in effect claim the law is not the law, please provide some evidence that courts have restricted state oversight of pharmacy to only purity and effectiveness of drugs.
vern humphrey:
What gives you the right to accuse me of that? When did I say unqualified people should be physicians, pharmacists, or pilots? I challenge you to provide a quote!
Let’s refresh your memory…
40.png
digitonomy:
Whatever your personal views on the wisdom of such regulation, your earlier statement was wrong that government interest in pharmacy regulation stemmed only from a 1906 federal law. States have much more wide-ranging interests which are legally recognized.
vern humphrey:
The only true interest is in ensuring food and drugs are pure and effective.
If government interest in regulating pharmacy is only ensuring the purity and effectiveness of drugs, there is no government interest in regulating the workers at the pharmacy, except for those compounding pharmacists actually involved in the production of drugs.
vern humphrey:
Once again, if what you say is true, the state could force Catholic physicians to perform abortions.
If what I say is true, the state could also force Christian Scientist physicians to provide medical care to children in danger of death. Unfortunately this is true. Which is why we must take care in selecting our public officials, and stay aware of our public institutions such as Boards of Pharmacy, so that we can prevent Catholic physicians from facing such a choice.
 
Here I thought we were talking about the law, rather than your personal opinion about what is just.
As opposed to talking about your opinion of what is just?

And the Constitution is the law of the land.
It’s pretty plain that states have a wider government interest in regulating pharmacy than simply the purity and effectiveness of drugs (which due to the interstate commerce involved, is mostly a federal area anyway). If it were not the case, aggrieved parties would have successfully challenged the status quo and won.
How does that make anything “plain?”
It’s not like pharmacy regulation is a recent untested fad. But as far as I know, only vern humphrey has seriously contested the constitutionality of boards of pharmacy having a wider scope than purity and effectiveness, and I’m not even sure he is serious.
As far as I know, only digitonomy has seriously claimed boards of pharmacy having the power to over-ride the Constitution.
If you are going to in effect claim the law is not the law, please provide some evidence that courts have restricted state oversight of pharmacy to only purity and effectiveness of drugs.
If you are going to in effect claim the Constitution is not the law, please provide some evidence that courts have overturned the First Amendment.
Let’s refresh your memory…If government interest in regulating pharmacy is only ensuring the purity and effectiveness of drugs, there is no government interest in regulating the workers at the pharmacy, except for those compounding pharmacists actually involved in the production of drugs.
In this case, there is no legitimate government interest in forcing a specific pharmacy to carry a specific drug, nor forcing a specific pharmacist to dispense it – and you have not shown the contrary.

The sole interest here is in forcing people to conform – to go in opposition to their consciences and religion in order to punish them for being Catholic and opposed to abortion and birth control.
If what I say is true, the state could also force Christian Scientist physicians to provide medical care to children in danger of death. Unfortunately this is true.
Give me an actual case of a Christian Scientist physician being forced to provide medical care.
Which is why we must take care in selecting our public officials, and stay aware of our public institutions such as Boards of Pharmacy, so that we can prevent Catholic physicians from facing such a choice.
Now you’re trying to blow smoke up me kilts.😛
 
I really hope a Muslim pharmacist claims discrimination on this. What a quandry that would put the state in. It seems that it is OK to discriminate against Christians but Muslims are another story.
This is where part of my resevervations come from. If a Catholic pharmacist is allowed to withhold a drug because of his/her religious beliefs, then obviously a Muslim would have the same right. I’m not sure which drugs a Muslim would find objectionable. If you were really sick, went to fill your prescription, and the person behind the counter told you he/she was a Muslim and couldn’t fill it, would you say “I’m so glad that person doesn’t have to go against his/her religious beliefs,” or would you be totally irritated?
 
If a woman is raped, she would have to know whether or not she has ovulated and by the time that could be determined with certainty, it could be too late to take a MAP in order to prevent ovulation. There is another method which only goes after sperm.
Also, this drug was banned and opposed in this country for many years, not just by pro-lifers, but also primarilyby hard core feminists who had nothing against abortion. This drug was used primarily in third world countries up until now since those people are poor and have no right to have children according to our State Department.
MAP is so dangerous to a woman. A good physicain would not suggest using it merely because of how harmful it is to a woman. But that is unimportant to the majority of feminists nowadays. Being available to any man, any time seems to be their top priority. If the woman dies or suffers health problems is unimportant to such people.
 
And the Constitution is the law of the land.
Just as regulations by state agencies are the law in the particular states.
vern humphrey:
As far as I know, only digitonomy has seriously claimed boards of pharmacy having the power to over-ride the Constitution.
I’m not the one who claims a conflict between the Constitution and state regulation of pharmacy beyond simple purity and effectiveness issues.
vern humphrey:
In this case, there is no legitimate government interest in forcing a specific pharmacy to carry a specific drug, nor forcing a specific pharmacist to dispense it – and you have not shown the contrary.

The sole interest here is in forcing people to conform – to go in opposition to their consciences and religion in order to punish them for being Catholic and opposed to abortion and birth control.
You kind of dodged the issue you frame this as a response to - why is there a government interest in regulating pharmacists when you claim the government interest in pharmacy regulation is limited to purity and effectiveness issues?
vern humphrey:
Give me an actual case of a Christian Scientist physician being forced to provide medical care.
Most Christian Scientists do not choose such a career field, in that it would conflict with their religious beliefs. Let us pray the same does not happen to Catholics.

I would reckon that the few Christian Scientists ever to be physicians were probably converts. But given that parents have been forced to ensure proper medical care for their children in danger of death, it’s hard to imagine that a hypothetical CS physician would be held to a lower standard regarding responsibility for the child’s health.
 
This is where part of my resevervations come from. If a Catholic pharmacist is allowed to withhold a drug because of his/her religious beliefs, then obviously a Muslim would have the same right.
Why not? The First Amendment covers Islam as well as Christianity, Judaism and even polytheistic religions.

Equally important, why should we not respect other people’s religions?
I’m not sure which drugs a Muslim would find objectionable. If you were really sick, went to fill your prescription, and the person behind the counter told you he/she was a Muslim and couldn’t fill it, would you say “I’m so glad that person doesn’t have to go against his/her religious beliefs,” or would you be totally irritated?
Heaven forbid that I should be irritated!!! Why if respect for civil rights meant that I had to suffer a little irritation now and then, I couldn’t go around punching peop[le in the face for disagreeing with me, now could I?😛

If the pharmacist is an employee, that’s between him and his boss. If the boss wants him to dispense those drugs and he refuses, let the boss deal with it.

If the pharmacist owns the pharmacy, and that pharmacy – for whatever reason – doesn’t dispense the drug you want, go to **another pharmacy.

The little town where I live – Mountain View, Arkansas, with only about 3,000 people – has four pharmacies. And I can get drugs by mail as well. What justification would there be for me to violate a pharmacist’s First Amendment rights?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top