British royal's fiancée renounces Catholic faith

  • Thread starter Thread starter chewchoo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No, as even the article says there is no more than SOME legal opinion that ONE Act possibly still applies, which is not at all the same thing as saying it ACTUALLY does still apply. It would need to be tested in the courts for a definitive answer. The opinion I’ve read, however, and I’ve read more than a small amount since the question was first raised here, is overwhelmingly to the contrary, so it hardly seems to be a ‘known fact’ that a Catholic cannot be PM.

With all respect, Nordar, I’m an Australian law student and have worked plenty in and around our legal profession - our citizens are for the most part incredibly ignorant of our laws, and the situation is no different in the UK or US.

In addition to the legal requirements, however, there are, which none of us has denied, a number of practical issues which may create difficulties for a Catholic PM. Most if not all of which, however, could be overcome by creative solutions such as Gordon Brown is employing by giving the appointment of Bishops back to Church authorities in the COE.
That is why I posted two seperate links, i am not disagreeing with what you are saying. I am saying that having grown up in Britain it is well known that regardless of what is legally written, to be a Catholic and become Prime Minister has never happened, is not going to happen unless there is some HUGE changes…

Being a law student does not change that fact, it does not have anything to do with ignorance of the law
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top