Break the Seal said Baton Rouge Court

  • Thread starter Thread starter glendab
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
To hockeyfan…I am the blogger/owner of the blog Rape Victims of the Catholic Church…you are a defender of the Pedophile Pimps,Priests and perverts of the Roman Catholic Church.

I WILL NOT ALLOW YOU TO USE MY INFORMATION ON MY WEBSITE, SEEKING TO BRING JUSTICE TO US, WHOM WERE RAPED, BRUTALIZED, AND HAD OUR SOULS STOLEN FROM US BY THESE DISGUSTING, PEDOPHILE PRIESTS AND COVERED UP BY THE PEDOPHILE PIMPS CARDINALS, BISHOPS AND ARCHBISHOPS.

Listen up and listen good.

I do NOT care for YOUR excuses.

These scum raped us, they stole our lives, they stole our souls and you freaks keep standing up and defending them.

Get this through YOUR thick skull.

The rape of children, the cover ups of these rapes, is not only a sin, it is a freaking FELONY.

In my opinion, ANYONE whom rapes a child, whom covers up the rapes of children, in the Roman Catholic Church deserves to be executed by using the Roman Catholic Churches own tools of the Inquisition.

There can be NO FORGIVENESS FOR WHAT THESE DISGUSTING CARDINALS, LIKE TIMOTHY DOLAN, ROGER MAHONY, BERNARD LAW, DONALD WUERL AND OTHERS HAVE DONE TO US AND CONTINUE TO DO TO US…DENY US JUSTICE FOR THE CRIMES COMMITTED AGAINST US AS CHILDREN.

NONE of you have ANY RIGHT to declare yourselves moral, nor holy. Your church raped us as children and now they seek to deny us justice, using the very same laws against us, they get our cases dismissed using the statue of limitations.

Then these disgusting freaks pay such degenerates as Bill Donohue to attack us, calling us liars, gold diggers out looking for a payday from this church.

I have had to listen to this disgusting excuse for a human being, say to my face, because I did not punch Leon Gaulin in the face while he was raping me, that meant not only did I want to be raped, I enjoyed being raped and I am a homosexual for it.

I got something to tell you boy…you are NOT worthy to even bend down and tie my laces…let alone use MY postings on my blog to spew your complete and utter garbage in your defense of allowing known pedophiles escape punishment for their crimes against us, by hiding behind your sick and twisted confessional bs.

Oh and boy?

Read the catechism:

PART THREE
LIFE IN CHRIST

SECTION TWO
THE TEN COMMANDMENTS

CHAPTER TWO
“YOU SHALL LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF”

ARTICLE 6
THE SIXTH COMMANDMENT

Offenses against chastity

**2356: Rape is the forcible violation of the sexual intimacy of another person. It does injury to justice and charity. Rape deeply wounds the respect, freedom, and physical and moral integrity to which every person has a right. It causes grave damage that can mark the victim for life. It is always an intrinsically evil act. Graver still is the rape of children committed by parents (incest) or those responsible for the education of the children entrusted to them. **

So listen up…don’t you EVER attempt to use my blog to defend these scum. Got me?
Excuse me but how does forcing a priest to break the seal of confession have anything to do with that?

And watch your language.
 
To hockeyfan…I am the blogger/owner of the blog Rape Victims of the Catholic Church…you are a defender of the Pedophile Pimps,Priests and perverts of the Roman Catholic Church.

I WILL NOT ALLOW YOU TO USE MY INFORMATION ON MY WEBSITE, SEEKING TO BRING JUSTICE TO US, WHOM WERE RAPED, BRUTALIZED, AND HAD OUR SOULS STOLEN FROM US BY THESE DISGUSTING, PEDOPHILE PRIESTS AND COVERED UP BY THE PEDOPHILE PIMPS CARDINALS, BISHOPS AND ARCHBISHOPS.

Listen up and listen good.

I do NOT care for YOUR excuses.

These scum raped us, they stole our lives, they stole our souls and you freaks keep standing up and defending them.

Get this through YOUR thick skull.

The rape of children, the cover ups of these rapes, is not only a sin, it is a freaking FELONY.

In my opinion, ANYONE whom rapes a child, whom covers up the rapes of children, in the Roman Catholic Church deserves to be executed by using the Roman Catholic Churches own tools of the Inquisition.

There can be NO FORGIVENESS FOR WHAT THESE DISGUSTING CARDINALS, LIKE TIMOTHY DOLAN, ROGER MAHONY, BERNARD LAW, DONALD WUERL AND OTHERS HAVE DONE TO US AND CONTINUE TO DO TO US…DENY US JUSTICE FOR THE CRIMES COMMITTED AGAINST US AS CHILDREN.

NONE of you have ANY RIGHT to declare yourselves moral, nor holy. Your church raped us as children and now they seek to deny us justice, using the very same laws against us, they get our cases dismissed using the statue of limitations.

Then these disgusting freaks pay such degenerates as Bill Donohue to attack us, calling us liars, gold diggers out looking for a payday from this church.

I have had to listen to this disgusting excuse for a human being, say to my face, because I did not punch Leon Gaulin in the face while he was raping me, that meant not only did I want to be raped, I enjoyed being raped and I am a homosexual for it.

I got something to tell you boy…you are NOT worthy to even bend down and tie my laces…let alone use MY postings on my blog to spew your complete and utter garbage in your defense of allowing known pedophiles escape punishment for their crimes against us, by hiding behind your sick and twisted confessional bs.

Oh and boy?

Read the catechism:

PART THREE
LIFE IN CHRIST

SECTION TWO
THE TEN COMMANDMENTS

CHAPTER TWO
“YOU SHALL LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF”

ARTICLE 6
THE SIXTH COMMANDMENT

Offenses against chastity

**2356: Rape is the forcible violation of the sexual intimacy of another person. It does injury to justice and charity. Rape deeply wounds the respect, freedom, and physical and moral integrity to which every person has a right. It causes grave damage that can mark the victim for life. It is always an intrinsically evil act. Graver still is the rape of children committed by parents (incest) or those responsible for the education of the children entrusted to them. **

So listen up…don’t you EVER attempt to use my blog to defend these scum. Got me?
First, read the post he wrote about the case in your blog
Secondly, if you don’t want your blog to be quoted then don’t make it public
Thirdly, what does any of what you say have to do with forcing an priest to break the seal of confession?
Finally, watch your language and don’t you dare accuse any innocents here. Your insults and accusations of people here only show how judgmental you are.
 
To hockeyfan…I am the blogger/owner of the blog Rape Victims of the Catholic Church…you are a defender of the Pedophile Pimps,Priests and perverts of the Roman Catholic Church.

I WILL NOT ALLOW YOU TO USE MY INFORMATION ON MY WEBSITE, SEEKING TO BRING JUSTICE TO US, WHOM WERE RAPED, BRUTALIZED, AND HAD OUR SOULS STOLEN FROM US BY THESE DISGUSTING, PEDOPHILE PRIESTS AND COVERED UP BY THE PEDOPHILE PIMPS CARDINALS, BISHOPS AND ARCHBISHOPS.

Listen up and listen good.

I do NOT care for YOUR excuses.

These scum raped us, they stole our lives, they stole our souls and you freaks keep standing up and defending them.

Get this through YOUR thick skull.

The rape of children, the cover ups of these rapes, is not only a sin, it is a freaking FELONY.

In my opinion, ANYONE whom rapes a child, whom covers up the rapes of children, in the Roman Catholic Church deserves to be executed by using the Roman Catholic Churches own tools of the Inquisition.

There can be NO FORGIVENESS FOR WHAT THESE DISGUSTING CARDINALS, LIKE TIMOTHY DOLAN, ROGER MAHONY, BERNARD LAW, DONALD WUERL AND OTHERS HAVE DONE TO US AND CONTINUE TO DO TO US…DENY US JUSTICE FOR THE CRIMES COMMITTED AGAINST US AS CHILDREN.

NONE of you have ANY RIGHT to declare yourselves moral, nor holy. Your church raped us as children and now they seek to deny us justice, using the very same laws against us, they get our cases dismissed using the statue of limitations.

Then these disgusting freaks pay such degenerates as Bill Donohue to attack us, calling us liars, gold diggers out looking for a payday from this church.

I have had to listen to this disgusting excuse for a human being, say to my face, because I did not punch Leon Gaulin in the face while he was raping me, that meant not only did I want to be raped, I enjoyed being raped and I am a homosexual for it.

I got something to tell you boy…you are NOT worthy to even bend down and tie my laces…let alone use MY postings on my blog to spew your complete and utter garbage in your defense of allowing known pedophiles escape punishment for their crimes against us, by hiding behind your sick and twisted confessional bs.

Oh and boy?

Read the catechism:

PART THREE
LIFE IN CHRIST

SECTION TWO
THE TEN COMMANDMENTS

CHAPTER TWO
“YOU SHALL LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF”

ARTICLE 6
THE SIXTH COMMANDMENT

Offenses against chastity

**2356: Rape is the forcible violation of the sexual intimacy of another person. It does injury to justice and charity. Rape deeply wounds the respect, freedom, and physical and moral integrity to which every person has a right. It causes grave damage that can mark the victim for life. It is always an intrinsically evil act. Graver still is the rape of children committed by parents (incest) or those responsible for the education of the children entrusted to them. **

So listen up…don’t you EVER attempt to use my blog to defend these scum. Got me?
Reported.
 
What is the Constitution of the United states says this in the First Amendment?

Any such law compelling a priest to reveal what he heard in Confession would apply here. This would not be a case like “any other citizen.” Even if it were, though, I am not sure I want to live in a country where they can force you to say anything, even if your morally on the wrong side. That doesn’t seem a far stretch from Totalitarianism.

I think I am getting too political, so I shall move on.

I hadn’t heard of the case your referring to, so I googled it and found this. rapevictimsofthecatholicchurch.wordpress.com/tag/archdiocese-of-st-louis/ Is this the case your speaking of? In this case, the plaintiffs allege, among other things, that “Jiang left $20,000 for the family after admitting to the abuse and then went on to directly confess his actions to (Archbishop) Carlson.” (rapevictimsofthecatholicchurch.com) Fist, how would the family know if Jiang confessed to the Archbishop that he did it? (which I believe he probably did commit the abuse. If he did, I hope he goes to jail) Even if he did confess to Carlson, the Archbishop’s point that the argument is not legal is valid. Now, if he knew outside the Seal of Confession I would be 100% for going after him. I still resent the way Cardinal Mahoney handled things in my own Archdiocese.

My problem with what I think you are suggesting is that you want to throw out religion for secular laws. Man’s laws are beneath God’s laws, not the other way around.

What if that cuts into the amount of people going to confession?

Let me also ask you this. Is it good to take away from the safety of our relationship with God for the good of secular laws? Also, if the church’s laws went away whenever they were convenient, would they mean much?
Hey boy…my name is Frank LaFerriere…and I am the blogger/owner of Rape Victims of the Catholic Church.

You listen up and you listen up good.

You will NOT use my blog to defend the indefensible you understand me?

You will NOT use my blog to spew your bs either.

I could care less about the roman catholics or their rules of confession. I could care less if a nuke was dropped on top of the Vatican and thousands of you freaks died.

You all lost your rights when your priests of this church raped us, stole our souls, destroyed our lives.

You all lost your rights when your Pedophile Pimps, such as Cardinal Timothy Dolan, Donald Wuerl, Roger Mahony, Bernard Law and many others covered up the rapes of us, by moving these disgusting pedophile priests from parish to parish, protecting them over us.

You all lost your rights when your leaders fight us every step of the way in seeking justice for the crimes committed against us, by hiding behind such laws as the statue of limitations and now your confessional rules.

You all lost your rights when YOU ALL violated the Catechism any damn way.

PART THREE
LIFE IN CHRIST

SECTION TWO
THE TEN COMMANDMENTS

CHAPTER TWO
“YOU SHALL LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF”

ARTICLE 6
THE SIXTH COMMANDMENT

Offenses against chastity

2356: Rape is the forcible violation of the sexual intimacy of another person. It does injury to justice and charity. Rape deeply wounds the respect, freedom, and physical and moral integrity to which every person has a right. It causes grave damage that can mark the victim for life. It is always an intrinsically evil act. GRAVER STILL IS THE RAPE OF CHILDREN COMMITTED BY PARENTS (INCEST) OR THOSE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE EDUCATION OF THE CHILDREN ENTRUSTED TO THEM.

Get it straight you little boy…
I was raped by Father Leon Gaulin in March of 1975 at St Thomas More Parish in Durham New Hampshire.

First he sucked my dick to “suck the demons” out of me.
Then he forced me to suck his dick so that I may receive his “sacred sacrament”.
Then he raped me anally, all the while making me say a penance of Our Fathers and Hail Mary’s while telling me that if I told ANYONE about his special healing I would burn in hell.

So boy…listen up.

I lived in fear, horror, self loathing for over 32 years while I hid what this disgusting ephebophile did to me. I thought I was the evil one, so much so I took the name of Damien, the Anti Christ from the Omen Series.

I though NO LONGER FEAR ANY OF YOU.

No boy…you all should start fearing ME.

For I will see that justice is done, that I will spend each and every day, for the rest of my life, exposing your sick and twisted Pedophile Pimps, Priests and Psychotic nuns…I will keep exposing you defenders of these scum for whom and what you are.

I will do all I can to see each and every one of these disgusting, souless, moraless scumbag Pedophile Pimps, Priests and you supporters of them in prison.

You’re church woke a sleeping tiger boy.

See the last straw?

Was knowing that Pedophile Pimp, Cardinal Timothy Dolan paying that equally disgusting Bill Donohue of the Catholic League to attack us victims.

When Bill Donohue said to my face, that because I did not punch Leon Gaulin in the face when he was raping me, that meant not only did I want it, I enjoyed it and I am a homosexual because of it?

That is when I declared all out war against ALL OF YOU!

So boy…you are NOT even worthy to tie my shoes, let alone use one of the postings from my blog to defend these disgusting scumbags.

Oh and let me clue you in on something ok?

Read Matthew 23…the whole chapter…because in it…Jesus Christ is telling us all…exactly all about this disgusting church whom claims to be the one true church…of his?

Jesus says…STFU…you bunch of disgusting, pedophile supporting scum.
 
A little girl was violated by someone. She went to Confession. She told her parents and they filed suit against the Church and a Priest, Father Bayhi to make him break the seal and defend himself against charges of being accomplice to the acts because of his silence. While my heart breaks for those whose lives were devastated by what happened, the perp isn’t the Priest and the Louisiana Supreme Court is way out of line. The Zenit article contains the Diocese’s response. I’ve quoted the part of the Diocese’s Response that impresses me the most:

"The position of the Diocese of Baton Rouge and Fr. Bayhi is that the Supreme Court of Louisiana has run afoul of the constitutional rights of both the Church and the priest, more particularly, has violated the Establishment Clause and the separation of Church and State under the first amendment. For a civil court to impinge upon the freedom of religion is a clear violation and the matter will be taken to the highest court in the land by the Church in order to protect its free exercise of religion. "

zenit.org/en/articles/baton-rouge-diocese-responds-to-court-order-to-break-seal-of-confession

Glenda
As a survivor of one of your disgusting pedophiles and owner/blogger of Rape Victims of the Catholic Church hear me…

You all lost your rights a long time ago, to call yourselves moral, holy or anything.

Read your catechism:

2356 Rape is the forcible violation of the sexual intimacy of another person. It does injury to justice and charity. Rape deeply wounds the respect, freedom, and physical and moral integrity to which every person has a right. It causes grave damage that can mark the victim for life. It is always an intrinsically evil act. Graver still is the rape of children committed by parents (incest) or those responsible for the education of the children entrusted to them.

Now listen to Jesus Christ:

It would be better for you to tie a huge millstone around your neck and throw yourself into the deepest of lakes than to harm a single hair on the head of a child.

Gee, you all might escape justice using your rules…but when you all get before Jesus Christ? Bring some suntan lotion…you’re going to need it where your souls are going.

Oh and do NOT throw that bs forgiveness at me either.

See to be forgiven for your sins? You MUST repent…and NONE of you have.

Yeah you are all so good about screaming about your rights under the Constitution…but what about my rights and the tens of thousands upon thousands of us whom were raped and destroyed by your disgusting pedophile priests?

I suppose though…your rights to rape kids and cover it up trumps our rights to have your disgusting rapists and pedophile pimps whom covered it up get away with their crimes against us right?
 
Americans , given the almost pathological hatred for any sort of Christianity now aggressively being push across your constitutional law, should expect more of this.
In England the Anglican and Catholic churches are so weak the Anglicans have given up the sanctity of the confessional and the English Catholic Church will be under greater attack on this issue
In Australia the left wing Labor party was considering make compulsion of such breach a law, but wiser heads eventually ruled.
The anti-Catholic hysteria will use the normal compassion felt for all victims of abuse to attack the authority of the church still respected by the civil authorities.
YAY another winner.

Punk.

Listen up you disgusting freak.

anti-Catholic hysteria will use normal compassion felt for all victims of abuse to attack the authority of the church still respected by civil authorities?

You disgust me.

I am one of those victims…but nope I am not a victim any longer.

See boy…it is time for you all to fear ME and the rest of my brothers and sisters, whom were raped, brutalized, terrorized, destroyed by your disgusting pedophile priests, your psychotic nuns and covered up by your Pedophile Pimp leaders.

You got a lot of guts to say that the church is still respected by civil authorities, when Ireland and many other countries populations and civil authorities would love to string you all up by your ears and hang you.

Ireland wants your disgusting pedophile church OUT. So does NSW, Australia and many others.

Oh and WE LOVE your compassion shown to us.

Head Pedophile Pimp, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, PAYS that disgusting scumbag, Bill Donohue of the Catholic League to go on the defense for him, attacking us priest rape survivors and psycho nun slave traders…to insult, defame and denigrate us.

I had the unpleasure of this scumbag telling me to my FACE…because I did not punch that disgusting ephebophile Leon Gaulin in the face while he was raping me, that meant not only did I want to be raped, I enjoyed it and I am a homosexual because of it…WITH ALL THE CONNOTATIONS THAT IMPLICATION BRINGS FROM YOUR DISGUSTING CHURCH IN ITS CONDEMNATION OF HOMOSEXUALS.

See boy…I used to live in FEAR of all of you. That priest really did that good for me…but it was after this disgusting degenerate defender said this to me that I sad ENOUGH IS ENOUGH I WILL NOT BE BLAMED FOR MY RAPE BY YOUR DISGUSTING PRIEST.

So Donohue, Dolan and the rest of you scum whom defend and stand up for these souless, moraless unholy scumbags…woke a sleeping tiger…and NOW I AM PISSED AND I NO LONGER FEAR ANY OF YOU…BUT YOU ALL SHOULD START FEARING ME.

See I am determined…I am trust me and I am on a MISSION FROM GOD…I AM GOING TO MAKE SURE EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOUR PEDOPHILE PIMPS WHOM COVERED UP THESE CRIMES AND EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOUR PEDOPHILE PRIESTS AND EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOUR PSYCHO NUNS GO TO WHERE YOU ALL BELONG…IN PRISON…GETTING YOUR JUST DESSERTS BY THE INMATES WHOM WILL LOVE YOU ALL.

There will NEVER be forgiveness for ANY of you…see because we do follow the True Masters teachings…that if you wish to be forgiven…YOU MUST TRULY REPENT…AND NONE OF YOU HAVE DONE THIS…IT IS PROVEN TIME AND TIME AGAIN, WHEN YOU DENY US SURVIVORS JUSTICE USING THE LAWS LIKE THE STATUE OF LIMITATIONS AND THIS **** TO HAVE OUR CASES DISMISSED.

Here is a clue sunshine…when you all do die…make sure you all have a bottle of suntan oil with ya…cause where Jesus is going to send your sorry butts…you are gonna need it.

For Jesus said:“It would be better for you to tie a huge millstone around your neck and throw yourself into the deepest of lakes than to harm a single hair on the head of a child.”

Well sunshine…just what do you think Jesus is going to do to all of you when you get before Him on this? I believe it will be the 9th level of Dante’s hell for all of you.
 
Survivors Prayer

Dear God,

We ask you to help us find healing and peace in our lives. Grant us hope in these times of trial. May Maria Goretti, who was strengthened by Your Grace, join with us in prayer for healing of all victims of abuse, particularly those abused as children or young adults.

Fill us with Your Love so that, as Maria prayed for her attacker, we too might have the courage to pray for the true conversion of our abusers, that they might seek Your Mercy through prayer and penance.

Loving God, pour into our hearts and lives Your healing Spirit, that the sacredness of every human person might be respected and protected as the precious image of God. Help us to live in the peace which Maria Goretti found in Christ and in the love of His mother, Mary.

We ask this in the name of Jesus Christ, our Lord.

Amen
 
Survivors Prayer

Dear God,

We ask you to help us find healing and peace in our lives. Grant us hope in these times of trial. May Maria Goretti, who was strengthened by Your Grace, join with us in prayer for healing of all victims of abuse, particularly those abused as children or young adults.

Fill us with Your Love so that, as Maria prayed for her attacker, we too might have the courage to pray for the true conversion of our abusers, that they might seek Your Mercy through prayer and penance.

Loving God, pour into our hearts and lives Your healing Spirit, that the sacredness of every human person might be respected and protected as the precious image of God. Help us to live in the peace which Maria Goretti found in Christ and in the love of His mother, Mary.

We ask this in the name of Jesus Christ, our Lord.

Amen
👍
 
:dts: :nope:

:nope: :dts: :whacky:

No, it isn’t. And I fully stand by the right of the priest to conceal information from the state.

You don’t get to make the rules. :whacky:

Wow boy…I wish you would say this to my face…see I am one of those whom were disgustingly raped by one of your pedophile priests…and I do not think…after you said this to my face…you would have any teeth left in your mouth.

I believe a lot of people would fully stand behind me as I beat you half to death and knock out your teeth for defending the indefensible…so why not come to my house and let’s test this theory of mine out shall we?

Because God’s law trumps that of man and feeling good inside.
 
Yes.
They did report it and the alleged perp died before they finished the investigation. The parents filed against alleged, deceased perp, the funeral home, the Diocese and priest. That was filed in '09.
Why the funeral home?
 
The alleged perp was president of the funeral home and it is also where one of the assaults took place.
I would appreciate it if you would cease from using the derogatory term “alleged perp” in reference to the accused.
 
It’s derogatory to whom?
That is how he is referred to even in the SP ruling, alleged perpetrator.
 
Official Statement of the Diocese of Baton Rouge

“Church law does not allow either the plaintiff (penitent) or anyone else to waive the seal of confession.”​

It sounds like legally the girl and the priest both would be protected because both of them fall under the seal which the church imposes.

And as such, the girl’s testimony would not count because she can’t waive the seal legally since this would violate the separation of church and state.

That is what I’m getting out of it.

Someone said that the penitent can give the priest permission to use confessional knowledge outside the confessional. Tho this is true, in legal court cases, the seal protects both penitent and confessor, and the court cannot ask for either to break this protective seal or use information guarded by this seal, because this is protected under the 1st amendment.

This would mean, I would think, that the court cannot ask for this info from either the penitent or confessor and therefore the info must be disregarded and thrown out.
Thus dissolving the case.

Praise be Jesus Christ
 
Official Statement of the Diocese of Baton Rouge

“Church law does not allow either the plaintiff (penitent) or anyone else to waive the seal of confession.”​

It sounds like legally the girl and the priest both would be protected because both of them fall under the seal which the church imposes.

And as such, the girl’s testimony would not count because she can’t waive the seal legally since this would violate the separation of church and state.

That is what I’m getting out of it.

Someone said that the penitent can give the priest permission to use confessional knowledge outside the confessional. Tho this is true, in legal court cases, the seal protects both penitent and confessor, and the court cannot ask for either to break this protective seal or use information guarded by this seal, because this is protected under the 1st amendment.

This would mean, I would think, that the court cannot ask for this info from either the penitent or confessor and therefore the info must be disregarded and thrown out.
Thus dissolving the case.

Praise be Jesus Christ
To waive the seal would mean it no longer existed. No one can do that. A penitent can speak of their own confession. A priest can never break the seal, speak what was said in any shape or form.

What they said doesn’t apply to her.
 
When a penitent speaks of their confession, the seal is still in tact, not broken. She is free to speak of it.

That is why it was a real surprise they allowed their legal team to take this approach.
 
From the ruling:
It follows, if the penitent
waives the privilege, the priest cannot then raise it to protect himself as he can only
“claim the privilege
on behalf of the person
,” not in his own right. La. Code E
vid
.
art. 511(C). Therefore, we find the appellate court erred in granting the Church’s
motion in limine, excluding all evidence of the confession in its entirety as the
child/penitent is free to testify and introduce evidence as to her own confession.

The way the court used waived doesn’t mean the same as the way the Diocese used it because they then finished with she was “free to testify and introduce evidence as to her own confession.”
 
That is because there is a church point of view outside of court and another view inside a court.

From the church’s point, the seal can only be broken by the confessor and not the penitent.

From the church’s point in a court of law, the court breaks the seal by wanting info from either the penitent or confessor.

Praise be Jesus Christ.
 
That is because there is a church point of view outside of court and another view inside a court.

From the church’s point, the seal can only be broken by the confessor and not the penitent.

From the church’s point in a court of law, the court breaks the seal by wanting info from either the penitent or confessor.

Praise be Jesus Christ.
She is the one giving it, it hasn’t been demanded of her by court or anyone else. They have not broken the seal nor any laws for allowing her to do something she wishes to do, talk about her confession.
 
She is the one giving it, it hasn’t been demanded of her by court or anyone else. They have not broken the seal nor any laws for allowing her to do something she wishes to do, talk about her confession.
The priest is the defendant. Do you think it is fair that the plaintiffs can bring up things said under the seal of confession that prevents him from either confirming or denying? How is that fair to the defendant?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top