BSF International studies vs Catholic doctrine (Edited Title & Split)

  • Thread starter Thread starter kpratt
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

kpratt

Guest
I attend a Bible Study @ BSF International. I love the classes. When I registered noone asked me what denomination I am nor to this day has anyone asked. I was asked to take the Homiletics class but noone asked me what denomination I am. BSF doesn’t promote any specific denomination it promotes only the truth of God’s word. It doesn’t teach the papacy because that would be promoting one specific denomination or religion whichever you prefer to call it. The Lord said “My house shall be called a house of prayer for all people”. No I am not Catholic or Protestant or Methodist or Baptist or any other denomination. I am a member of the Church that is made without hands, I believe in God’s word (each and every word). I have yet to understand how so many people can teach from the same bible and believe so many different things. Just a few thoughts. Oh and I have a question to ask. I ask this question simply out of my own curiosity or you may call it ignorance if you choose to but it is something I have not understood for some time and maybe you can shed some light on this for me. Why in the Catholic Church are the members required to call the Pope or Minister whichever Father eventhough Jesus said “Do not call any man Father for you have only one Father which is in heaven”? and why does the Catholic Church require that each member go to the Minister for forgiveness in repentance when the bible says that Jesus is our High Priest that he is our mediator between us and God, he is our intercessor and we need no other. Again I ask only out of curiosity because I don’t understand this.
 
I attend a Bible Study @ BSF International. I love the classes. When I registered noone asked me what denomination I am nor to this day has anyone asked. I was asked to take the Homiletics class but noone asked me what denomination I am. BSF doesn’t promote any specific denomination it promotes only the truth of God’s word. It doesn’t teach the papacy because that would be promoting one specific denomination or religion whichever you prefer to call it. The Lord said “My house shall be called a house of prayer for all people”. No I am not Catholic or Protestant or Methodist or Baptist or any other denomination. I am a member of the Church that is made without hands, I believe in God’s word (each and every word). I have yet to understand how so many people can teach from the same bible and believe so many different things. Just a few thoughts. Oh and I have a question to ask. I ask this question simply out of my own curiosity or you may call it ignorance if you choose to but it is something I have not understood for some time and maybe you can shed some light on this for me. Why in the Catholic Church are the members required to call the Pope or Minister whichever Father eventhough Jesus said “Do not call any man Father for you have only one Father which is in heaven”? and why does the Catholic Church require that each member go to the Minister for forgiveness in repentance when the bible says that Jesus is our High Priest that he is our mediator between us and God, he is our intercessor and we need no other. Again I ask only out of curiosity because I don’t understand this.
Thanks for asking some very good questions. But it is all about truth. BSF does do some good work. That is not in dispute. The problem is that they don’t teach all the truth and leave out very important points. That is my concern.

Regarding your question about calling no man “father” the answer goes like this. In the OT times, there were two major rabinical schools, the schools of Hilel and Schimi. Each school had it’s own master teacher which they called a “FATHER”. So when St. Paul says “I will be a father to you”, what he is saying is that since he is an apostle he is the one who will pass on the faith and not someone who does not know what they are talking about like the judaizers. He will now be the “father” to them since Christ was the “father” to him on the damascas road.

As far as going to a priest for confession, that is covered in John 20 when Jesus passes on his power of forgiving sins to the apostles (and their successors). Remember in Mattew 28 Jesus passes on all authority He has to them. If you have other questions please feel free to ask, especially why you believe in a church that has no authority might be a good question.

mdcpensive1 (good luck in studying)
 
Thanks for asking some very good questions. But it is all about truth. BSF does do some good work. That is not in dispute. The problem is that they don’t teach all the truth and leave out very important points. That is my concern.

Regarding your question about calling no man “father” the answer goes like this. In the OT times, there were two major rabinical schools, the schools of Hilel and Schimi. Each school had it’s own master teacher which they called a “FATHER”. So when St. Paul says “I will be a father to you”, what he is saying is that since he is an apostle he is the one who will pass on the faith and not someone who does not know what they are talking about like the judaizers. He will now be the “father” to them since Christ was the “father” to him on the damascas road.

As far as going to a priest for confession, that is covered in John 20 when Jesus passes on his power of forgiving sins to the apostles (and their successors). Remember in Mattew 28 Jesus passes on all authority He has to them. If you have other questions please feel free to ask, especially why you believe in a church that has no authority might
be a good question.

I have not found that BSF teaches anything but truth and I am one that has no problem walking away from false teachings and would do so in a second if I thought so. Concerning “father” issue and passing on of faith… Faith can not be passed on by any man because it is written that faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word of God. It is God that opens the ears of our heart to understand the truth which then gives us faith and the more truth we understand the more our faith increases. The bible also says that it is not of any private interpretation that we should trust in the Lord to show us the truth and lean on his understanding only and not on our own or any mans but his and his alone. Giving all this the question still remains why do you call a man father when our Lord Christ Jesus says plainly not to. I don’t even call my dad father because Jesus said “No man” he didn’t say no man except, he plainly said no man and I understand this saying because our Father is to be given all praise honor and glory and calling another man Father takes away this praise honor and glory and places it on a mere man. Concerning the forgiveness of sins I went to the scripture you spoke of and read it then I thought well maybe the Catholic bible says something different so I happened to have an 1895 Catholic bible because I love antiques and I love Gods word so I went and read it and found no difference. In John 20 he says that he breathed on them the holy spirit meaning his disciples. The bible teaches that all who are truly saved receive the holy spirit and Paul teaches that we are all called to be the disciples of Christ and Jesus teaches that we all have the ability to forgive for he said forgive just as your Father in heaven forgives you but if you do not forgive neither will the Father forgive you. Jesus also spoke these words in Matthew 23 “be ye not call Rabbi for one is your Master,Christ and all ye are brothers and call no man your Father upon earth for one is your Father which is in heaven. Neither be ye called Master for one is your Master, Christ. So giving these things the same question still remains if Jesus gave authority to all to forgive why does man ( man being used as non gender specific) give authority to only a few men to give forgiveness. I do not mean to sound harsh or anything that is not my intention. I am one that takes the words of God as a whole together and trust him to teach me. I can not use just a verse here or a verse there but the whole of it all again because Jesus said " Thou shall not live by bread alone but by every word that proceeds out of the mouth of God” and to your question concerning a church without authority. The bible teaches that Christ is the head of the Church and that Christians are the members of his body. Christ is the only one that has authority over the Church. Jesus says that his temple is a temple made without hands and not of this world. This is the church I gladly serve because he says that even though we live in this world we are only strangers in this world ( I believe the exact word used is aliens of this world).

mdcpensive1 (good luck in studying)
 
… Jesus said “Do not call any man Father for you have only one Father which is in heaven”?
Is it also wrong then to call one’s male parent “Father”?
and why does the Catholic Church require that each member go to the Minister for forgiveness in repentance when the bible says that Jesus is our High Priest that he is our mediator between us and God, he is our intercessor and we need no other. Again I ask only out of curiosity because I don’t understand this.
*John 20:22-23 And when he had said this, he breathed on them, and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.” *

With this separate bestowal of the Holy Spirit, Jesus empowered the apostles to forgive sins and made it a part of their ministry as leaders of His Church. Of course, sinners would have to come to them and inform them of the sins they had committed before the apostles would know whether they could forgive them or not.

As you study the Old Testament, especially Leviticus, you’ll see that the practice of confessing sins (and making sacrificial offerings for one’s sins) was a ritual God instituted for His Chosen People. So Jesus was not introducing a whole new concept, but rather bringing to fulfillment the rite that had served as a forerunner and preparation. Sinners still need to seek forgiveness, but the sacrificial offerings of animals etc. were no longer required as Jesus is the sacrificial offering for our sins.
 
kpratt, I thank you for getting back with a question. You have given me so much to respond to I don’t think I can do it justice. I felt sadness when you said you do not call your father by “father”. I think you are misunderstanding scripture. I don’t want to be judgemental, but with so many passages in scripture that talk about fathers, there has to be another meaning than the one you have. For instance, in the first few lines of Mat 1 there are many ancestors called fathers. It is mentioned about 20 times. In the beginning of Acts 7, three people were called father, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. And then there is Philemon, line #10 where Paul says he is a father. With so many people being called father in scripture I don’t understand how you could say one line according to your understanding negates all the rest of places where it is used. You said you have to take scripture in it’s totality so I ask that you please reflect on what I have shown you to see if it makes any sense to you. If not, please let me know. There may be something I don’t understand about how you arrived at your interpretation.

It’s late, so I will try to respond to your other questions later. I am praying for you and others as we all journey to the Lord.
mdcpensive1
 
Why in the Catholic Church are the members required to call the Pope or Minister whichever Father eventhough Jesus said “Do not call any man Father for you have only one Father which is in heaven”?
Do you also hate your mother and father because Jesus Christ said so in Luke 14:26?

Even the first Christians understood that Jesus Christ was using hyperbole (exagerated speech) when He made that statement about calling no man Father and they did not take Him literally. How do we know? Because St. Stephen later addressed the Jewish high priest and other members of the Jewish Council as “Brethren and Fathers.” (Acts 7:2) Likewise, St. Paul addressed the Temple crowd as “Brethren and Fathers.” (Acts 22:1) If it is ok for Christians to address even non-Christians as “Fathers” and these verses prove that it is, why would you object to addressing Christian pastors as “Fathers”?
…and why does the Catholic Church require that each member go to the Minister for forgiveness in repentance when the bible says that Jesus is our High Priest that he is our mediator between us and God, he is our intercessor and we need no other. Again I ask only out of curiosity because I don’t understand this.
Even the first Christians understood that the priests of the Church had a ministerial role in the forgiveness of sins. In New Testament times, sickness among Christians was sometimes associated with sinfulness (see 1 Corinthians 11:30) and what does the Bible advise a sick Christian to do? St. James says he is to call for the priests of the Church and let them pray over him and anoint him with oil that he might be healed and his sins forgiven. So, not only are you to confess your sins to God but, in the company of His priests, you are to “confess your sins to one another.” (James 5:14-16)
 
Hello kpratt,

Welcome to the CAF Forum
Just to help you out a little on the computer set-ups.

When you want to set something apart in a quote box, you’ll need to make sure the sentences you want quoted are bracketed in the following manner:
At the start of the part you want in the quote box, type the word QUOTE in capital letters and put it in brackets. After the last sentence you want included in the quote box, type a slash mark first and then quote in all capitals /QUOTE and put it in brackets.
(I couldn’t include the brackets because if I did, the explanatory sentences would automatically have been put in a quote box when I posted, and the capitalized words would have disappeared. :))

When you click on the quote box to respond to a post, that whole post will come up enclosed in the QUOTE and /QUOTE directions. If you want to split the post when responding, you’ll have to add the proper quote directives where needed, making sure each of the split sections have a bracketed QUOTE at the beginning and a bracketed /QUOTE at the end.

If you just want to indent a section, follow the same procedure except use the word “indent” instead of “quote”. INDENT and /INDENT all in capitals and enclosed in brackets.

If you want to change anything on your post, you have 20 minutes in which to do it. Just hit the “Edit” button that will be down at the bottom of your post for those 20 minutes.

Hope this will help you.
 
… I am one that takes the words of God as a whole together and trust him to teach me. I can not use just a verse here or a verse there but the whole of it all…
But can you see that is exactly what you are failing to do - failing to take Scripture as a whole. You’re taking the one line of Scripture “Call no man father” and making it stand alone - without considering all the other passages where males are called father; without seeking an understanding of Jesus’ meaning that still allowed for those usages by His followers.

Jesus Himself uses the word “father” in referring to someone’s male parent here on earth.
 
But can you see that is exactly what you are failing to do - failing to take Scripture as a whole. You’re taking the one line of Scripture “Call no man father” and making it stand alone - without considering all the other passages where males are called father; without seeking an understanding of Jesus’ meaning that still allowed for those usages by His followers.

Jesus Himself uses the word “father” in referring to someone’s male parent here on earth.
exactly Nita. Very well said. Kpratt you are misunderstanding Matthew 23. Do you also not call people teachers as Matthew 23 say?. Then pray tell what did you call all those people that taught you when you were in school?

Don’t call anyone Doctor then because that is the Latin word for teacher. Do not call anyone Mister then because Matthew 23 forbids that you call anyone Master and the word mister is just another way to say Master.

Jesus is using hyeprbole to teach that the Pharisees were setting themselves up as the ultimate authority without looking to God.

Paul in the 1 Corinthian epistle says he is the spiritual father of the Corinthians is he teaching something different than Jesus?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top