Cain: For the poor, it's '9-0-9'

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
=Ghosty;8501759]The FICA is 15% total, but as you say that’s not the worker’s contribution. I don’t know how forcing the employers to give a 7.65% pay raise to employees would work out, and I don’t see how such an idea would fly with those who want the FICA tax cut in the first place, especially since the idea is to cut employer costs. 😛
A cut in taxes is a cut in taxes. 😉
**Personally I’d just prefer to see an actual budget cut **(especially in military spending, not because I’m a pacifist, but because I believe we can get by on national defense with far less spending than we do now), rather than a “budget neutral” tax proposal that simplifies the tax code (very good) while shifting the tax burden towards the middle and working classes (very bad). Cain’s proposal is, IMO, the worst of both worlds because it keeps the current level of spending while increasing the burden on those who are least able to handle it.
Now on this we agree. Cut spending - I like Ron Paul’s cut of $1.5 trillion the first year. 🙂

Jon
 
It sure beats the 22% they are currently paying …
  • Marty Lund
There is no 22% tax bracket. There is a 15% and a 25%, among others. See page 98 of irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/i1040gi.pdf.

There is a 10% bracket for a single person with taxable income under $8,375. The 15% starts at $8,375 and goes up to $34,000. The 25% begins there and goes up to $82,400.

For married people, the 10% bracket goes from $1 to $16,750. The 15% starts at $16,751 and goes up to $68,000. The 25% begins there and goes up to $137,300.

Most of these are hardly “poor”.

In any event, Cain’s 9-9-9 [and 9-0-9] idea is no deal because they add up to 27% and 18% respectively, and all taxes are ultimately paid by people at the bottom who cannot pass them on because there is no one below them on the economic pyramid.

This is all academic anyway because government needs to collect taxes to pay for services the people want, and ultimately only people pay taxes. All proposals merely use different routes to collect the same amount of taxes from John Q. Public.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top