Borat

  • Thread starter Thread starter Belcanto
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Belcanto

Guest
I saw Borat this evening. Basically, it’s a mockumentary about one Borat Sagdiyev, a Kazhak TV reporter, sent by Kazhakstan to make a documentary about America.

Borat (played by Sacha Baron-Cohen) interacts with real-life Americans; I was surprised to learn that almost all of the scenes were real. Some parts were funny. For example, in one part, Borat is on a New York subway. He opens his suitcase, and a rooster flies out. That was quite amusing. Overall though, I think the movie falls flat. Here’s the review by the USCCB, which pretty much reflects my opinion of the movie:

British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen best known as the titular character of HBO’s “Da Ali G. Show,” inhabits another one of his peculiar personas in the juvenile and cumbersomely titled mock documentary “Borat! Cultural Learning of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan” (20th Century Fox). Cohen is Borat Sagdiyev, a clueless, anti-Semitic journalist from Kazakhstan who travels to the United States to report on the American way of life. (Think a wacky combination of Charlie Chaplin, Alexis d’Tocqueville and Yakov Smirnoff.) After seeing Pamela Anderson in an episode of “Baywatch” while staying in a New York hotel, the chauvinistic Borat becomes infatuated with her, embarking on a cross-country odyssey with his portly producer, Azamat (Ken Davitian), to meet and woo the curvaceous actress. Some of the outrageous pranks – many involving real people not in on the joke – are, admittedly, funny. (At one point, Borat’s suitcase flies open on a crowded subway unleashing a live rooster on the startled straphangers.) But in satirizing American culture and politics, any wit is heavily outweighed by vulgarity, as Cohen and director Larry Charles go for shock laughs that range from the distasteful (in the opening tour of his village, Borat introduces viewers to the “town rapist”), to the visually gross (a naked Borat and Azamat get into a protracted tussle in their hotel room that spills out into the hallway and, eventually, a packed convention room downstairs). The film contains pervasive coarse sexual and scatological humor, crass sight gags, masturbation, nudity, some irreverent remarks, and excessive rough and crude language, as well as some ethnic stereotypes. The USCCB Office for Film & Broadcasting classification is O – morally offensive. The Motion Picture Association of America rating is R – restricted. Under 17 requires accompanying parent or adult guardian

Anyone else seen it, or have thoughts on the movie?

Pax Tecum,
Jay
 
Sacha Baron-Cohen who plays Borat is actually a Jew. Ive seen his material before and I dont think that he is particularly funny.
 
what does his being a Jew have to do with anything?
I think that he is pointing out that Borat isn’t actually antisemitic.

I keep hearing about this movie and wondering about it.

To some who has watched it. Is it a mean spirited movie?Is he trying to make the unsuspecting people in his movie appear dumb.
 
I think that he is pointing out that Borat isn’t actually antisemitic.

I keep hearing about this movie and wondering about it.

To some who has watched it. Is it a mean spirited movie?Is he trying to make the unsuspecting people in his movie appear dumb.
Not mean-spirited in the same sense as MTV’s “Jackass.” He doesn’t make the people look dumb- they do that all by themselves. However, I thought that the scatalogical, sexual, and crude visual humor effectively killed whatever satirical message the movie was trying to convey.

Pax Tecum,
Jay
 
I am very upset that many theaters are practicing censorship on Borat. :mad: There arent any near me to see this. This will be a blind buy when it hits dvd. The reviews from people I generally agree with have all said its really funny.
 
He’s offensive but very funny too, his brand of comedy is great because it shows that if you speak with an accent and act like you’re not from around here, you can pretty much say and do anything you want.

He also does a gay character on Da Ali G Show which is hysterical, because he typically goes to fashion shows and shows what insipid, transparent, blowhards a lot of these people are. In one interview he makes a statement like “fashion saves more lives than doctors”, and the delusional fashion icon he’s interviewing says “yes I think so”, then goes into a two minute reason why fashion saves more lives than doctors, it’s great…

That and South Park are my guilty pleasures.
 
Saw it with my wife yesterday. There were parts where I could barely breath between my thunderous peals of laughter.

There was only 1 scene at the end that I found objectionable - don’t wan’t to divulge anything for those who haven’t seen it yet. It lasts about 5 - 10 seconds.
 
Saw it last night and thought it was overall hilarious BUT the men mastubating over Pamela and the numererous homosexual innuendos when Borat gets in a fight with his friend while being naked really turned me away from ever wanting to see it again.

I found it pretty repulsing after that scene. I was thinking as a Catholic…isnt it bad that we are consciousely aware that we are entertaining ourselves with such “coarse sexual humor?”

Peace,

Regis University Student
 
I don’t know if being entertained by that brand of humor is a problem…I would say that it is a problem if it is a near occasion of sin…for example, you are influenced by the the scene of masturbating over Pam Anderson to go home and do the same thing, then you should avoid that sort of thing…
Saw it last night and thought it was overall hilarious BUT the men mastubating over Pamela and the numererous homosexual innuendos when Borat gets in a fight with his friend while being naked really turned me away from ever wanting to see it again.

I found it pretty repulsing after that scene. I was thinking as a Catholic…isnt it bad that we are consciousely aware that we are entertaining ourselves with such “coarse sexual humor?”

Peace,

Regis University Student
 
The critics gave it all 5 stars. I was familiar with him ahead of time and knew what to expect. But my friend and I felt it was more of a mixed bag than a fantastic movie. Some parts had us dying with laughter, other parts were too crude or disgusting and went on way too long (the wrestling scene.) My friend found the anti-semitism too much, and I can see her point, but I do understand that as a Jew he’s not truly that way. The reason I’m familiar with him is because my Jewish friend is a huge fan…she goes to a Jewish summer camp and he’s huge there.
 
I saw the movie and thought is was really funny. I can see how it may be offensive. I thought the awkward position he puts people in was very entertaining. Being from New York I was laughing hysterically how he tried to introduce himself to everyone on the subway with a kiss.

Not that I have a problem with the Bishop’s reveiw, but I found it inconsistant with their glowing reveiw of Brokeback mountain.

I’ll take Borat anyday.
 
The critics gave it all 5 stars. I was familiar with him ahead of time and knew what to expect. But my friend and I felt it was more of a mixed bag than a fantastic movie. Some parts had us dying with laughter, other parts were too crude or disgusting and went on way too long (the wrestling scene.) My friend found the anti-semitism too much, and I can see her point, but I do understand that as a Jew he’s not truly that way. The reason I’m familiar with him is because my Jewish friend is a huge fan…she goes to a Jewish summer camp and he’s huge there.
Yes, exactly. I thought that “Borat” had some good things going for it, but the “shock humor” just ruined the movie for me.

Pax Tecum,
Jay
 
Michael Medved (observant Jew)described it as raw and very adult and funny.
 
Saw it last night and thought it was overall hilarious BUT the men mastubating over Pamela and the numererous homosexual innuendos when Borat gets in a fight with his friend while being naked really turned me away from ever wanting to see it again.

I found it pretty repulsing after that scene. I was thinking as a Catholic…isnt it bad that we are consciousely aware that we are entertaining ourselves with such “coarse sexual humor?”

Peace,

Regis University Student
Hmmmm. Tempted?
 
Wow after the responses here I am gonna take that I worded my post wayyy wrong!! No, not tempted. And for anyone’s information I am a girl,🙂 All I was trying to say was… Those particular scenes really bothered me. There, i’ll keep it simple.

Peace,

Regis University Student
 
I’ve watched Cohen on HBO and enjoyed his brutal satire…to a point. After fifteen minutes or so, you’ve pretty much heard and seen his whole act. A good bit of it is just plain dopey. I don’t think I could sit through a feature length “Borat”. The toilet humor and coarse sex wears thin, too, but that’s seemingly mandatory today.
 
I’m a female too, and there were several times I thought of ducking out and buying some depends, cause I was sure I was going to pee myself from laughing so hard.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top