BODIES: The Exhibition

  • Thread starter Thread starter Island_Oak
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

Island_Oak

Guest
Has anyone else had the opportunity to view this amazing exhibition that is touring the country? bodiestheexhibition.com/bodies.html What do you make of it as Catholics? As fellow human beings? Does the Church have any position on it morally?
 
I have been to the BodyWorlds exhibit in St. Paul, which looks very similar.

It was AMAZING! To see firsthand the intracacies of the human body, the blood vessels, the nerves…AMAZING!

The coolest thing was the family of all blood vessels. It was like lace.

When I was viewing the embryo/fetus/preborn and infant room, people were amazed that a 6 week old baby actually looked human!

I do believe it is very educational.

My kids (preteen and teen) saw it as well.
 
I, too, am planning to take my kids–and hoping that viewing actual human bodies will be more amazing & awe-inspiring than frightening or disgusting.

Like you, I marveled at the intricate dissection–the nerves and blood vessels were indescribable in their detail. I also viewed the fetal examples–both those that died pre-term because of various life-threatening defects/conditions and those in different stages of development. The 5 week old fetus had fingers and toes no bigger than the diameter of a thread–yet each was visible and you could clearly count each one of them.

I would highly recommend it to anyone–but was curious about what, if anything, the Church would say about this.
 
Well, at one point using human cadavears was not allowed (because the way they were probably obtained), but obviously now, Catholic Universities and Med Schools with full knowledge of the hierarchy obtain bodies for the purpose of education and with the consent of the donors. At Creighton University for instance, they have a memorial service with families who wish to attend. As long as people come with the proper respect and gratitude, it can be a great learning experience that praises the Glory of God for the Beauty in which he knit us in our Mother’s womb and we continue to grow today.
 
I’m really disturbed by this display. I think it is disrespectful and sensationalistic. Would you want to see your mother’s body treated this way? Your child’s? Your brother’s?

This isn’t medical students learning anatomy so they can heal. This is a public exhibition of corpses.

😦
 
I also find it disturbing. I know this would frighten my daughter.

I watched the the video on the site and it does seem very sensationalistic to me. IMO it doesn’t seem to respect the dignity of the body God gave us. A skinless, naked, dead guy holding a football? These are not plastic models but actually human beings, would God want us coating them with polymer and putting them on display? I don’t know, but I don’t think so.
 
I have never been to the actual display so I cannot comment myself on whether they show proper respect, but IMO the appropriate age audience (adults) could look at the human body dissected and it not be violating God’s law of respect for bodies. If they are putting the bodies in strange poses with footballs, I question that as far as acceptability.
 
I’m not sure, but I believe that when the guy who started this first began to exhibit these, it was condemned by the local bishops (Germany?). I don’t remember.

One of the exhibits is here in Las Vegas. From what I’ve read, these, at least, are the bodies of Chinese nationals, unclaimed and obtained from the government. I believe that the exhibit is morally objectionable and gravely sinful. It has the effect of objectifying a human being for the gratification of others (the viewers), it has the effect of objectifying a human being for profit (those who are making money), and it is a horriblly disrespectful way to repose a body. The Church insists on the reverent treatment of the dead. Finally, I find it sad and horrifying that, if these bodies are indeed dead Chinese, these people lived their lives under a godless Communist regime and now they’re spending their deaths being gawked at by a bunch of jaded capitalists who have too much time and more money than is good for them.

Don’t go see this!
 
I’m not sure, but I believe that when the guy who started this first began to exhibit these, it was condemned by the local bishops (Germany?). I don’t remember.

One of the exhibits is here in Las Vegas. From what I’ve read, these, at least, are the bodies of Chinese nationals, unclaimed and obtained from the government. I believe that the exhibit is morally objectionable and gravely sinful. It has the effect of objectifying a human being for the gratification of others (the viewers), it has the effect of objectifying a human being for profit (those who are making money), and it is a horriblly disrespectful way to repose a body. The Church insists on the reverent treatment of the dead. Finally, I find it sad and horrifying that, if these bodies are indeed dead Chinese, these people lived their lives under a godless Communist regime and now they’re spending their deaths being gawked at by a bunch of jaded capitalists who have too much time and more money than is good for them.

Don’t go see this!
very articulate. Thanks for saying so well what I wanted to say.
 
Well I saw the show in NYC and thought it was great.

As to JKirkLVNV post I have a question…how do you address people that donate their bodies to science after they die?
 
Well I saw the show in NYC and thought it was great.

As to JKirkLVNV post I have a question…how do you address people that donate their bodies to science after they die?
I would reckon that to be entirely different. That isn’t an objectification of a human being for profit or for entertainment. Usually, it’s to advance the science of medicine, ie, to help people. If I’m not mistaken, the Church doesn’t frown on this, though she still requires that after all legitimate purposes have been exhausted, the remains are reposed/disposed of in a way that is in keeping with our inalienable human dignity.

From the Catechism: “2301 Autopsies can be morally permitted for legal inquests or scientific research.”
 
I believe that the exhibit is morally objectionable and gravely sinful. It has the effect of objectifying a human being for the gratification of others (the viewers), it has the effect of objectifying a human being for profit (those who are making money), and it is a horriblly disrespectful way to repose a body.
You are rightly concerned and sensitive to some of the issues this exhibit raises. However, I have to say that the demeanor of the staff in Seattle struck me as noteable in its efforts to make this a dignified and respectful experience. The entrance is quiet and dimply lit. There are reminders posted that these are actual bodies on display for purposes of education and as such deserve respect and dignified conduct by observers. Most of the displays are not encased–so you could just reach out and touch them–but there are posted requests not to do so–again out of respect–and I witnessed no violation of this. Without exception, the response from the attendees around me was a hushed, whispered awe of what they were seeing for the first time. It is at once intimate and familiar, strange and amazing.
…Finally, I find it sad and horrifying that, if these bodies are indeed dead Chinese, these people lived their lives under a godless Communist regime and now they’re spending their deaths being gawked at by a bunch of jaded capitalists who have too much time and more money than is good for them. Don’t go see this!
I’m not sure quite what to make of this. There’s not much we can do for dead, godless communists–if indeed that is what/who these individuals were in life. This show is certainly not an effort to penalize them for their “godless” ways. We really have no way of knowing, much less judging the heart, soul or conscience of any of those whose bodies are on display. Further, no one I observed in attendance with me could have been rightly described as a “jaded capitalist” with “too much time and more money” simply looking for a cheap thrill among a bunch of Chinese cadavers. It is impossible to leave the exhibit without a renewed and profound sense of wonder and awe over the human body we all inhabit and deep gratitude for the opportunity to view by means of the deceased that which would be utterly impossible from the living.
 
Body World is sensationalistic, morbid entertainment for people with too much time (and money) on their hands. It is a gruesome display, a circus of dead bodies riding horses and kicking soccer balls. What if one of those bodies were your loved one? Would you want the world to behold every naked muscle fibre of their being?

Whatever happened to rest in peace?
 
Body World is sensationalistic, morbid entertainment for people with too much time (and money) on their hands. It is a gruesome display, a circus of dead bodies riding horses and kicking soccer balls. What if one of those bodies were your loved one? Would you want the world to behold every naked muscle fibre of their being?

Whatever happened to rest in peace?
I did not find it gruesome at all. In fact, like another poster said, the place was very nice - quiet and respectful. People were in awe at what they were witnessing. I think it makes (some) people realize that what they do CAN and DOES affect their bodies (smoking, overeating, drinking to excess) to the negative.

If it were one of my loved ones?? Well, I believe once the body dies, the person is no longer there. It is really just a shell. The soul is long gone. So, no, I guess if a loved one’s body could educate another, I would not mind at all.

My junior high kids visited the exhibit as a science class field trip last year. They go to a Catholic school.
 
The exhibition I saw in Houston was very respectful and beautiful. It showed how amazing our bodies are. Some of the scenes involved a degree of humor, but it was a way for the viewer to connect with the humanity of the bodies. I agree with the earlier poster who noted that the unborn child looked so very human; I hope that visitors took note as it could reach people who automatically resist any perceived “preaching” on the subject.

Also, the bodies were donated. This was an important point for me.

I recommend the exhibit.
 
A few times this exhibit has gone too far- I did not like the cross-section of a pregant woman and her child.

But, other than that the exhibit is very educational. We just have to try and tread the fine line of morality and decency when it comes to things like this.
 
I saw a book (in the children’s section of the library) based on this, and was so upset by it that I wrote a poem about it – what I sometimes do when I can’t deal with something any other way.
It may be all right from an educational standpoint, but it rubs me the wrong way. I wrote:

Man, Unwinged

There is an artist in Europe,
this is true, and therein
lies the horror,
who uses a human body, deceased,
with all the paperwork no doubt
completed, signatures notarized,
forms correctly filled in,
every i dotted and t crossed,
and with it creates art.

The SS colonel had a lampshade
made of human skin
stretched on a frame,
no doubt it cast a mellow light,
soothing for reading of an evening,
for counting up the totals of the men,
women and children sent to the
crematorium that day.

He flays the body,
and injects plastic into the muscles,
thus displaying his own ingenuity
as well as the creator‘s.

You may see the human figure,
as if striding,
one hand that never will grasp again
outstretched as if to grasp,
muscles spread like wings,
like feathers, attached at the insertion
only.
The red of muscles preserved, the blue of veins,
the symmetry and splendor of the human form.
And the parted lips,
the blank glass-eyeball stare,
the fled spirit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top