Brown Scapular Questions. Please

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pyjamarama
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So can I wear this scapular or not with the piece missing?
If you want to wear a scapular, wear a scapular. A scapular means cloth over the shoulders, which, for the abbreviated versions, needs the two pieces of cloth. If you have only one cloth, then it’s not a scapular.

Just get some brown cloth and sew it onto the strings and you’re done. You have a scapular and the blessing transfers to it. Without the second piece, it’s just a badge.
 
Thank You.

Not sure why it took 23 posts to get the answer though?
 
I was under the impression it needed to be Brown wool, & not ju6a “brown cloth.”
 
Doesn’t have to be wool any more according to the Carmelite Scapular Catechesis.

See paragraph 4 on the second last page.
http://dev.thereseocds.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Scapular-Catechesis-Online.pdf

And the last page here (this is the Scapular Catechesis we have posted many times previously, it is now available at a different website than previously but I understand it is also sold by the Carmelites in booklet form).
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1c8LQjlOpM-DLmtV5MSdAtdNF_zUbSGAi/view
 
Last edited:
No as the Scapular Catechesis says. Also look at full Carmelite habits. You will see that they don’t wear wool anymore, including their full scapulars. It is not practical.

Any cloth will do, including felt, cotton, silk, polyester, etc.
 
Last edited:
No @Justin_Mary, the General Curia of the Carmelite Order clearly states that any brown fabric is acceptable. Wool is not required. “The Scapular consists of two brown or dark pieces of material, joined together by two ribbons.” You can read a compilation of sources here on CAF or at this link on the Carmelite Order’s website.
 
I feel your angst. 😃 I’ve also discovered over the decades that some folks find Teresa easier to comprehend than John; I fell in that category early on and to a certain extent I still feel a certain kinship with Teresa while I truly appreciate and value John’s logic. That’s why it is so wonderful to have their collected works on my hard drive, indexed, in the original Spanish and in two English translations. I can study, compare texts, and hone my own skills as a translator. When I researched Fr. Cliff’s pedigree, his studies at Salamanca and coursework at the Teresianum certainly equip him to write on the Spanish mystics.

Your recollection of the gist of the matter is 100% correct. That’s what Teresa says in her Life and that’s what John says over and over in his works. And Therese reduces the teaching of both to this simple phrase: everything is a grace.
 
for further clarification. the blessing regarding the scapular is the blessing is attached to the person. the sacramental of the scapular is an outside sign of an interior consecration to our lady of mt Carmel. though the scapular itself is blessed when one is enrolled it is primarily the one where wears it who is recievimg the blessing. the power of the scapular is in YOU not the object. sure there are requirements of wearing it to fulfill the promise but it is You who has the blessing that’s why unlike other sacramental subsequent scapular do not need to be blessed unless they are the Medal! the medal needs to be blessed as many times as different colors or types of scapular to be a replacement for them. if you do the first nine fridays and first five saturdays you are promised the final penitence and dont need to be wearing a sacramental during death. the scapular like the rosary is a powerful tool but beware of superstition it is not a get out of hell free card.
 
the scapular like the rosary is a powerful tool but beware of superstition it is not a get out of hell free card.
Thanks so much @PaladinSword, this is such an important point.

Our Carmelite Prior General Joseph Chalmers, O.Carm. and Discalced Carmelite General Superior Camilo Maccise, O.C.D. emphasized this point several times in their messages to the Carmelite family, and in particular in their 2001 joint message, With Mary the Mother of Jesus.

In this letter that they issued on the occasion of the 750th Anniversary of the Carmelite Scapular they wrote:
Sacramentals are described as sacred signs; they belong therefore to the world of symbol and meaning. In our contemporary society it is common to say that there is a crisis of religious symbolism; at the same time our societies can be powerfully moved by secular symbolism. National flags, for instance, speak profoundly to many people. Symbols are material things or images that point to a meaning beyond themselves. Very often their meaning or suggestiveness lies in their power to speak to us at various levels: they not only communicate some information, but they touch us at the level of feeling. In symbols we can find both growth and decay. Religious symbols can degenerate into magic, if their spiritual or theological meaning is no longer communicated; they are thereby reduced to something like a charm that might bring good luck.
They reflected on the “stages in the life of a symbol.” First, an engendering experience, where the Virgin is perceived to be Carmel’s Patroness; second, the phase of dogma, which was a reflection on the meaning of the scapular for Carmel. Their explanation of the third and fourth stages speak to the element of magic:
A third stage in the life of symbols is found when contact is lost with the original experience. At this time either the symbol is ignored or is met with skepticism, whilst other people hold on blindly to the symbol in a kind of fideism, which does not attend to its origin or meaning. This last stage can be very close to magic. What is then needed at a time of skepticism or fideism is a reflective reconstruction of the symbol. This fourth stage is a task for every generation. We need to see the Scapular within the whole of Carmelite spirituality, and especially in relation to the core Marian themes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top