Burning CD’s from the library

  • Thread starter Thread starter JellyBeanMuffin
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are interested enough in an album you should purchase it. Think about the artists and producers…they deserve to be compensated.
Paying taxes doesn’t mean you have 100% rights/ownership to items in the town.
 
Last edited:
You might be interested to know that if you buy music from Amazon and download it, you do not own it. In that you can’t then give that music to anyone else.
 
I don’t have the money to buy everything I’m interested in 😦
Most of us don’t. But that doesn’t justify violating copyright. We do without the things we can’t afford if we can’t get them legally.
 
Last edited:
There are lots of issues here. First off the content may not be under copyright protection. You don’t always know if something is actually under copyright. Something could predate modern copyright, it could have not had a copyright renewed as required, it may have been purposefully put in the public domain, or if it is something made by the government it can’t be copyrighted. Admittedly these are probably unlikely, but they are considerations. But for example if the library had a Linux operating system install CD you could absolutely copy that.

Second your dad’s idea is interesting, but it probably won’t hold up in court.

Finally, it isn’t a mortal sin. If anything it is a venial sin. You are breaking a more trivial law like speeding.
 
Our small town library has a service called “Freegal”. Each patron is given access to a large library of music and my legally download 4 or 5 (I forget) each week. You then legally own them as much as anyone owns any other digital music.
 
I also don’t think I own everything in the town. I just thought that if taxes are paid to fund a library to provide that stuff, it would be like a joint ownership.
Where do you draw the line? Does joint ownership extend to the books the library buys, like if you really enjoyed that novel you get to keep it. They have a bunch of computers for people to use so maybe you can take one home, especially if your budget is limited.
It doesn’t work that way!
 
Just to get them, listen once, and then return it?
Yes.
Don’t we own part of that music since we pay taxes?
No.
I really don’t agree with the copyright law
It is a just law regarding compensation for those
who own the material. You are not free to disobey just laws.

Yes doing so is against the moral law, and now that you’re aware of it, yes… a sin. Mortal or venial depends upon how much you are stealing.
does this mean I should delete all my music I’ve burned?
Yes.
I’m not going to sell these and they’re already been paid for
Only for one perwon’s use at a time. Copying them is wrong.
 
I don’t have the money to buy everything I’m interested in 😦
Options to get around that include YouTube or paying a monthly subscription for Spotify or Apple Music. You won’t actually own the songs but will be able to listen to everything you want 🙂
 
There is no question of restitution, since you’ve not done any damage to the copyright holders, and possessing pirated material is not illegal, so there is no obligation to destroy them.

Using these burned CDs (in private, public display is a whole nother matter) may or may not constitute “copying” for legal purposes, and thus be technically illegal, depending on precisely how the process of playing them works on your computer. However I don’t think such a technical violation of the law would be a sin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top