I realize that many of you are confused and, in some cases, angry with me in response to the Frank Borzellieri situation. Let me begin by stating my fundamental believe that racism is evil. We as Catholics reject racism in all of its ugly forms. I am deeply sorry for the pain that has been caused, among our faith family and beyond, by these recent events.
As your pastor, I apologize for my mistake in judgment: in hindsight, I should not have hired Mr. Borzelleri. I ask for your forgiveness. We celebrate diversity in our Church, in fact, the word Catholic means “universal”—all persons everywhere are welcome. I realize that there has been a lot of emotions expressed by many following the article, and I understand their pain. I did my best to correct the situation and now, please God, we will find a new and very qualified principal for Our Lady of Mount Carmel School, which remains an excellent place of nurture and growth for so many priceless, precious children.
Please allow me to provide a little background. Some will argue that Mr. Borzelleri should never have been working here in the first place. That point was not clear to me when I first hired him. When Mr. Borzellieri applied in 2009 to be principal here at Mount Carmel, my search committee assisted me in the decision to hire him. The search committee represented the full diversity of the school population and included teachers and parents. His credentials were quite good and so the committee recommended him as principal. Neither myself, nor any of the members of the search committee knew of Mr. Borzelleri’s political writings at the time of his hiring. I read them after he was hired as principal.
In addition, it is my understanding that Mr. Borzelleri had the support of many minorities including Roy Innis, the national chairman of the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE), a black civil rights organization, who said in 2000 that Mr. Borzelleri was known for “getting into the trenches with black people and trying to help them instead of standing in a glass house and merely pontificating on the need to help black people…. I am proud to call Frank Borzelleri my friend.” My decision on whether or not to keep Mr. Borzelleri employed at our school was not such an obvious one to make. He had worked in two other minority-dominated schools before coming to Mount Carmel, and there was never any complaints from parents or students about him sent to the Archdiocese.
Regarding these views, I was quoted as saying: “Do I agree with all of it? No. But I think much of it is valuable and logical and reasonable. A lot of his ideas would actually benefit minorities.” My words were taken out of context. The question to me about whether I agree with all of it referred not to all of his racial views – which I strongly condemn – but to other views expressed in his books. Keep in mind, Mr. Borzelleri’s ideas cover a very wide range of topics like the value for children of reciting in school the pledge of allegiance and the merits of Christopher Columbus’ expeditions to the new world. The truth is that I disagree with his racial views. Racism is a sin. I have dedicated my life to living among and serving one of the most racially mixed and culturally diverse parishes in the Archdiocese of New York. Moreover, as a son of an immigrant I disagree with his views on immigration and his pessimistic attitude about the rising of population rates among certain demographic groups.
I pray for all victims of racism and unjust discrimination. I know that you do the same. In the spirit of love and forgiveness, please keep Mr. Borzelleri and his family in your prayers as well.
Thank you for your prayers and support,
Father Eric Rapaglia, Pastor